">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
US mission in Afghanistan tougher than Iraq
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Search
Search:
US mission in Afghanistan tougher than Iraq
AFP - Wednesday, January 14
KABUL (AFP) - - The United States is hoping a strategy similar to the one it used to improve security in Iraq, including an influx of troops, will work in Afghanistan -- one of president-elect Barack Obama's priorities.
But US and Afghan officials say the mission will be more difficult here as Afghanistan is splintered by tribal rivalries and weakened by the existence of militant safe havens across the border in Pakistan.
"We cannot just take the tactics, techniques and procedures that worked in Iraq and employ them in Afghanistan," General David Petraeus, commander of US forces in the Middle East and Central Asia, recently told Foreign Affairs.
At the start of 2006, Afghanistan was touted as a US military success, while Iraq was mired in a seemingly endless spiral of violence.
Today, the tables have turned: 2008 was the deadliest year for US soldiers in Afghanistan since they arrived in 2001, and the least deadly in Iraq since the start of the invasion there in 2003.
Washington helped reduce the violence in Iraq and pave the way for progress toward political reconciliation by sending more troops, intensifying operations and co-opting some of the rebels into militias paid to help maintain security.
The US military is hoping to implement a similar plan in Afghanistan, where security has worsened in the past two years as the Taliban-led insurgency has gathered pace.
Between 20,000 and 30,000 extra US troops are due in Afghanistan this year, almost doubling the number of American soldiers on the ground from the current 32,000 -- compared with 146,000 in Iraq.
Nearly 35,000 troops from other countries are also deployed here.
The bulk of the US reinforcements are expected to be sent to the south and east -- hotbeds of insurgent activity along the porous 2,400-kilometre (1,500-mile) border with Pakistan .
US officials and senior Obama advisers told Tuesday's Washington Post that the deployments were not an Iraq-like "surge", but rather a way to gain time to re-evaluate US goals and develop a new sweeping strategy for Afghanistan.
Last month, outgoing US President George W. Bush acknowledged an influx of troops here would likely make things worse before they get better.
"You'll see violence tick up," Bush told reporters on Air Force One en route to Kabul for a farewell visit.
"The degree of difficulty in Afghanistan is high. Nevertheless, the mission is essential."
The differences between Iraq and Afghanistan are manifold, and the fight for Afghanistan could be far longer than the conflict in Iraq.
Infrastructure here is dire, with a lack of secondary roads making it more difficult for troops to manoeuvre, and there are fewer skilled workers.
Beyond the logistical difficulties, the main challenge appears to be whether foreign forces can maintain a semblance of stability long enough for Kabul to build up its own security forces .
In Iraq, the US army has already handed over power to local authorities in 13 of 18 provinces with 560,000 policemen and 260,000 soldiers protecting 28 million people.
The security forces in Afghanistan, which has a similar population but a larger surface area covered by rugged mountainous terrain, lag well behind those of Iraq, with only about 80,000 soldiers and 70,000 police.
Corruption is rife in the police, while the absence of government authority in villages is often cited as a reason for the resurgence of the Taliban.
To address these shortcomings, the United States has spoken of creating local militias -- as in Iraq -- for community-level security.
But the idea has stirred concern in Kabul, which remembers all too well the bloody factional conflicts of the 1980s.
"Afghanistan is not Iraq," said Hamidullah Tarzi, a finance minister in the 1989-1992 communist regime.
"Here the people are much more divided and the tribal issue is very strong -- all these (new) militias are going to fight each other."
Ahmad Nader Nadery, of Afghanistan's Independent Human Rights Commission, says the answer lies not in a US troop surge, but in turning the conflict into "an Afghan war."
"The solution is to reform the police and to reinforce the army," he told AFP.
Another complicating factor for the United States is the question of how to flush Taliban and Al-Qaeda-linked militants out of Pakistan's lawless tribal zones along the Afghan border.
"One cannot adequately address the challenges in Afghanistan without adding Pakistan into the equation," Petraeus has said.
Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari and Afghan President Hamid Karzai pledged a new era of cooperation following talks in Kabul last week.
But questions remain about Islamabad's ability to control its powerful Inter-Services Intelligence agency, which Kabul says is the godfather of the Taliban.
The United States could also face problems if its NATO partners abandon the fight.
The alliance's supreme commander, US General Bantz Craddock, predicted that US forces would have to be in Afghanistan for "at least" a decade.
But he admitted that financial concerns and low public support could prompt European countries to pull troops out just as Obama looks for back-up.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: Asia Pacific
RPT-UPDATE 3-Asian Development Bank in cash call to boost loansReuters - 30 minutes ago
Irish PM leads trade mission to JapanAP - 38 minutes ago
RPT-GLOBAL MARKETS-Asian shares recover, but confidence lagsReuters - 42 minutes ago
Singapore's UOL makes bid for UIC, Singapore LandReuters - 1 hour 1 minute ago
Sri Lanka buries 41 unclaimed Tiger bodiesAFP - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
Enlarge Photo
US mission in Afghanistan tougher than Iraq
Most Popular – Asia Pacific
Viewed
Abbas blasts Israeli 'annihilation' in Gaza
Massa looking to future in F60
Britain's Prince Harry apologises for racist language
Passionate Bush defends legacy in final news conference
Automakers put on brave face at tense Detroit auto show
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Other News on Wednesday, 14 January 2009
Israeli forces squeeze Gaza city
Pentagon: 61 ex-Guantanamo inmates return to terrorism
| International
|
Hundreds flee for lives as Israel pounds Gaza by land and air
US-TECH Summary
Mexico's Calderon leaves door open to NAFTA discussions
| International
|
Europe gas halted as Russia-Ukraine deal falters
Tito Jackson Sued By Brooklyn Woman Claiming To Be His Daughter
Iraq official: Biden affirms 'responsible' pullout
Yahoo to name Bartz as new CEO: report
Ukraine leader accuses Russia of 'blackmail' over crisis
LRA rebels in Congo turned more deadly by offensive
| International
|
Forrester sees drop in IT spending in 2009, first since 2002
Despite Gaza toll, Israeli media focus on Israel
Europe gas halted as Russia-Ukraine deal falters
Somali pirates release Turkish ship: company source
| International
|
China defends Internet policies against Amnesty charges
US trade deficit drops 27% on plunging global trade
New audit of Iraq's rebuilding has a familiar ring
Abbas blasts Israeli 'annihilation' in Gaza
U.S. helps Africa's armies talk to each other
| International
|
Netanyahu: Hamas must be toppled
No flying cars at this year's Detroit auto show
Israeli envoy plans 'decisive' talks in Egypt
China has close to 300 million Internet users: survey
Hamas leaves door open to Gaza truce deal with Israel
Chu warmly received at Senate confirmation hearing
Yahoo to name Bartz as new CEO: report
| Technology
|
Clinton promises 'smart power' under Obama
Former Osama bin Laden courier goes on trial
Clinton faces questions on her husband's charity
NKorea: US must alter 'hostile' policy
Dalai Lama invited to receive Rome honour
US, Mexico pledge cooperation on drugs
Parents of sick kids reject China's payout plan
U.S. Braces For Arctic Temps, Blizzard-Like Conditions
State Dept: Israeli PM flat wrong on Rice
NKorea releases Japanese drug smuggler: state media
U.S. Trade Deficit Falls As Americans Buy Less
Clinton to seek 'cooperative engagement' with Russia
Clinton vows 'aggressive effort' against NKorea proliferation
Florida Lawmaker Kendrick Meek To Run For U.S. Senate In 2010
10 suspected Islamic militants tried in Indonesia
IRS Warns About Email Scams, Asks Public To Report Fraud
Sony shock again? Slump may mean operating loss
Sen. Hillary Clinton Being Grilled By Committee On Her Appointment As Secretary Of State
No suggestion of recklessness in sailor’s death: coroner
Body Of Annapolis, MD Man Found Floating In Harbor At Sailing Club Identified
Sri Lankan jets pound rebel positions in the north
Bush Bestows Congressional Gold Medal On Ex-British, Australian PMs, Colombian President
Sony shock again? Slump may mean operating loss
China exports fall at fastest rate in 10 years
China's population of Net users hits 298 million
Warner makes Bollywood debut with kung fu comedy
| Entertainment
|
Fox says not planning massive TV network layoffs
| Entertainment
|
Howie Mandel released from Toronto hospital
| Entertainment
|
Publicist: Hargitay has partially collapsed lung
`Class,' `Bashir' make Oscars' foreign short list
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Warner makes Bollywood debut with kung fu comedy
Evocative and real, 'Notorious' is a B.I.G. winner
'Waltz with Bashir' among Oscars foreign film hopefuls
Czech artist admits deception in EU art exhibit
Geoffrey Rush and Susan Sarandon come to Broadway
`Prison Break' to wrap after 4 seasons
Howie Mandel released from Toronto hospital
Senator: Missing American in secret prison in Iran
Israeli forces squeeze Gaza
| International
|
Iraqi voting rules raise concern about challenges
Autodesk exec Carol Bartz named CEO
U.S. says Iran still a malign influence in Iraq
| International
|
Italy rabbis pull out of dialogue, accuse Pope
| International
|
Study sees no eye cancer risk from mobile phones
IBM makes MRI scans 100 million times better
Latvian anti-government protest turns into riot
| International
|
Study sees no eye cancer risk from mobile phones
Former Japan Cabinet minister quits ruling party
Obama scrambles on Geithner and bailout concerns
Australia offers up 'best job': lounge in paradise
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 566
Pentagon says 61 ex-Guantanamo inmates return to terrorism
Study sees no eye cancer risk from mobile phones
| Technology
|
Hillary Clinton Vows To Sound Alarm On Darfur If Sworn In As U.S. Sec Of State
Wall Street Ends Mixed On Choppy Trading
Foul Play Still Suspect In Deadly Kansas House Fire
Seoul shares open lower; caution before earnings
Weak US consumer confidence 'biggest concern:' Toyota
24s Jack Bauer gets conflicted on torture
| Entertainment
|
Leonard Cohen to play first U.S. show in 15 years
| Entertainment
|
Waltz in foreign Oscar running
| Entertainment
|
China Hits 298 Million Internet Users
Salsa star Blades donates recordings to Harvard
Capsule reviews of `Notorious' and other films
Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, it's skycar
Review: `Defiance' a muted telling of great story
Football leads Fox to prime-time ratings win
Video games expected to evolve in 2009
Stone meets Bolivia's Morales for interview, coca
Leonard Cohen to play first U.S. show in 15 years
Filing: Polanski does not seek return to US
Publicist: Affleck, Garner name daughter Seraphina
New York Doctor Demands $1.5 Million From Ex-Wife For Kidney
Rocket attack on northern Israel from Lebanon
3 rockets fired from Lebanon fall on Israel
Fear and threats as Ethiopian troops quit Mogadishu
| International
|
EU keeps up pressure after Russia-Ukraine gas deal falters
NATO supply route in SW Pakistan reopens after blockade: police
China Internet users soar to 298 million
Italy rabbis pull out of dialogue, accuse Pope
| International
|
Global rush for 'best job in world' crashes Australian website
US mission in Afghanistan tougher than Iraq
US Senate, House launch YouTube channels
Autodesk exec Carol Bartz named CEO
Pakistan torn over how to handle Taliban: experts
Iraq joins nations banning chemical weapons
Report: Aborigines to suffer from climate change
Uphill battle for Chavez in Venezuela vote: polls
| International
|
Russia's neighbors feel pain of slowdown
| International
|
Calderon says Mexico can address U.S. trade concerns
| International
|
RPT-UPDATE 3-Asian Development Bank in cash call to boost loans
Chinese children snatched for sale by biker gang
| International
|
Irish PM leads trade mission to Japan
Bush unaware if bin Laden was close to being captured
Oil higher in Asia on OPEC chief's comments
RPT-GLOBAL MARKETS-Asian shares recover, but confidence lags
Chavez: OPEC could further reduce output
Authorities: Missing pilot in custody in Florida
Singapore's UOL makes bid for UIC, Singapore Land
Sri Lanka buries 41 unclaimed Tiger bodies
WWII bomb seriously injures Japanese: officials
Former BART Officer Accused Of New Year Shooting Arrested
Car hire company bills family after sons crushed by glacier
Dad Faces Charges Of Selling Underage Daughter Into Marriage, Groom For Rape
Report: Aborigines to suffer from climate change
Hunt Launched For Wanted Man Who Crashed Plane To Fake Death, Escape Lawsuits
Washington Court Rules Sex Between Teacher, 18-Year-Old Student Is Legal
Japanese businessman committed second murder: LA police
Judge Convicts Teen For Mom's Murder Over Video Game
Activist held after protest outside Shanghai meeting: rights groups
Google hopes to take on Microsoft using resellers
| Technology
|
New York Knicks Center Hit With Sexual Harrassment Charges
New Yahoo CEO lacks Web and deal-making chops
| Technology
|
Directors Approve Citigroup, Morgan Stanley Joint Venture
Japan shares gain on bargain-hunting
China Internet users soar to 298 million
| Technology
|
China's next export: Starbucks coffee
GM, Chrysler to skip Tokyo Motor Show: reports
Macau gaming heir looks to Taiwan
China chemical plant project moved after protests
Intel Capital invests $23 million in India
China's newest export: Starbucks coffee
S.Korea posts first monthly job loss in 5 yrs
Seoul shares end up 1.3 pct; motors, banks advance
Relatives angry at Indonesian search efforts
Yuan settlement trial confirmed for Shanghai: state media
Search for Indonesian ferry survivors fruitless
WALL-E and Man on Wire critics' top picks
| Entertainment
|
Hollywood actors remain in limbo on strike vote
Ozzy Osbourne family to return to TV-- reloaded
| Entertainment
|
Actors union meeting ends with no date for strike vote
Brendan Fraser joins Harrison Ford in drama
| Entertainment
|
Emmanuelle Chriqui joins Russian roulette thriller
| Entertainment
|
Jackie Chan circles Karate Kid remake
| Entertainment
|
Hollywood actors remain in limbo on strike vote
| Entertainment
|
Warner eyes cuts, Watchmen talks proceed
| Entertainment
|
Old World-New World women winemakers meet
Most accessible US inauguration won't be for many
"WALL-E" and "Man on Wire" critics' top picks
Brendan Fraser joins Harrison Ford in drama
Jordan home sales up amid property recession fears
Emmanuelle Chriqui joins Russian roulette thriller
Japan-flavored Taiwan film gets China release date
Can Obama make Washington the capital of cool?
`WALL-E,' `Man on Wire' top Golden Tomato Awards
Maman-minister: France debates politics and motherhood
California Dad Barters Daughter For $16,000, Food; Police Gets Her Back After Groom Fails To Pay
Investor Fakes Plane Crash, Disappears On Motorbike To Escape Lawsuits
'Halo 3' Addict Guilty Of Killing Mom, Shooting Dad
Bin Laden urges jihad against Israel
EU premiers plead for gas
| International
|
German economy shrinks 1.5-2.0% in fourth quarter
Indonesia probes ferry disaster as families join search
| International
|
Michelle Obama, set to be much more than 'mom-in-chief'
Pakistanis reopen Afghan force supply route
| International
|
Senate panel considers Obama's EPA pick
Saudi Sept 11 suspect tortured in Guantanamo: report
Taiwan arrests presidential office employee
Man Utd heading to Asia for pre-season tour
NKorea to crack down on markets to stem imports
Swiss sweep as Federer, Wawrinka win at Kooyong tennis
China revises figures, 'becomes world's number three economy'
Taiwan justice minister defends mocking Chen skit
Top separatist leader arrested in Indian Kashmir
China quake parents want answers to ruined schools
Obama's Hope, Optimism Campaign Battle Cry Being Used By Merchandisers
18 illegal immigrants flee Indonesian detention
Biden To Return From Final Congressional Trip Wednesday
China: Labradors sniff for drugs after planes land
Financial Adviser Who Allegedly Faked Plane Crash Arrested In Florida
Obama To Name Campaign Adviser As Federal Communications Commission Chair
HK stock index gains 0.3 percent; HSBC off 4.1 pct
British bank RBS says has sold Bank of China stake
Economic recovery still far off, says Invesco
South Korea's jobless rate rises in December
Pakistan's 6-mth T-bill cut-off yield at 14.0108 pct
China shares rebound on rise in lending
Toyota managers voluntarily buy cars to lift sales
China raises '07 growth, passing Germany
For kids in Slumdog slum, life is not as upbeat
| Entertainment
|
China cuts gasoline, diesel prices
No. 2 Taiwan shipper to add terminal at top island port
Cute canines run amok in Hotel for Dogs
| Entertainment
|
Taylor Swift to guest star on CSI
| Entertainment
|
Obama Expected To Announce Tech Adviser As FCC Chair
British women more worried about weight than cancer: poll
John Woo says his Chinese epic is transnational
Abdul declares loyalty to `Idol,' denies criticism
Taylor Swift to guest star on "CSI"
Cute canines run amok in "Hotel for Dogs"
Tape shows irrelevance of Bin Laden: White House
India army says Pakistan deployed troops on border
| International
|
Europe's .eu Internet domain marks three millionth address
Israel stops Iranian aid ship heading to Gaza
Technology alone 'won't assure youth safety on Internet'
US retail sales plunge shock 2.7% in December
Osama Bin Laden calls for jihad over Gaza
Demand for "best job in the world" crashes website
Absence, silence stir speculation on Castro health
| International
|
Internet threat to minors overblown, study suggests
IBM wins most U.S. patents in 2008
Japanese gang member released from NKorea
Internet threat to minors overblown, study suggests
| Technology
|
Singaporean terror suspect in Indonesia says ready to face consequences
Demand for best job in the world crashes website
| Technology
|
U.S. arrests wealth manager accused of faking death
Mobile download of movies and games available soon
North East CDC increases economic assistance from S$1.4m to S$3m
IBM wins most U.S. patents in 2008
| Technology
|
Indian army chief confirms Pakistan troop movements
Afghan minister: Old customs impede women's rights
Tennessee Grappling With Desire To Cut State Sales Tax On Groceries Amid $1B Deficit
Sri Lanka says it has seized northern peninsula
Boston Mayor Proposes One-Year Salary Freeze For City Workers
Register of Family Physicians may be set up to raise standards of care
U.S., Other Recessions Forecast To Cause Cuts In Technology Spending
Al Franken Asks Minnesota Supreme Court To Force Officials To Issue Election Certificate
Report: There Are 3.4 Million Stalking Victims In The U.S. Yearly
Second Round Of Deep Job Cuts At Largest North American Heavy-Duty Truck Engine Manufacturer
Budget Shortfalls Might Force 2 New York City Hospitals To Close By February
Incoming Treasury Sec. Tim Geithner Asked About Taxes, Housekeeper's Work Status
Financial Crisis Underway For California Hospitals