Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Afghan security plans 'a tall order'
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Afghan security plans 'a tall order'
AFP - Monday, November 23
Send
IM Story
Print
Afghan security plans 'a tall order'
KABUL (AFP) - – Afghan government plans to boost army and police numbers massively have been greeted with scepticism by diplomats and military experts who say the figures are too ambitious.
Afghanistan lacks the capacity to recruit and train men in large enough numbers, they said, despite a pledge by President Hamid Karzai to take over the nation's security from foreign troops by the end of his new five-year term.
Defence Minister Abdul Rahim Wardak used a ceremony on Saturday in Kabul, where NATO took over command of Afghan army training from the United States, to announce that security force numbers would be cranked up to 400,000.
"Our programme is to have a total of 240,000 soldiers," ministry spokesman Zahir Azimi told AFP, more than double the current total of about 100,000.
The hope is to have 150,000 by the end of next year, he added, with the rest "in following years".
Police numbers would rise to 160,000 from the current 97,000, said Zamarai Bashary, interior ministry spokesman, with the deadline "under discussion".
Experts said recruiting such numbers would be difficult because Afghanistan lacks a pool of literate young men, as well as veterans with leadership skills, facilities for training and grooming, and money for weapons and ammunition.
"That means they will have to be raising trained soldiers at a rate of 3,000 people per month -- that's a very tall order," said a military attache in Kabul, speaking on condition of anonymity.
"They will have to find more than 100,000 at least semi-educated young men who are volunteers to join the army. It will be difficult," he said.
Afghanistan's first batch of 120 officers passed out earlier this year after four years' training at the National Military Academy.
NATO said that 800 troops, or three companies, graduated from an accelerated combat-training programme on Sunday, taking the Afghan army a "step closer to meeting its goal" of extra troops.
After their five weeks of training, the forces would be deployed across the country, NATO's International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) said.
Increasing police numbers involved similar problems to the army, said a Western diplomat, speaking anonymously.
Wardak spoke "prematurely," he said, as interior ministry working groups are yet to complete reports on which such decisions will be based.
"There is no way we can recruit that many people," the diplomat said.
"The numbers are political. The Afghans are under pressure from the United States to boost the numbers, but the Afghans are also putting on the pressure for support to do so."
Western allies are pressuring Karzai to bolster security forces and take responsibility for the war, now into a ninth year against Taliban-led insurgents, so their own forces can be drawn down.
Afghan defence forces are backed by more than 100,000 NATO and US soldiers taking the operational lead in battling the insurgents, who are spreading their footprint across the country.
The United States and NATO are eager to cut deployments in response to Western public opinion, which increasingly wants troops to return home.
US President Barack Obama is considering a large increase in US troop numbers, expected to be announced after Thursday's Thanksgiving holiday and to include a component of trainers.
General Stanley McChrystal, US and NATO commander in Afghanistan, has adopted a strategy called "partnering" in which Afghan and foreign soldiers train, live and fight together.
But NATO commanders, who last month approved a plan to accelerate the training programme, said the Afghan army is plagued by desertions and drug addiction.
Out of the some 94,000 Afghan soldiers trained so far, 10,000 have deserted, said General Egon Ramms, commander of the operational headquarters in charge of ISAF. Some 15 percent are drug addicts, he said.
The police, one member of which shot dead five British soldiers this month, are prone to corruption and their training has been inefficient, he said.
McChrystal plans to double the size of the Afghan police within a few years. Their losses are expected to reach 1,500 killed this year, and some 10,000 are AWOL.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Philippine kidnappers kill 21 in 'political massacre' AFP - 2 hours 8 minutes ago
Yemen captors of Japanese hostage insist on swap AFP - 2 hours 34 minutes ago
China 'sentences quake activist to three years' AFP - 2 hours 56 minutes ago
Gunmen fire on Americans' home in Indonesia AFP - Tuesday, November 24
Anger builds as China mine toll hits 104 AFP - Tuesday, November 24
News Search
Top Stories
Atlantis astronauts begin third and last spacewalk
U2 to headline Glastonbury festival
Atlantis astronauts begin final spacewalk
Executives testify in Airbus insider trading probe
OECD area shakes off recession with fragile rebound
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Antarctic ice loss vaster, faster than thought: study
BA warns cabin crew over strike: report
Crisis forcing hard-up Spaniards to sell their hair
Harnessing the power of salt, Norway tries osmotic power
US economy will 'bounce back': Indian PM
More Most Viewed »
Alcohol helps cut heart disease risk for men: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 23 November 2009 Failed N. Ireland car bomb highlights terror threat
Iran releases ex-official on bail in mass trial
Dissidents suspected in N. Ireland bomb attempt
Alleged Iraq bombers offer confessions
Egypt's president warns Israel over Jerusalem
Sudan delays elections by six days
| International
|
Iran wants nuclear fuel guarantees
Saudi troops killed in Yemen rebel clashes: report
| International
|
Iran's Mousavi tells government to end intimidation
Iran's Mousavi tells government to end intimidation
| International
|
Algeria court acquits two ex-Guantanamo detainees
| International
|
Pakistan troops repulse militant attack
Iran begins war games to protect atom sites
RI bishop asked Kennedy in 2007 to avoid Communion
Police identify gunman in deadly Saipan rampage
Indonesian ferry sinks; 29 dead, some 240 rescued
Democrats: Health care bill saves money and jobs
Officials: Pakistani troops kill some 40 militants
Va. Military Institute faces sexism accusations
China mine explosion death toll reaches 92
Senate moderates frustrate other Democrats on bill
Dalai Lama says Obama not soft on China
Durbin says deadline looming for health care bill
NRC investigating radiation at Three Mile Island
Indonesian ferry sinks; 25 dead, some 240 rescued
Schumer says public option can pass the Senate
China's defense minister travels to North Korea
Indonesian ferry sinks; 15 dead, some 230 rescued
Nelson might not back next step for health bill
Senate Dems frustrated with sway held by moderates
Smash Twilight sequel enters record books
| Entertainment
|
Jackson, Swift face off at American Music Awards
Tensions between British, US military over Iraq
BA warns cabin crew over strike: report
China families protest mine disaster, toll hits 104
| International
|
News Corp, Microsoft hold talks on Google: report
Iraq says October 25 bombers came from Syria: spokesman
Spanish PM vows sweeping reforms to boost economy
Harnessing the power of salt, Norway tries osmotic power
eBay apologizes for technical glitch in search function
Indonesian ferry sinks; 29 dead, most survive
| International
|
Laptop becomes reality for Uruguay's schoolchildren
Iraqi parliament fails to reach election deal
| International
|
Sudan delays elections by six days
Somali pirates holding 12-year-old hostage: Spanish skipper
US-TECH Summary
US economy will 'bounce back': Indian PM
eBay says fixes search glitch on website
China quake activist jailed for three years
| International
|
Antarctic ice loss vaster, faster than thought: study
Pakistani militant group an intractable Indian foe
| International
|
Saudi troops killed in Yemen rebel clashes: report
| International
|
Laptop becomes reality for Uruguay's schoolchildren
eBay says fixes search glitch on website
| Technology
|
Study: kids watching hours of TV at home daycare
Winners at the American Music Awards
Japan mulls F-35 purchase as next main fighter jet
Australia battles wildfires as threat eases: officials
S.Korea ignores N.Korea offer to resume tours
Palin dines, prays with Rev. Billy Graham in NC
Chinese dissident Huang Qi sentenced to 3 years
SF area officer, passenger injured during arrest
4 Taiwan fishing vessels detained by Myanmar
Hundreds rescued as 29 die in Indonesia ferry sinking
Key senators seek changes on US health care bill
Khmer Rouge prison chief anxious as trial wraps up
China quake activist jailed for three years
Swimmers, poets among 2010 Rhodes Scholars from US
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Grand Canyon to change 'unfair' permit system
Demonstration at UC Santa Cruz ends peacefully
Cambodia begins final arguments in KRouge jail chief trial
Taiwan to curb Chinese investment in key sectors: report
Miners' families want answers in China mine blast
NZ consumer confidence eases in November -survey
Survivors recount China mine disaster; 104 dead
S.Korea won up on stock-linked deals, trade data
Seoul shares rangebound;KEB jumps on Hana interest
S.Korean bonds down on KDI report, auctions
Japan markets closed
Taylor Swift wins five American Music Awards
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares open up on foreign buying, KEB
Michael Jackson's glove sells for $350,000 at auction
| Entertainment
|
Hundreds rescued, 29 die as Indonesia ferry sinks
Winners at the American Music Awards
Taylor Swift wins five American Music Awards
Sting warns of hydroelectric project in Amazon
Two hurt as bulls flee Tom Cruise film set
'New Moon' wolfs down $140.7M in opening weekend
Flashy Indian brides struggle with high gold prices
Attorney: Jackson's doctor returning to work
Ubisoft steps up videogame fitness with virtual coach
Rare Charles Darwin book in toilet in Britain
Iran police arrest 12 couples for partner swapping
Executives testify in Airbus insider trading probe
Spotify launches application for Nokia phones
Iraq parliament passes new vote law
| International
|
OECD area shakes off recession with fragile rebound
Iran prez seeks new legitimacy in visit to Brazil
Atlantis astronauts begin third and last spacewalk
IMF head says world economy 'highly vulnerable'
Two Afghan ministers suspected of embezzlement
| International
|
Pakistani forces attack Taliban, kill 22
| International
|
Afghan security plans 'a tall order'
Murky ocean depths hide abundance of life
Israel-Hamas prisoner swap deal near: officials
| International
|
Remains of British hostage found in Lebanon
| International
|
Taiwan to curb China investment: report
Lochte ends Phelps's reign as swimmer of year
Khmer Rouge torturer had broad autonomy, lawyer says
| International
|
Gunmen kill 21 in Philippine political war
| International
|
India tests nuclear-capable missile after sunset
| International
|
Spotify launches application for Nokia phones
Microsoft, News Corp weigh web pact: source
| Technology
|
Tweets or bleats? Tool measures importance on Twitter
| Technology
|
Transgender murderer renews electrolysis request
Gunmen kill 21 in Philippine political war
Lawyer: 9/11 defendants want platform for views
Gunfire at home of US teachers in Indonesia's Aceh
21 Filipinos killed on way to file election papers
Medical marijuana finds social outlet in Ore. cafe
Obama to speak on education, present rights award
Khmer Rouge torturer had broad autonomy, lawyer says
The nation's weather
Philippine kidnappers kill 21 in 'political massacre'
Zimbabwe women, receiving rights award, speak out
Philippine army says 21 people killed in south
FBI wants public's help in civil rights killings
AP NewsAlert
Trial for Khmer Rouge prison chief concludes
Gunmen kill 21 in Philippine political violence
Reliance shares rise over 3% on LyondellBasell bid
Taiwan export orders see first rise in 13 months
JAL seeks 40% pension benefits cut for bailout
Gold hits record high past $1,160 per ounce
Cuba film institute founder looks back on 50 years
PREVIEW-Pakistani c.bank likely to slash policy rate
Taiwan jobless rate drops in October
Bio-fuel growth raises concerns about forests
Smash Twilight sequel enters record books
| Entertainment
|
Two foreign funds compete to buy S.Korea builder
S.Korea c.bank to call in Fed-funded bank loans
Indonesia president set to act on corruption scandal
CORRECTED-Indonesian ferry with over 200 people on board sinks
China's Haitong Securities to buy Hong Kong broker
Brad Pitt's production company enters Dark Void
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights