Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down's video
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (6)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 1-Google execs convicted in Italy for Down's video
4:32am EST
Dutch parties tussle over approach to far right
23 Feb 2010
US Jan mass layoffs edge up on weak manufacturing
23 Feb 2010
Pentagon OKs lifting ban on women in submarines
23 Feb 2010
How long can the U.S. dollar defy gravity?
23 Feb 2010
How long can the U.S. dollar defy gravity?
23 Feb 2010
Pentagon OKs lifting ban on women in submarines
23 Feb 2010
Yahoo partners with Twitter to boost social features
1:10am EST
Dutch parties tussle over approach to far right
23 Feb 2010
Democrats: Say Goodbye to Wall Street?
7:36am EST
SPECIAL REPORT
Inside Apple's fortress of secrets
Inside a walled city in South China and amid intense security, employees are provided with dormitories, canteens, recreation facilities, even banks, post offices and bakeries. The goal? Keep Apple's secrets. Full Article
Apple's iPad e-book store to use DRM: report
Mobile operators unite to fight Apple app store
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down's video
Wed Feb 24, 2010 9:08am EST
Related News
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down syndrome video
4:05am EST
Verdict due in Google defamation case in Italy
Tue, Feb 23 2010
Verdict due in Google defamation case in Italy
Tue, Feb 23 2010
Italy targets Facebook site attacking Down's kids
Tue, Feb 23 2010
Italy targets Facebook site attacking Down's kids
Tue, Feb 23 2010
Bill Echikson, senior manager of communications of Google Inc, speaks to the media after a court passed the sentence for three Google executives in Milan February 24, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/ Paolo Bona
MILAN (Reuters) - A Milan court convicted three Google Inc executives on Wednesday for violating the privacy of an Italian boy with Down's syndrome by letting a video of him being bullied be posted on the site in 2006.
Technology | Media | Italy
Google will appeal the six-month suspended jail terms and said the verdict "poses a crucial question for the freedom on which the internet is built," since none of the three employees found guilty had anything to do with the offending video.
"They didn't upload it, they didn't film it, they didn't review it and yet they have been found guilty," said Google's senior communications manager, Bill Echikson, in Milan.
The court convicted senior vice-president and chief legal officer David Drummond, former Google Italy board member George De Los Reyes and global privacy counsel Peter Fleischer. Senior product marketing manager Arvind Desikan was acquitted.
The executives, none of whom are based in Italy, do not face actual imprisonment as the sentences were suspended, while an appeals process in Italy can take many years.
They were not in Italy for the hearing. Drummond is based in California, Fleischer in Paris and Desikan in London, while De Los Reyes has since retired, Echikson told Reuters.
The complaint was brought by an Italian advocacy group for people with Down's syndrome, Vivi Down, and the boy's father, after four classmates at a Turin school uploaded a clip to Google Video showing them bullying the boy.
"A company's rights cannot prevail over a person's dignity. This sentence sends a clear signal," public prosecutor Alfredo Robledo told reporters outside the Milan courthouse.
Down's syndrome is the most common genetic cause of mental retardation, occurring in about 1 out of 700 live births.
The video was filmed with a mobile phone and posted on the site in September 2006.
"THREAT TO NET FREEDOM"
Google argued that it removed the video immediately after being notified and cooperated with Italian authorities to help identify the bullies and bring them to justice.
It says that, as hosting platforms that do not create their own content, Google Video, YouTube and Facebook cannot be held responsible for content that others upload.
Drummond said in a statement the verdict "sets a dangerous precedent" and meant "every employee of any internet hosting service faces similar liability." He said the law was clear in Italy and the European Union that "hosting providers like Google are not required to monitor content that they host."
Fleischer said if employees were "criminally liable for any video on a hosting platform, when they had absolutely nothing to do with the video in question, then our liability is unlimited."
The prosecutors accused Google of negligence, saying the video remained online for two months even though some web users had already posted comments asking for it to be taken down.
Down's syndrome support group Vivi Down said in a statement that it was "very satisfied" with the guilty verdict.
Censoring of web sites has become a hot issue in Italy in recent months, following a spate of hate sites against officials including Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi.
The government briefly studied plans to black out Internet hate sites after fan pages emerged praising an attack on the premier, but the idea was dropped after executives from Facebook, Google and Microsoft agreed to a shared code of conduct rather than legislation.
(Additional reporting by Emilio Parodi and Eleanor Biles; writing by Stephen Brown in Rome; Editing by Elizabeth Fullerton.)
Technology
Media
Italy
Comments
See All Comments (6) | Post Comment
Feb 24, 2010 8:20am EST
The genetic disorder is actually Down syndrome and not Down’s Syndrome. Also, retardation is no longer “politically correct”. The term to use now is developmentally delayed.
As a mother of a 10-year daughter with Down syndrome, it frightens me that this behavior goes on, but that Google allowed it to be uploaded to their site.
cnwwebb
Report As Abusive
Feb 24, 2010 8:35am EST
I don’t think it is fair that Google be prosecuted. 1) They actively removed the video. 2) They used the video to actually help find the bullies involved. How on Earth does this make them guilty ??
You tell me.
Aussieme
Report As Abusive
Feb 24, 2010 9:09am EST
It’s not right that Google was found guilty. They guilty parties are those that bullied the child and posted the video. Google is a place where people can upload and share information. Google is not responsible for what others do.
That would be like charging a landlord with indecency because his tenants engage in particular sexual practices in the home. The landlord has nothing to do with what a person does in their home. Likewise Google has nothing to do with what people post on the web. They will take down offensive content if notified. But that doesn’t make them responsible for what others do.
Benny_Acosta
Report As Abusive
Feb 24, 2010 9:24am EST
This ruling and the Italian government in general is retarded. This whole affair is a perfect parallel the retard people who banned pork to prevent the spread of swine flu. Followed to its logical conclusion, this ruling would prevent google from being a conduit of free speech in places like Iran and China where free speech saves lives daily.
Freedom of speech is such an important and powerful thing that the “dignity of an individual” would be insignificant in comparison. That is to say the argument that some video of a person with down syndrome being abused damages their dignity is absurd. Only a child would think in such a manor. The only dignity damaged by such a video are the bullies themselves. Adults should understand and feel compassion for the victim – that does not diminish the victims dignity. Should we also ban videos of the tragedy in Haiti because they should have stood up to the earth quake? What kind of retarded thinking is this?
riluve
Report As Abusive
Feb 24, 2010 9:37am EST
This whole affair is a perfect parallel to the people who banned pork to prevent the spread of swine flu. Followed to its logical conclusion, this ruling would prevent google from being a conduit of free speech in places like Iran and China where free speech saves lives daily.
Freedom of speech is such an important and powerful thing that the “dignity of an individual” would be insignificant in comparison. That is to say the argument that some video of a person with down syndrome being abused damages their dignity is absurd. Only a child would think in such a manor. The only dignity damaged by such a video are the bullies themselves. Adults should understand and feel compassion for the victim – that does not diminish the victims dignity. Should we also ban videos of the tragedy in Haiti because they should have stood up to the earth quake?
riluve
Report As Abusive
Feb 24, 2010 10:57am EST
This is ridiculous! If an offensive poster is placed on a billboard that is attached to a private wall, and the owner takes down the poster as soon as notified, will the owner be legally responsible for having violated the right of the offended individual? The verdict against Google seems to indicate that the owner will be. Is there a precedence for this?
doctorbabaguy
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (6)
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Bernanke says rates to stay low for long time
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told Congress on Wednesday that a weak job market and low inflation would likely allow the central bank to keep interest rates at very low levels for "an extended period."
Senate passes $15 billion jobs package
New home sales hit record low
Obama to appeal to business chiefs on job creation
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down's video
Toyoda arrives for grilling in Congress
| Video
» More Top News
Grilling to test Toyoda's mettle
Toyota's chief faces Congress amid allegations the automaker deliberately avoided a recall to save money. Follow our live coverage at 11 a.m. ET. Full Article
Braced for tough questions
Factbox: What will change?
Video: Toyota driver's accelerator panic
Autos
Vancouver 2010:
Yuna shows a license to thrill
Kim Yuna's Bond Girl skating routine ended with a mimed pistol firing -- a warning shot to the South Korean's rivals. Full Article | Slideshow
A crush that led to Olympic gold
Games enthralled by emotion on ice
Canada's men's hockey regains footing
2010 Winter Olympics
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 24 February 2010 CORRECTED-Iran says any fuel swap must be on its territory
No home broadband for one-third of US population: survey
Dutch to hold elections on June 9 after govt collapse
US-TECH Summary
US consumer confidence plunges 10.5 points
Intel says hackers attacked around time Google hit
Mobile phone subscriptions to top 5 bln this year
Iraqi politician raises eyebrows with Saudi trip
Sudan to offer Darfur rebels government posts
Mobile phone sales slide in 2009: study
At least 30 killed in fighting in southern Sudan
Google dismisses German concerns over 'Street View'
India-Pakistan talks only the first stepping stone
|
Egypt police kill migrant at Israel border
Intel announces jobs, venture capital plan
Her Facebook status changed to "single?" Ur dumped
China says Google hacking claims "groundless"
Niger junta names Mahamadou Danda prime minister
|
Afghan leader takes control of vote fraud panel
Troops sent to quell unrest in Bangladesh town
Intel says hackers attacked around time Google hit
|
China calls on US to 'undo damage done' by Dalai Lama meet
Xerox sues Google, Yahoo over search patents
|
US general hails Pakistan's arrests of Taliban
Arizona Military Base Shooting Leaves One Dead, One Injured
U.S. commander lauds Pakistani efforts on militants
Mobile phone subscriptions to top 5 bln this year
|
Migrants face peril from Thai registration deadline: HRW
Winter Storm Brings Snow To Central Texas
Li out, Dementieva wins at Malaysia Open tennis
Armed Gunman Robs Pizza Delivery Man Of Food, Cash
Disney And Dooney & Bourke Add New Handbags To Co-Brand Collection
NATO commander makes televised apology to Afghans
KieranTimberlake Wins Competition To Design U.S. Embassy In London
Kathy Griffin Lines Up Rare Alaska Tour Date
Police: 5 dead, 60 buried by Indonesian landslide
Dalai Lama to 'tweet' on Tibet
FDIC's Troubled Bank List Grows In Q4
U.S. Consumer Confidence Tumbles On Employment Concerns
Lisa Lavie And Participants Talk YouTube Version Of "We Are The World"
CMA Announces Dean, Husky, Sherrill And Williams As Newest Hall Of Famers
Toyota chief admits expansion 'too quick'
Japan's Dai-ichi Mutual plans $16.5 billion IPO
India's Maruti recalls 100,000 cars over fuel leak
New Met season to feature Wagner's 'Ring,' higher prices
Abbey Road studios to be listed by British authorities
First Superman comic sells for $1 mln
Abbey Road studios win preservation order
Indonesian police say villager shot in Aceh raid
Bristol Palin to make TV debut in teen pregnancy show
|
Tolstoy takes Christopher Plummer to the Oscars
|
Lindsay Lohan still loves Ronson, hopes to reconcile
|
Universal signs new deal with Lloyd Webber
|
Cheryl Cole to separate from husband
|
British Scientist: "They" Could Already Be Here
Abu Dhabi 'Vanity Plate Record Breaker'
World should avoid isolating Iran: Brazil
US Navy lifts ban on women in submarines: officials
Iraq's March 7 poll could bring peace or chaos
Viewers get a channel of their own on Cablevision
Decompression plan for quake-hit Haitian capital
|
Afghan president takes control of election watchdog
Florida Senator Nelson Wants Re-Examination Of Fishing Restrictions
US would lose cyberwar: former intel chief
Tough road ahead once Afghan assault over
Family Film "Everybody's Fine" Arrives On DVD
Nigerian president returns from Saudi hospital
|
Tenacious D Guitarist's Side Project Trainwreck Chugs Along
Britain warns Afghanistan over election watchdog
Norwegian curlers' trousers fit for a king
Comedian Melissa Peterman Joins Big Machine Records
Pink Visual takes porn piracy battle to US court
A "model" Islamic education from Turkey?
Yahoo partners with Twitter to boost social features
Iran seizes Sunni militant from flight 'in blow to US'
Booted "Idol" Contest Chris Golightly Sings The Blues At Press Conference
Google slashes Nexus phone early termination fee
Intel says hackers attacked around time Google hit
Cuba pushes Latin American cooperation without U.S.
|
Apple eager to field new iPad tablet computer: CFO
Pediatrician Indicted For Abusing 102 Girls Since 1998
Intel victim of cyberattack at same time as Google report
A model Islamic education from Turkey?
|
Agriculture Secretary Reiterates Child Obesity Epidemic, Endorses First Lady's Initiatives
Spirituality May Improve Medical Treatment In Clinically Depressed Patients
Congress Skeptical That Toyota Has Resolved Safety Problems
Vladimir Putin criticizes tycoons who underinvest in power
|
Former Vice President 'Feeling Good' After Mild Heart Attack
Thai red shirts set mass anti-government rally for March
|
Clinton holds talks with UAE foreign minister
Saudi stands trial over Jakarta hotel bombings
US, SKorea envoys visit China amid NKorea hopes
US Army's lax supervision cited in Blackwater case
Police: 15 dead, 57 buried by Indonesian landslide
UN chief: Reject skeptics, climate danger is real
US warns Iran: time and patience 'running out'
Yahoo partners with Twitter to boost social features
|
Compromise climate bill coming
Viewers get a channel of their own on Cablevision
|
Saudi man stands trial over Indonesia bombing
NATO in 'crisis'; Europe averse to military force: Gates
Afghan: US bomb squad on the frontlines
Indonesian landslide death toll, number of missing rise
LG Display considers additional production line
|
US Lawmakers' Toyota connections
Australian spies to pursue people-smugglers abroad
Intel says hackers attacked around time Google hit
|
Watching the Games? Switch on your cellphone
|
Indonesian stands trial over hotel bombings
Google slashes Nexus phone early termination fee
|
China's Communists issue ethics code
Verdict due in Google defamation case in Italy
|
HK economy seen growing 4-5 percent in 2010
Seoul shares fall; Hyundai Motor, LG Display down
Japan exports jump in January on Asian demand
PAKISTAN
G20's future in question amid new challenges
BRIEF-Moody's: risk concentration hits Taiwan banks strength
Seoul shares down; Hyundai Motor, LG Elec retreat
Toyota chiefs blame fast rise, admit recall limits
Taiwan dollar slides, tracks reduced risk appeal
Korea Hot Stocks-LG Elec down after laundry machine problems
Police: 6 dead, 66 buried by Indonesian landslide
More than 70 feared dead in Indonesian landslide
Charlie Sheen follows wife on rehab road
|
Bigelow vs. Cameron in historic Oscar race
|
Comedy director falls for Undomestic Goddess
|
Lee's protege to return to Chinese screens
Winter Games seen on TV by over half of Americans
|
ABC aims to cut 300-400 jobs: source
|
Comedy director falls for "Undomestic Goddess"
Lindsay Lohan still loves Ronson, hopes to reconcile
|
Freestyle's X-factor eyes new frontier
Ben Kingsley gambles on success in Bollywood debut
Charlie Sheen follows wife on rehab road
ABC aims to cut 300-400 jobs: source
Judge OKs another same-sex marriage in Argentina
Winter Games seen on TV by over half of Americans
"Assassin's Creed" book plays off videogame
Burberry flies high at London Fashion Week
Fighting in Afghan assault slows, residents flee
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down syndrome video
General strike grips Greece, grounds flights
|
Greek workers strike over austerity plan
Italy convicts Google executives over bullying video
Karzai criticized over Afghan poll watchdog move
|
EU probing trio of Google complaints
Woman Left 11-Year-Old Daughter Home Alone To Vacation In Florida
Son of Hamas co-founder 'spied for Israelis'
U.S. missile strike kills 8 militants in Pakistan
|
VH1's "Famous Crime Scene" Profiles Death Of Michael Jackson With New Details
Google faces EU scrutiny after complaints
Dubai now seeking 26 suspects in Hamas killing
|
LG Display considers additional production line
Authorities Identify School Shooting Suspect; One Victim Critical
Israel to push China to support Iran sanctions
|
Twitter tweets fly into search results
Matt Damon Rumored To Play RFK In Planned Biopic
Three Lebanese charged with spying for Israel
|
Indian Vegetable May Slow Or Kill Breast Cancer Cells
Sudan to free 57 Darfur rebels: justice minister
|
Germany parries Greek broadside over Nazi occupation
|
Jennifer Lopez Parts Ways With Longtime Label
Russia says won't back crippling Iran sanctions
|
LG Display considers additional production line
U.S. missile strike kills 8 militants in Pakistan
Army says gunbattle kills 6 in Indian Kashmir
Google execs convicted in Italy for Down's video
|
Expert: China GM rice may be market-ready by 2013
Expert: Jemaah Islamiyah offshoot ran Aceh camp
Afghan provincial official gunned down in south
Intel officials: US missiles kill 4 in NW Pakistan
Google faces EU scrutiny after complaints
|
Google scraps China leg of Nexus One event: source
|
S.Korea's Kim sets new skating record
China sent 300,000 tons of food to N.Korea last year
Intel officials: US missiles kill 3 in NW Pakistan
Bangladesh arrests more than 70 in ethnic violence
Global recovery doubts send Asian markets lower
PREVIEW-Taiwan Jan export orders growth seen most on record
Malaysia says economy out of recession
Report: China restricts loans to local government
Hyundai recalls new Sonata sedan over latches
China's Hummer buy may take private equity route
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Japan stocks down on yen rise, weak US data
Shhh! Indians told to keep the noise down
World trade suffers biggest drop since WWII
Have babies to win gold, say Russian champions
Google's China recruitment despite withdraw threat
Bigelow vs. Cameron in historic Oscar race
Saudi man funded Indonesian militants, trial hears
Once a renegade, Tarantino turns Hollywood insider
|
Emily Dickinson's desire explored in U.S. novel
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights