Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Afghan war review shows tilt to hitting militants
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Afghan war review shows tilt to hitting militants
By ANNE GEARAN and DEB RIECHMANN,Associated Press -
Thursday, December 16
Send
IM Story
Print
BAGRAM AIR FIELD, Afghanistan – The latest White House review of the war in Afghanistan to be released Thursday will show that coalition forces have relied heavily on air strikes and night raids against insurgents as part of the overall strategy, U.S. and NATO officials said.
The emphasis on such counterterror operations _ aimed at killing and capturing militants _ could reflect the difficulties the U.S. military has faced in carrying out the other, main part of its strategy, known in military parlance as counterinsurgency, or COIN _ to clear the enemy out of a particular territory, then focus on holding and developing it to win over the local Afghan population.
"It may be an indication that U.S. goals in Afghanistan and Pakistan are being narrowed from a broad COIN mission to something closer to the stated goal of disrupting and defeating al-Qaida," said Rick Nelson, a retired Navy officer who served in Afghanistan last year and is now a counterterrorism expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.
NATO officials say both are part of the overall strategy being employed by Gen. David Petraeus, the commander of American and NATO forces in Afghanistan. The alliance insists that at the same time that the coalition has stepped up counterterror operations, it also has increased its work to bring development and better governance to Afghanistan's 34 provinces.
But the long-awaited review of the war strategy that President Barack Obama is due to release on Thursday will show a greater than expected emphasis on counterterror operations, said NATO and U.S. military officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because the review has not yet been released.
Nelson said that doesn't mean that counterinsurgency, the lifeblood of Petraeus' strategy, is being abandoned. But the shift in emphasis demonstrates that U.S. and NATO forces ultimately need to be able to target senior Taliban and al-Qaida leaders who live in Pakistan.
"This means cutting lines of communication, interdicting supply lines, and putting pressure on safe havens across the border" in Pakistan, Nelson said.
On Wednesday, the commander of NATO forces in eastern Afghanistan predicted heavier fighting this winter, with more militants staying in Afghanistan instead of slipping over the border into Pakistan.
Maj. Gen. John Campbell, commander of NATO coalition forces in eastern Afghanistan, told reporters that attacks typically decrease over the winter months, as Taliban and other insurgent footsoldiers sit out the coldest weather in hideouts on Pakistan's side of the fluid, rugged border.
"We think right now _ what our intelligence is telling us _ we're probably going to see about a 15 to 20 percent increase in the amount of attacks compared to the same time frame of 2009," he said at Bagram Air Field, about an hour's drive northwest of Kabul. "So, we think many are going to stay and try to fight."
Marine Gen. James Cartwright, vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, hinted at the heavier emphasis on counterterrorism missions earlier this month in an interview with The Associated Press. He said then that, because of the realities on the battlefield, the war assessment would include adjustments to the current strategy _ things like the "balance" of counterinsurgency to counterterrorism.
In a speech last week at the National Press Club, Cartwright said: "When we started, we probably were more aligned with counterinsurgency. The emphasis is shifting."
That is because the coalition needs to reduce the number of militants who attack in Afghanistan and then escape to Pakistan, out of the reach of coalition forces, he said.
"So the balance of the force that was really weighted more toward counterinsurgency is starting to shift to have an element of counterterrorism larger than we thought we were going to need when we started," he said.
The two approaches were hotly debated for months before Obama embraced a hybrid strategy incorporating elements of both when he ordered 30,000 U.S. reinforcements to Afghanistan one year ago.
At the same time that coalition troops are working to rout insurgents, secure population centers and bolster governance, special forces operations captured 2,469 insurgents and killed 952 insurgents in the 90-day period ending Dec. 2, according to coalition figures.
The coalition also has ramped up the air war in Afghanistan since this summer. In the first 11 months of the year, coalition aircraft have used 5,465 bombs and Hellfire missiles, exceeding the 4,184 dropped in all of last year.
A heavier emphasis on military might, as part of the overall war strategy, departs from Petraeus' belief that killing and capturing insurgents on a large scale is self-defeating. The theory has been that for every insurgent captured or killed, the coalition forces made multiple enemies and helped recruit new fighters. Petraeus has repeatedly said that the coalition cannot kill or capture its way out of the insurgency.
Andrew Exum, a civilian adviser to former Gen. Stanley McChrystal, said if the coalition is shifting strategies it's news to Petraeus and his commanders.
"That having been said, it is true that the United States and its allies will eventually shift away from counterinsurgency toward a more limited counterterrorism mission between now and 2014," said Exum, who just returned from Kabul on Tuesday. "I do not see that shift taking place anytime in the next 12 months, though."
The review is expected to identify insurgent safe havens in Pakistan as a stubborn problem that U.S. pressure on Pakistan has done little to address.
Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, on a holiday USO tour to the front lines of the war, said the U.S. will continue to press its case with Pakistan that routing insurgents in bordering North Waziristan is in the interest of both Pakistan and the United States. But U.S. officials have largely concluded that Pakistan is unwilling to mount a major offensive in North Waziristan, partly because it would be too labor-intensive and would be too politically risky.
Former U.N. envoy to Afghanistan Kai Eide warned against escalation of military operations in an opinion piece released Wednesday that calls for a political solution to the war.
It is time to recognize that there are "serious flaws" in the U.S.-led war strategy, Edie wrote in the piece, which suggests cease-fires as a means of curbing the fighting.
"The counterinsurgency strategy does not work in the Afghan context," he wrote. "Instead of a `clear-hold-build' strategy, it has _ predictably _ become a `clear and clear again' exercise."
"More of the same will only bring greater resentment among the population and greater stubbornness in the insurgency."
Eide also said that military pressure will not nudge the insurgents to the negotiating table.
"The Taliban will not allow itself to be humiliated into a dialogue," he wrote.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Bloodshed feared as would-be I.Coast leader calls march AFP - Thursday, December 16
British court to decide on WikiLeaks founder's bail AFP - 12 minutes ago
Obama to unveil Afghan strategy review AFP - 1 hour 17 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 1 hour 52 minutes ago
US sues BP, eight others over Gulf oil spill AFP - Thursday, December 16
News Search
Top Stories
US man is HIV-free after stem cell transplant
US sues BP, eight others over Gulf oil spill
Suicide bomber kills 33 at Iran procession
Russian rocket with three crew blasts off into space
Tame US inflation backs Fed spending plan
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Record profits forecast for airline industry
Scarlett Johansson, Ryan Reynolds call it quits
US man is HIV-free after stem cell transplant
Britain's jobless total hits 2.5 million
Ho, ho, crunch: Santa's a crash risk, say doctors
More Most Viewed »
NASA finds new form of life... on Earth
Defiant Obama defends tax cuts, eyes 2012
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 16 December 2010 News
Iraq gets U.N. greenlight for civil nuclear program
Man kills four in Spain shooting rampage
Red Cross paints grim Afghan picture before review
|
US Air Force blocks news sites posting WikiLeaks
Iran suicide bombings kill 39 during ceremony
Riots expose Russia's problems ahead of World Cup
News
Stem cell transplant 'cures' HIV: study
Turkish army plot trial to revive tensions
Iraq gets U.N. green light for civil nuclear program
|
Irish parliament narrowly backs massive bailout
Survey names Facebook best place to work
News
South Sudanese shrug off home hardships to vote
Tame US inflation backs Fed spending plan
About 200 Islamic extremists in Sweden: intel
Nokia, Siemens to sell stake in telecom venture: report
Berlusconi seeks fresh start after bitter Italy vote
|
Iraq business elite flourish in Jordan safe haven
Scarlett Johansson, Ryan Reynolds call it quits
Atos shares jump on Siemens deal for IT giant
Russia blasts Britain for paranoid spymania
|
Egypt's Bedouin smugglers ply arms trade to Gaza
Social networking sites can help prevent pandemics: experts
Kenyan ministers named as suspects in vote violence
|
Afghan armed groups interfere in Red Cross work
Violence, protest plans stir Ivorian conflict
|
Japan government will not appeal court defeat over dyke
Thailand's Red Shirts to step up activities: new head
Ponting clinging to captaincy
Facebook founder named Time's 'person of year'
Management Tip of the Day: Ways to manage your online image
Tokyo bill set to restrict 'extreme sex' manga
Scarlett Johansson and Ryan Reynolds to divorce
Police stop religious gatherings in Indian Kashmir
News
HP wins $1.4 billion outsourcing contract from E.ON
Nokia, Siemens to sell stake in telecom venture: report
WikiLeaks hactivists look to improve attack software
|
Nokia Siemens buy of Motorola network ops wins EU nod
China's Shaolin Temple plans to open branch in Taiwan
France's Versailles palace to host luxury hotel
Inmates' cook-off serves up cheer in Peru prison
Samsung buys local medical equipment maker
Indonesia seeks jail for 'blasphemous' American
Fiennes directorial debut, Wenders 3D pic at Berlin fest
Women wrestling in the Bolivian Andes
Bubble fears as Taipei property prices hit record
Austerity bites for elderly in Britain
News
Great Firewall no obstacle for China's Facebook game makers
America's poor face bleak Christmas
Moscow starts ruble-yuan trading
Spain's BBVA bank takes step into Indian banking
News
Indian activists welcome crackdown on microfinance firms
Sandra Bullock tops People's most intriguing list
|
China foreign direct investment up 38 percent in November
News
Film critic Ebert to debut TV show in January
|
List reveals top places for spotting celebrities
|
Obama to unveil Afghan strategy review
YouTube wants Web show maker Next New Networks: report
UK judge to rule on bail for WikiLeaks's Assange
|
China PM seeks to ease political tensions with India
|
Asylum seeker deaths pressures Australia minority government
|
News
Lebanon says it uncovers Israeli spy devices
|
Man kills four in Spain shooting rampage
Cuba claims it made economic strides in 2010
|
German doctors declare cure in HIV patient
|
Lebanon says it uncovers Israeli spy devices
Afghan war review shows tilt to hitting militants
US troubleshooter hopes to 'make a difference' in N.Korea
Twitter financing values company at $3.7 billion
|
Nepal plane crash kills all 22 on board: police
Analysis: Gorilla Glass could become Corning's King Kong
|
YouTube wants Web show maker Next New Networks: report
|
News
Approval of Internet traffic rules likely: analysts
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
EBay acquires its mobile application developer
|
Baidu sees growth rate slowing in 2011
|
Aretha Franklin reported to have pancreatic cancer
Toshiba sees LCD profit on smartphone boom
|
'Boo Boo the bear is voice of reason': Timberlake
TV watchdog targets depiction of teen girls
Italian court increases sentences for 23 CIA agents
US-TECH Summary
U.S. seeks to build WikiLeaks conspiracy case
Obama, on eve of review, cites Afghan war progress
Approval of Internet traffic rules likely: analysts
Olivia Wilde transforms herself for Tron: Legacy
|
Aretha Franklin released from hospital
|
Five lessons of the fall TV season
|
Sesame Street ready to return to China
|
TV watchdog targets depiction of teen girls
|
Star power of little use in How Do You Know
|
Susan Boyle's Gift keeps on giving atop chart
|
Dozens feared dead after refugee boat smashes on Australian
Taiwan mulls China investments in local LCD firms -paper
Sarah Jessica Parker joining New Year's Eve
|
US and China sign trade deals, Beijing seeks more
Hyundai Steel export prices rise; iron ore costs more
News
Sandra Bullock tops People's most intriguing list
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Mercosur inks tariff deal with India, others
News
California mom sues McDonald's over Happy Meals
Bruni says Sarkozy often thinks about second term
|
Crash of Taiwan air force plane kills its 2 pilots
Seoul shares rangebound;foreign buying,U.S. data help
News
Sarah Jessica Parker joining "New Year's Eve"
News
WRAPUP 1-NZ confidence data points to gradual recovery
Global Weather-Asia-Celsius
News
News
Five lessons of the fall TV season
NZ 2013 govt bonds yield 4.10 pct at tender
News
US and China sign trade deals, Beijing seeks more
Star power of little use in "How Do You Know"
Seoul shares open lower as euro zone weights
Susan Boyle's "Gift" keeps on giving atop chart
NZ manufacturing perks up in November
Australia resumes hunt for refugee boat victims, toll rises
Toshiba plant to make LCD panels for Apple: report
Analysis: Gorilla Glass could become Corning's King Kong
Twitter valued in billions as popularity climbs
EBay acquires its mobile application developer
eBay buys mobile software maker Critical Path
WikiLeaks hactivists look to improve attack software
Study sees 1.2 billion illegal UK song downloads in '10
Human rights court condemns Ireland over abortion
Hochtief shareholder to sell up to Spain's ACS
News
Afghan violence kills 18 as Obama reviews war
|
Attacks in Afghanistan kill 3 kids, NATO soldier
Bing search upgrades include Facebook 'likes'
Heavy firing in Ivory Coast's Abidjan before march
|
Putin issues chilling message to tycoon Khodorkovsky
News
Assange arrives in London court to hear bail fate
Sweden probes blasts, no new threat level
|
Europe battles to shield the euro for good
France calls for restraint in Ivory Coast
Old catching up to young on US Internet: study
More than 1,000 held in Russia amid ethnic tensions
News
Square Enix slashes outlook, delays game launch
Putin talks up recovery, slams ethnic violence
|
Facebook face recognition finds friends in photos
Kenyans march to protest ICC's naming of suspects
|
News
South Korea to hold live fire drill on disputed island
|
Richardson in N.Korea, hopes to 'make a difference'
News
Europe rights courts faults Ireland on abortion ban
|
Israel can't defeat Hezbollah: Israeli expert
|
China PM on India charm offensive
American man gets jail time for blasphemy
Indonesian Christians uneasy over Islamic hard-line group's overture
22 killed in Nepal plane crash
Taipei 101 New Year's fireworks to set record
Australia make horror start in third Ashes Test
CNN host Larry King hands over his vintage microphone
All 22 passengers and crew dead in Nepal plane crash: police
Missing Nepal plane found, all 22 aboard killed
Facebook sales likely to hit $2 billion in 2010: report
|
Sesame Street ready to return to China
Large yuan swings will hurt China economy: media
News
Analysis: California calling European tech start-ups
|
Asiana Airlines mulls selling stake in Korea Express
Start-up sector seen thriving on tech advances
|
KIA recovers from crisis, ups production in Slovakia
Nokia expands patent row with Apple in Europe
|
News
S.Korea's bank levy to exclude local debt -report
Square Enix slashes outlook, delays game launch
|
Currency swaps may be included in S.Korea bank levy
Seoul shares dip on autos, euro zone worry
News
Study sees 1.2 billion illegal UK song downloads in '10
|
News
King's Speech, Fighter lead SAG film nominees
|
Piers Morgan flying flag for UK in King slot
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights