Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
 
 Read more with google mobile :
Priests' comments on Jews, Muslims embarrass Pope
| International
|
 
 My Profile 
					 
                    
            
            
                
			
		
  
	
	
	
    
		
	
     
Top News
Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
Subscribe
  
	
  
	
	
	
    
		
	 
	 
         
         
        
	
	
  
  
  		
  	You are here:
  
    Home
    
      >
      News 
      
      >
      International 
      
      >
      Article
	
    
		
	
  
 
    
               
      
Home
        
Business & Finance
        
News
        
U.S.
                
Politics
                
International
                
Technology
                
Entertainment
                
Sports
                
Lifestyle
                
Oddly Enough
                
Environment
                
Health
                
Science
                
Special Coverage
                
Video
                
Pictures
                
Your View
                
The Great Debate
                
Blogs
                
Weather
                
Reader Feedback
                
      
	
    
		
	 
	 
         
         
        
	
	
  
               
      
	
Do More With Reuters
		
RSS
		
Widgets
		
Mobile
		
Podcasts
		
Newsletters
		
Your View
		
Make Reuters My Homepage
	
Partner Services
		
CareerBuilder
		
Affiliate Network
	
Professional Products
		
Support (Customer Zone)
		
Reuters Media
		
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
 
      
    
      
    
	
		
Priests' comments on Jews, Muslims embarrass Pope
	
Fri Jan 30, 2009 9:15am EST
 
	 
               
       
	
	
	 
		
			Email | Print | 
Share
 | Reprints | Single Page
	
			[-]
			Text
			[+]
	
	
	
	
      
 
 
		
    
    
By Philip Pullella
    
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - Outbursts about Jews and Muslims by Italian leaders of an ultra-traditionalist Roman Catholic group show the challenge facing Pope Benedict as he tries to bring them back into the Church.
    
Benedict attempted Wednesday to defuse an international furor over his decision to lift the excommunication of four traditionalist bishops including Richard Williamson, who denies the full extent of the Holocaust and believes there were no gas chambers.
    
The Pope expressed his "full and unquestionable solidarity" with Jews and warned of the dangers of Holocaust denial.
    
But the next day a priest who is a regional leader of the same ultra-traditionalist group as Williamson, the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX), made headlines by telling a local newspaper "gas chambers existed at least for disinfecting" inmates but he wasn't sure if they were used to kill them.
    
The priest, Floriano Abrahamowicz, defended Williamson. He said it was "impossible for a Christian to be an anti-Semite" and that the whole controversy was part of a "very powerful campaign against the Vatican."
    
He said Williamson had been "imprudent to get into technical matters" about whether people had died by gassing or not.
    
The affair has angered Jews. Pope Benedict has given credence to "the most vulgar aspect of anti-Semitism" by rehabilitating a Holocaust denier, death camp survivor Elie Wiesel, the author and Nobel Peace Prize winner, said in an interview with Reuters this week.
    
Some analysts believe Benedict failed to anticipate the furor because he is too isolated.
    
"This is a solitary papacy and Benedict is paying the price," said Professor Alberto Melloni, head of The John XXIII Center for Religious Studies in Bologna.
    
He concurred with Vatican sources who said Benedict had not consulted widely inside the Vatican or beyond before lifting the excommunications, whose effect was to exclude the bishops from communion with the Church.
    
"If he had called any five bishops at random around the world for advice I think they would all have said 'no'. Even if there had not been a Holocaust denier, this mess was so predictable it's amazing," Melloni told Reuters.
    
DAMAGE CONTROL
    
The Vatican has been in damage control mode since Saturday, when the excommunications were lifted in an attempt to heal the first schism in the Church in modern times.
    
For the seventh consecutive day, Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi was compelled to speak out yet again Friday after Abrahamowicz's comments were splashed on the front pages of most Italian newspapers.
    
Lombardi said denying the Holocaust was bad enough when it was done by lay people "but even more grave when it comes from the mouth of priest or a bishop, a Christian minister, whether he is united or not with the Catholic Church."  Continued...
    
    
      
View article on single page
         
        
      
 
               
      
	
    
		
 
	
		
 
		
Share:
		
Del.icio.us
		
Digg
		
Mixx
		
My Web
		
Facebook
		
LinkedIn
	
	
  
      
               
      
 
	
			
 
		
  		    Next Article:
		At least 15 dead, dozens missing, from Kenya fire
		
 
			
		
 
	
      
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
	
     
Also on Reuters
Slideshow 
Slideshow: Flying through life -- from birth into adulthood
Full Coverage: The Year in Review 2008
Blog: So many ways to say goodbye...to your job
  
	
    
						
						
						
	
		
		More International News
    
  
  
		
				Hamas wants new leadership for Palestinians
			
		
				Russia and Cuba seal new partnership at Kremlin
			
		
				North Korea, trying to jolt Obama, warns South
			
		
				Turkish PM returns to hero's welcome after Gaza row
  |  Video
			
		
				Ethiopia says 4.9 million people need food aid
			
		
More International News...
  
	
    
  
	
	
    
     
     
    
    
        
	
		
		 
	
		
     
		
	 
               
       
      
               
       
      
	
	
 
	
		
	
    
		
	
  
	
    
		
Editor's Choice
	
     
Slideshow 
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.  Slideshow 
  
	
  
	
    
		
          
	 
	 
         
         
        
	
  
 
 
	
    
				
Most Popular on Reuters
				
					
					
Articles
					
Video
					
				 
			
			
  
               
      
	
	
		
		
						
				
			
Republicans in high-stakes challenge to Obama  |  Video
				
		
			Cost of shoring up U.S. banks may be in trillions
				
		
			Naked couple surprises diners in stroll
				
		
			Russian protesters storm Putin party office
				
		
			Snow study shows California faces historic drought
				
		
			Cuomo eyes return of $4 billion in early Merrill bonuses: report
				
		
			Turkish PM returns to hero's welcome after Gaza row  |  Video
				
		
			Fidel Castro demands Obama return Guantanamo base
				
		
			Blagojevich ousted as Illinois governor  |  Video
				
		
			Recession rocks Hollywood's showbiz papers
				
		
		
			
			
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
		
		
      
               
      
	
	
		
            
                  
                  
										
                  Video 
		
    
			
 Peres, Erdogan clash
    
			 Blagojevich removed from office
    
			 Hero's welcome for Erdogan
    
			 Stimulus bill revives "Buy American"
    
			 Monkey with a mission
    
			 Obama seeks deal with Republicans
    
			 Potty-trained parrot
    
			 Dog cloning cheaper but still bites
    
			 Girl marries dog in bizarre ritual
    
			 Potty-trained parrot
    
	
		
		
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
	
	
      
	 
The Great Debate
World Affairs:
The Afghan narco-state
Bernd Debusmann
To understand why the war in Afghanistan, now in its eighth year, is not going well for the U.S., take a look at two statistics on corruption and drugs.  Commentary 
	
	
                    
	
	
      
Reuters Deals
 
The global destination for corporate leaders, deal-makers and innovators
Knowledge to Act
  
	
    
		
 
 
	
  
          
  
    
Reuters.com: 
    Help and Contact Us  | 
    Advertise With Us  | 
    Mobile  | 
    Newsletters  | 
    RSS  | 
    Interactive TV  | 
    Labs  | 
    Reuters in Second Life  | 
    Archive  | 
    Site Index  | 
    Video Index
    
Thomson Reuters Corporate: 
		Copyright  | 
		Disclaimer  | 
		Privacy  | 
		Professional Products  | 
		Professional Products Support  | 
		About Thomson Reuters  | 
    Careers
  	
 
  	
International Editions:
  	
  	Africa  | 
  	Arabic  | 
  	Argentina  | 
  	Brazil  | 
  	Canada  | 
  	China  | 
  	France  | 
  	Germany  | 
  	India  | 
  	Italy  | 
  	Japan  | 
  	Latin America  | 
  	Mexico  | 
  	Russia  | 
  	Spain  | 
  	United Kingdom  | 
  	United States
    
 
    
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
    
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
 
 Other News on Friday, 30 January 2009
 Shoe monument for man who threw footwear at Bush
 Somali pirates seize German gas tanker
 A look at Blackwater in Iraq during the war
 Playboy Cancels Pre-Game Super Bowl Party
 Iran hopes for positive U.S. policy change
| International
|
 Ford plans cuts but won't seek US aid in wake of 5.9 bln Q4 loss
 Three candidates slain ahead of Iraq polls
 Three candidates slain ahead of Iraq polls
| International
|
 Economic distress erupts on the streets
 U.S. says open Gaza border to choke arms smuggling
 Russian protesters storm Putin party office
| International
|
 Sudan and Chad accuse each other of helping rebels
 Spanish court investigates 2002 Israeli Gaza attack
| International
|
 Iraqi shoe hurler inspires art in Saddam hometown
 Sunni political voice gets tuned for elections
 Shoe monument for man who threw footwear at Bush
| International
|
 Iraqis to vote in al Qaeda's last stronghold
 Iraq bars Blackwater, tarnished by civilian deaths
 UN needs more than $600m for Gaza
 Pakistan arrests gang over Danish embassy attack
 SKorean firm says it cloned dogs using stem cells
 Afghan presidential poll delayed for poor security
 Pakistan busts 'high-profile terror network': police
 Obama telephones Japanese prime minister
 Blagojevich Maintains He Did No Wrong, Asks Senate Not To Be Booted
 Ohio Family Of Four Having Financial Struggles Dead In Murder-Suicide
 Obama Puts Domestic Economy Problems On Front Burner While Juggling International Worries
 Economic Issues Agenda In Obama's Feb. 19 Visit To Canada
 California Seeks To End Court Oversight Of Healthcare In State Prisons
 Bank of China's Zhu sees US consumption slump
 Illinois May Swear In New Governor Thursday After Impeachment Trial Of Rod Blagojevich
 Report: Army To Recall 16,000 Sets Of Body Armor
 Fixing The Nation's Public Correctional Systems Requires New Ideas
 Shell posts 2.8 bln dlr loss on tumbling oil prices
 Republican Party Set To Vote For Next Chairman
 Pakistan to meet initial program targets
 Settlement reached on Heath Ledger's life insurance
| Entertainment
|
 Pitt and Jolie too busy to celebrate
| Entertainment
|
 John Updike pondered death in new poem
| Entertainment
|
 Hollywood actors, studios set new contract talks
| Entertainment
|
 Just A Minute With: Dancing with Stars champ Brooke Burke
| Entertainment
|
 Pitt and Jolie "too busy" to celebrate
 Hollywood actors, studios set new contract talks
 NY Philharmonic to play short piece by teen
 British songwriter John Martyn dead at 60
 BC-Best-sellers-Books-PW
 Doctor to late wrestler pleads guilty in drug case
 Authors to Washington Post: Save Book World
 John Updike pondered death in new poem
 Nederlander sure 'Thriller' feud will be resolved
 Filing: Settlement in Heath Ledger insurance suit
 Great expectations for Yves Saint Laurent art sale
 Vienna's Opera ball sold out, despite crisis: organiser
 U.S. says all options on table to deal with Iran
 Blackwater says it could leave Iraq with 72 hours
 Russia turns back the clock with Castro visit
 Amazon profit up, Kindle demand 'unusually strong'
 North Korea's Kim in command after health scare: U.S.
| International
|
 Official: Ahmadinejad will run for re-election
 Turkish PM storms out of heated Mideast debate
| International
|
 British govt promises broadband access for all
 Stem cells 'reset' immune system in MS patients: study
 First black Iraqi runs in elections
 US-TECH Summary
 Battle lines harden on US stimulus
 Nortel exits WiMax business
 Obama, allies move stimulus fight into high gear
 North Korea scraps all accords with South
| International
|
 Obama envoy meets Palestinian leaders in West Bank
 Whiners or satirists? Blog charts woes of dating Wall St bankers
 Chavez tells Obama to give Guantanamo back to Cuba
| International
|
 US tech sector job cuts hit five-year high: firm
 RIM's Storm costlier to make than iPhone: report
 India to sign IAEA deal on Monday: ambassador
| International
|
 Somalia's parliament to elect new president
| International
|
 Pakistan seizes suspects in Danish Embassy attack
 NKorea declares past accords with South 'dead'
 North Korea scraps all accords with South
 NKorea says it won't honor past accords with South
 U.S. says North Korea's Kim in command after health scare
 UN nuclear chief supports US-Iran talks
 RIM's Storm costlier to make than iPhone: report
| Technology
|
 Jan 29 Highlights In U.S. Economy
 Alaska's Mount Redoubt Displays Increased Seismic Activity
 UN nuclear chief says Obama offers hope of 'saner' world
 Whiners or satirists? Blog charts woes of dating Wall St bankers
| Technology
|
 Developing: Illinois State Senate Votes To Remove Gov. Rod Blagojevich
 Wall Street Dips On Jobs, Housing Data
 Nortel exits WiMax business
| Technology
|
 Jobless Claims Hit New Record; Highest Since Recording Began In 1967
 Obama Signs Emergency Declaration For Storm-Hit Kentucky And Arkansas
 Report: Toyota expecting first net loss
 SKorea records current account surplus for third month
 Toyota to revise down profit forecast further: reports
 Japan industrial production falls, unemployment up
 Seoul shares open lower as econ worries weigh
 Japanese inflation slows sharply as economy cools
 S.Korea c.bank says 2-3 pct growth unlikely in '09
 China pledges multi-million-dollar aid to Senegal
 Settlement reached on Heath Ledger's life insurance
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Up to seven firms could bid for fraud-hit Satyam: director
 Pitt and Jolie too busy to celebrate
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 John Updike pondered death in new poem
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Hollywood has a lot riding on Steve Jobs
 Hollywood actors, producers union to meet next week
 Kelly Clarkson leaps to top of singles chart
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Hollywood actors, studios set new contract talks
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 U2, Plant/Krauss join Grammy lineup
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Just A Minute With: Dancing with Stars champ Brooke Burke
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Dylan, will.i.am on tap for Super Bowl ad
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Child star, parents happy to be part of `Slumdog'
 Dylan, will.i.am on tap for Super Bowl ad
 Slumdog film team defend treatment of slum kids
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Hollywood has a lot riding on Steve Jobs
 Hollywood has a lot riding on Steve Jobs
| Entertainment
| Reuters
 Wyeth's 'Christina's World' in Pa. this weekend
 Jennifer Hudson films new video
 James Brown survivors await settlement over estate
 Springsteen hopes to inspire in Super Bowl show
 U2, Plant/Krauss join Grammy lineup
 Kelly Clarkson leaps to top of singles chart
 `Anytime' squeezes talk show into 5 minutes online
 Scientists Predict Eruption On Alaska's Mount Redoubt
 Ohio Family Having Financial Struggles Dead In Murder-Suicide
 Iraqi city of Mosul key electoral battlefield
 U.S. says open Gaza border to choke arms smuggling
| International
|
 Plastered in posters, Iraq's Basra waits for polls
 Dell plots smartphone foray, eyes Apple: report
 Iran hopes for positive U.S. policy change
| International
|
 Turkish PM returns to hero's welcome after Gaza row
 Soldier suicides hit record in 2008: US Army
 North Korea, trying to jolt Obama, warns South
| International
|
 Forty people missing after Kenya supermarket blaze
| International
|
 Pakistan says nine bomb attack suspects arrested
| International
|
 Diplomat says Mumbai attack not planned in Pakistan
| International
|
 Illinois lawmakers oust corruption-tainted governor
 Oil languishes below $42 on bad US economic news
 Sri Lanka urged to end war reporting ban
 Dell plots smartphone foray, eyes Apple: report
| Technology
|
 US military judge refuses to suspend Guantanamo trial
 Oil higher after OPEC comments
 Indian PM to leave hospital this weekend: report
 Russia's Lavrov urges 'new era of co-operation'
 U.S. Military Recalls Peanut Butter Products In European Bases
 Jailed Ex-CIA Spy In New Espionage Charges, Son Also Indicted
 Nine Pakistan suspects due in court over attacks
 Fidel Castro demands Obama return Guantanamo base
 Hackers Steal Data Of Millions Of Jobseekers From Monster.com
 US envoy backs UN's 'responsibility' to civilians
 Blackwater Banned In Iraq For 'Excessive Use Of Force'
 Senate approves bill to delay digital TV
| Technology
|
 Indonesia prosecutors want life for ex-bank official
 Ailing Castro throws first punch at Obama
 War Court Judge Defies Obama, Will Try USS Cole Bombing Suspect
 Williams sisters win Auz tennis doubles title
 Developing: Quinn Replaces Impeached Blago As Illinois Governor
 WHO refuses to rule out pig-to-human transmission of Ebola virus
 Venezuela's Citgo resumes heating oil donations
 Malaysia battling worst-ever dengue outbreak
 Rohingya not recognized as ethnic group in Myanmar
 4 more Filipinos had Ebola Reston virus infection
 Hitachi forecasts $7.8 bln loss, cuts 7,000 jobs
 Japan shares fall on weak earnings, economic data
 SKorea's industrial output plunges in December
 Japan top mobile carrier says 9-month profit rises
 Honda quarterly profit slumps, cuts annual target
 Seoul shares end 0.4 pct lower; but Hynix rallies
 WRAPUP 3-S.Korea's c.bank vows to do all it can to help economy
 Jiangxi plans $17 billion in railway spending
 Action pic Taken primed to take box-office crown
| Entertainment
|
 Online Job Site Hacked For Third Time, Data Of Millions Of Users Stolen
 Piracy, controversy mar Slumdog's India run
| Entertainment
|
 Kelly Clarkson leaps to top of singles chart
| Entertainment
|
 Senate approves bill to delay digital TV
| Entertainment
|
 'Idol': Judges misconstrued 'Be careful' remark
 U2, Plant/Krauss join Grammy lineup
| Entertainment
|
 US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
 Action pic "Taken" primed to take box-office crown
 Madonna resuming Sticky & Sweet tour
| Entertainment
|
 Senate approves bill to delay digital TV
 Fox to pick up Narnia franchise for third film
| Entertainment
|
 Piracy, controversy mar Slumdog's India run
 Dylan, will.i.am on tap for Super Bowl ad
| Entertainment
|
 Madonna resuming Sticky & Sweet tour
 Springsteen promises high-energy halftime show
 Fox to pick up Narnia franchise for third film
 Heated Gaza Debate Sparks Walkout By Turkish Prime Minister
 Father And Son Spies Charged For Getting Espionage Payments From Russia
 Turkish PM returns to hero's welcome after Gaza row
| International
|
 Turkish PM hailed as hero after Davos spat
 Iraq on high alert after election candidates shot dead
 Economic crisis savages Japanese companies
 Zimbabwe opposition to decide on joining government
 Police again question Israel's Olmert on corruption
 Erdogan receives hero's welcome after Gaza spat
 Plastered in posters, Iraq's Basra waits for polls
| International
|
 New deal reached on Fortis asset sale to BNP
 Zimbabwe's MDC seen backing Tsvangirai on cabinet
| International
|
 U.S. says all options on table to deal with Iran
 Philippines says finds four new human Ebola cases
| International
|
 Somali parliament to elect new president
| International
|
 After confrontation, back to business at Davos
 Poverty drives Myanmar Rohingyas into death traps
| International
|
 Castro takes first swipe at Obama
 SKorean allegedly confesses to killing 7 women
 Piano prodigy back home for Seoul concerts
 Sri Lanka to rebels: Let civilians flee war zone
 Feature: Gateway City To The FL Keys Signals Mixed Omens For Regional Economy
 Watchdog urges media access to Sri Lankan war zone
 Court Favors Schwarzenegger, 2-Day Unpaid Forced Leave For State Workers Upheld
 Grim Report Expected For Q4
 After Meeting With Economic Team, President Decries $18 Billion Worth Of Wall Street Bonuses
 Sultan backs bigger Brunei role in Philippines peace talks: Manila
 Diplomat: Mumbai attack not planned in Pakistan
 Philippines orders closure of refugee camps in south
 Analysis: Obama-China relations off to rocky start
 Thousands flock to Islamic gathering in Bangladesh
 Honda quarterly profits dive 89%
 Japan factory output plunges, jobless rate jumps
 DAVOS-S.Korea currency market basically stabilised -PM
 NEC's loss widens, plans to cut 20,000 workers
 Japan's NEC cutting 20,000 jobs
 NEC to cut 20,000 jobs worldwide as losses widen
 Hitachi sees massive loss
 Honda cuts annual forecast as 3Q profit tumbles
 HK stocks climb on China stimulus hopes
 ANA posts quarterly loss due to weak travel demand
 Kelly Clarkson leaps to top of singles chart
| Entertainment
|
 Iran cleric tells Obama not to repeat Bush's warnings
 ETA vows to fight on as it marks 50th anniversary
 Hamas wants new leadership for Palestinians
| International
|
 Hitachi warns of $7.8 billion loss, to restructure
 Folk Legend John Martyn Dies At 60
 Spotlight on vote-buying on eve of Iraqi ballot
 Russia and Cuba seal new partnership at Kremlin
| International
|
 Octuplets' mother already had six children: report
 Heath Ledger's $10 Million Insurance Lawsuit Settled
 Group: Settlement info implicates Israeli gov't
 Jessica Simpson And Father Joe Simpson Accused Of Causing Fitness Company Meltdown
 Ethiopia says 4.9 million people need food aid
| International
|
 Exxon notches record profit of $45.22 bln
 Mumbai attack not planned in Pakistan: diplomat
| International
|
 Priests' comments on Jews, Muslims embarrass Pope
| International
|
 US puts up $20 million for Gaza relief
 Diplomat: Mumbai attack not planned in Pakistan
 Hitachi warns of $7.8 billion loss, to restructure
| Technology
|
 Sri Lanka rules out cease-fire with rebels
 Oil below $42 on dismal US economic outlook
 Diplomat says Mumbai attack not planned in Pakistan
 Record-breaking heat scorches southern Australia