InfoAnda - Insight: On welfare reform, French resistance |

China's Huawei sets up cyber security center in Britain | | 6 December 2010

Aussies muscled out of world basketball championships | 6 September 2010

Analysis: AT&T faces tough year after losing iPhone exclusive | | 11 January 2011

The Nano, world's cheapest car, to hit Indian roads | Technology | | 23 March 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Insight: On welfare reform, French resistance |

Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Home Business Business Home Economy Technology Media Small Business Green Business Legal Deals Earnings Summits Business Video Markets Markets Home U.S. Markets European Markets Asian Markets Global Market Data Indices M&A Stocks Bonds Currencies Commodities Futures Funds peHUB World World Home U.S. Brazil China Euro Zone Japan Mexico Russia Afghan Journal Africa Journal India Insight Global News Journal Pakistan: Now or Never? World Video Politics Politics Home Front Row Washington Politics Video Technology Technology Home MediaFile Science Tech Video Opinion Opinion Home Chrystia Freeland Felix Salmon Jack Shafer Breakingviews George Chen Bernd Debusmann Gregg Easterbrook James Pethokoukis James Saft John Wasik Christopher Whalen Ian Bremmer Mohamed El-Erian Lawrence Summers The Great Debate Unstructured Finance Newsmaker MuniLand Money Money Home Analyst Research Global Investing MuniLand Reuters Money Alerts Watchlist Portfolio Stock Screener Fund Screener Personal Finance Video Life & Culture Health Sports Arts Faithworld Business Traveler Left Field Entertainment Oddly Enough Lifestyle Video Pictures Pictures Home Reuters Photographers Full Focus Video Article Comments (2) Slideshow Full Focus Editor's choice A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Warning: Graphic content Full Article Follow Reuters Facebook Twitter RSS YouTube Read Congressman Phil Roe performs CPR on man at airport 20 Sep 2011 Georgia condemned man's polygraph request denied | 11:16am EDT Google+ opens up, takes fight to Facebook 5:43am EDT Philadelphia police complain about filthy stations 20 Sep 2011 Actor Tom Sizemore arrested, held briefly in Los Angeles 20 Sep 2011 Discussed 132 Obama to propose $3 trillion in deficit cuts 76 Geithner’s ”succinct” message irks Europeans 54 New York meetings open to avert Palestinian crisis Watched Self-driving car takes to the road Tue, Sep 20 2011 Human skin strengthened with spider silk can stop a bullet Tue, Sep 20 2011 Scarlett's naked pics, Tyler Perry is highest paid Wed, Sep 14 2011 Insight: On welfare reform, French resistance Tweet Share this Email Print Related News Italy downgraded, IMF says Europe behind the curve Tue, Sep 20 2011 Lenders press Greece to shrink state and avoid default Mon, Sep 19 2011 Obama backs away from Social Security in deficits plan Thu, Sep 15 2011 EU warned of credit crunch threat, French banks hit Wed, Sep 14 2011 Perry targeted by rivals in Republican debate Tue, Sep 13 2011 Analysis & Opinion Who stands for the public in Murdoch vs the government? More for the rich Related Topics World » 1 of 5. A man identified as Georges poses with a daily newspaper in a Paris park September 19, 2011. For up to four months every year -- the time required to become eligible for unemployment benefits -- Georges works as a waiter or bartender, earning 3-4,000 euros ($4,000-5,500) a month. Then he arranges to be laid off, amicably if possible. For the rest of the year he pockets unemployment benefits worth 54 percent of his pay and makes up the difference by working -- off the books -- in bars and restaurants. Credit: Reuters/Benoit Tessier By Nicholas Vinocur PARIS | Wed Sep 21, 2011 10:22am EDT PARIS (Reuters) - In a cozy bachelor pad on the Paris Left Bank, Georges, a 26-year old would-be advertising executive, exhales cigarette smoke and describes how he games the French welfare system. For up to four months every year -- the time required to become eligible for unemployment benefits -- Georges works as a waiter or bartender, earning 3-4,000 euros ($4,000-5,500) a month. Then he arranges to be laid off, amicably if possible. For the rest of the year he pockets unemployment benefits worth 54 percent of his pay and makes up the difference by working -- off the books -- in bars and restaurants. "It's crazy," he says. "I have two arms, two legs, there's no reason I shouldn't be working. But the way the system is set up, there's just no incentive to do it all the time." By at least one measure, France has the most generous welfare system in the world. The state spends more than 20 percent of GDP on social benefits a year, or more than 500 billion euros ($700 billion). Benefit fraud cost the country 20 billion euros in 2010, according to a bi-partisan parliamentary report in June. That is about two-thirds of the social security system's budget shortfall, which is expected to reach 30 billion euros in 2011. The social security deficit is a big part of France's public deficit, measured at 148.8 billion euros in 2010. An August 2011 online poll by the Metro free paper showed 68 percent of French people want welfare beneficiaries to be tracked more closely. Now French politicians say it is time to get serious. In April, President Nicolas Sarkozy launched a campaign to go after welfare cheats. The government is drawing up a national register of all welfare recipients to make it easier to target people collecting benefits illegally. Some politicians have even suggested that people who collect a subsidy designed to help jobseekers find work known as the revenu de solidarite active (RSA) should be forced to make some sort of active contribution in return. But true reform will be difficult. In France, rich and poor alike exploit opportunities for gain, even illegal ones. From bosses who dodge social fees to workers who want more paid holiday when it suits their schedule, it sometimes can seem as if the whole society is bending the rules. At the same time -- and despite the polls -- accusing people in public is widely seen as distasteful. Politicians may talk about a crackdown but they also know they cannot be seen to hurt the poor. Dominique Tian, a deputy in Sarkozy's center-right UMP party and one of the authors of the report on benefit fraud, goes as far as to call it a French taboo. "Our country is less permissive than our neighbors to the south, but at the same time, we French are fond of our contradictions," says Jean Mallot, a socialist member of the parliamentary commission looking into ways of toughening defenses against fraud. "People scream and shout about what they see as criminal behavior, but are tolerant when it comes to the small things." HOW TO CHEAT Georges' lifestyle is one such small thing. The slender-built university dropout, who would give his first name only, lives rent-free thanks to the generosity of a relative. He gave up law studies three years ago to try his luck as a rapper, but found the lifestyle difficult to maintain while working full-time as a waiter at a chic Parisian cafe. The solution -- unemployment -- was a no-brainer. "I wish I had figured it out sooner," he says, before pointing out that he has paid into the unemployment system. Georges' off-the-books job should disqualify him from receiving jobless benefits. But he has not filed a tax return since he began working at 17. When his current benefits run out, he plans to apply for the RSA, which would entitle him to a free monthly transport card and aid for clothing, childcare, rent and skills training. Most of his friends, he says, live off a combination of RSA payments, illegal work, and other benefits. He feels no pressure from the unemployment office to report his income, or to be entirely truthful about the status of his job search. Nor does he see any stigma in taking handouts. "On the contrary; it's the people working full-time for a crap salary who are the fools." At a government jobs agency not far from Georges' flat, adviser Helene Thierry is not surprised when a reporter recounts Georges' story. Thierry has been helping people find jobs and paying out benefits since 2007, handling up to 200 cases at once, and says it is unusual for the often overworked advisers at her agency to check the finances of benefit recipients. When suspicions come up or a recipient fails to meet their obligations, penalties are "almost never" enforced. "The workload is too big to follow up on every excuse, and even when you discover that someone has lied about this or that, you don't want to cut them off," Thierry says, adding that her colleagues share this view. Thierry suspects that some 20 percent of job-seekers on her books are "delinquent" in some way. The biggest problem is people who miss their monthly meetings -- a good sign they are working without telling the agency. Some well-to-do RSA beneficiaries treat the payment as an allowance, she says. "I once had a girl who came in yelling because we had cut off her RSAs," she says. "We had discovered somehow that she was living in a 300-sq-m flat and clearly wealthy. But she felt entitled to the RSA as pocket money. That's a common attitude: people feel the state owes them an allowance." Georges, who has a different adviser, even hints at a degree of collusion with the woman who handles his benefits. "She even warned me against working for temp agencies, since they denounce you (to authorities)," he said. PRIVATE CHECKS In the absence of tough checks by public officials, employers are making more use of private inspectors. Franck Charpentier is the founder of Mediverif, a private inspection service hired by companies to check up on their staff. One familiar problem is the worker who calls in sick for a morning, then disappears for the whole of August -- the month when much of France goes on holiday. Calls and visits to their home go unanswered. At the end of August, they return to work saying they were too ill to answer the door or telephone, or check the post. "We have dozens of such cases every year," Charpentier said. According to a study by Alma Consulting, French workers are absent an average of 17.8 days a year. That, says Charpentier, may be good for his own company, but it hurts the country. And he doesn't see things changing quickly. "You'd think people would keep themselves in check, but we haven't seen any fall in the number of cases since we started to operate," he said. "It's become a form of social dialogue: when there is a conflict at work, when an employee is unhappy, he calls in sick. People know that social security will not investigate their case immediately, if at all." NO MONOPOLY ON CHEATING Cheating the system is not exclusive to France, of course. Open a tabloid newspaper in most countries in Europe and there's a good chance you will find a story about a benefit cheat caught abusing the common good. Germany had "Florida Rolf," a man named and shamed in Bild newspaper for using benefits to fund a lifestyle of leisure in Miami. In Sweden, a woman took 2 million crowns ($300,000) from social security while illegally running two businesses. In Britain, the government funds sharply produced television spots with the slogan "It's not if we catch you, it's when." But the French don't like to get personal. Newspapers write about general increases in fraud -- as with an April report showing a 19 percent jump in detected cases between 2009 and 2010 -- but stories that point the finger at individuals are rare. That instinct, according to Pierre Morange, a UMP member who heads the parliamentary benefit fraud commission, runs deep. For years there has been a longstanding refusal, running right through media and public life, to even admit such things happen. "Everyone denied it," he said. Morange believes France's gentle approach stems partly from by the country's Catholic tradition, which blurs the line between charity and social security. Welfare beneficiaries are viewed as unfortunates in need of a helping hand, rather than temporarily unemployed workers, he says. Any acts of fraud, as sins go, are "venial" and thus excusable. A 2010 study by Sciences Po sociologist Pierre Lascoumes, which examined attitudes toward fraud in 17 European countries, backs that view. Lascoumes showed that French people are among Europe's sternest when it comes to obeying the law but see practical situations differently. Asked whether it is acceptable to commit a "gentle" form of fraud, such as avoiding sales tax on services, French respondents were more tolerant than any other nationality. "France occupies a unique position," Lascoumes concluded. "We are in a situation where principled positions appear rigid, ... giving way to transgressions in practice when faced with a concrete situation." It's a different story in plain-speaking Protestant northern Europe where Swedish Finance Minister Anders Borg last year called on his countrymen to "stop drinking and get back to work." Jobs adviser Helene Thierry, who spent three months in Stockholm on a work exchange program at the Swedish jobs agency, has seen this tough love applied on the ground. While her Swedish counterparts were generous in handing out benefits, she said, job seekers who failed to check in regularly had their benefits cut. "There are no questions asked. In France we are much more lenient... It's a cultural difference." RIGID RULE, SOFT PRACTICE Morange believes things in France are "moving in the right direction." But seven years after he set up his parliamentary group, many of his initiatives are still snaking their way through the system. The problem is less a lack of laws, more the fact that they are not applied. Two scathing reports published last year by France's national auditor listed the shortcomings: sluggish adoption of anti-fraud measures, failure to share best practices, failure to follow up on clear signs of fraudulent behavior, and a lack of communication, to name but a few. Further undermining change is a lack of political consensus. Jean Mallot, the socialist member of the committee, argues that benefit fraud amounts to a relatively small portion of the total. Companies that fail to declare workers and pay social fees are responsible for a much bigger portion of the problem, according to a 2010 report by France's national auditor. Like other Socialist politicians, Mallot says the focus on fraud is a government tactic to cover up its failure to fix unemployment, which runs at nearly 25 percent for people aged 18-25. "We should not be telling people that we're going to plug the deficit gap by fighting against welfare fraud," says Mallot. "By introducing ever stricter controls, we could maybe recuperate 2 or 3 billion euros at most. But it's unrealistic to say we would get back 10 or 20 billion - those are imaginary sums." POLITICALLY, A FALLING KNIFE While polls show two-thirds of French think the government should act, getting too tough can be fatal, as former Europe minister Laurent Wauquiez learned when he said in May that abuse of the welfare system had become a "cancer" in French society. Wauquiez came in for a hailstorm of criticism from right and left, as politicians accused him of unfairly targeting France's poor. Sarkozy himself mused aloud whether Wauquiez should be fired from the government, according to three French news sources. He was given a new position as Secretary of State for European Affairs, a slight demotion, in a reshuffle. At the same time, inaction can also hurt, as former presidential contender Lionel Jospin, a Socialist, found in 2002. "Jospin lost the election partly because he ignored abuse of the social protection system," said Marc Levy, a pollster at Harris Interactive. "Working class people found there was not enough of a gap between their salaries and aid for the unemployed." That means politicians must find the line between being too generous and too tough. "You don't have to be a clairvoyant to see that without a fair reassessment of our welfare model, our country is headed for tensions, violence, bitterness, deepening of inequality and defiance of the public good," sociologist Jacques Etcheheguy wrote in the left-leaning weekly Marianne in 2007. (Edited by Sara Ledwith and Simon Robinson.) World Tweet this Link this Share this Digg this Email Reprints We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/ Comments (2) aligatorhardt wrote: Playing with numbers can make things sound more significant than they are. Out of the money spent on social support, the fraud amounts to 4% of GDP. They are throwing together social security, welfare and unemployment to reach the 20 billion Euros out of 500. So for $%of the economy, they concentrate on fraud from the poor, when fraud from the rich is many times greater. Of course the poor do not supply sufficient bribes for officials, so they are the problem. Sep 21, 2011 4:21am EDT -- Report as abuse Tiu wrote: Symptoms of the parasitic values held by those at the top filtering down through the system. Pity the honest worker surrounded by scabs on all sides. Sep 21, 2011 10:49am EDT -- Report as abuse See All Comments » Add Your Comment Social Stream (What's this?) Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Back to top Reuters.com Business Markets World Politics Technology Opinion Money Pictures Videos Site Index Legal Bankruptcy Law California Legal New York Legal Securities Law Support & Contact Contact Us Advertise With Us Connect with Reuters Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS Podcast Newsletters Mobile About Privacy Policy Terms of Use Our Flagship financial information platform incorporating Reuters Insider An ultra-low latency infrastructure for electronic trading and data distribution A connected approach to governance, risk and compliance Our next generation legal research platform Our global tax workstation Thomsonreuters.com About Thomson Reuters Investor Relations Careers Contact Us Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Wednesday, 21 September 2011
Cabrera, Fukudome blasts help Tribe overcome White Sox
Iran won't retaliate for nuclear scientist killings |
Al-Shabaab, militia clashes claim five in Somalia
Impunity rules during Zimbabwe's “transition”
Syrian forces kill three in raids, two police shot |
Sheryl Crow to write music for Broadway adaptation of "Diner"
At 2 feet tall, Illinois woman named world's shortest
Michigan quarterback shows weaknesses despite being dangerous with the ball
Puntland legislator gunned down in central Somalia
Head of Arab broadcaster Al Jazeera resigns |
Elite rehab center opens in East Hamptons
Nuclear data feared stolen in hacks of Japanese sites
Aid programme dramatically improves health service
Exclusive: Facebook seeks exec to build Hollywood, media ties |
U.S. calls online poker site a global Ponzi scheme |
Oracle Q1 revenue, EPS slightly ahead of Street view |
Google+ opens up, takes fight to Facebook |
Analysis: AT&T may have to settle for weaker T-Mobile tie-up |
Adobe forecast surprises Wall Street, shares rise |
RIM will struggle to restore credibility: analyst |
Elcoteq's subsidiary files for bankruptcy |
Disney, Cameron to build Avatar theme park |
Record 27.7 million watch Men bury Charlie Sheen |
Jagger's new band, formed on a whim, gets Superheavy |
Exclusive: Facebook seeks exec to build Hollywood, media ties |
Disney, Cameron to re-imagine a theme-park Avatar |
Obama to meet Palestinian leader amid U.N. crisis |
U.S. says Pakistan's ISI using group for proxy war |
African Union recognizes Libya's new rulers |
American Woodcrafters Recalls to Repair Bunk Beds Due To Fall Hazard
Explosion damages Amsterdam court: police |
NBA labor talks set to go on without Hunter, Stern Wednesday
Ravens ink defensive tackle Haloti Ngata to five-year pact
Study predicts sexual recovery after prostate cancer treatment
Illinois Builds $200 Million Wind Farm
Syrian forces kill seven in raids, two police shot |
Windows 8 dev tablets lands on eBay
Secretary Panetta certifies end of DADT policy, calling it “historic”
On peace day, Afghans bury murdered peace broker |
Obama talks with Erdogan, condemns bombing in Turkey |
Bodies of 35 people dumped in Mexican port city |
In bid to revive protests, Yemenis rush to martyrdom |
Insight: China activists challenge power with election push |
Oracle expects strong Q2, firms up tech outlook |
Quanta says Taiwan staff down as client orders fall |
Microsoft boosts dividend 25 percent |
Glam Media to acquire social platform Ning |
Telemar 5-year $1 bln revolving loan could be Latam bellwether |
Actor Tom Sizemore arrested, held briefly in Los Angeles |
Gavin DeGraw feeling Sweeter after attack |
Lawyer denies media report on U.S. men departing Iran |
Vietnam set for more landslides
Pastoralists have their own solutions
Life found in Dead Sea
Tony Bennett apologizes for 9/11 comments
Snipers, shelling raise death toll in Yemen capital |
Troy Davis maintains innocence as execution nears
Gulf voters slouch to the polls
Full Tilt Poker termed "global Ponzi scheme"
Switch hands and eat less
West Hollywood a step closer to being fur free
Google Plus now open to all
Amanda Knox appeals trial enters final stretch |
Supporters of pope's German visit blast boycott |
Egypt's army says emergency law in place till June |
Insight: On welfare reform, French resistance |
U.S. says Pakistani spies using group for proxy war |
HP's board considers ousting CEO: report |
Google spurns Oracle $2.2 billion Android damage claim |
Netflix, Discovery in streaming deal for TV shows |
Apple granted 40 patents in China: report |
Schmidt confident regulators will clear Google |
Exclusive: Facebook seeks exec to build Hollywood, media ties |
Nikon unveils its first mirrorless cameras |
French papers team up to break Apple stranglehold |
Rome film festival to honor Richard Gere |
Disney, Cameron to create theme-park Avatar |
Netflix, Discovery in streaming deal for TV shows |
A Minute With: Bob Weir looking back to Grateful Dead '72 |
Exclusive: Facebook seeks exec to build Hollywood, media ties |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01