Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Med, nursing schools teaching alternative remedies
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Med, nursing schools teaching alternative remedies
By MARILYNN MARCHIONE,AP Medical Writer -
Monday, November 2
Send
IM Story
Print
EDITOR'S NOTE: Ten years and $2.5 billion in research have found no cures from alternative medicine. Yet these mostly unproven treatments are now mainstream and used by more than a third of all Americans. This is one in an occasional Associated Press series on their use and potential risks.
___
Future doctors and nurses are learning about acupuncture and herbs along with anatomy and physiology at a growing number of medical schools. It's another example of how alternative medicine has become mainstream. And it's often done with Uncle Sam's help.
The government has spent more than $22 million to help medical and nursing schools start teaching about alternative medicine _ lesson plans that some critics say are biased toward unproven remedies.
Additional tax money has been spent to recruit and train young doctors to do research in this field, launching some into careers as alternative medicine providers.
Doctors need to know about popular remedies so they can discuss them nonjudgmentally and give competent advice, the government says, and many universities and medical groups agree.
"Patients are using these things" whether doctors think they should or should not, and safety is a big concern, said Dr. Victor Sierpina, an acupuncturist at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston who heads a group of academics who favor such training.
But to critics, it's like teaching Harry Potter medicine. Students are being asked to close their eyes to science principles that guide the rest of their training in order to keep an open mind about pseudoscience, they say.
"I'm concerned about the teaching of illogical thinking to medical students" and lending credence to biologically implausible theories like distance healing and energy fields, said Dr. Stephen Barrett, a retired physician who runs Quackwatch, a Web site on medical scams.
Teaching about alternative medicine implies acceptance of it and "potentially creates more gullibility and less critical, objective thinking," said Dr. Wallace Sampson, editor of the journal Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine. "This will be felt in many indirect ways," he said, including judgment errors, misguiding people with severe diseases, and lax standards and laws.
The real issue is not whether alternative medicine should be taught, but how, said Dr. Joseph Jacobs, former head of the federal Office of Alternative Medicine.
"The parallel here is creationism versus science," Jacobs said. "If the topic is taught objectively, to help students communicate with patients, it's a good idea. If it's being taught as part of an advocacy, for acceptance among physicians, I think that's a little bit bogus."
Sometimes the line is blurry.
Some schools have close ties to alternative medicine providers or advocates who shape information on the schools' Web sites or classes for students and the public. Two examples:
_The University of Arizona's Center for Integrative Medicine has medical residency programs in hospitals around the country, partly sponsored by well-known advocate Dr. Andrew Weil, the center's founder. A private group that promotes such care, the Bravewell Collaborative, gives scholarships for dozens of the Arizona school's students to get hands-on training in integrative care clinics.
_The University of Minnesota offers medical students an elective course in alternative healing methods at a Hawaiian medical center founded by a philanthropist-advocate of such care, although students pay their own transportation and living expenses. In interviews with an Associated Press writer in 2007, several students raved about things they had tried firsthand, and said they returned more willing to recommend acupuncture, meditation, yoga, herbal remedies and other nontraditional care.
"Consumers are demanding it" and more research is needed to see what works, said Mary Jo Kreitzer, who directs the Minnesota school's alternative medicine curriculum. "Ultimately we need to align policy" so that insurers pay for these therapies, she said. "You could say that in that respect, we are advocates."
The field got a boost 10 years ago, with creation of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. It made merging alternative and mainstream medicine "a central and overarching goal" and gave $22.5 million to 12 medical schools, two nursing schools and the American Medical Student Association to develop curriculum plans.
Kreitzer's and Sierpina's universities got grants, and both are active in the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine _ 42 centers involved in researching or advocating for complementary and alternative medicine, or CAM.
However, a review of some of those teaching plans by Drs. Donald Marcus and Laurence McCullough of Baylor College of Medicine in Houston concludes that they are "strongly biased in favor of CAM," cite poor-quality research, and were not updated after better studies revealed a therapy did not work. The review is in the September issue of the journal Academic Medicine.
The section on herbals in the Medical Student Association's plan was written by the head of the American Botanical Council, an industry-supported research and education group, the article says.
Sierpina, the head of the medical school consortium, said the purpose of these lesson plans is not propaganda.
"We are not trying to make students CAM practitioners," but to train them to be "sensitive to where people come from, their folk medicine, their home remedies," he said.
Just as there are true believers who ignore evidence that something doesn't work, there are true doubters who are guilty of "arrogant thinking that we've got it all figured out," Sierpina said.
Dr. Mehmet Oz agreed. The Columbia University heart surgeon and frequent Oprah Winfrey guest, now with his own TV show, has long shown an open mind toward complementary and alternative medicine.
"Medicine is very provincial. We grow up thinking the way others have taught us to think. We are naturally biased. It is imperative that we look at what alternative cultures offer us, that we at least are fair in our skepticism of their impact." Otherwise, "we run a risk of locking out newcomers" with fresh ideas, he said.
That would be people like Jimmy Wu, a newly graduated doctor from the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Raised in a family originally from Taiwan, Wu said traditional healing practices are "very much ingrained" in how he thinks about sickness and health.
"It's just a very different way of observing" a patient to decide on treatments, rather than relying so heavily on lab tests and other traditional medical tools, he said.
The Madison medical school offered an optional course in alternative medicine. Seeking more than that, Wu spent a summer in Beijing with a university faculty member observing traditional Chinese medicine and acupuncture, and hopes to include these in a family medicine practice someday. With so many people using alternative care, "it is important that it be treated more than just an afterthought" by medical schools, Wu said.
Officials at several top schools say they teach respect for patient choices, but do not teach unproven remedies or theories.
"All medical treatments ought to be held to the same standard," whether a prescription drug, an herbal pill or a mode of care, said Dr. Philip Gruppuso, Brown University's associate dean for medical education.
For example, acupuncture comes up in several places in the curriculum where there is evidence that it may help certain types of pain. However, students are not taught about body meridiens that allegedly channel energy, which acupuncturists claim to affect. Whether a school is promoting magical thinking about a therapy depends "more on how it's taught than what's taught," Gruppuso said.
At Harvard University, students have a couple of elective courses in such topics as mind-body medicine, but a spokeswoman said the university does not advocate or teach alternative medicine.
Georgetown University, which started the nation's first graduate degree program in complementary and alternative medicine, strives for objectivity, said the program's director, Hakima Amri.
"We are giving the facts, teaching what we know today. We are not promoting anything," she said.
That means straight talk about controversial fields like homeopathy, or the energy medicines qi gong and reiki, which claim to heal through a healer's powers, even at a distance.
"The science is not there to support that," Amri said.
Georgetown's goal is "to train a new generation of open-minded but critical physicians or scientists," she said. "We have seen students who come who are all enthusiasm about CAM because they've seen it work on their grandmother or someone like that. Then they go through the program and they see it differently. We want them to be really critical, able to separate the good from the bad."
___
On the Net:
Medical school group: http://www.imconsortium.org/cahcim/about/home.html
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Clinton arrives in Morocco on Mideast peace push AFP - Monday, November 2
Iran frees two Karoubi allies on bail-media Reuters - Monday, November 2
Karzai rival quits Afghan run-off Reuters - Monday, November 2
Honduran Congress to review crisis accord Tuesday AP - Sunday, November 1
No Philly transit union strike during World Series AP - Sunday, November 1
News Search
Top Stories
Putin tells EU of risk to gas supply via Ukraine: reports
Gulf single currency may face delay: bank chief
Abdullah pulls out of Afghan run-off election
ECB rates on hold, experts view bank loan policy
Iceland lifts capital controls as crisis eases
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Somali centenarian weds 17-year-old
US stocks slide ahead of Fed rate decision, jobless data
Arise, Sir Dracula! Christopher Lee knighted
Hamilton seizes pole in Abu Dhabi GP
Iceland lifts capital controls as crisis eases
More Most Viewed »
Mobile phone giant Nokia sues Apple over patents
Huge dinosaur find in China 'may include new species'
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 2 November 2009 Ten killed as Iraq hit by new spate of bombings
Italian police arrest fugitive mafia brothers
Gulf single currency may face delay: bank chief
Sudanese register for first free vote in 24 years
Israel holds Jewish settler accused of killing Arabs
Honduran opposition leader key to ending conflict
| International
|
Iran police to confront "illegal" November 4 rallies
Kosovo hails ex-president Clinton, unveils his statue
| International
|
Dozens killed in Somali fighting: rights group
| International
|
Saudis find arms cache linked to August arrests
Sudanese register for first free vote in 24 years
| International
|
Frustrated in Iraq, U.S. troops eye Afghan action
Iraq polls 'at risk' without vote details
Obama community college proposal may not be enough
Med, nursing schools teaching alternative remedies
Analysis: With few options, US accepts Karzai
Govt says swine flu vaccine catching up to demand
Geithner: Economy rebounding, but job growth lags
Seattle police say officer killed in shooting
Pakistan's capital now resembles besieged city
White House: Afghan troop decision within weeks
Protectionism a threat to recovery: Chinese official
Afghan challenger drops out of runoff election
Limbaugh calls Obama 'immature, inexperienced'
Acid ship 'sinks in China's Yangtze'
Iran warns of crackdown on any opposition protest
Pakistan zeroes in on major Taliban bases
Flex spending accounts face hit in health overhaul
Thai police arrest two people in stock rumour probe
China stamp fetches record price
Pakistan hopes to rout Taliban by late December
S.Lanka seek to stop US quzzing general over war
Michael Jackson film dances to No. 1 worldwide
| Entertainment
|
Truck, pilgrim bus collide, killing 8 in Indonesia
Honor Student Shot Dead Outside Of Homecoming Football Game
Suspect In Baghdad Bombing Killed After Struggle With Interrogators
Temporary 9/11 Memorial set On Fire
Seattle Police Officer Shot And Killed
White House Releases Visitor's List
Police Launch Manhunt For Convicted Rapist After Six Bodies Found In Home
U.S. Troops To Be Stationed In Colombian Bases
Economic High Points And Low Points For Week
VIX Rises 20 Percent On U.S. Market Worries
Federal Investigation: Results In On Drywall Chemicals, But Implications Still Uncertain
Russian envoy says Miliband visit chance to 'reset' ties
Karzai rival Abdullah quits Afghan run-off
| International
|
British govt in new bailout to troubled banks: reports
US lender CIT files for bankruptcy
Iran wants U.N. fuel plan reviewed
| International
|
Israel delays expulsion of 1,200 children of foreign workers
At least 15 killed in Rawalpindi blast: police
| International
|
Kosovo hails ex-president Clinton, unveils statue in his honor
| International
|
Norwegian warship in sea-battle off Somali coast: EU
Employment turnaround likely at start of 2010: Geithner
Miliband in Russia to thaw ties
Putin tells EU of risk to gas supply via Ukraine: reports
Italian police arrest fugitive mafia brothers
Taiwan president safe after smoke pours from plane
| International
|
Boat with 40 people sinks near remote Cocos Islands
| International
|
Iran frees two Karoubi allies on bail: media
| International
|
Hawaii celebrates canonization of first saint
Texas vets reunite with Japanese-American rescuers
Bay Bridge won't be open for Monday morning drive
NH restaurant sets meatball record
Mexico reaches record of 100 extraditions to US
North Korea calls for direct talks with U.S
Rescue under way after boat sinks off Australia
New York City Marathon Sees First American Win In Two Decades
Afghan's Karzai effectively handed 2nd term
Pakistan security forces kill at least 7 militants
Police: NJ mom stabbed son, self over custody fear
Japan aims to bury greenhouse gas emissions
China vaccinates over 3.7 million for swine flu
Hundreds of foreign militants on run: Pakistan army
Boat with 40 people sinks near remote Cocos Islands
Philly transit talks postponed until Monday
Mexico extradites 11 fugitives to US
Over 20 feared dead as boat sinks off Australia
GOP ex-candidate endorses Democrat in NY race
Already the main Afghan war hub, Bagram is growing
Aliens target Earth again in "V" revival
No eternity with Marilyn Monroe as crypt auction fails again
| Entertainment
|
S.Korean display makers plan $6.9 bln capex in 2010
Scandal does not hurt David Letterman's ratings
| Entertainment
|
Mel Gibson and girlfriend welcome a baby girl: media
| Entertainment
|
Transsexual Miss World contest aims to boost awareness
New Zealand growth to quicken in H2
Seoul shares fall 1 pct; Hyosung up on Hynix news
S.Korea manufacturing growth slows in Oct
Jackson tragedy begets cinematic triumph
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea T-bonds rally on weak shares, U.S. woes
Berlin Wall resurrected in Los Angeles
Seoul shares open 2.4 pct lower on U.S. jitters
UK singer Cheryl Cole scores chart double
Calle 13, Luis Fonsi set for Latin Grammy awards
Jackson tragedy begets cinematic triumph
Aliens target Earth again in V revival
| Entertainment
|
Calle 13, Luis Fonsi set for Latin Grammy awards
| Entertainment
|
Michael Jackson's 'This Is It' thrills movie-goers
HBO filmmakers get inside Obama campaign
UK singer Cheryl Cole scores chart double
| Entertainment
|
Michael Jackson film dances to No. 1 worldwide
Qatari firm in talks to make Prophet Mohammad film
Iran wants new nuclear fuel talks, deepening doubts
S.Korea seeks Chinese help to track cyber attacks
Scientists map genome of pig
US-TECH Summary
Hit streaming service Spotify eyes U.S. music fans
Bomb blast in Pakistan's Rawalpindi kills 35
| International
|
Nepal cabinet to meet on Everest: minister
Karadzic to appear in war crime court
| International
|
Global crisis hitting IT spending: Microsoft chief
Analysis: Iran in no hurry to cut nuclear deal
Karzai declared Afghan vote winner
Europe probe tracks global warming impact on water
Arab states disappointed with U.S.-Israeli talks
| International
|
Iran wants new nuclear fuel talks
| International
|
China slams U.S. for sending Uighurs to Palau
| International
|
Slumdog stars 'may lose allowance' for skipping school
Al Qaeda calls for home-made bomb attacks in West
| International
|
Civilian deaths in Iraq jump higher in October
| International
|
Recovering Thai king appears in public again
| International
|
Crisis has not halted migration hope of poor: Gallup
| International
|
Taiwan president safe following flight incident
Hit streaming service Spotify eyes U.S. music fans
| Technology
|
15 feared dead as boat sinks off Australia
Malaysia state helps jaded couples beat the blues
Scientists decode DNA of pig, a research favorite
Tribes claim wind farm would destroy sacred ritual
Obama to meet with economic board, Swedish PM
Massive fire blazes on leaking Australian oil rig
Murder trial to begin in Ark. TV anchor's death
Blast kills 35 in Pakistan's Rawalpindi
Audit: KBR must trim Iraq work force or face fines
Cheney FBI interview: 72 instances of can't recall
China protest halts Bangladesh Tibet exhibition
Bombing outside bank kills at least 20 in Pakistan
Focus falls on cause of collision off Calif. coast
Blast near Pakistan's capital kills at least 20
China chief says space arms inevitable: state media
Taxing the rich
Suicide bomber kills 34 outside Pakistan hotel
Health care plan hits rich with big tax increases
Trio of Japanese automakers lift forecasts
Shen Wei: Top China modern dance group takes time
Elton John aims for return to stage after illness
| Entertainment
|
Palestinian film, Team Qatar win Doha festival prizes
Bridgestone to quit F1 in late 2010
East of the Iron Curtain, humour helped society cope
Sands looks to raise $2.5B with Hong Kong IPO
Corruption dispute flares in Indonesia
Michael Jackson film dances to No. 1 worldwide
| Entertainment
|
Indonesian inflation up 2.57% in October
"Twilight" sequel soundtrack hopes to make killing
Twilight sequel soundtrack hopes to make killing
| Entertainment
|
China start-up stocks plunge on profit-taking
Military 'terps' head to war to win peace -- and visas
Arab filmmakers struggle for funds as industry grows
| Entertainment
|
Driver-less car in high-speed rally assault
Seoul shares fall 1.4 pct; Hyundai Motor tumbles
S.Korea c.bank to collect $1.2 bln in FX loans
Suzuki Motor profit down 63.4 pct in first half
Scandal does not hurt David Letterman's ratings
German child-care subsidy sparks nursery spat
Thai inflation rises for first time in 2009: govt
Indian Kashmir starts safaris as violence falls
No eternity with Marilyn Monroe as crypt auction fails again
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights