Home
U.S.
World
Entertainment
Sports
Business
Health
Science
Technology
Politics
Offbeat
Environment
Travel
News
Articles
Senate Panel Approves Climate Change Bill Despite GOP Boycott
November 5, 2009 1:46 p.m. EST
Kris Alingod - AHN Contributor
Washington, D.C. (AHN) - The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee reported out a climate change bill on Thursday despite a boycott by Republican members, who had required a complete analysis of the measure before participating in the committee debate.
The bill crafted by Chair Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) passed by a vote of 11-1, with none of the seven Republicans in the committee voting.
The sole lawmaker who cast a "nay" was Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT), a moderate Democrat who wants a lower carbon reduction target that can gain enough votes on the full Senate floor.
The Kerry-Boxer bill aims for a 20 percent reduction of carbon pollution by 2020 from 2005 levels, and 80 percent by 2050. The reductions will be done through a cap-and-trade system that will allow companies to buy and sell vouchers according to whether they want to pay for the right to keep polluting or gain the incentive for reducing emissions.
The top Republican in the committee, Sen. James Inhofe (R-OK), had repeatedly made clear that action on the measure should only be continued after minority members had received a full economic analysis from the Environmental Protection Agency. He expressed "deep disappointment" with the panel's passage of the bill, accusing Boxer of "violat[ing] the rules and longstanding precedent of the committee."
"The Republicans offered a clear path forward to a bipartisan markup, but it was summarily rejected by Chairman Boxer," Inhofe, who believes global warming is a hoax and who was chairman of the Environment panel under the Bush administration, said in a statement.
"[Boxer] decided to ignore the entreaties of all 6 ranking members from Senate committees with some share of jurisdiction over climate change legislation, as well as leading moderates in the Senate. Her action signals the death knell for the Kerry Boxer bill," he added.
Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN), who unlike Inhofe believes in global warming, also said, "Republicans want and expect to participate in any bill about clean energy but.. the American people need to know what this legislation will cost them in utility bills, jobs, their taxpayer dollars, gas prices and how much it will actually help the environment."
Boxer said the vote was "in full accordance with longstanding Committee and Senate Rules."
An EPA analysis, she explained, would be "duplicative and a waste of taxpayer dollars because the environment agency had said "their economic analysis was 'unprecedented' in scope and was never done for any other energy or climate bill at this stage of the process. "
"The absence of the Republicans during the EPA's presentation was a clear message that their criticism of the EPA analysis was not a substantive one," Boxer added, referring to the EPA briefing boycotted by minority members on Tuesday.
The agency has issued a 38-page discussion paper on the bill and an analysis of a similar measure in the House, dubbed the Waxman-Markey climate change bill. But Republicans had sought a complete study with modeling runs.
"I want to be very clear about what the Republicans want: we want a markup of this bill," Inhofe had said in an emphatic statement during Wednesday's committee hearing. "Madam Chairman, choosing the other course would be unwise... You and I have a lot of work to do: the highway bill and many others. We can't render the Committee irrelevant."
The Kerry-Boxer bill has the support of Exelon Corporation, the nation's largest electric and gas utility, but is opposed by Republicans and the American Farm Bureau Federation, both of which warn that a cap-and-trade program would raise energy costs.
Exelon Chairman and CEO John Rowe testified before the committee last week, "Without prompt action, the utility industry will be caught in a carbon purgatory: we will lack the certainty we need to make the large-scale investments in clean generation that are necessary to both keep the lights on and meet the challenges associated with climate change."
"We firmly believe that cap-and-trade legislation can accomplish our national environmental objectives while ensuring robust economic growth," Rowe added. "To moderate price increases to consumers, Exelon supports the free allocation of 40 percent of emissions allowances to local delivery companies, which will sell the allowances and use the proceeds to mitigate costs for customers. To be abundantly clear, neither Exelon nor its shareholders will profit from the allowances to local delivery companies."
The same day, however, American Farm Bureau Federation President Bob Stallman told the committee, "Families will be hit hard with higher energy costs under any cap-and-trade program, an amount that could total up to $200 billion a year for American taxpayers. That will put enormous strain on family budgets."
"Agriculture and forestry can play a key role in any future national energy policy," added Stallman. "But [the bill] fails to recognize this role and would in fact penalize the very sectors that have the best opportunity to reduce greenhouse emissions in the most cost-effective manner for all."
The cap-and trade system of the Kerry-Boxer bill exempts all farmers and 98 percent of businesses, covering only the largest emitters in the nation which initially will be about 7,500 facilities that account for three?quarters of nationwide carbon pollution.
The Waxman-Markey bill, on the other hand, requires most companies to buy carbon permits from the federal government.
It seeks to reduce emissions by 17 percent in 2020, by 42 percent in 2030, and by 83 percent in 2050.The measure was passed by the House Energy and Commerce Committee in May by a vote of 33-25. The full House approved the measure a month later by a narrow 219-212 vote.
The National Farmers Union supports the Waxman-Markey bill, but only after the Agriculture Department, and not the EPA, was made overseer of an offset program providing credits to farmers who use environmentally-sound practices. The bill already has the backing of BP America, Caterpillar, Conoco, Johnson & Johnson, Shell, Siemens, the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Sierra Club.
Senate Republicans have been pushing an alternative proposal that aims to build 100 nuclear power plants over two decades, electrifies half of all vehicles over the same period, and uses oil found off-shore for the remaining energy needs of the nation.
Boxer has included provisions on nuclear energy in her bill, but the GOP has said a cap-and-trade measure with or without nuclear power is still an energy tax.
Copyright © 2003 - 2009 AHN - All rights reserved.Redistribution, republication. syndication, rewriting or broadcast is prohibited without the prior written consent of AHN.License AHN news for your website, business, digital signage network or publication.
Recent Posts
Most Popular Comments
Recent Comments
Popular Threads
Home | U.S. | World | Entertainment | Sports | Business | Health | Sci / Tech | Politics | Weird / Offbeat
Follow AHN on Twitter
AHN Social News connects you with friends and the news
Client Login | Submit News | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | Content Services © 2009 AHN All Rights Reserved
Other News on Friday, 6 November 2009 Iran detains journalist for French news agency
Mont Blanc shrinks by foot-and-a-half
Microsoft raises cloud computing concerns
Abbas offers to quit over stalled peace process
| International
|
WHO urges people to maintain guard over swine flu
France's Kouchner slams US, Germany and Karzai
IAEA found nothing serious at Iran site: ElBaradei
| International
|
Bank of England pumps billions more into economy
Abbas says he will not seek re-election: PLO
Microsoft CEO sees Yahoo partnership outside U.S.
Walmart.com offers top 10 pre-order DVD movie titles at $10
Cocaine's charge through Europe undiminished: report
Israel accuses Iran of war crime over arms ship
Israel urges action against Iran over weapons ship
Saudi air force hits Yemen rebels after border raid
Hurricane Ida pummels Nicaragua east coast
| International
|
Iraq MPs to vote electoral law: panel chief
Regional summit seeks to end Zimbabwe crisis
| International
|
Who built Berlin Wall? Most Russians don't know
| International
|
Karadzic counsel appointed, trial to resume in 2010
| International
|
Somalis hijack grain ship, take Spaniards hostage
| International
|
Ohio woman: I got away from serial killing suspect
Senate blocks census citizenship question
Beatles remasters heading to USB
| Technology
|
Chinese activist risks jail with letter to Obama
FBI: Arrest made in slaying of New Mexico nun
Best Buy to install Google mobile applications
| Technology
|
October sales offer relief to merchants
Ericsson sees Nortel deal closing very soon
| Technology
|
China air force much improved though still lagging
India restricts coverage of Dalai Lama's trip
Iraqi held in Ariz. honor killing on suicide watch
Intel hit by NY antitrust suit, kickbacks alleged
| Technology
|
Former NYC Police Commissioner Kerik pleads guilty
Foreign buyers hate fakes unless they're shopping
Seniors' lobby endorses House Dem health care bill
'You hit a what?' SUV nearly slams into elephant
Senate Democrats advance climate bill without GOP
German Red Cross worker shot in Indonesia's Aceh
Congress set to expand homebuyer tax credit
Thailand, Cambodia pull envoys in Thaksin row
Taiwan hit by 6.0-magnitude quake: govt
Toyota surprises with profit, boosts forecast
Ailing JAL suspends 16 more routes
Indian food inflation jumps to 13 pct
NZ Q3 investor confidence near 2-year high-survey
Pakistan's forex reserves ease to $14.23 bln
Rihanna embarrassed she fell for man like Brown
| Entertainment
|
Killers slay audiences with live show experience
Cheap Christmas cheer as champagne bubble bursts
A Minute With: Michael Fassbender and his Fish Tank
| Entertainment
|
'My voice is back', sings tenor Villazon
Awash in notes? Piano drowns in Andsnes concert
| Entertainment
|
Comedian Mo'Nique gets serious in 'Precious'
Malawi threatens arrests over Madonna school row
Art under the big top: The roving Pompidou
Outrage over wall blocking free U2 Berlin concert
Cesaria Evora to begin comeback concerts in Paris
Story told of contradictory Civil War general
Maine's Farnsworth Art Museum hires new director
Two charged over murders of Russian lawyer, reporter
UN calls for probes of alleged Gaza war crimes
Droid joins 'Google phone' army in smart phone war
Judge orders US music website to drop Beatles songs
Angry words as timetable for climate deal slips
Gunmen wound two army men in Pakistani capital
| International
|
Pirates take crew of Spanish trawler to Somalia: minister
Google lets users see stored account data
Israel rejects U.N. assembly vote on Gaza war
Israel complains to U.N. over alleged Hezbollah arms
Zelaya says pact to end Honduran crisis has failed
| International
|
Wall St swine flu vaccinations spark uproar
New pathway for DNA damage from nano-particles: study
Student stuns Iran by criticizing supreme leader
FCC approves AT&T's bid for Centennial: sources
Israel rejects U.N. assembly vote on Gaza war
| International
|
Abbas rules out re-election, complicating peace efforts
ElBaradei won't rule out run for Egypt presidency
US-TECH Summary
China adopts malaria diplomacy as part of Africa push
| International
|
Israel complains to U.N. over alleged Hezbollah arms
| International
|
Verizon to sell HTC Android phone for $99.99
EU agrees on Internet, telecoms user rights
Abbas offers to quit over stalled peace process
ECB, BoE hold interest rates at record lows
Forgotten land could decide Turkey-Armenia peace
| International
|
Ericsson sees Nortel deal closing "very soon"
Best Buy to install Google mobile applications
Rage against GM over 10,000 planned job cuts at Opel
Saudi strikes to continue until Yemen rebels ejected
| International
|
AFP reporter may be freed at weekend-Iran official
Depression Ida dumps heavy rain on Nicaragua
| International
|
Beatles remasters heading to USB
Microsoft CEO sees Yahoo partnership outside U.S.
Iraq lawmakers can't agree on election law _ again
Droid joins 'Google phone' army in smart phone war
Abbas says will not seek re-election
Gunmen wound two army men in Pakistani capital
SKorean woman passes driver's exam on 950th try
Global Weather-Celsius
U.S. regulators mull changes to phone access rules
| Technology
|
California county settles again in squad car case
Intel in talks with India's ITI for joint venture: report
| Technology
|
Ferry accident in southern China kills 2 Dutch
Verizon to sell HTC Android phone for $99.99
| Technology
|
Myanmar vote plan clouds new US dialogue
Thieves steal truck with H1N1 vaccine in Milwaukee
Calle 13 wins 4 Latin Grammys in Las Vegas
APEC to maintain stimulus till recovery in place: draft
China PM heads to Egypt for Africa summit
Indian Sikhs defy advice to pray in Pakistan
Cousin of shooting suspect says family is shocked
Guitar Hero brings higher revenue for Activision
| Technology
|
China adopts "malaria diplomacy" as part of Africa push
Truck crash kills 19 in northern China
Van stolen 35 years ago in Wash. state recovered
Denver immigrant asylum center latest to close
Obama, House Dems press for health care votes
Obama delays Capitol Hill pitch on health care
Cheney urges strong U.S. commitment to Afghan war
Cougars, hot in Hollywood, endangered in real life
Malaysia says Airbus A400M delivery to be delayed
POSCO starts work on steel plant in Turkey
South Korea OK's India free trade agreement
US says SKorea trade deal 'within reach'
USTR Kirk says S.Korean trade pact needs new auto deal
China's growing thirst for African oil
Seoul shares up on foreign buying;Hyundai Mobis gains
Golden Girls star McClanahan has heart surgery
| Entertainment
|
Muhammad Ali's former brand maker takes on opera
| Entertainment
|
Carrie Underwood on track to top U.S. pop chart
| Entertainment
|
S.Korean bonds steady early despite firmer stocks
Winners at the 10th Annual Latin Grammy Awards
S.Korea mulls $7 bln injection into KIC in 2010
Judge orders US music website to drop Beatles songs
No decision yet on Oprah Winfrey move to cable
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares higher on Hyundai Mobis, brokerages
Calle 13 wins 5 Latin Grammys in Las Vegas
Morgan Freeman settles lawsuit over crash
| Entertainment
|
Florida grapples slippery giant snake invasion
Christmas Carol brings early cheer to box office
| Entertainment
|
Hal Holbrook shines in "Evening Sun"
Carrie Underwood on track to top U.S. pop chart
U2 warms up Berlin for Wall anniversary
Bette Midler to end Las Vegas shows in January
| Entertainment
|
U2, Beyonce draw fans for MTV's Berlin show
Study Finds Internet, Computer Use Helps Keeps Elderly Mental Acuity Elevated
Winners of the 16th annual MTV Europe Music Awards
Search For Missing Florida Baby Ends Underneath Sitter's Bed, Child Found Unharmed
Tyson Found Guilty Of Labor Law Violations In Alabama
Winfrey takes gospel singer Winans off her show
Update: Fort Hood Shooting Death Toll Rises To 12, Obama Condemns Rampage
Dow Surges Past 10,000 On Jobless, Production News
Gunfire Kills 9, Injures 20 In Fort Hood
President Obama Says U.S. Help For Bangladesh To Continue
Senate Panel Approves Climate Change Bill Despite GOP Boycott
FBI Arrests Suspect In Brutal Slaying Of New Mexico Nun
Miami Coast Guard Cutter Seizes Five Tons Of Cocaine During October
Algal Foam Kills 10,000 Seabirds Off Washington State Peninsula
Windows 7 debut a hit: NPD
"Guitar Hero" brings higher revenue for Activision
Search For Missing Florida Baby Ends Underneath Sitter's Bed, Child Found Unharmed
Worlds First Arabic Speaking Robot Constructed in UAE
Auditor General Says Ottawa Has No Emergency Response Plan
Miami Coast Guard Cutter Seizes Five Tons Of Cocaine During October
Woman Finds Croaker In Bag Of Greens
Iowa Cat Catches Swine Flu
South Carolina Man Pleads Guilty To Having Sex With Horse
Mozambique Migrant Wins Courtcase Against Western Canada Lottery Corporation
Judge In Gotti Case Offers Jurors Licorice
Israel keen on Abbas staying in office: reports
British Airways to cut extra 1,200 jobs amid losses
New 'smart' electrical meters raise privacy issues
No takers for Abbas' Palestinian presidency
| International
|
Intel in talks with India's ITI for jv: report
Iraqi kidnappings unabated even as violence eases
RBS reports sharp loss, expects slow recovery
Zimbabwe proposes local ownership of foreign firms
| International
|
Israel rejects UN vote approving Gaza report
Royal Bank of Scotland reports sharp loss
14 charged in Wall St insider trading probe
Taliban turns screws on UN in Afghanistan
Bangladesh police say Islamists target U.S. interests
| International
|
Defusing poor man's minefield in Afghan south
| International
|
Serbia charges six for 1992 killings in Bosnia
| International
|
Internet censorship seen liable to WTO challenge
| Technology
|
Pakistani army enters final militant stronghold
Former NY Police Commissioner Bernard Kerik Pleads Guilty To Corruption
Pa. locals, Flight 93 families united by history
'Yakuza' gunman in Japan wounds three, kills himself
Investigators Raid Home Of Alleged Gunman In Ft Hood Shooting Rampage
Update: Fort Hood Shooter Alive; Declared Sole Gunman In Rampage
APEC seeks to slash emissions by 2050
Gunman alive after killing 13 at Texas army base
Japan PM says no US base deal before Obama visit
Obama to sign extension of jobless benefits
Ida Downgrades To Tropical Depression As It Sweeps Across Nicaragua Dumping Heavy Rainfall, Nearing Honduras Border
States with jobless rates of 8.5 percent and above
Obama Signs Unemployment Insurance Extension, Home Buyer Credit Friday
Third gun attack on brigadier in Pakistan capital
Ft. Hood suspect reportedly shouted `Allahu Akbar'
Twin gang leaders sentenced to 17 years in China
Obama to sign homebuyer, jobless bill assistance
Medical marijuana shops abound in California
Villagers flee war zone as India battles Maoists
Remote Indian state readies for Dalai Lama visit
Mafia twins jailed for 17 years in China
Philippines to buy rice from Vietnam, SKorea
Uzbek state energy firm seals $2.5B plant deal
Asia boosts Hermes luxury sales: company
Korea Life may raise around $2 bln in IPO-sources
MARKETS-KOREA-STOCKS/ (UPDATE 2)=2
Hollywood calls on Clooney for holiday movie cheer
| Entertainment
|
South Korea says mortgage loan growth slows in Oct
Elton John on mend, resuming tour dates
Britney Spears in Australian lip synch furore
China blasts US steel pipe duties as protectionist
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
S.Korea spotted buying dlrs to check won's rise -dealers
Prius top-selling car in Japan for sixth month
In Berlin, music fans build a new history
In Berlin, music fans build a new history
| Entertainment
|
Gay rights a tall order in ex-communist bloc
South Africa tries to enlist men in AIDS battle
Mercury winners Elbow back in the studio
Caesar rises: 20 years of water digs on display
Kashmiri saffron industry withers
Red Cross suspends work in Indonesia's Aceh
Indonesia extends Australia refugee boat's stay
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights