Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Analysis - Protests show Iran opposition alive, changing
Reuters - Wednesday, February 16
Send
IM Story
Print
By Paul Taylor
PARIS - Anti-government protests by thousands of Iranians inspired by the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia show Iran's "Green" pro-democracy movement is still alive despite a fierce crackdown by the authorities.
But the chances of demonstrations snowballing into the kind of uprising that swept veteran Egyptian and Tunisian rulers from power seem remote in the near term, since Iran's security forces are united in defending the 32-year-old Islamic Republic.
Monday's rallies in Tehran and other cities, in which two people died and dozens were wounded and arrested, were the first big show of opposition on the streets since authorities crushed protests against a disputed 2009 presidential election.
"After 20 months of oppression and more than a year without a significant public rally, despite the house arrests of its key figures, and in the face of intimidation and beatings, the Green Wave proved that it could still surge," analyst Scott Lucas of Birmingham University wrote on the EA Worldview website.
The scale of the protests seemed to take the authorities by surprise and contrasted starkly with government assertions that the Green movement is a spent force, and that support for the Islamic system is overwhelming.
"The regime for two years claimed that it had finished what it called the biggest conspiracy, or as we call it the Green movement. They arrested, they executed, they killed, they tortured, raped ... to prevent any more demonstrations," said Alireza Nourizadeh, director at the Centre for Arab and Iranian Studies in London.
"Yesterday it showed that they are wrong and the people still have hope," he said.
"SEDITIONISTS"
State television branded the protesters "hypocrites, monarchists, thugs and seditionists," and Parliament President Ali Larijani accused the United States of supporting them to distract attention from its own setbacks in the Middle East.
Hardline Iranian lawmakers urged the judiciary to hand down death penalties to reformist opposition leaders Mehdi Karroubi and Mirhossein Mousavi, the two defeated presidential candidates, for fomenting the unrest, state media reported.
Denied a permit for a rally in solidarity with the Egyptian and Tunisian movements, the two are under house arrest.
Security forces prevented them attending the march, arrested at least 20 pro-reform activists before the rally and took their websites offline, opposition activists reported.
But witnesses said the mostly middle-class protesters who defied the ban and converged on Tehran's Azadi Square barely mentioned the names of Mousavi and Karroubi.
Their slogans were aimed directly against Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, branded a "tyrant," rather than at hardline President Mahmoud Ahmadijenad, the witnesses said.
That suggests support for reformists trying to improve the Islamic system from within may have been overtaken by a more radical opposition to the entire system.
"Because the regime expends all its efforts on saying that everything's normal and everyone loves us, even small signs of dissent are significant in puncturing this fiction," said Ali Ansari, professor of Iranian studies at St. Andrews University.
"This will give people in Iran hope."
While the authorities' verbal tirades against the protesters have been fierce, the demonstrators were treated less violently than those who took to the streets in 2009 to denounce alleged vote-rigging in favour of Ahmadinejad.
The elite Revolutionary Guards and the Basij militia were mostly kept off the streets and out of sight on Monday.
Instead, uniformed police and plainclothes agents were deployed to control the crowds and they used mostly non-lethal teargas rather than live ammunition, to avoid causing casualties.
Nevertheless, one person was shot dead and another killed in unexplained circumstances. A conservative lawmaker, Kazem Jalali, described them as "martyrs," implying they had been killed by "terrorists" rather than security agents.
Police prevented protesters from staying on overnight in the square, a rallying point for the 1979 Islamic revolution that overthrew the Shah, in an attempt to turn it into a permanent focal point as Egyptian activists did in central Cairo.
"This is not Tunisia. This is not Egypt. This is Iran, where Azadi Square did not become the new Tahrir Square yesterday," Lucas said.
HARD CORE
While the political support base for the Iranian system has narrowed in recent years due to the exclusion of reformists and dissident clerics, and to endemic factional feuds, the security forces show every outward sign of remaining loyal to the regime.
Unlike in Tunisia and Egypt, where the army command's refusal to open fire on the people led to the fall of entrenched dictators, Iran's security and intelligence forces showed in 2009 they were willing to use lethal force repeatedly.
Revolutionary Guard veterans hold key government positions from Ahmadinejad on down, and control major business interests. The Basij militia is under strong ideological control. The regular army is weak and kept well away from internal security.
"There is still a hard core that is convinced of the Islamic revolution's legacy and also there very large vested interests ... and those are now intertwined with the security establishment," said Professor Anoush Ehteshami, an Iran expert at Durham University.
"They are not likely to let their privileges to go lightly because unlike in Tunisia and Egypt, if this elite goes, this elite will suffer bloodshed at the hands of the people."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Tunisia extends state of emergency, ends curfew AFP - 2 hours 51 minutes ago
Bahrainis demand regime change after two killed AFP - 1 hour 34 minutes ago
South Sudan rebel clash death toll tops 200 AFP - Wednesday, February 16
Guantanamo inmate admits terror charges AFP - Wednesday, February 16
Woman, teen daughters slain in Mexico violence AFP - 26 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Happy as Larry: new Downing St cat to fight rats
Deutsche Boerse, NYSE Euronext merge
Contador cleared of doping charges - spokesman
Eurozone economy sputters in fourth quarter
NASA spacecraft sends pictures of comet flyby
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
US golfer Woods finds old habits hard to shake
Russia loses military satellite: reports
US auto sales jump 17 percent in January
Dow closes over 12,000 for first time since June 2008
Egypt's Mubarak to step down at September election
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 16 February 2011 Iran MPs rage against opposition after deadly demo
US-TECH Summary
Analysis
ARM sees boost from high-end smartphones
Contador cleared of doping charges
Google CEO avoids answering Twitter question
Sudanese arms trainer pleads guilty at Guantanamo
Deutsche Boerse, NYSE Euronext merge
Apple subscription service challenges publishers
NASA spacecraft sends pictures of comet flyby
Obama warns Arab world: get ahead of reform curve
Barclays bank hikes profit, cuts bonuses
Samsung says low-end phones not for profit
Special report: Has Mohamed ElBaradei's time arrived?
|
Egypt's Mubarak in failing health
Analysis: Bumpy road in Africa for Europe's telco vendors
Renegade militia kills over 200 in S.Sudan: officials
|
Vodafone, Orange fined 63 mn euros in Romania
Over 200 dead in south Sudan "massacre," officials say
Kaspersky tips Android to dominate mobile
Apologetic Kerry tries to smooth Pakistan row
Food prices at dangerous levels: Robert Zoellick
|
HTC launches social smartphones with Facebook
China January inflation stays high at 4.9%
Iraq protesters demand jobs in countrywide rallies
|
Nokia-Microsoft pact seen creating Google rival
Asian literary prize shortlist to be unveiled
Tunisia to work with Italy to stem migrant tide
|
Japan school hit by suspected food poisoning scare
US-TECH Summary
Thousands lose homes in Philippines slum blaze
Samsung says low-end phones not for profit
Nokia-Microsoft pact seen creating Google rival
Bob Dylan to launch Asian tour in April
Nokia aims for Windows phone by year-end
Taiwan cardinal set for historic China trip
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Russia's Irina Shayk gets Sports Illustrated cover
Coldplay, Beyonce to play Glastonbury festival
Marc Jacobs: the middle-aged enfant terrible
Nokia-Microsoft pact seen creating Google rival
|
Nepal's casinos under threat of closure
Google CEO says tried hard to woo Nokia
|
ARM sees boost from high-end smartphones
|
Analysis: Nvidia's comeback comes under scrutiny
|
Bollywood descends into Hitler's bunker at Berlin fest
Famous Bollywood studio up for sale: reports
Samsung says low-end phones not for profit
|
Analysis: Bumpy road in Africa for Europe's telco vendors
|
Russia to launch Muslim television channel
Coldplay to headline Glastonbury festival
HTC unveils 5 smartphone models
|
Gang Of Four seek contentment on new album
EBay, Telefonica's 02 in smartphone app deal in UK
|
Home Depot to hire 60,000 seasonal workers nationwide
Surrogate grandma produces baby grandson for daughter
Intelligence chief says terrorists shifting to smaller attacks against US
Beloved volunteer killed while trying to save stray dog
Federal probe set into fatal shooting of Pace University student
Delta ends SkyMiles expiration
New report throws doubt on origin of 2001 deadly anthrax attacks
Two U.S. citizens among seven charged in conspiracy to aid Taliban
Los Angeles County worker dies unnoticed on job
Alvin Greene tries again, now for South Carolina House seat
Lady Gaga heading for hit, with Madonna's blessing
|
Hannah Montana destroyed family, Miley's dad says
|
Russia's Irina Shayk gets Sports Illustrated cover
|
Coldplay, Beyonce to play Glastonbury festival
|
Egypt junta names panel to reform constitution
Rapper Tinie Tempah is big winner at Brit Awards
Happy as Larry: new Downing St cat to fight rats
IMG to spread Major League Gaming globally
No decision on Petraeus exit from Afghanistan: US
Computer crushes human 'Jeopardy!' champs
Deutsche Boerse, NYSE Euronext merge
Defector admits 'fabricating' Iraq WMD intel
NASA spacecraft unravels comet mystery
LG Elec says aims to sell 5 million 3D TVs in 2011
Berlusconi to face under-age sex trial in April
Iran MPs want death penalty for opposition leaders
|
NATO chief Petraeus to leave post by end of year: report
Twitter users seek privacy in WikiLeaks case
'German Fritzl' admits fathering kids with stepdaughter
Analysis: Nvidia's comeback comes under scrutiny
Pakistan says U.S. prisoner Davis has immunity
|
Egyptian army says it hopes for elections in 6 months
CBS reporter Lara Logan assaulted in Egypt
Bahrain protesters gather in capital for third day
|
Clinton renews call for Internet freedom
India's cornered PM vows to press on despite scandals
|
Renegade militia kills over 200 in S.Sudan-officials
Apple unveils digital media subscription service
Iraqi defector fabricated WMD intelligence: report
|
Riots break out in Libyan city of Benghazi
|
Cambodia to ask ASEAN to monitor ceasefire with Thailand
TMZ launches tours of Hollywood's infamous hot spots
Too much hysteria over cyber attacks: US experts
Elizabeth Taylor improving, but remains in hospital
Tokyo, Moscow have highest expat rents: survey
Fight computer viruses like epidemics: Microsoft
Zsa Zsa Gabor's husband puts fur coats up for sale
Pakistan says U.S. prisoner Davis has immunity
U.S. concerned by violence in Bahrain protests
LG Elec says aims to sell 5 million 3D TVs in 2011
Indian PM vows corruption crackdown after scandals
Al Qaeda militant-turned-witness released
US-TECH Summary
Japan whalers suspend hunt, may end mission early
Pampered songbirds vie for fame in Indonesia
Mum uploads video of nude daughter to find a suitor
Computer crushes human 'Jeopardy!' champs
Apple says Foxconn suicide measures 'saved lives'
Reporters roughed up near China activist's home
Bruno Mars and Janelle Monae announce joint tour
TMZ launches tours of Hollywood's infamous hot spots
N. Korea's Kim marks birthday amid shortages
Rapper Tinie Tempah is big winner at Brit Awards
Dell blows past targets, but doubt persists
|
Sean Penn presses case for helping Haiti rebuild
IMG to spread Major League Gaming globally
|
Canada's Arcade Fire steal show at UK's BRIT awards
Chinese telco gearmakers aim to leap U.S. barriers
|
LG Elec says aims to sell 5 million 3D TVs in 2011
|
Elizabeth Taylor improving, but remains in hospital
Zsa Zsa Gabor's husband puts fur coats up for sale
Brooklyn Decker's model-to-actress challenge
Seoul shares dip as autos, refiners fall
Analysis: Nvidia's comeback comes under scrutiny
|
S.Korea eyes steps to avert household debt crisis
Game eyes step change in online revenue
|
KEPCO consortium signs $1.43 bn UAE power plant deal
U.S.-Ecuador pollution row deepens; Chevron accuses state-run firm of pollution
New award for journalistic courage featured in worldwide teen journalism contest
Japan, India sign free trade pact
Clinton calls for "ground rules" protecting internet freedom and security
"30 Rock" leads nominees of first-ever "Comedy Awards"
New Zealand economy probably back in recession in Q4
U.S. stocks pull back as January retail sales dip
Seoul shares dip as autos, refiners fall
Korea Hot Stocks
Seoul shares open lower after mixed data; LG dips
South Korea expresses interest in Panama mining
Airline group says S China congestion big problem
Lady Gaga heading for hit, with Madonna's blessing
|
HTC unveils 5 smartphone models
Elizabeth Taylor improving, but remains in hospital
|
Google 'very, very proud' of cyber revolutionary
Bruno Mars and Janelle Monae announce joint tour
|
Zsa Zsa Gabor's husband puts fur coats up for sale
|
Canada's Arcade Fire steal show at UK's BRIT awards
|
Hannah Montana destroyed family, Miley's dad says
|
Sean Penn presses case for helping Haiti rebuild
|
TMZ launches tours of Hollywood's infamous hot spots
|
Iran regime calls for 'hatred' rally against opposition
Berlusconi 'not at all worried' about sex crime trial
Smartphones 'new El Dorado for computer criminals'
Pro and anti-government supporters clash at Tehran funeral
Controversial Swedish wolf hunt ends, one escapes
Drugs giant Sanofi agrees $20.1 bn Genzyme takeover
Labor unrest as Egypt moves towards democracy
|
Egypt strikes continue despite military warning
China's microbloggers on new front of Internet
Cell-based flu shot beats current vaccine: study
French minister contacted Tunisia dictator on trip: aide
Iran opposition leaders defiant amid execution calls
Egypt-inspired protests gain pace across region
|
Game eyes step change in online revenue
Banks 'had to know' of fraud, Madoff says
Chinese telco gearmakers aim to leap U.S. barriers
Pro-, anti-govt supporters clash at Tehran funeral
|
Only 'best will do' for Arsenal in Barca clash
Berlusconi vows to stay on, not worried by scandal
|
N.Korean defects to South amid Kim Jong-il festivities
|
Rioting hits Libyan city of Benghazi
|
Top CBS reporter sexually assaulted in Egypt
India's cornered PM vows to press on despite scandals
|
Three killed, dozens injured in Iraqi protests
|
India telecoms probe: Ambani meets investigators
Indian tycoon Ambani questioned over telecom scam
India's cornered PM vows to press on despite scandals
Ecuador cockfighting fans battle proposed ban
'World's happiest man' advocates meditation
Indonesia's radical Islamic group promises no attack on Ahmadiyah
A minute with: Martin Lawrence talking "Big Mommas"
S. Korean footballers Park, Cha out with injuries
Malaysia cancels controversial Iranian's concert
Orange warns Nokia-Microsoft against closed system
|
Korea Line's fate to be decided in court
Scottish Deerhound 'best in show' in New York
China's microbloggers on new front of Internet
|
Asia Naphtha-S Korea Samsung Total buys H2 March cargo
EDITORIAL: Pyongyang's ruler
ARM sees boost from high-end smartphones
|
South Korea's Incheon Airport named world's best for 6th year
China announces shakeup of rare earths industry
Orbitz posts wider quarterly loss
|
Toyota celebrates rare opening of Japan plant
Etisalat upbeat on Zain deal success
|
LG puts hopes on 'next generation' 3-D TV
Airline group says China congestion big problem
Prince William, Kate to visit Canada post-wedding
|
A minute with: Martin Lawrence talking Big Mommas
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights