">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Critics warn US air strikes bolstering Taliban
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Search
Search:
Critics warn US air strikes bolstering Taliban
AFP - Sunday, May 10
KABUL (AFP) - - Charges that scores of villagers died in US bombings against the Taliban have led to demands for a halt in air strikes amid warnings that civilian casualties are driving Afghans to join the insurgency.
ADVERTISEMENT
But the US and NATO forces taking on the militants say air power is an essential advantage that insurgents are trying to disable by engineering situations in which it harms civilians.
Several investigations are trying to clarify what happened in the western province of Farah nearly a week ago when troops battling Taliban fighters called in the strikes.
President Hamid Karzai says around 130 civilians, including children and the elderly, were killed in the bombings; a local investigation says 147 civilians died, including 94 girls.
The US military concedes only that "a number" of civilians died although it is not yet clear how.
The bombs hit compounds where people had taken refuge from the fighting, Granai village tribal chief Mohammad Na'eem Qader told AFP by telephone.
"At that time there were no Taliban in the village," he said, adding that US President Barack Obama must "stop his military from bombing innocent people or the people will join the Taliban. This is dangerous for him."
Karzai meanwhile demanded an end to air strikes saying they were not an effective way of fighting terrorism but rather cause civilian casualties.
Any military action that harms civilians becomes a recruiting tool for the insurgents, parliamentarian and former army general Noor-Ul Haq Ulumi told AFP.
"The more you kill civilians, the more you've added to the list of your enemies. One house you destroy, one person you kill, you've added 10 to your enemies," said Ulumi, who heads parliament's defence committee.
And in Afghanistan's complicated battleground where insurgents are often among ordinary people, "Using air strikes is like using an artillery shell to kill a fly," he said.
"Would you bombard an American facility if a few Taliban broke into it somehow?" he asked.
Ulumi said the security forces would do better to surround areas where militants were holed up and wait them out. "You don't need to kill women and children only because there are few enemy fighters hiding among them," he said.
The Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission has long called for an expansion of ground forces and a reduction in air strikes for the same reason, commissioner Nader Nadery told AFP.
Civilian casualties win support for the Taliban and play into their propaganda against the government and international forces, he said.
The Farah incident "is likely to be the largest and most tragic loss of life to US bombs so far in Afghanistan," added Human Rights Watch.
"Yet another devastating error inevitably calls into question the continued viability of the use of US and NATO airpower in Afghanistan," said researcher Rachel Reid.
Military procedures in place to stem the civilian toll from air strikes, including verifying intelligence before launching attacks, were not working and must be reviewed, she said.
The United Nations says nearly two-thirds of 828 civilians allegedly killed by pro-government forces in the conflict last year died in air strikes.
Insurgents were however responsible for 55 percent of 2,118 civilian deaths in 2008, the deadliest year since the 2001 US-led invasion ousted the Taliban regime, it says.
And humanitarian groups have warned that a surge of about 21,000 US troops this year will likely see more civilians caught up in the fighting.
The military defends air power as one of the its main technical advantages over the Taliban.
"It gives us speed, manoeuvrability and reach and it is one of the most devastating capabilities against the insurgents," said US military spokesman Colonel Greg Julian.
"That is why they are focusing so much effort on creating civilian casualties in order to attempt to prevent our use of it."
Brigadier General Richard Blanchette, from the NATO-led force, said air power is indispensable in saving Afghan and international troops under attack.
It also provides a "significant advantage" over the Taliban where terrain impedes manoeuvre of troops and supplies or the remoteness of locations hampers the use of ground forces.
However, "The insurgents can produce propaganda that would use the 'fog of war' to pretend that insurgents killed in air strikes were civilians," he said.
In the western city of Herat a villager who had brought three of his wounded children to the burns unit of hospital was bitter.
"We have no government, we have no one to help us," Barakat-Ullah told AFP. "We hate the Americans, I hated them before and I still hate them."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Asia Pacific
Myanmar opposition calls for Suu Kyi medical careAFP - 1 hour 40 minutes ago
Thousands flee as Pakistan lifts Swat curfewAFP - 1 hour 48 minutes ago
Japanese Prince Akishino off on European tourAFP - Sunday, May 10
Japan confirms fourth case of swine fluAP - Sunday, May 10
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific regionAP - Sunday, May 10
Enlarge Photo
Critics warn US air strikes bolstering Taliban
Related Photos
Slideshow Full Photo Coverage: War On Terror
Most Popular – Asia Pacific
Viewed
Obese young men have less hope of marriage: study
British store admits it boobed in bra row
Geithner's warning on speed of economic recovery
Court okays breast removal for transsexual teen: report
Murdoch leads charge to get readers to pay online
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Sunday, 10 May 2009 Gunships and planes strike Pakistan Taliban in Swat
| International
|
U.S. forces shoot Iraqi boy dead after grenade attack
| International
|
Bomb blast kills 5 in southeast Turkey
| International
|
Guinea forces fire on rioters in capital
| International
|
Mali pursues al Qaeda suspects in north: source
| International
|
Bomb kills seven Afghan workers: police
Pakistanis flee Swat as offensive intensifies
| International
|
Critics warn US air strikes bolstering Taliban
Pope to visit site of Jesus' baptism in Jordan
| International
|
Zuma to announce South African cabinet on Sunday
| International
|
U.S. forces shoot Iraqi boy dead after grenade attack
Venezuela oil takeovers may leave 22,000 jobless
Iraqi leader calls for anti-corruption campaign
New flu kills U.S. man, spreads to Australia, Japan
| International
|
After stress tests, banks seek to shed US aid
Bomb blast kills 5 in southeast Turkey
Tycoon to continue Mia Farrow Darfur hunger strike
Pope in Israel seeks closer Jewish-Catholic bond
Argentina's Kirchner to run for Congress
| International
|
$70-80 good price for oil: French economy minister
Pope disappoints Muslim leaders
Fiat boss evokes 'difficult decisions' in Opel takeover
Turkey has no plans to abolish rural militia
Race for Iran presidency hots up
More Severe Weather Expected For Midwest
White House Aide Resigns Over New York Flyover Controversy
US terror suspects subjected to sleep deprivation
Most Santa Barbara Wildfire Evacuees Allowed To Return Home
Snake's Head Found In Side Order Of Veggies At TGI Fridays
Cleanup begins after Midwest storms killed 6
Body Found May Belong To Georgia Professor Wanted For Triple Homicide
Huge fire after Moscow gas pipeline blast
U.S. Air Traffic Control System Vulnerable To Attack, FAA Investigators Say
Cuban parliament president dismisses Obama
Boston Trolley Driver Texting Girlfriend When He Crashed Into Another Trolley
Small plane crashes in northern Nevada, 5 killed
Jury Acquits Mine Owner Of Knowingly Exposing Residents, Workers To Asbestos
Prof wanted in killings found dead in Ga. woods
Texas Couple Arrested For Shooting At Passing Vehicles, Wounding 4 People
NH toddler left alone on school bus for 45 minutes
Afghan President, U.S. Military Differ in Death Count From U.S. Air Strikes
RI gas explosion injures 6 firefighters, 1 officer
Wildfire evacuees longed for home, even the weeds
Cell phone ban may follow Mass. trolley crash
Japanese Prince Akishino off on European tour
Japan confirms fourth case of swine flu
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Swine flu death toll tops 50
From exile, Kadeer steps up Uighur cause
Navy sinks Tiger boats as S. Lanka troops advance
Yao to miss rest of NBA playoffs with broken foot
India's Rahul Gandhi: dynastic political heritage
Badminton Sudirman Cup all about second place
Japan minister defends stimulus spending package
Desperation in Pakistani hospitals, refugee camps
Talks between Diageo, United Spirits still on: report
Bangladesh growth seen at nearly 6 pct
Fido, frequent flier, gets his own airline
Do-it-yourself wine comes to Bordeaux country
Chance for Obama to jab at DC's establishment
Wounded soldier finishes London Marathon
Funny man Fallon a college graduate after 15 years
HBO series details Alzheimer's pain, progress
Indonesian president's party name election winner
Pro-cannabis protesters gather in Amsterdam
Indonesian president's party named election winner
Comedy not just a laughing matter, TV execs discover
Indonesia releases general elections results: report
`Star Trek' boldly goes to $31M at box office
First Asian tour group in post-Saddam Iraq
Sri Lanka, Tamil Tigers trade blame for civilian deaths
| International
|
NATO war games hinder U.S.-Russia ties: Putin
| International
|
South Africa's Zuma moves Manuel to powerful new role
| International
|
Afghan students protest against civilian casualties
| International
|
Australian zoo evacuated after orangutan escape
Russia's Putin warns against arms race over N.Korea
| International
|
Georgia's Saakashvili to meet opposition
| International
|
Clashes kill at least 65 in Somalia in 3 days
| International
|
Philippine typhoon death toll rises to 36
Petraeus: Taliban threaten existence of Pakistan
Obama aide: Seems no one knows bin Laden's status
Jones: Airstrikes remain part of Afghan strategy
Syria criticizes renewal of US sanctions
Google prime target for regulators
Petraeus: al-Qaida not operating in Afghanistan
Upfront costs complicate Obama's health care plan
US-Russia relations hurt by NATO war games: Putin
Iran court hears appeal by jailed US reporter
Chadian troops 'have defeated rebel forces'
Obama the star at reporters' annual dinner
Lawyer defends jailed US reporter at Iran court
Credit crunch dulls glitz of Cannes festival
| Entertainment
|
Police: Boat sinks in Bangladesh
Pakistani civilians flee anti-Taliban offensive
Afghan double suicide attack kills, wounds 20
Sri Lankan doctor: Artillery kills 378 civilians
Afghanistan suicide bombs kill, wound at least 20
Nepal president appeals for majority govt
Philippine typhoon death toll rises to 36
Kuwait, China sign energy and other agreements
Pakistanis flee Swat as fighting escalates
New Zealand house prices weaken further in April
Sri Lanka official: Artillery kills 257 civilians
Russia to sign nuclear pact with Japan: reports
Luxury brands look to China amid global crisis
SKorea to set up resources development fund
Coming soon! Cannes' battle of the movie giants
Did France's 'New Wave' shoot its cinema?
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Credit crunch dulls glitz of Cannes festival
Arab and Jew to sing for peace at Eurovision
East Germany comes alive for kids at Berlin show
VH1, Logo among winners at GLAAD Media Awards
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights