Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
New mammogram advice raises questions, concerns
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
New mammogram advice raises questions, concerns
By JOCELYN NOVECK,AP National Writer -
Wednesday, November 18
Send
IM Story
Print
NEW YORK – For many women, getting a mammogram is already one of life's more stressful experiences.
Now, women in their 40s have the added anxiety of trying to figure out if they should even be getting one at all.
A government task force said Monday that most women don't need mammograms in their 40s and should get one every two years starting at 50 _ a stunning reversal and a break with the American Cancer Society's long-standing position. What's more, the panel said breast self-exams do no good, and women shouldn't be taught to do them.
The news seemed destined to leave many deeply confused about whose advice to follow.
"I've never had a scare, but isn't it better to be safe than sorry?" asked Beth Rosenthal, 41, sitting in a San Francisco cafe on Monday afternoon with her friend and their small children. "I've heard of a lot of women in their 40s, and even 30s, who've gotten breast cancer. It just doesn't seem right to wait until 50."
Her friend agreed. "I don't think I'll wait," said Leslie David-Jones, also 41, shaking her head.
For most of the past two decades, the American Cancer Society has been recommending annual mammograms beginning at 40, and it reiterated that position on Monday. "This is one screening test I recommend unequivocally, and would recommend to any woman 40 and over," the society's chief medical officer, Dr. Otis Brawley, said in a statement.
But the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, a government panel of doctors and scientists, concluded that such early and frequent screenings often lead to false alarms and unneeded biopsies, without substantially improving women's odds of survival.
"The benefits are less and the harms are greater when screening starts in the 40s," said Dr. Diana Petitti, vice chair of the panel.
Breast cancer survivors who were diagnosed at a young age were among the more vocal critics of the new guidelines.
"This sure seems like a big step backwards to me," said Debbie Hayes, who was diagnosed with Stage 2 breast cancer at age 33 after finding a lump during a self-exam. A mammogram, ultrasound, biopsy and finally a mastectomy and chemotherapy followed.
"People are being diagnosed even in their early 20s," said Hayes, now 53 and a volunteer coordinator for the Chicago-based Breast Cancer Network of Strength. "Mammograms are a key element of that."
But another breast cancer survivor thought the new guidelines sounded about right _ even though she was diagnosed at age 37, two years ago.
"They seem pretty sensible to me," said Claire Mayne, of San Francisco. "The death rate is not going down because of the earlier mammograms. I'd feel comfortable telling a friend to wait until she was 50."
Mayne was more doubtful, though, about the advice on self-exams; that's how she found her own cancer.
Most women in their 40s interviewed for this article said they planned to stick with the old mammography recommendations, at least for now.
"I have two young children," said Amber Smart, a 47-year-old mother in Agoura Hills, Calif. "There's a lot of years left that they need me." She's been having mammograms every six months, since she was 44, to make sure that certain dense areas of her breasts aren't cancer.
"I think it's kind of sad that they're basically saying, 'We can't afford to pay for the few people who may have it in their 40s, so a few people are going to die,'" Smart said.
Judy Finley, a flight attendant from Dallas, called the new recommendations "a terrible idea," and said she was especially worried that insurance companies might "pick up on this and quit paying for mammograms from 40 to 50."
"I think it would be really sad," said Finley, who was walking through the Crown Center mall in Kansas City, Mo. "And I don't know how the U.S. government or a panel of government officials can think they know better than the American Cancer Society."
But there were those who saw the new guidelines as potentially a relief, a development that could save women from endless stress, false positives and perhaps needless procedures.
"I can't tell you how many friends I have who've gone through severe worries from false scares," said Maren Waxenberg, a Manhattan mother. "At least three of them have had biopsies. And it turned out to be nothing."
Waxenberg herself, 46, has not yet had a mammogram. "I'm not concerned at this age," she said. "I plan to do it, but there's no sense of urgency."
The new guidelines are for the general population, not those at high risk of breast cancer because of family history or gene mutations.
They say:
_Most women in their 40s should not routinely get mammograms.
_Women 50 to 74 should get a mammogram every other year until they turn 75, after which the risks and benefits are unknown. (The task force's previous guidelines had no upper limit and called for exams every year or two.)
_The value of breast exams by doctors is unknown. And breast self-exams are of no value.
Medical groups such as the cancer society have been backing off promoting breast self-exams in recent years. Decades ago, the practice was so heavily promoted that organizations distributed cards to be hung in the shower demonstrating the circular motion women should use to feel for lumps.
As for mammography, the panel's new recommendations are more in line with international guidelines, which call for screening to start at age 50; the World Health Organization recommends the test every two years, and Britain says every three years.
They were sharply challenged by the cancer society on Monday.
"The task force advice is based on its conclusion that screening 1,300 women in their 50s to save one life is worth it, but that screening 1,900 women in their 40s to save a life is not, Brawley wrote.
That stance "is essentially telling women that mammography at age 40 to 49 saves lives, just not enough of them," he added.
But Dr. Amy Abernethy of the Duke Comprehensive Cancer Center agreed with the task force's changes.
"Overall, I think it really took courage for them to do this," she said. "It does ask us as doctors to change what we do and how we communicate with patients. That's no small undertaking."
__
Associated Press writers Marilynn Marchione in Milwaukee, Stephanie Nano in New York, Evelyn Nieves in San Francisco and Heather Hollingsworth in Kansas City, Mo., contributed to this story.
___
On the Net:
Government advice: http://www.ahrq.gov/clinic/uspstf/uspsbrca.htm
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
More charges against dad, sons in child sex case AP - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
Foreign demand rises for long-term US assets AP - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
Iran says UN watchdog has cleared nuclear program AP - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
Astronauts inspect space shuttle in case of damage AP - 1 hour 19 minutes ago
Colo. medical pot suppliers will have to pay taxes AP - 1 hour 23 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Sarah Palin pushes book - and possible comeback
Stamp out bank secrecy, corruption watchdog says
British inflation climbs 1.5%: official data
UBS targets annual pre-tax profits
Fed seeking to ensure strong dollar: Bernanke
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Paris rampage after cash giveaway cancelled: police
Mystery of Bangladesh's mass arsenic poisoning solved
Still losing cash, GM to repay aid early, plans 2010 IPO
OPEC head: $75 to $80 a barrel a 'good price'
Space shuttle Atlantis launches
More Most Viewed »
Somali centenarian weds 17-year-old
Fibre may keep asthma, diabetes at bay, study finds
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 17 November 2009 French van heist anti-hero surrenders in Monaco
UN nuclear watchdog wants more answers from Iran
Samsung, Acer team up with AT&T on netbooks
GM to repay aid early, sees 2010 share offering
Diary of Mussolini's mistress reveals rabid anti-Semite
In China, Obama says sites like Twitter should be open
EU welcomes deal to cut tuna catch by 40%
Israel could annex more of West Bank
Deadly attack as French general meets Afghans
India plans fingerprint IDs for billion-plus citizens
Secrecy raises fears of more Iran atom sites
Cisco raises offer on Norway's Tandberg
U.S. demands Kenya deliver Rwanda genocide suspect
| International
|
IBM makes Big Blue cloud
Six killed, 6 wounded in Kirkuk car bomb blast
U.N. preparing Iraq-Kuwait reconciliation plan
| International
|
Nintendo Wii may provide actual exercise: study
Iraq presidency puts January vote in doubt
Gaddafi asks food summit to stop Africa landgrab
| International
|
Iran taunts nuclear 'enemies' amid new US warning
Afghanistan launches unit to tackle corruption
Samsung, Acer team up with AT&T on netbooks
Yemen tribesmen kidnap Japanese engineer: local official
12 Afghans dead in attack targeting French general
Japan, US to seek 'solution' to Okinawa base row
Afghan gov't announces anti-corruption squad
9 killed, 58 hurt in Bangladesh bus collision
Families seek support for 3 hikers jailed in Iran
India fraud office to prosecute Satyam founder
Japan's economy posts strongest growth since 2007
Pfizer move a new blow to Conn. city in land fight
YouTube gets Hispanic shows in Univision deal
| Technology
|
Obama presses Internet freedoms in China
Pro-Cuba embargo money flows to US lawmakers
LA pushes to get repaid for $3M Jackson memorial
Police find body of missing 5-year-old NC girl
Millions will have to repay part of tax credit
Top Rwanda genocide fugitive in Kenya: US envoy
Fed cracks down on gift card abuses
Feds: Kuwaiti company conspired to defraud US
Trial delayed for former nurse charged in killings
Michelin to invest $867 mln in Indian tyre plant
Grameenphone soars on Dhaka bourse debut
Taiwan, China sign pact on financial firm exchange
Pakistani shares rise; rupee firms
Q&A: New Leona Lewis CD echos growth, strength
Janet Jackson blames doctor for Michael's death
| Entertainment
|
Fearless kids more likely to be adult criminals: study
Palin says presidency not on my radar screen
| Entertainment
|
Century-old whisky to be retrieved from polar ice
Enid Blyton banned by BBC for decades: memos
YouTube gets Hispanic shows in Univision deal
| Entertainment
|
Where have all the protests gone? US students in limbo
Calls mount for woman to take a top EU post
France's top rap artist makes comeback
LA pushes to get repaid for $3M Jackson memorial
Wicker Man, Equalizer actor Edward Woodward dies
Study: Plastic Chemical May Make Boys Effeminate
Hundreds Of Emiratis Blacklisted For 'Lax 'Attitude Towards Work
Ft. Pierce Man Leaps From Moving Car To Avoid Crack Cocaine Arrest
Texas Man Crashes $1 Million Car Into Lake
Former High School Student Returns Library Books 51 Years Later
Vintage Champagne Bottle From Former Princess Diana's Wedding Expected To Sell For More Than $2,000
Prince Harry Smooches Male Admirer For Beer
Franchise Sues Burger King Over $1 Double Cheeseburger
UN: Once-secret Iran nuke plant to start in 2011
European ministers agree Albania should be EU candidate
IAEA sees risk Iran hiding more nuclear activity
| International
|
One-fourth of teen drivers text behind the wheel
Fed seeking to ensure strong dollar: Bernanke
IAEA sees risk Iran hiding more nuclear activity
'Unfriend' is New Oxford American word of the year
Still losing cash, GM to repay aid early, plans 2010 IPO
French van heist anti-hero surrenders in Monaco
Palestinians seek EU support for independence
Semiconductor revenue to fall 11 percent: Gartner
U.N. court overturns Rwandan's genocide conviction
| International
|
Thirteen anti-Qaeda tribe members killed in Iraq
Internet inches closer to 'internationalisation'
Space shuttle Atlantis launches
Israel warns Palestinians over seeking recognition
Oldest US newspaper for gays and lesbians shutting down
Gunmen kill 13 men execution style west of Baghdad
France welcomes Iraqi leader for state visit
Afghanistan launches unit to tackle corruption
Taiwan, China may develop electric cars together
Europe's first 'personalised paper' rolls off the presses
European publishers give Google book deal cautious welcome
Microsoft co-founder Allen diagnosed with cancer
| Technology
|
YouTube launches channel for citizen journalists
| Technology
|
Wildfire almost contained in Southern Calif.
Obama: US, China want climate change deal
CAPITAL CULTURE: Sotomayor adds celebrity to court
Obama: China has helped US pull out of recession
Obama urges early China talks with Dalai Lama reps
In-orbit inspection scheduled for space shuttle
Time Warner to spin off AOL on December 9
| Technology
|
Group: Founder of Tibetan Web site gets 15 years
Reports: Army to probe alleged shooter's career
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
N.Korea kidnapped Chinese in refugee crackdown: report
Kuwaiti firm charged with defrauding US military
Unfriend is US dictionary's 2009 word of the year
Twins separated after marathon Australia surgery
Obama, Hu open key talks in Beijing
Washington pilot gets 25 years for molesting boys
SKorea sets greenhouse gas reduction target
Navy: Missing plane wreckage found off Texas coast
China fuels US foreign student boom
Journalists kept in court after Jackson MD leaves
Palin talks politics, family ahead of book release
Seoul shares fall, program selling extends losses
S.Korea c.bank rate policy to focus on growth
OECD sees S.Korea growth above 4 pct in 2010-report
Korea Hot Stocks
Underwood says Idol winners should play to fans
| Entertainment
|
S.Korean bonds up on U.S. lead, govt support plans
Seoul shares gain; LG Elec, Tong Yang Life up
YouTube launches channel for citizen journalists
| Entertainment
|
SunPower investigates possible accounting errors
Peter Jackson asked to up the agony in Lovely Bones
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea Oct dept store sales growth at 14-mth high
New hit film 2012 beats estimate by $5 million
| Entertainment
|
YouTube launches channel for citizen journalists
Composer Legrand spinning windmills of his mind
| Entertainment
|
Taiwan signs financial agreements with China
Susan Boyle reveals she was hit, bullied as child
Composer Legrand spinning windmills of his mind
Palin talks politics, family ahead of book release
Mass. judge tosses lawsuit against Hasselbeck
Underwood says "Idol" winners should play to fans
Michael Jackson's father to challenge star's will
New hit film "2012" beats estimate by $5 million
Fan frenzy at LA premiere of 'New Moon'
Heidi, Spencer Pratt shopping own reality TV show
US-TECH Summary
Britain plans Afghan handover conference
Ransom paid for Spanish trawler: Somali pirates
NATO chief confident of big troop increase
| International
|
CORRECTED:Qualcomm CEO pins hopes on China, smartbooks
UBS targets annual pre-tax profits
Israel army punishes troops for settlement protest
Sarkozy urges Middle East peace talks
Obama says China agrees on Iran nuclear transparency
| International
|
Pakistan seizes main Taliban bases
| International
|
Microsoft co-founder diagnosed with cancer
Baghdad's once ravaged zoo comes back to life
Soldiers' mutiny raises concern in Israel
| International
|
Lingering effects of Baghdad blasts on Iraqis
New site shows Iran insists on enrichment
| International
|
Recognizing Palestinian state premature: EU
| International
|
Israel rebuffs calls for Jerusalem settlement halt
| International
|
Civilian death toll almost trebled in Afghan attack
| International
|
Baghdad's once ravaged zoo comes back to life
| International
|
Report: EU ignoring Turkmen rights abuses
4 dead in car-train crash near SC-GA state line
Death toll passes 30 in Myanmar ferry sinking
Rally at Cleveland bodies house thanks coroner
Yemen says talks underway to free Japanese hostage
Qualcomm CEO pins hopes on China, smartbooks
| Technology
|
Methodology for AP poll on health care and taxes
Scores feared dead in Myanmar ferry crash: officials
Texas A&M remembering fatal '99 bonfire collapse
Amazon to launch Kindle in Canada
| Technology
|
Suspected rebels attack freight train in India
Death Of Chicago Board of Education Ruled As Suicide Amid Doubts
The nation's weather
Driver Trying To Flee Florida Accident Causes Fiery Crash Killing Another Motorist
Report: 49 Million, Or 14.6 Percent, Of Americans Hungry; 1.02 Billion Hungry Worldwide
Obama pushes human rights in meetings with Chinese
'Premature' to recognise Palestine state, says EU
Postal Service Delivers News Of $3.8 Billion Deficit
Afghan officials worried over bold attack in east
Global health alliance targets chronic illnesses
Polls: At Least 60 Percent Of Voters Think Palin Unqualified For 2012
New mammogram advice raises questions, concerns
Obama prods China on yuan but Hu silent
Update: Shuttle Atlantis Successfully Launches Astronauts On Work Commute To Space
AP IMPACT: Tobacco execs quickly find tax loophole
Police Find Body Of Missing NC Girl Dumped Along Highway
SPIN METER: Did Obama grovel?
USGS Reports Central Oklahoma Rocked By Second Earthquake In 48 Hours
Parents Of Murdered Anchorwoman Accepts Life Sentence On Killer
Hutchison Decides Against Leaving Senate During Governor Race
Pakistan stocks end down; monetary policy on Nov 24
Vietnam Internet users fear Facebook blackout
IMF chief urges China to let yuan rise
Court rules against Microsoft in China font case
Kia's US auto plant begins production
Pakistani c.banks buys 21 bln rupees of T-bills
Taiwan banks eye branches in China after MOU: report
Sarah Palin says presidency not on my radar screen
| Entertainment
|
Crawford's attempted blackmailer turns self in
Florence + The Machine: the voice that bewitched pop
Indian Skies To Be Lit Up With Annual Meteor Shower With A Slight Difference
Antidepressant Increases Libido In Women
Four Pacquiao Fans Die From Heart Attack While Watching Boxing Bout
Brazilian Police Search For Blogger Who Exposes Cheating Women
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights