Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Signs point to shift on gays in military
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Analysis: Signs point to shift on gays in military
By ROBERT BURNS,AP National Security Writer -
Thursday, February 4
Send
IM Story
Print
WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama may get his wish to allow gays to serve openly in the military _ not because of his powers of persuasion but because arguments against it have lost traction over time.
A cultural shift since Congress passed a legal ban nearly a generation ago has changed the debate.
For many younger members of the military _ those doing the bulk of the fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq _ it's hardly a debate at all. Polls show they care little about sexual orientation in their ranks.
Views in the wider society have evolved; gay marriage is now legal in five states and the District of Columbia. Opinion surveys say a majority of Americans think it's OK for gays to serve in uniform.
Jason Jonas, a 28-year-old former Army staff sergeant from Tempe, Ariz., said he knew of openly gay soldiers in his intelligence unit at Fort Bragg, N.C., but their lifestyle never affected unit morale.
"I don't think it is anybody's right to say who can and who can't fight for their country," said Jonas, who served in Afghanistan before being injured. He is no longer in the Army. "Nobody cares. Don't ask, don't tell is kind of a joke."
It will not go unnoticed among military members that their most senior uniformed leader, Adm. Mike Mullen, told a Senate panel Tuesday that he personally believes it is time to allow gays to serve openly. It's just wrong, Mullen said, that gays must "lie about who they are" to defend their country.
Although Obama said he would work to change the law this year, Defense Secretary Robert Gates gave him some extra leeway by telling Congress the Pentagon would need at least a year to implement the changes. Gates' comment gave the impression that he thinks repeal is almost inevitable, although a leading Republican voice on defense matters, Sen. John McCain of Arizona, opposes the change.
"I fully support the president's decision," Gates said. "The question before us is not whether the military prepares to make this change, but how we best prepare for it," adding that the final decision rests with Congress.
In the meantime, Gates said he is seeking latitude in how the law is enforced, and there are indications that the military already is honoring the ban mostly in the breach.
According to figures released Monday, the Defense Department last year dismissed the fewest number of service members for violating the policy than it had in more than a decade. The 2009 figure _ 428 _ was sharply lower than the 2008 total of 619.
Overall, more than 10,900 troops have been discharged under the policy.
The list of countries that permit gays to serve openly in uniform has grown to 28, including Canada, Israel, Australia and most of Europe. Many of those nations have troops fighting alongside U.S. soldiers in Afghanistan, and Mullen said in his testimony Tuesday that he has seen no indication that the different policy on gays by the allies in Afghanistan has hurt the war effort.
Yet in the U.S., there remains a powerful rhetorical weapon for opponents of lifting the ban _ fear that it would weaken a military at war.
It's a question that cuts to the heart of why sexual orientation has been such a sensitive topic in the military in the past _ and remains so among those who see repeal of the 1993 ban on allowing gays to serve openly as putting still more stress on a military already under strain from years of conflict.
Mullen said he shares that concern, even as he became the first sitting chairman of the Joint Chiefs to publicly advocate allowing gays to serve openly. He told the Senate Armed Services Committee "there will be some disruption in the force" if the law is changed and it will add to the military's burdens.
"Our plate is very full" already, he said.
Obama entered the White House as an advocate of repealing the ban, but he let it rest for a year. Last week, in his State of the Union address, he vowed to work with Congress this year "to finally repeal the law that denies gay Americans the right to serve the country they love because of who they are."
When President Bill Clinton took office in 1993, he ignited a political firestorm by trying to use his executive powers to end the policy _ not written into law at that point _ of discriminating against gay service members in the military.
Congress stopped him by passing a law that does not explicitly prohibit gays or lesbians from serving but requires them to serve in silence. If they acknowledge their sexual orientation or engage in a homosexual act, they can be expelled.
But if not asked, they need not disclose it and may continue to serve. Thus the "don't ask, don't tell" moniker.
In the 1993 statute is language that supporters of the status quo say justifies limiting the rights of gays to serve. It calls the military a "specialized society" in which life is "fundamentally different from civilian life." And so it is. But the cultural differences are not necessarily as stark as in 1993.
Walter Slocombe, a defense consultant who was a senior policy officer in the Pentagon during most of the Clinton administration, says the current ban is wrong and can be changed without major disruptions.
Most military members "won't care one way or another," he said in an interview, although it should not be overlooked that all branches of the military struggle to some extent with racial, religious and gender tensions.
"That's a result of having a military that reflects the diversity of the country," he said.
___
EDITOR'S NOTE _ Robert Burns has covered national security and military affairs for The Associated Press since 1990.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Iran sends rocket with animal menagerie into space AP - 1 hour 30 minutes ago
SC's Jenny Sanford: E-mails spell end of marriage AP - 1 hour 38 minutes ago
Denver mom to sue school after child's mouth taped AP - 1 hour 41 minutes ago
UK model Katie Price weds cage-fighter boyfriend AP - 1 hour 49 minutes ago
BK probes black's claim of white worker spitting AP - 1 hour 56 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
US debt to hit ceiling by end February: Treasury
Gunslinger reflex helps save lives: UK research
EU backs Greek debt efforts
Content is 'electronic emperor' says Murdoch
Low serotonin linked to infants' sudden cot death: study
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Low serotonin linked to infants' sudden cot death: study
Healthy adults need less sleep as they age: study
Germany decides to buy Swiss tax-dodger data
French court asks did Continental cause Concorde crash
Content is 'electronic emperor' says Murdoch
More Most Viewed »
Scientists praise Obama as Doomsday clock reset
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 3 February 2010 Dictatorship still exists in post-1979 Iran: Mousavi
Russia-Ukraine spy scandal erupts on eve of vote
Obama to meet Dalai Lama despite China warnings
|
Nokia, SAP, G&D start anti-counterfeiting joint venture
Germany to pay $3.5m for Swiss data on tax dodgers
Iran says ready to send enriched uranium abroad
|
Obama to highlight jobs, small business lending
Militants pledge to float more bombs toward Israel
Yemen rebels say open to Saudi prisoner swap
|
Anger as pope condemns Britain's gay-friendly laws
Online gamers set for consolidation wave in 2010
Concorde trial seeks cause of deadly crash
Concorde trial starts in France 10 years after crash
|
Taliban influence growing, US military chief warns
Mexico Senate wants answers about student massacre
|
Clare Short slams Blair argument for Iraq war
Bosnian police raid radical Muslim stronghold
|
Polish PM sees euro convergence plan approved Wednesday
|
Haiti aid operation still has way to go, U.N. says
|
Iraq's Basra to ban beggars to prevent attacks
Hamas leader says Israel prisoner swap at impasse
|
Iran to execute nine protesters 'soon'
US senator asks companies about China rights practices
Nokia, SAP, G&D start anti-counterfeiting joint venture
Obama to meet Dalai Lama despite China warnings
Amazon loss on e-book pricing could fuel trend
|
US warns Japan child custody laws could harm ties
Thai coalition to defy PM in push for constitutional change
Law barring lies about military medals faces test
S.Korea says it won't reward N.Korea for summit
China police boss in dock over mob links
Federal agent says he may have erred in Ohio sting
Feng shui master loses bid for ex-lover's fortune
Motor City freeze: Detroit home encased in ice
Pakistani Taliban: No need to prove leader alive
US militant suspects complain of torture in Pakistan
Punxsutawney Phil's text: Better late than never
U.S. missile strike kills 10 militants in Pakistan
Ford US auto sales jump 24 percent in January
Myanmar may free Suu Kyi during polls: Thailand
Salazar discusses wind farm with Mass. tribes
Top uniformed officer: Gay ban should be lifted
DC Metro police hold anti-terror drill
'Andy Griffith' producer Aaron Ruben dies at 95
Only living American WWI vet turns 109 in W.Va.
China cancels 80% of Iraq debt
Softbank profit soars, buys stake in Ustream
Toyota says global expansion not to blame for recall
Oscar odds and ends and facts and figures
The top 10 singles and albums on iTunes
'The White Ribbon' top contender for foreign Oscar
Former `Boston Legal' actor dies in US crash
'Avatar', 'The Hurt Locker' top Oscar nominations
Review: Nneka delivers passionate CD on society
Lifting gay ban is 'right thing to do': US military chief
Rio residents head to beach at night to escape heat
Ceausescu's son seeks ban on play on ex-Romanian dictator
One in three Taiwanese women want new husbands: poll
Iran says ready to send uranium abroad as UN wants
Number of web addicts in China soars: survey
China warns against Obama-Dalai Lama meeting
|
Content is 'electronic emperor' says Murdoch
Israel must "roll back" and end occupation
Internet Explorer a champ but Chrome a contender
Iran test-fires satellite carrier: report
|
Apple iPad to ignite tablet computer market: ABI
Content is 'emperor of all things electronic': Murdoch
Low serotonin linked to infants' sudden cot death: study
Google tailoring tablet computer software
Bomb kills four foreigners in Pakistan
|
Microsoft's Bing will make money: executive
Biden: Iran leaders sow seeds of own destruction
Iran makes new nuclear offer, U.S. ready to listen
|
Next threat to Amazon's $9.99 books? Rupert Murdoch
Lancet formally retracts 1998 paper linking vaccine and autism
Iran: US missile system to sow Gulf division
Israel launches air strikes in Gaza
|
Study links excessive internet use to depression
Families blame Mexico's Calderon over massacre
|
Google attacks 'wake-up call'
North Koreans starving after currency move: reports
|
Comments getting out of hand, Engadget turns them off
7 injured in blast in northern Australia
Sodomy trial of Malaysia's Anwar set to start
Cyberthieves are hiring, using online ads
|
Christmas bomb suspect "cooperating" with U.S
New Zealand virgin auctions herself for tuition
Nearly a ton of pot seized near U.S.-Mexico border
SWAT team responds to cap gun at Wash. school
Thailand braces for fresh political instability
Next threat to Amazon's $9.99 books? Rupert Murdoch
|
Lifting gay ban 'right thing to do': US military chief
Study links excessive Internet use to depression
|
Police to probe Hong Kong feng shui master's fake will
American convicted of sex abuse
Australia relaxes travel ban for Fijian minister
CO girl killed when school bus collides with car
Report: Top NKorean official fired over inflation
Malaysia's Anwar faces sodomy trial
Pro-Beijing party to boycott Hong Kong elections
Trial begins for Pa. woman who pierced kittens
Texas couple guilty of enslaving Nigerian widow
Sex offender convicted in Wis. triple homicide
Microsoft's Bing will make money: executive
|
Oil, trucking industries sue Calif. over fuel rule
Recovering Asia looks beyond Fed to China
Vietnam bank executive held over bribes: reports
Fitch warns China banks face big 'bubble risk'
China Q1 lending to halve in crackdown on loans: report
Report: Top NKorean official fired over inflation
US chides Toyota over massive recall
Hyundai sales soar in US amid Toyota recall
PAKISTAN
Apple's Wozniak: Toyota may have software trouble
More questions as 'Lost' begins its last season
North Koreans starving after currency move-reports
John Mayer puts on free concert for SC fans
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Brits celebrate Oscar nominations
Songwriter Brooks makes $1.25M bail in NY sex case
Exes, couples among Oscar nominees
Oscar snubs "Avatar's" motion-capture actors
Oscar snubs Avatar's motion-capture actors
|
Correction: Miss America story
Exes, couples among Oscar nominees
|
8.1 mln pounds for Picasso work not seen since 1967
Friends Sidibe, Mulligan among 12 Oscar first-timers
|
"Dear John" -- return to sender
White Ribbon tipped as early Oscar favorite
|
Film studios look to cash in on Oscar nominations
|
An Education set to benefit from Oscar nominations
|
Brits celebrate Oscar nominations
|
Michael Jackson doctor not due to surrender: lawyer
|
Bomb kills 20 in Iraqi Shi'ite city of Kerbala
Britain urges military co-operation with France: report
Cuba's Internet revolution edges forward, with limits
EU backs Greek debt efforts
'At least 17 dead, 116 wounded' in Iraq attack
US-TECH Summary
Iran hails successful satellite launch
Court ordered to rule again on Bashir genocide charge
|
Iraqi police: 20 killed in Karbala blast
Iran says launches satellite rocket
Hamas gives U.N. response to Gaza war crimes report
|
Iran sends rocket with animal menagerie into space
Housing Haiti's homeless sparks debate as rains loom
|
Afghan leader cancels meeting with top Muslim body
|
Bomb kills 20 in Iraqi Shi'ite city of Kerbala
|
Student denies charges as Iran protest trial resumes
|
Obama plan worries cities that rely on space jobs
Obama to meet governors at White House
Ex-POW in Iraq war recalls nightmares, depression
Chinese language tutor sought for US-born panda
Obama responds to ire over 2nd anti-Vegas remark
Sanctions stay until N.Korea resumes nuclear talks: US
Analysis: Signs point to shift on gays in military
China seeks language tutor for US-born panda
Hope returns after year of steep US dairy losses
AOL posts profit, but subscribers dwindle
|
Australian official urges balance in India reports
Comcast profit up on Internet, phone subscribers
|
Friend charged with hiding Fla. lotto winner death
Vote chief rejects Sri Lanka rigging charges
Space rock worth thousands stirs ownership debate
Creator of Australia's 'Skippy' dies
SPIN METER: Pols cool to public-financed campaigns
Reports: Top NKorean official fired over inflation
North Koreans starving after currency move
Conn. mom, triplets die after their births at home
Malaysia's Anwar pleads not guilty to sodomy
Philippine massacre victims seek relief from ASEAN
Taiwan's UMC posts $137mln profit
Cambodian PM names 3 likely listings on new bourse
Japan's Mitsubishi UFJ posts nine-month profit
Pakistani o/n rates, rupee flat; stocks up
India service sector major growth: survey
Honda profit soars as cost cuts offset lower sales
Asia plane orders could top trillion dollars
Two Koreas set to discuss tourism projects
Sharp posts $100 million profit on cost cuts
Sharp narrows losses but market remains bleak
Studio rolling out "Harry Potter," "Titans" in 3D
Murdoch says Fox, Conan have had "conversations"
Worst movies of all time led by Clooney's Batman
|
"Entourage" star zooms in on "Teenage Paparazzo"
Avatar, Hurt Locker square off at Oscars
|
Historic German studio celebrates record Oscar run
|
Model Katie Price marries again
|
Pakistan eunuchs face life full of struggles
Frontier Gandhi brings Pashtun peace icon to life
|
Jackie Collins begins "Girl" whirl
"An Education" set to benefit from Oscar nominations
Soldiers march to a different beat in Afghan war
Studio rolling out Harry Potter, Titans in 3D
|
Murdoch says Fox, Conan have had conversations
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights