">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
`Hillary: The Movie,' now showing at Supreme Court
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
`Hillary: The Movie,' now showing at Supreme Court
By JESSE J. HOLLAND,Associated Press Writer AP - Monday, March 23
WASHINGTON - Months after its debut, "Hillary: The Movie" faces nine of the nation's toughest critics: the Supreme Court.
ADVERTISEMENT
The justices' review of the slashing documentary financed by longtime critics of Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton could bring more than just a thumbs up or thumbs down. It may settle the question of whether the government can regulate a politically charged film as a campaign ad.
David Bossie, a former Republican congressional aide who produced the Clinton movie and another describing then-Sen. Barack Obama as an overhyped media darling, said his films are about important moments in American politics.
"The outcome of this case will dictate how we're able to make films and educate people about them," he said.
At issue in the case being argued before justices Tuesday is the 90-minute anti-Clinton movie and television ads Bossie wanted to air during the 2008 primaries advertising the film.
Bossie's group, the conservative Citizens United, released the movie as Clinton, then a New York senator, was competing with Obama for the Democratic presidential nomination.
The movie is unquestionably anti-Clinton, featuring commentary from conservative pundits, some of whom specifically say Clinton was not fit to be commander in chief.
One scene, which was used in an ad, has Dick Morris, a former adviser to President Bill Clinton who is now a critic of the Clintons, saying the senator is "the closest thing we have in America to a European socialist."
The movie was shown in eight theaters. Bossie's group wanted to run ads on television in key election states during peak primary season and show the movie on cable television's video-on-demand.
Federal courts said the ads would violate the McCain-Feingold law, the popular name for 2002 revisions to the nation's campaign finance laws. Judges called "Hillary: The Movie" a 90-minute attack ad, rulings that would require Citizens United to identify the financial backers for the ads if they were to appear on television.
The court also said that if Bossie's group showed the movie on cable television, financial backers would have to be named and the group would have to pay the cost of airing the movie.
Citizens United appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that "Hillary: The Movie" should not be considered a political ad. The group says there is nothing in the movie urging people to vote against Clinton. The group says the film is more of a documentary comparable to critical television news programs such as "Frontline," "Nova" and "60 Minutes."
"The fact that 'Hillary' presents a critical assessment of Sen. Clinton's political background, character, and fitness for office does not convert the movie ... into an appeal to vote against Sen. Clinton," said Theodore Olson, Citizens United's lawyer.
"Indeed, a critical exposition of the political background and policy views of a former first lady and sitting U.S. senator is precisely the type of uninhibited, robust, and wide open debate and discussion that the First Amendment protects and encourages," Olson argues.
A panel of federal judges disagreed, calling "Hillary" nothing but an extended-length political attack ad. The Justice Department agreed, saying "'Hillary' is a 90-minute advocacy piece whose unmistakable meaning is that Hillary Clinton should not be elected president.
Some question whether that declaration strays too close to regulation of journalists, who generally have been exempt from campaign finance rules.
Without passing judgment on the content of "Hillary," the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press filed a brief supporting Citizens United, telling the Supreme Court that the media has been critical of presidential candidates since George Washington.
"By criminalizing the distribution of a long-form documentary film, as if it was nothing more than a very long advertisement, the district court has created uncertainty about where the line between traditional news commentary and felonious advocacy lies," the group said.
If the decision is upheld, "I can certainly see journalists running afoul of this law in the future," lawyer Lucy Dalglish said.
This isn't the first time documentary filmmakers have been questioned in relation to campaign finance laws. Citizens United in 2004 sought to keep filmmaker Michael Moore from advertising "Fahrenheit 9/11" _ which was critical of President George W. Bush _ in the run-up to the presidential election.
The Federal Election Commission, charged with enforcing the McCain-Feingold law, dismissed the complaint after Moore said he had no plans to run the ads during election season.
Bossie said Moore's success is what inspired him. "Michael Moore forced me to recognize the power of documentary film," said Bossie, who was involved in the House's investigation of Bill Clinton that led to the president's impeachment and trial.
So regardless of what the Supreme Court decides, expect to see more politically charged movies from Citizens United.
Soon after Obama secured the nomination, Bossie's organization came out with "Obama: The Hype Effect" and ran into the same legal problems with the Federal Election Commission. That didn't stop the group from having free DVDs inserted into The Columbus Dispatch, The Cincinnati Enquirer, The (Cleveland) Plain Dealer, The Palm Beach (Fla.) Post and the Las Vegas Review-Journal.
Bossie expects to produce at least 15 movies at his Washington-area studio by the next presidential election in 2012. Among them, he says, will be "Stimulate This," an indictment of the recently enacted economic stimulus package.
The case is Citizens United v. FEC, 08-205.
___
On the Net:
Citizens United: http://www.citizensunited.org
Hillary: The Movie: http://www.hillarythemovie.com
Federal Election Commission: http://www.fec.gov
Background on the case: http://tinyurl.com/cfltxp
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle
Jackie Chan lends star power to hometown festivalAP - 2 hours 57 minutes ago
Natasha Richardson to be buried near upstate homeAP - Monday, March 23
British reality TV star Jade Goody deadAFP - Monday, March 23
`Hillary: The Movie,' now showing at Supreme CourtAP - Monday, March 23
British reality TV star Jade Goody dies of cancerReuters - Monday, March 23
Most Popular – Entertainment
Viewed
Prince Charles blue over green crusade
Madoff loses bail appeal as victims' rage revealed
Opel boss hints at closing German plants
Obama budget deficit could hit 1.845 trln dlrs
Arrest warrant issued for Lindsay Lohan
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Sunday, 22 March 2009 Armed clashes kill 21 in Russia's Dagestan
| International
|
Israel breaks up Arab capital events in Jerusalem
| International
|
Obama's Afghan task 'tougher' than Iraq
Protesters march by Pentagon, call to end Iraq war
For tourists, seeing Iraq one checkpoint at a time
Israel marks soldier's 1,000th day in captivity
Obama defends Geithner, budget
U.S. hands almost all Sunni guards to Iraqi control
Prince Charles blue over green crusade
Chavez trims budget, adds debt to counter crisis
| International
|
Afghans mark New Year amid bloodshed
Opel boss hints at closing German plants
11 dead as blasts mar Afghan New Year
Prince Charles blue over green crusade
2 US Navy vessels that collided arrives Bahrain
Canadian kidnapped in Darfur back home
Suspected drug cartel hitman arrested in Mexico
Danish premier hot tip for new NATO chief
Slovak presidential election goes to second round
Thousands march against mafia in Naples
Germany in mourning for victims of school massacre
EU rebuff Russian calls for new security structure
Harrison Ford proposes to girlfriend: report
| Entertainment
|
Province supplying Beijing water drying up: state
Mugabe's wife beats assault charges in Hong Kong
Depeche Mode prepares for Tour of the Universe
| Entertainment
|
Philippines, Red Cross clash over hostage release
Fire guts residence of former Japan PM Yoshida
Thai PM rules out cabinet shake-up
Pakistan's top judge back at work after protests
Harrison Ford proposes to girlfriend: report
Pakistan's chief justice reinstated
Tribune sues Warren Beatty over Dick Tracy rights
China quake school toll stirs grim findings and anger
Report: Nissan planning luxury hybrid in 2010
Fire destroys former Japan prime minister's home
'Modest' Japanese CEOs escape public ire
Malaysia's next PM calls for 'massive' change
1 million unemployed expected in Thailand
China sees stimulus package bringing growth
China horseman eyes Bejing to London ride
Minister: Japan needs aggressive public spending
Germany: no sex please we're in recession
SKorea, EU eye conclusion of free trade talks
Harrison Ford proposes to girlfriend: report
China wants to restructure auto industry
Couture's well-kept secret
Berkeley students dominate college TV awards
Nominees for the third Asian Film Awards
Korean Western top contender at Asian Film Awards
British singer Natasha Bedingfield weds in Malibu
Desperate tent city revival for America's homeless
Rachael Ray hosts SXSW party, Hold Steady headline
Turkey could block Rasmussen at NATO
Netanyahu seeks to reassure Egypt over FM pick
Sudan scholars tell president to drop Qatar trip
Lethal air pollution booms in emerging nations
Wife of founder of Iran's Islamic republic dies
Iran sets terms for U.S. ties
| International
|
Military hangs `Help Wanted' sign in Afghanistan
Pakistan's deposed judge resumes office
| International
|
Hamas leader welcomes Obama's "new language"
U.S. military, Afghan police dispute deaths in raid
| International
|
Poland hopes U.S. will not let it down on shield
| International
|
Hamas leader welcomes Obama's new language: report
| International
|
Chinese detain Tibetan monks after riot
| International
|
Pope, in Angola, recalls youths killed in stampede
| International
|
Israel says car bomb defused at shopping mall
| International
|
Sudan scholars tell president to drop Qatar trip
| International
|
Wen urges innovation to fight crisis: state media
'Tug-of-love' pair not in Russia: diplomat
Slovakia's president poll heads for second round
China arrests Tibetan monks after attack on police
British reality TV star Jade Goody dies of cancer
| Entertainment
|
Tibetan monks held after China police attacked
Chinese detain Tibetan monks after riot
Bomb near Philippine market injures at least 7
Iraqi PM says shoe-thrower had fair trial
Bikers brawl through Australian airport; 1 dead
Pakistan's deposed judge resumes office
India's Tata Motors to launch ultra-cheap Nano car
Pakistan reinstates chief justice
Jackie Chan lends star power to hometown festival
Man killed as bikers brawl in Australian airport
Natasha Richardson to be buried near upstate home
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
British reality TV star Jade Goody dead
South By Kanye West? Rapper plays SXSW
Reality TV star Jade Goody dies after cancer fight
`Hillary: The Movie,' now showing at Supreme Court
British reality TV star Jade Goody dies of cancer
Can't decide which handbag to buy? Rent it first
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights