InfoAnda - Analysis: Will battle for Kandahar win the war?

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

Fears Australian piracy case could shut off net | 1 February 2010
ESPN's Allen Iverson documentary holds few surprises | | 12 April 2010
Myanmar says Suu Kyi party must apologize for sanctions | | 19 February 2011

Stork Craft Recalls More Than 2 Million Cribs | 25 November 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Analysis: Will battle for Kandahar win the war?

Yahoo! My Yahoo! Mail More Yahoo! Services Account Options New User? Sign Up Sign In Help Yahoo! Search web search Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Africa Europe Latin America Middle East North America Analysis: Will battle for Kandahar win the war? By DENIS D. GRAY,Associated Press Writer - Monday, August 30 Send IM Story Print KANDAHAR, Afghanistan – Since the war began, this southern city and surrounding countryside have been marked as the heartland of the Taliban, the insurgents' springboard to retake all of Afghanistan. It has witnessed some of the bloodiest fighting. Now, as U.S. and allied forces wrestle with urban warlords and take on die-hard insurgents in booby-trapped orchards and grape fields, the battle for Kandahar city is being described as the decisive campaign, a linchpin of American strategy to win the 9-year-old conflict. "As goes Kandahar, so goes Afghanistan," has almost become the military's mantra. Not all agree, arguing even if success in Kandahar is achieved, the war will be far from over. That success is far from guaranteed: the obstacles are overwhelming, the time to overcome them may prove too short, and victory may hinge not on what happens on the ground in Kandahar, but in the American political arena. "This is Western military thinking which is totally irrelevant to Afghanistan," says Marc Sageman, a former CIA operative in the region now with the Washington-based Foreign Policy Research Institute. "You can pacify Kandahar and you'll still lose the war because Afghanistan remains a highly decentralized society, and in the countryside, the Kabul government has little legitimacy." Southern Kandahar is unquestionably important. The city itself, the country's second largest with some 500,000 inhabitants, served as the capital of the Taliban during its years in power. Al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden used it as his base during the 9/11 attacks. Now, the insurgency draws its greatest strength from the province and the neighboring region, dominated by the Pashtun ethnic majority who form the Taliban core. "If you win in Kandahar it will have a major effect throughout the south. If Kandahar flourishes, other things will flourish. This is an iconic place for the Pashtun psyche," the British commander of NATO forces in the south, Maj. Gen. Nick Carter, told reporters recently. In other words, the domino theory, Afghan-style. Others argue the focus on Kandahar and the surrounding province of the same name is diverting troops and resources from other areas of the country where the insurgents are making significant gains, that the war, according to some on-the-ground U.S. officers, must be fought village by village, valley by valley. Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff, has estimated the insurgency has spread to about one-third of the country's districts. Shadow Taliban governors, some reports say, exist in 33 of the country's 34 provinces. And there are other strategic hotspots besides Kandahar, including the Kabul region and stretches of the border with Pakistan, where al-Qaida _ Washington's prime target when the war was launched in 2001_ is concentrated. Commanders describe the operation for Kandahar _ dubbed "Hamkari Baraye Kandahar," or "Cooperation for Kandahar" _ as not a conventional offensive but rather a "slow, rising tide," where military muscle plays a secondary role. At its height, roughly 25,000 NATO and Afghan troops will be deployed in the city and surrounding countryside. "This is not Stalingrad or Fallujah. This fight is about governance, the mobs, the mafia," Carter said. "Success will be judged how we connect a credible Afghan government to the population." But some tough fighting is taking place, with U.S. and Afghan forces concentrated on the city's western approaches to stem the inflow of fighters, suicide bombers and funds. About 80 percent of one Taliban stronghold, the lush and heavily mined Arghandab Valley, has been secured, Carter says, and next month a major operation will be launched in adjacent Zhari, an insurgency-wracked district where the radical Islamist movement was founded in 1994. Within the city, "sleepers" have been planted to gather information, and plans call for U.S. military police and the Afghan National Police to have blanketed Kandahar with 11 security stations by the end of September. Intelligence-led operations will target what Carter calls "a resilient insurgency." Simultaneously, development projects are to be rolled out, including temporary measures to boost electric power, which is not expected to come on full stream until 2014. But perhaps the toughest, and most essential, nut to crack will be the parallel, warlord government that has taken root in a vacuum left by the decimation of tribal leadership and the absence of effective Kabul governance. Among several families essentially running the city is that of Ahmed Wali Karzai, the half brother of President Hamid Karzai who has shown little inclination to remove his relative despite widespread allegations of his involvement in racketeering, drug-trafficking and assassinations of rivals. The younger Karzai denies those allegations. "The problem in Kandahar is that the population views government institutions as predatory and illegitimate, representing the interests of key power-brokers rather than the populace," wrote the U.S.-based Institute for the Study of War last month. An earlier survey of the province, roughly the size of Israel, showed endemic corruption, along with a lack of security and basic services. The situation "sets conditions for a disenfranchised population to respond either by not supporting the government, or worse yet, supporting the Taliban," it says. Eighty-five percent of respondents in the survey, funded by the U.S. Army, said they regarded the Taliban as "our Afghan brothers." Most were against the "Cooperation for Kandahar" mission. NATO commanders concede that transforming mafia-style rule with a semblance of clean, representative government along with other tasks are a massive undertaking. Will there be enough time to do it? "Kandahar's significance is political rather than operational. If (NATO commander Gen. David) Petraeus fails to achieve success there by next summer, President Obama will have a very difficult time making the case that his Afghan strategy is working. In that event, time will run out," says Andrew J. Bacevich, professor of international relations and history at Boston University, and a Vietnam War veteran. And politics do not seem to be on Obama's side. A nationwide poll this month conducted by The Associated Press and GfK Roper Public Affairs and Corporate Communications showed 58 percent of Americans opposed the conflict, while only 38 percent supported Obama's expanded war effort. "Eleven months are enough to make a dent. But (U.S.) counterinsurgency doctrine presupposes a long term commitment," says Arturo Munoz, an expert on Afghanistan at the RAND Corporation, referring to Obama's pledge to begin pulling U.S. troops out of the country in July next year. "The current doctrine constitutes a viable and effective strategy. The big question is whether the American body politic is willing to expend the resources, time and blood needed to implement it." A study by the RAND think tank looking at 90 insurgencies since 1945 found it took an average of 14 years to defeat insurgents. The current U.S. counterinsurgency doctrine _ COIN for short _ was adopted just three years ago in Iraq. Focused on protecting and winning over the population, COIN is summarized as "shape, clear, hold, and build." The doctrine has its critics. "The U.S. is still conceptualizing a war it should be actively fighting as if the next year were somehow to be the first year of the war," writes insurgency expert Anthony H. Cordesman in a recent study for the Center for Strategic and International Studies. The head of the U.S. Special Operations Command, Adm. Eric Olson, has said too much emphasis is being placed on protecting locals and not enough on fighting the enemy. "Counterinsurgency should involve countering the insurgents," he says. Some of COIN's key assumptions were questioned at a March conference in England of government officials, military officers, aid agencies and academics. Rather than winning hearts and minds, a conference summary said, aid may have the opposite effect when "many Afghans believe the main cause of insecurity to be their government, which is perceived to be massively corrupt, predatory and unjust." With the clock ticking, COIN faces its first major test of the 9-year war in Kandahar. ___ Denis D. Gray is The Associated Press bureau chief in Bangkok, Thailand, and has reported on Asia for more than 30 years. Recommend Send IM Story Print Related Articles Four Ugandan peacekeepers killed in Mogadishu AFP - 33 minutes ago S.Africa's Zuma orders talks to end strike AFP - Tuesday, August 31 UK-World Summary Reuters - 25 minutes ago Bulgaria jails men for murder in decade-long trial Reuters - 25 minutes ago Earl strengthens to major Caribbean hurricane AFP - 26 minutes ago News Search Top Stories Gun rampage leaves seven dead in Slovakia US spending, incomes edge upward Japan announces 920 bln yen stimulus package Sweden's HQ Bank announces involuntary liquidation Child health at risk from non-prescription drugs: study More Top Stories » ADVERTISEMENT Most Popular Most Viewed Most Recommended Earth's upper atmosphere shrinking, scientists say Russian spy courts new scandal with racy photo shoot Joy and tears greet US Army troops back from Iraq Paris Hilton arrested for cocaine possession Child health at risk from non-prescription drugs: study More Most Viewed » Obama endorses mosque plan near Ground Zero Earth's upper atmosphere shrinking, scientists say Tiger's ex breaks her silence on sex scandal Belgian man dies of South Asian superbug Most US students think Beethoven is a dog More Most Recommended » Elsewhere on Yahoo! Financial news on Yahoo! Finance Stars and latest movies Best travel destinations More on Yahoo! News Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Subscribe to our news feeds Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS » More news feeds | What are news feeds? Also on Yahoo! Answers Groups Mail Messenger Mobile Travel Finance Movies Sports Games » All Yahoo! Services Site Highlights Singapore Full Coverage Most Popular Asia Entertainment Photos World Cup 2010 Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Community - Intellectual Property Rights Policy - Help

Other News on Monday, 30 August 2010
Gun rampage leaves seven dead in Slovakia
Ten held over Beirut clash amid arms control talks
Exclusive: Obama to widen sanctions on North Korea |
US-TECH Summary
Anger at German banker's comments on Jews, Muslims
Infineon sells wireless group to Intel
Afghan president criticizes anti-terror strategy
Palestinian PM Fayyad says time for Israeli answers |
US spending, incomes edge upward
Moscow death rates 'up 50% in heatwave'
Nokia, Siemens confirm NSN investment talks: report
Somali rebels kill four AU peacekeepers |
Two Russian pilots abducted in Darfur: army
Abbas, Palestinians should die
Abducted U.S. aid worker released in Darfur |
Google acquires social networking startup Angstro
Sweden's HQ Bank announces involuntary liquidation
Israel won't extend settlement freeze ahead of talks
Iraq says sale of donated U.S. computers legal
Egypt urges EU to bolster U.S.-led Mideast peace bid |
Nine dead in Russian retirement home blaze
Japan announces 920 bln yen stimulus package
Iraqis say war "not ending" despite U.S. drawdown
Americans Spending Up In July
Seven U.S. troops killed in south Afghan bombings |
Zara takes the plunge into crowded online market
12 suspected rebels killed in Chechnya: president
Child health at risk from non-prescription drugs: study
Seven US troops, politician killed in Afghan attacks
Pastor Sent To Jail In Case Of Mistaken identity
North Korea's Kim says wants nuclear talks restarted |
France Socialists challenge Sarkozy on security
3PAR says HP acquisition bid 'superior' to Dell's
Joy and tears greet US Army troops back from Iraq
Suspect In Utah Sheriff Deputy's Death Arrested
Israeli actors boycott theatres in settlements
Sanofi-Aventis makes 18.5 bln dollar bid for US Genzyme
Serbia ready for Kosovo compromise, up to a point: Tadic
Public Protests over Unemployment in Saudi Arabia
Libya to free 38 radical Islamists: attorney general |
Analysis: Will battle for Kandahar win the war?
PR firm staff wrote iTunes 'customer' reviews
"The Last Exorcism" Finishes At 1st Place At The Weekend Box Office
Core business: Genome of the apple is laid bare
Car bomb kills Afghan official in east |
"American Idol" Still Pining Over Elton John To Be Judge
Suspicion of 'racist' thinking on Roma expulsions
Afghanistan's blasted Buddhas beckon tourists
Microsoft appeals to Supreme Court over i4i patent
Nearly 15,000 war missing still haunt the Balkans
Obama To Mark End Of Combat Missions In Iraq With Tuesday Address
Senator Kerry warns of instability in Pakistan |
Internet Age overhaul of USA Today to cost jobs
Small Plane Makes Emergency Landing On Georgia Golf Course
7 US troops killed in latest Afghanistan fighting
Putin opens Russian side of oil pipeline to China
Nokia, Siemens confirm NSN investment talks: report
Indian Born Archie Panjabi Takes Her First Emmy
Paris Hilton arrested for cocaine possession
Father Suspected In Fatal Arizona Shooting Found Dead
Lenovo to develop game consoles in China: report
Nokia and Intel launch joint research lab
Wife of ex-GOME chairman paroled in China
'Spiderman' arrested after scaling Sydney skyscraper
Human bones found at Australia backpacker murder site
Many evacuated as Indonesian volcano erupts again
Antigua, Caribbean brace for Hurricane Earl
Nokia, Intel say MeeGo software off to good start
Flood spares Pakistan city as waters recede
BlackBerry to offer India access: govt source |
Angelina Jolie to write, direct movie on Bosnia war
Australian 'kingmakers' resume talks
3M to buy Cogent for more than $900 million |
"Slumdog" helps usher in Hollywood's Indian era
Thousands flee Indonesian volcano
Tangible signs of life to arrive at 9/11 memorial
Intel seeks to close mobile gap with Infineon unit |
LG Display says in talks with Compal for JV
China, Russia boost efforts to save tigers
Britney Spears may return to "Glee"
Google acquires social networking startup Angstro |
7 Folsom inmates hurt after riot, shots fired
Taiwanese LCD maker files second suit against Sony
Bank of Japan announces fresh easing measures
Carter brings American home from North Korea
Online video key to Disney, Time Warner Cable row |
Jolie to star in romantic film set in Bosnian war: UNHCR
"Kingmakers" make new demands in Australia deadlock
Guard troops to deploy to Arizona border on Monday
Dell says assessing 3PAR offer after HP trumps bid |
Jolie to film love story set in Bosnia war
Brewer condemns report to UN mentioning Ariz. law
Iraq says sale of donated U.S. computers legal |
Accused Somali pirate pleads guilty in U.S. court
Nokia, Siemens confirm NSN investment talks: report |
Paul Allen's firm sues Silicon Valley giants |
Accused Russian arms trader blasts media coverage
Rossellini to head Berlin Film Festival jury
RIM looks forward as India, other challenges loom |
Drama series 'Mad Men' wins at Emmy awards
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
New faces keep Emmys broadcast fresh
"30 Rock" crushed at Emmys
Australia immigration prison riot hits second day
On Italian beaches, dog lifeguards are on watch
Indonesia eyes new capital as Jakarta bursts at seams
HBO leads Emmys pack, powered by "Temple Grandin"
CORRECTED
First-timers and new shows shake up Emmy awards
Pakistani central bank deputy seen getting top job
George Clooney wins humanitarian award at Emmys
Pakistan stocks end down; rupee weaker; o/n rates up
Time takes its toll on Latvia's 'Old Believers'
Japan announces fresh stimulus measures
Taiwan regulators to meet on stalled AIG unit deal
Emmy wins prove modern families are U.S. hits |
Japan announces 920 billion yen stimulus package
First-timers and new shows shake up Emmy awards |
HBO leads Emmys pack, powered by Temple Grandin |
China state giants outstrip private firms: report
S.Korea c.bank to buy back 2-year MSBs from Sept
New faces keep Emmys broadcast fresh |
George Clooney wins humanitarian award at Emmys |
India gives BlackBerry 60-day reprieve
30 Rock crushed at Emmys |
Seoul shares gain 1.8 pct on banks, steelmakers
Last Exorcism edges out Takers at box office |
Venice festival gambles on youth, movie mavericks |
Paris Hilton released after cocaine arrest: lawyer |
Lennon's toilet sells for $14,740 at UK auction |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01