Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Israel's top general says Iran unlikely to make bomb
|
Edition:
U.S.
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
Home
Business
Business Home
Economy
Technology
Media
Small Business
Legal
Deals
Earnings
Social Pulse
Business Video
The Freeland File
Markets
Markets Home
U.S. Markets
European Markets
Asian Markets
Global Market Data
Indices
M&A
Stocks
Bonds
Currencies
Commodities
Futures
Funds
peHUB
World
World Home
U.S.
Brazil
China
Euro Zone
Japan
Mexico
Russia
India Insight
World Video
Reuters Investigates
Decoder
Politics
Politics Home
Election 2012
Issues 2012
Candidates 2012
Tales from the Trail
Political Punchlines
Supreme Court
Politics Video
Tech
Technology Home
MediaFile
Science
Tech Video
Tech Tonic
Social Pulse
Opinion
Opinion Home
Chrystia Freeland
John Lloyd
Felix Salmon
Jack Shafer
David Rohde
Bernd Debusmann
Nader Mousavizadeh
Lucy P. Marcus
David Cay Johnston
Bethany McLean
Edward Hadas
Hugo Dixon
Ian Bremmer
Lawrence Summers
Susan Glasser
The Great Debate
Steven Brill
Jack & Suzy Welch
Fred Kempe
Breakingviews
Equities
Credit
Private Equity
M&A
Macro & Markets
Politics
Breakingviews Video
Money
Money Home
Tax Break
Lipper Awards 2012
Global Investing
MuniLand
Unstructured Finance
Linda Stern
Mark Miller
John Wasik
James Saft
Analyst Research
Alerts
Watchlist
Portfolio
Stock Screener
Fund Screener
Personal Finance Video
Money Clip
Investing 201
Life
Health
Sports
Arts
Faithworld
Business Traveler
Entertainment
Oddly Enough
Lifestyle Video
Pictures
Pictures Home
Reuters Photographers
Full Focus
Video
Reuters TV
Reuters News
Article
Comments (0)
Full Focus
Editor's choice
Our best photos from the last 24 hours. Full Article
Images of March
Follow Reuters
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
YouTube
Read
Apple crushes Street targets, dispels iPhone fears
|
11:17am EDT
Britain in recession means more woe for government
|
12:18pm EDT
Washington sues Florida city over firefighter tests
23 Apr 2012
Breivik rails at psychiatrists for calling him insane
10:58am EDT
2nd Heart Attack Grill Victim? Woman Collapses While Eating Burger
24 Apr 2012
Discussed
326
Washington sues Florida city over firefighter tests
98
Nugent says had ”solid” meeting with Secret Service
86
New curbs on voter registration could hurt Obama
Watched
Jim Rogers: U.S. to plunge into recession in 2013
Tue, Apr 24 2012
Hong Kong graft probe widens
Tue, Apr 24 2012
Rihanna has "Time" on her side
Tue, Apr 24 2012
Pictures
Reuters Photojournalism
Our day's top images, in-depth photo essays and offbeat slices of life. See the best of Reuters photography. See more | Photo caption
Inside North Korea
Rare scenes from within the reclusive state. Slideshow
Olympic pub crawl
A look at the many traditional east end pubs that are situated within a mile of the Olympic Park where the 2012 Olympic Games will take place this summer. Slideshow
Israel's top general says Iran unlikely to make bomb
Tweet
Share this
Email
Print
Related News
Nuclear talks don't exempt Iran from attack: Barak
Tue, Apr 17 2012
Iran says ready to resolve nuclear issues
Mon, Apr 16 2012
Danish foreign minister: no room for weakening Iran sanctions
Mon, Apr 16 2012
Iran, big powers agree - to keep talking
Sun, Apr 15 2012
Iran, powers set for high-stakes nuclear talks
Fri, Apr 13 2012
Analysis & Opinion
Analysis: Egypt’s new politics make Israel ties a target
Egyptian MPs demand that Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa quit over Jerusalem trip
Related Topics
World »
Israel »
By Jeffrey Heller and Maayan Lubell
JERUSALEM |
Wed Apr 25, 2012 11:47am EDT
JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israel's military chief said he does not believe Iran will decide to build an atomic bomb and called its leaders "very rational" - comments that clashed with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's assessment.
Lieutenant-General Benny Gantz's remarks, in an interview published on Wednesday in the left-wing Haaretz newspaper, drew little attention in Israel on its annual remembrance day for fallen soldiers, when political discourse is suspended.
But they will add fuel to an internal debate on the prospects of Iran weaponizing its uranium enrichment program and the wisdom and risks of any Israeli military strike to try to prevent Tehran from becoming a nuclear power.
"Iran is moving step-by-step towards a point where it will be able to decide if it wants to make a nuclear bomb. It has not decided yet whether to go the extra mile," Gantz said.
But, he said, Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei could opt to produce nuclear weapons should be believe that Iran would not face reprisal.
"In my opinion, he will be making a huge mistake if he does that and I don't think he will want to go the extra mile," Gantz said.
"I think the Iranian leadership is comprised of very rational people. But I agree that such a capability in the hands of Islamic fundamentalists, who at some moments may make different calculations, is a dangerous thing."
Israel, believed to have the Middle East's only nuclear arsenal, has not ruled out military action against Iran should economic sanctions fail to curb its nuclear program, saying all options were on the table.
Only last week, in a speech during Israel's Holocaust remembrance day, Netanyahu said: "Today, the regime in Iran openly calls and determinedly works for our destruction. And it is feverishly working to develop atomic weapons to achieve that goal."
Tehran denies seeking the bomb, saying it is enriching uranium only for peaceful energy purposes and that its nuclear program is a threat to no one.
Speaking on CNN on Tuesday, Netanyahu said he would not want to bet "the security of the world on Iran's rational behavior". A "militant Islamic regime", he said, "can put their ideology before their survival".
The portrayal of Iran as irrational - willing to attack Israel with a nuclear weapon even if it means the destruction of the Islamic Republic in retaliatory strikes - could bolster a case for pre-emptive bombing to take out its atomic facilities.
Netanyahu had already been stung at home by his former spymaster, Meir Dagan, who said that such an Israeli strike on Iran would be a "ridiculous" idea.
Shannon Kile, a nuclear proliferation expert at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, said Gantz's description of Iranian leaders as rational was "quite an interesting turnabout".
"Hopefully, it is going to reduce the incentives for any sort of pre-emptive or preventive military action, at least for the time being," Kile said.
The United States has also not ruled out military action as a last resort. But many allies of Washington, and even some senior U.S. officials, fear such an attack could ignite a broader war and only temporarily halt Iran's nuclear advances.
Gantz's assessment appeared to be in step with the view of the top U.S. military officer, General Martin Dempsey. He said in a CNN interview in February he believed Iran was a "rational actor" and it would be premature to take military action against it.
Israeli political sources said at the time that the remarks by Dempsey - who also suggested Israel's armed forces could not deliver lasting damage to Iranian nuclear sites - had angered Netanyahu.
INTERNATIONAL CONCERN
Israeli Defence Minister Ehud Barak raised international concern about a possible Israeli strike several months ago when he spoke about time running out for effective Israeli military action against Iranian nuclear sites buried deep underground.
And Netanyahu, while noting that Iran has made no apparent decision to begin constructing a bomb, has voiced impatience with the pace of nuclear talks that began this month between Tehran and six world powers, the first such negotiations in more than a year.
"Either Iran takes its nuclear program to a civilian footing only, or the world, perhaps us too, will have to do something. We're closer to the end of the discussions than the middle," Gantz said.
However, he also said international pressure on Iran "is beginning to bear fruit, both on the diplomatic level and on the economic sanctions level".
Netanyahu said on CNN the sanctions were "certainly taking a bite out of the Iranian economy but so far they haven't rolled back the Iranian program or even stopped it by one iota.
"Unfortunately, that's not achieved by talks in which Iran has one goal, to stall, delay, run out the clock; that's basically what they're doing."
Gantz, a lanky former paratrooper who has served as Israel's military attaché in Washington, was asked in the Haaretz interview what impact his view would have on government decision-making on Iran.
"Whatever weight the government decides to ascribe it," he said.
"I say my opinion according to my own professional truth and my strategic analysis. I will say it sharply: I do not forget my professional ethics. The government will decide after it hears the professional echelon and the army will carry out, in a faithful and determined manner, any decision that is made."
Kile said he was surprised Gantz had spoken out, "because normally the Israeli military leadership on the nuclear issue has been quite subdued", with former intelligence officials "coming out and trying to cool ... the possible Israeli impetus towards military action".
Gantz took over as chief of staff a year ago but has been less outspoken on strategic issues than his predecessor, Gabi Ashkenazi. He was not the first choice for the job; the preferred candidate, Yoav Gallant, had to bow out because of a property scandal.
In at least one turning point in Israeli history, the government chose to ignore a strong warning from the military's top general about the intentions of a long-time adversary.
In 1977, then-chief of staff Mordechai Gur famously cautioned the cabinet that Egyptian President Anwar Sadat's offer to visit Jerusalem could be a smokescreen for war preparations. Sadat's trip led to a peace treaty in 1979.
(Additional reporting by Fredrik Dahl in Vienna; Editing by Mark Heinrich)
World
Israel
Tweet this
Link this
Share this
Digg this
Email
Reprints
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment on reuters.com.
Add yours using the box above.
Edition:
U.S.
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
Back to top
Reuters.com
Business
Markets
World
Politics
Technology
Opinion
Money
Pictures
Videos
Site Index
Legal
Bankruptcy Law
California Legal
New York Legal
Securities Law
Support & Contact
Support
Corrections
Connect with Reuters
Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn
RSS
Podcast
Newsletters
Mobile
About
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
AdChoices
Copyright
Our Flagship financial information platform incorporating Reuters Insider
An ultra-low latency infrastructure for electronic trading and data distribution
A connected approach to governance, risk and compliance
Our next generation legal research platform
Our global tax workstation
Thomsonreuters.com
About Thomson Reuters
Investor Relations
Careers
Contact Us
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 25 April 2012 Exclusive: U.S. eyes options to restart Afghan peace talks
|
Venezuela's Chavez sends video postcard from Cuba
|
Israel legalizes three West Bank outposts
|
Mexico presidential front-runner builds on big lead: poll
|
Analysis: Egypt's new politics make Israel ties a target
|
FBI chief in Yemen, drone kills AQAP leader
|
Apple crushes Street targets, dispels iPhone fears
|
Facebook deals may add week to IPO timing: source
|
LightSquared creditors unite against Phil Falcone
|
Oracle confronts Google's Schmidt about Java
|
Apple infringes on Motorola Mobility patent: ITC judge
|
U.S. eyes broader cyber-threat pact with companies
|
Analysis: As technology shifts, Asian giants wrestle for TV control
|
Dick Clark had prostate surgery day before death
|
Philippines, U.S. stage war games in face of China warning
|
Analysis: Myanmar's military moves amid Suu Kyi no-show
|
U.S. concerns over Okinawa base plans prompt Japan to delay announcement
|
China says hopes U.S.' Myanmar moves not aimed at Beijing
|
Pakistan army uses bullets, and classrooms to fight militancy
|
China makes veiled warning to North Korea not to carry out nuclear test
|
Dutch call Sept vote, leaving months of uncertainty
|
Japan fears nuclear plant sits atop active geological fault
|
Pakistan tests nuclear-capable ballistic missile
|
Apple crushes Street targets, dispels iPhone fears
|
Still in the frame, the camera defies smartphone onslaught
|
Facebook deals may add a week to IPO timing: source
|
Huawei forecasts handset shipments above 100 million this year
|
App aims to make Hey Sexy a sound of old New York
|
Analysis: As technology shifts, Asian giants wrestle for TV control
|
Mathai and Cheesa sent home from The Voice
|
Beach Boys go retro on first new single in 20 years
|
Dancing With the Stars says goodbye to Gladys Knight
|
Rocker Ted Nugent shoots one black bear too many
|
Shirley MacLaine grows old and mean
Breivik rails at psychiatrists for calling him insane
|
Syrian forces shoot up bus, U.N. derided
|
Murdoch never asked a UK prime minister for anything
|
Analysis: Secretive far-right party taps into Greeks' anger, fear
|
Pope orders cardinals to investigate Vatican leaks
|
Libya bans religious, tribal or ethnic parties
|
Israel's top general says Iran unlikely to make bomb
|
France's Sarkozy rules out deal with far right
|
South Sudan frees prisoners to defuse tensions
|
Nokia, HTC win European patent ruling
|
In Canada, phones poised to challenge credit cards
|
Intel to challenge antitrust fine in EU court
|
Shutterfly says no rival bids for Kodak business
|
Ericsson raises hopes mobile gear market stabilized
|
Beyonce named People's most beautiful woman
|
Hitler's Mein Kampf may return to Bavarian schools
|
Indonesian film may help revive local martial art
|
Egypt actor to appeal jail term for defaming Islam
|
A Minute With: John Cusack on Poe and 'The Raven'
|
UK teen sensation Maynard says he's no Justin Bieber
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights