Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Afghan outlook bleak as Taliban grabs territory
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Afghan outlook bleak as Taliban grabs territory
By JASON STRAZIUSO,Associated Press Writer -
Monday, October 12
Send
IM Story
Print
KABUL – My closest Afghan friend held out his Taliban-era photo. A decade younger, he had a thick black beard that the oppressive regime forced men to grow.
My friend won't grow one again. He is already thinking about when to flee.
As generals, politicians and pundits in Washington debate the next best step for America's eight-year war in Afghanistan, the Taliban takes new territory by the day, despite the record 64,000 U.S. troops here.
I arrived in Afghanistan in spring 2006, just as violence began to explode. I leave after three years as the chief correspondent for The Associated Press, and never have things seemed so ominous. As one of America's top military analysts, Anthony Cordesman, says: The U.S. "is now decisively losing."
No one thinks Kabul will fall while American forces are here. But even top U.S. commander Gen. Stanley McChrystal's latest assessment says that without reversing insurgent momentum in the next 12 months, defeating the insurgency will no longer be possible.
The quiet truth whispered by soldiers in the field and aid workers in Kabul is that the Afghan government is not likely to ever control southern Afghanistan's wildlands, the foreboding territory beyond the provincial capitals.
Villagers fear thieving police more than militants, and the August presidential election laid bare how pervasive corruption is here. The Taliban is playing to the general disgust with corruption by offering itself as an alternative.
Mullah Abdul Salam Zaeef, a large man with a woolly black beard, once served as the Taliban's ambassador to Pakistan. He always greets me with a smile and seems an unlikely representative for a hardline regime. He uses an iPhone _ though his grandson recently broke it.
Zaeef is a conduit between the Afghan government and Mullah Omar's Taliban. Zaeef told me the militant leadership refers to its forces not as Taliban now, but as "mujahedeen," a throwback to the Afghan "holy warriors" who ousted the Soviet Union at the end of the 1980s. The reason is that only one out of 10 militant fighters is a true "Taliban." The rest are ordinary Afghans, Zaeef said.
That bodes extremely ill for U.S. and NATO efforts.
"Every day you are killing people. Dozens of people. They have brothers, they have fathers, they have sons," Zaeef said. "The Taliban are my brothers, the Taliban are my sons. The Taliban are my cousins. They are not different from us. They did not come from the sky. They did not come from another Earth. They are all from Afghanistan."
McChrystal wants to shift the fight from killing militants to protecting the population. But the U.S. is now eight years into the fight, and there are signs _ the spreading of the insurgency to the north, rising U.S. deaths _ that it could be too late.
McChrystal knows the issue of civilian deaths caused by U.S. forces has turned many Afghans against the West. I witnessed my first such deaths in the summer of 2006, when I shadowed Lt. Will Felder and his platoon on a night-time helicopter invasion of Helmand province's Baghran valley.
Felder, a West Point graduate who left the Army in June after fulfilling his five-year commitment, battled in Helmand, Kandahar and Paktika provinces. He is frank about his time here.
"The things that we were able to accomplish tactically obviously were useless. You can pretty much point to every area we gained, to any sort of tactical success, and in the intervening years those areas have been lost and gained tactically many times," Felder told me from Atlanta, where he is a first-year law student.
"The only thing I can take away from it being successful is none of my soldiers got killed," he said.
It waas on Felder's mission in Baghran that I saw a B-1 bomber destroy a mud house that militants had overrun, killing an apparently innocent elderly couple inside.
"We moved into an area, secured it, at the loss of American lives and certainly Afghan lives, spending a great deal of money and making promises to civilians in the area," he said. "And then we left."
The U.S. was also slow to identify the Taliban comeback for what it was. A top U.S. military official in Kabul told me that for too many years the rising violence here was mistakenly seen as a rise in crime, the drug trade, and corruption. Instead, he said, it was the beginning of an insurgency against the government.
The Taliban's leaders, and their al-Qaida partners in Pakistan, decided to make a stand, "to fight the West," the official said.
Now, the harsh social rules that Taliban imposed under their reign in the 1990s have already returned _ or never left _ in many of Afghanistan's hinterlands, like rural Helmand. Women can't leave the house unaccompanied. Music and movies are banned. Beards are mandated.
As Washington debates whether to send 10,000, 20,000 or 40,000 more forces, it's worth remembering that a former top commander here, U.S. Gen. Dan McNeill, said in an interview with NPR last summer that "well over 400,000" troops are needed to tame the country. He then called it "an absurd figure," because Afghanistan will never see that many troops. U.S. and NATO forces now number 100,000. The Afghan army has 90,000.
After eight years, fewer Americans than ever support the war. More troops would mean more forces driving over increasingly lethal roadside bombs.
There is little domestic support for the decades of work Afghanistan requires. That's why, Zaeef told me, Taliban leaders, militant commanders and ordinary Afghans are already laying the groundwork to prevent another civil war when the U.S. and NATO draw down.
"Afghans have to decide the future, to make a solution for the future. I think many people they are trying to do that," Zaeef said. "It's not guaranteed that civil war will not happen, but the people are trying to prevent it." He would not elaborate.
Peace talks between the Taliban and President Hamid Karzai's government in Saudi Arabia last year went nowhere, said Zaeef, who took part in the failed attempt. U.S. officials say talks are unlikely now that the Taliban has the upper hand.
The latest fiasco _ the Aug. 20 election _ was so widely rigged that it will take months of investigations to declare a winner. Worse yet, the fraud has shown the world precisely how crooked the Afghan government is, bringing the most salient question to the fore: Do American families want their sons and daughters to die to defend it?
Russia's ambassador to Afghanistan, Zamir Kabulov, recently told AP that McChrystal is trying his best to succeed, but that "at this stage it will be very difficult for him to change the direction" of the war.
"The more troops you bring the more troubles you will have here," said Kabulov, who knows from the experience of the Soviets, who were defeated bitterly in Afghanistan more than two decades ago.
My memories of Afghanistan will last forever: The kids chasing kites. Cringing every time a U.S. convoy passed, because of the threat of a bomb attack. Hearing bullets whiz over my head while in the field with troops. Seeing a rare woman driver. And seeing a little Afghan girl burned within an inch of her life by white phosphorus rescued by U.S. military doctors.
A best-case scenario for the country is that the U.S. and NATO train enough Afghan soldiers to protect the provincial capitals, and the U.S. maintains a small counter-terrorism force to watch over al-Qaida and Pakistan. The wild hinterlands will be left for the Taliban.
But Zaeef believes the Taliban will rule again one day, though they may not be able to take Kabul by force. How long will America stay? As the Taliban likes to say: "The Americans have the watches, but the Taliban has the time."
That is why my Afghan friend has already decided he will sell his home and leave Afghanistan if the Taliban infiltrate Kabul. My friend survived one Taliban regime. He is now laying plans so he won't have to do it again.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US choppers bring aid in stricken Philippine city AP - Monday, October 12
UN chief acknowledges fraud in Afghan vote AP - Monday, October 12
Police say Irish priest abducted in Philippines AP - Monday, October 12
Commandos storm Pakistan army HQ, freeing 39 hostages AFP - Monday, October 12
Gunmen abduct Irish priest in southern Philippines: police AFP - Monday, October 12
News Search
Top Stories
Dollar facing 'power-shift': analysts
Boyzone singer Gately dies in Spain
Russian economy to shrink 7.5% in 2009: Medvedev
First clown in space lands back on Earth
Opel rescue dogged by European divisions
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Boyzone singer Gately dies in Spain
First clown in space lands back on Earth
Obama slams big business on credit reforms
Airlines set own emission targets
NASA blasts moon with rocket in search for water
More Most Viewed »
Oldest hominid skeleton sheds light on human origins
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 12 October 2009 US envoy leaves Mideast without peace talks deal
N.Ireland republican group 'to renounce violence'
Three blasts kill at least 16 in western Iraq
Abbas defends delay of Gaza war crime report vote
| International
|
Triple attacks kill 19 in western Iraqi city
Afghan vote fraud 'significant': UN special envoy
Victim's parents hang young Iranian murderer
Chavez says Obama did nothing to deserve Nobel
| International
|
Sri Lanka's president scores new election win
| International
|
U.S. experts train Iraqis to tackle bomb scourge
'Sixteen killed' in western Iraq car bombs
Phase 1 of PCB removal on Hudson wrapping up
CDC official downplays risk from swine flu vaccine
Profile of W.P. Snyder Jr. paddlewheel towboat
Groups help imperiled Iraqis come to US
US choppers bring aid in stricken Philippine city
UN chief acknowledges fraud in Afghan vote
Police say Irish priest abducted in Philippines
Commandos storm Pakistan army HQ, freeing 39 hostages
Gunmen abduct Irish priest in southern Philippines: police
Senate GOP leader says he would back troop request
50,000 short of water in south China drought
Obamas attend Episcopal church near White House
Pakistan nukes safe despite militant threat: Clinton
McCain says Palin remains strong force in the GOP
Philippines speeds up relief in typhoon-hit north
As economy grows, so do China's garbage woes
Afghan outlook bleak as Taliban grabs territory
China raises limit on foreign investment in stocks
Vince Vaughn victorious with "Couples Retreat"
Director Polanski feels depressed in jail: lawyer
Chinese directors pay tribute to quake-hit city
Indonesia detains 260 Sri Lankan migrants
Vince Vaughn victorious with Couples Retreat
| Entertainment
|
Boyzone singer Gately, 33, dies in Mallorca
| Entertainment
|
Ahmadinejad sees no obstacle to further nuclear talks
Environment activists occupy British parliament roof
Pakistan bombs militants, ground offensive imminent
| International
|
Mexico shuts down state-run power company
South Korea seeks talks with North on deadly floods
| International
|
Nobel Economics Prize wraps up awards season
Palestinians vow new push for war crimes report
Philippines orders rice imports as typhoon costs mount
| International
|
US Marines sweep 'Taliban' villages for home-made bombs
Dollar facing 'power-shift': analysts
Mitterrand, hit by sex furor, wins fresh support
| International
|
Insurers escalate criticism of health overhaul
Gay activists march for 'equality,' 'freedom' in US
Gay rights advocates march on DC, divided on Obama
Man arrested in '68 hijacking of flight from NY
Wash. landslide blocks highway, forces evacuations
Filipino troops search for kidnapped Irish priest
Attacks demonstrate Taliban resurgence in Pakistan
Filipino police search for kidnapped Irish priest
Official: Census takers want teams after Ky. death
Australia resettles boat explosion survivors
Schwarzenegger OKs school bill required by US law
Russian spacecraft with circus tycoon lands safely
1 adult killed, students hurt in Idaho bus crash
Omaha police search for suspect in street shooting
China mine owners flee after accident kills 14: report
Thousands of 'Red Shirts' rally against Thai govt: police
California tests ignition devices for DUI drivers
News
S.Korea says to keep close eye on house prices
Seoul shares weighed by refiners;Lotte Shopping up
Japanese stock markets closed for national holiday
Korea Hot Stocks
S.Korea fin min reaffirms to keep easing policy
Seoul shares open up on techs, Hyundai Heavy
NZ guest nights flat in August
First clown in space hosts show to save Earth's water
| Entertainment
|
Former East German model city fears ghost town future
A bruising 'Oleanna' tackles political correctness
Gately, of Irish boy band Boyzone, dies in Spain
Streisand pulls off US, British charts double
Filmmaker Nichols graduates to AFI lifetime honor
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Boyzone singer Gately, 33, dies in Mallorca
China, sector crisis to dominate Frankfurt Book Fair
Pope canonises 'lepers' apostle' and four others
Armenia leader to pursue thaw in Turkey visit
Britain announces £16 bln state asset sell-off
US-TECH Summary
Poorer nations to get donated swine flu vaccine: WHO
China bans foreign investment in online games industry
Policeman, attacker hurt in Milan blast
UK halts business with Iran firms on nuclear fears
North Korea fires missiles
| International
|
Recession-hit Britain to sell off state assets
Advancing Marines test new Afghan war doctrine
| International
|
China sentences six to death over Xinjiang riots
| International
|
UK halts business with Iran firms on nuclear fears
| International
|
Polls show Russians back crisis plan: Putin's party
| International
|
Indonesia confirms two wanted militants killed
| International
|
Israel not undermining al-Aqsa foundations: Netanyahu
| International
|
Kenyan police arrest American heading for Somalia
| International
|
Watchdog alters Afghan recount rules
| International
|
Four Sudan Islamists to hang for US diplomat murder
Afghan member of panel investigating vote resigns
AP NewsAlert
Clinton vows help to solve N. Ireland deadlock
Disease outbreak concerns after Indonesian quake
Stars in singing tribute on Lowery's 88th birthday
Suspect in 1968 hijacking 'arrested in NY'
Arthur Levinson quits Google board amid govt scrutiny
| Technology
|
Yale to hold memorial service for slain student
Blast near Pakistan's Swat valley kills 41
Acer sees revenue up as tech demand returns
| Technology
|
Tropical storm in Pacific strengthens off Mexico
US wants 'new relationship' if Karzai re-elected
Analysis: Vitriol, invective at the speed of light
Bangladesh police: Man confesses to 11 slayings
China bans foreign investment in online games industry
| Technology
|
A 6.4-magnitude quake hits South Pacific
Malaysian state offers free trips to warring couples
NM school goes from worst to among best in 3 years
Energy high on agenda for Putin visit to China
Indonesia remembers Bali bombing
China asks WTO to rule on trade dispute with EU
Tengzhong seeks govt approval for Hummer deal
Philippines readies rice imports after typhoons
Taiwan dollar falls on U.S. rate expectations
India August industrial production jumps 10.4 pct
India industrial output surges
India August industrial production surges 10.4 pct
China's Huijin new shares purchases: banks
Seoul shares slip on refiners; Lotte rises
Vietnam launches 3G mobile services
New Michael Jackson single hits the airwaves
| Entertainment
|
Former flight attendant sues Oprah over sex claim
| Entertainment
|
Up rises again overseas
| Entertainment
|
ETimor lawmakers attack govt on militia leader
Australians mourn Bali blast victims
UK artist shrugs off critics of Trafalgar piece
Iraqis finally enjoy a night at the theatre
New Michael Jackson single hits the airwaves
"Up" rises again overseas
Former flight attendant sues Oprah over sex claim
Bertrand Russell 'maths comic' hits bestseller lists
Filipino directors: Don't pander to festivals
Michael Jackson's new song released
Television 'ban' for Australian toddlers: report
Discreet sex education breaks Indian taboo
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights