Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
COMMENTARY: Exposing hypocrisy of nations
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
COMMENTARY: Exposing hypocrisy of nations
ANN - Friday, January 7
Send
IM Story
Print
Kuala Lumpur (The Star/ANN) - For the past several weeks, WikiLeaks has treated the world to an insider's view of the diplomatic process.
We always knew that international affairs was full of hypocrisy and double standards; now we see it on public display.
Understandably, WikiLeaks founder, Julian Assange, has become the subject of intense American fury. Not since Osama bin Laden has anyone managed to stir up such ire.
Neo-conservative 'mullahs' in the US quickly labelled him a "terrorist" and wondered why he was still alive. Some called for his execution while others urged that Assange be pursued with the same urgency that was devoted to al-Qaeda and the Taliban.
In America such talk is, of course, called free speech; if it came from other countries it would be condemned as an unholy 'fatwa' equal to the one against Salman Rushdie decades ago. Perhaps the leaked cables should be renamed "Wikiverses."
But kudos to Australian Foreign Minister Kevin Rudd for standing up for Assange. I wish more countries would stand up for their citizens that way.
The US marshalled its economic might to try to shut Assange down. Corporations like Visa, Paypal and Amazon quickly fell into line, behaving more like employees of the US government than the international corporations they are supposed to be.
When China insisted that Google should censor itself within China, it was accused of undermining free speech and interfering with the operations of a multinational. Secretary Clinton opined that "even in authoritarian countries information networks are helping people discover new facts and making governments more accountable."
Now that the shoe is on the other foot, things are a little different.
Washington also seems to expect that everyone should support US law and join the assault against Assange. The message the Americans are now getting is that the world does not feel obliged to protect the secrets of other nations. It's open season when it comes to state secrets.
The leaks from Singapore, of course, grabbed our attention. While there was high praise for China, Singaporean officials appear to have only contempt for other Asian countries.
Their assessment of the situation in Malaysia was particularly damning. Singapore officials including Mr. Bilahari Kausikan, the permanent secretary of the foreign ministry, infamously described Malaysia as "confused and dangerous," while our leaders were considered "incompetent" and "opportunistic."
Some Malaysians might, of course, share this view but it is always galling when it comes from across the causeway.
Diplomats are naturally expected to speak their minds in private but once private conversations become public, they cannot be ignored.
Was the diplomatic equivalent of a slap on the wrist that was delivered by our foreign minister to the high commissioner for Singapore sufficient to assuage national pride?
Bilahari should have been told, in no uncertain terms, that he would not be welcomed in Malaysia for the time being. Certainly the December 22nd meeting of the Joint Implementation Team should have been postponed.
After all, how can we welcome so quickly someone who is so contemptuous of us?
How things have changed but that's diplomacy for you.
The leaks reveal many other interesting facets of international politics as well.
American ambassadors, for example, dutifully reported back to Washington an array of human rights abuses in their respective countries. Their reports detailed cases of torture, abuse and murder. Yet, there was often no corresponding outrage from Washington.
It only strengthens the view that America is selective in how it handles human rights abuses.
Iran, for example, has been rightly castigated for a long list of human rights violations, but, as the leaked reports indicate, such abuses are pretty common in many Middle Eastern and Central Asian countries as well.
It would appear that governments that are supportive of the US are given greater latitude to abuse their own people than those which do not.
If the leaked reports are accurate, they also expose the hypocrisy of the British who made much of the genocide in Sudan while doing little about the more than US$9bil (1/10th of Sudan's GDP) that Sudan's president has reportedly stashed away in British banks.
Business is business, I suppose.
As well, the leaks reveal how embassies gather dirt on foreign leaders. One leader was caught by Dubai customs with US$52mil in cash. Another leader was alleged to have eight Swiss bank accounts.
Private wheeling and dealing by leaders, high-level cases of nepotism, rape, murder, sexual peccadillos and corruption were all carefully noted.
And this mainly from overt sources, i.e. through diplomatic channels. One has to wonder what foreign intelligence agencies like the CIA must be gathering through covert and other means.
Such information could badly compromise the leaders concerned and render them susceptible to coercion and blackmail at critical times.
Think what that could mean for the independence and sovereignty of many states.
Perhaps, that which is sometimes hailed as a diplomatic breakthrough might simply be the result of common blackmail.
We like to think that diplomacy is about noble values, grand principles and great visions, but it really is about narrow national interests, itself an ill-defined set of objectives that is best known only to those who get to define it.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Laos general Vang Pao dies in California: hospital AFP - 22 minutes ago
Korean, US forces lower alert status: report AFP - 36 minutes ago
Two Koreas and U.S. militaries lower alert - report Reuters - 37 minutes ago
England captain toasts 'special' Ashes series triumph AFP - 44 minutes ago
India ruling party losing public support - poll Reuters - 50 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Germany closes 4,700 farms in dioxin scare
Obama tipped to name Sperling to top economic post
Cautious optimism ahead of US jobless numbers
Jackson dead before paramedics arrived, court told
Japan wants 'concrete' N. Korea steps before talks
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Falling blackbirds baffle Arkansas officials
Hasta la Vista: Arnie quits as California governor
Goldman deal 'values Facebook at $50 billion'
Spain lotto winner nearly loses millions by tossing tickets
Brazil's 2010 trade surplus lowest in 8 years: official
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 7 January 2011 France fears 'economic war' after Renault spy scandal
US-TECH Summary
VW, Daimler to sign $5bn Chinese contracts: source
GameStop's holiday sales disappoint, shares drop
De Niro to lead Cannes film festival jury
Nvidia's new mobile chips in Acer, Dell devices
Sony stays loyal to 3D at CES gadget fest
US Treasury asks Congress to lift debt ceiling
I.Coast's Gbagbo has 'blood on his hands' says rival
Always connected lifestyle on display at CES
Israel airport wifi blocks political sites
Sudan still not agreed to bigger UN force: official
|
Probe may push Facebook to early stock offering
U.S. bars financial dealings with Ivory Coast president
Analysis: Microsoft embrace boost for ARM, worry for Intel
U.S. to send 1,400 Marines to Afghanistan
Apple launches app store for Macs, a la iPhone
Sony stays loyal to 3D at CES gadget fest
Iran sent US spy back to Armenia: report
Former boss feared Pakistan suspect's extremism
Microsoft sold over 8 million Kinects in 60 days: CEO
U.S. healthcare law repeal hurts deficits
Pakistan bows to opposition demands on fuel price
US protests over Vietnam treatment of diplomat
Microsoft sold 8 mln Kinects in first two months
"Twilight" and Katy Perry among People's Choice winners
Geithner says U.S. could hit debt limit by March 31
China expels drug safety official from party: report
Skype acquires Qik mobile video company
|
Thai MP in Cambodia court over border incident
Analysis: Facebook ignites Bubble 2.0 chatter
|
Pakistan PM reverses petrol hike under pressure
India food inflation accelerates to year-high
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Nvidia's new mobile chips in Acer, Dell devices
|
Anna Nicole Smith boyfriend likely to escape jail
Swiss festival invites jailed Iranian film maker Panahi
Berlin museum extends popular Hitler exhibition
Japanese politician, 50 gives birth to first child
De Niro to lead Cannes film festival jury
Batman's French Muslim ally angers US bloggers
China to buy 6.0 bn euros of Spanish debt: report
China to build $1.5 bn trading centre in Thailand
Taiwan's HTC posts 70 percent rise in 2010 profit
Coffee capsule inventor aims for Asia with tea
Anna Nicole Smith boyfriend likely to escape jail
|
Paula Abdul dances back into hearts of viewers
|
Egypt Copts mark Christmas under tight security
Britain raises terror threat level at airports: report
Two Koreas and U.S. militaries lower alert: report
|
Toshiba year-end TV sales strong but 3D weak
US sends 1,400 more Marines to Afghanistan
Cautious optimism ahead of US jobless numbers
Australia floods cause months, possibly years, of damage
|
France fears 'economic war' after Renault spy scandal
Afghans protest Iran fuel truck ban
Gates hopes to bolster U.S.-China military dialogue
|
Jackson dead before paramedics arrived, court told
Samsung seeks 15 percent TV sales jump in smart TV push
Egypt's Mubarak warns Israel against new Gaza war
Israel: No Iran bomb before 2015
|
Japan wants 'concrete' N. Korea steps before talks
Verizon CEO ponders shift to use-based mobile plan
China confirms President Hu to visit U.S. from January 18
|
Iraqis look to U.S. foe Sadr to help stabilise state
Chilean scientists seek alcoholism vaccine
UN's Ban names panel for Haiti cholera probe
|
LG eyes 2-3 times rise in smartphones, focus on high-end
Iran denies detaining American woman
Egypt Copts mark Christmas under tight security
Clinton condemns Belarus crackdown, meets activists
|
RIM seeks 2 years to address email security: report
Mubarak says Israel must revise position on talks
Sony aims for No. 2 spot in tablet devices
Corrected: Record high food prices stoke fears for economy
|
Pakistan-Afghanistan to hold peace jirga
Samsung profit set to recover on gadgets after dip
Pope prays for Christians after Copt attack
Cambodia says KRouge trial should preserve peace
Israelis bribed to admit U.S. goods to Gaza
FCC head urges swift action on spectrum crunch
Chinese fireworks artist tries to shift blame over disappointing show
Data security center in Utah targets cyberspace
Cargo ship fire kills four Chinese off S. Korea
US-TECH Summary
Thai opposition eyes Thaksin's sister for PM
Australia coal industry may see long disruption due to floods
Samsung seeks 15 percent TV sales jump in smart TV push
England captain toasts 'special' Ashes series triumph
LG eyes 2-3 times rise in smartphones, focus on high-end
China smoking deaths could triple by 2030: report
Sony aims for No. 2 spot in tablet devices
Fake Indonesian inmate exposes prison corruption
Samsung seeks 15 percent TV sales jump in smart TV push
|
Samsung profit set to recover on gadgets after dip
Two Koreas and U.S. militaries lower alert
Toshiba year-end TV sales strong but 3D weak
|
Why French are world champs in pessimism
COMMENTARY: Exposing hypocrisy of nations
India's magicians: striving hard not to disappear
Verizon CEO ponders shift to use-based mobile plan
|
FCC head urges swift action on spectrum crunch
|
Oprah delighted with OWN network launch
Eminem, Drake lead rap sales surge in 2010
RIM seeks 2 years to address email security: report
|
US judge zaps Harry Potter plagiarism suit
LG eyes 2-3 times rise in smartphones, focus on high-end
|
Michael Jackson doctor kept mum about propofol at hospital
Facebook documents reveal strong profits: source
|
Case dismissed against Anna Nicole Smith boyfriend
Sony aims for No. 2 spot in tablet devices
|
Sundance invites 26 to world premiere of film
Samsung profit set to recover on gadgets after dip
|
Mass bird and fish deaths stoke curiosity
Indian animators to partner with US TV firm
China SAIC shares jump on strong 2010 sales
China rare earth curbs could raise prices: report
Seoul shares end up 0.4 pct on autos, Samsung Elec down
Korea Hot Stocks-Hyundai Motor up, savings banks rally
Pakistan
Samsung Q4 profits seen lower at $2.67 bn
Seoul shares end up 0.4 pct on autos, Samsung Elec down
S.Korea won down on firm dlr, foreigners stock sales
Michael Jackson doctor kept mum about propofol at hospital
|
Seoul shares open down, Samsung Elec falls
Case dismissed against Anna Nicole Smith boyfriend
|
Sundance invites 26 to world premiere of film
|
Oprah delighted with OWN network launch
|
Piers Morgan vows a butt-kicking talk show on CNN
|
ARM says Microsoft needs it for mobile
Homeless man finds success with golden voice
|
Eminem, Drake lead rap sales surge in 2010
|
Skype buys smartphone video star Qik
Mike Tyson, pigeon fancier, gets his own TV show
|
EU rejects Iran's offer of atomic site tour
Germany closes 4,700 farms in dioxin scare
Taliban attack kills 17 at Afghan public bath
German imports hit all time high in November
Obama names Sperling to top economic job
Israel says sees no Iranian atom bomb before 2015
Ivory Coast's Gbagbo expels UK, Canada envoys
Dell unveils Android tablet, smartphone
EU rejects Iran's offer of atomic site tour: Ashton
|
Israeli troops kill wrong man in Hamas raid
Model security shows mainstream move of Iraq's Sadr
|
Citing deficit, Gates moves to cut US defense budget
'Suicide attack kills 17 at Afghan public bath'
Israeli troops kill wrong man in Hamas raid
|
Germany closes 4,700 farms in dioxin scare
Suicide attack kills 17 in southern Afghanistan
US-TECH Summary
Pakistani party to rejoin coalition; reforms deferred
|
U.N. refugee agency warns on Greek anti-migrant fence
|
Suicide bomber kills 17 in Afghanistan
Samsung profit set to rebound; fights for connected TV
Sony aims for No. 2 spot in tablet devices
Afghanistan suicide blast kills 17 in bathhouse
|
LG eyes 4-fold jump in 2011 smartphone sales
Korean, US forces 'lower alert status'
Ghana neutral on Ivory Coast, opposes force: president
|
US 'cannot accept' China military power: state media
2 fiery packages put Md. mailrooms on alert
Parents demand answers in China lead poisoning
Vietnam War 'secret army' chief dies in US hospital
Vang Pao, Hmong guerrilla leader, dies in Calif.
Note in fiery Md. package complained of road signs
Pakistani party to rejoin coalition
Meet the new boss: Daley is Obama chief of staff
Malaysia royal commission to probe political death
Police: Gunman suspended before school shooting
Philippine boy survives three days at sea
Jackson dead before paramedics arrived, court told
Disturbing video shows attacks on disabled victims
Laos general Vang Pao dies in California: hospital
ARM says Microsoft needs it for mobile
|
Celeb tweets make impact on top stories in 2010
Hyundai Motor preferred bidder for S. Korea builder
Pentagon announces plans to rein in spending
Cubans fret as massive job cuts get under way
Taiwan's exports at 32-year high
Kenya cracks down on out-of-hours drinkers
Pakistan to defer IMF-demanded sales tax-PM Gilani
India, Pakistan in onion trade wrangle
Local.com cuts fourth-quarter outlook
|
China eyes deeper German economic ties: report
Indonesia reassures on surging food prices
Taiwan promises swift review of AIG unit sale
Taiwan's new nuclear plant delayed
US banks win approval for China joint ventures
US automaker Ford says China sales hit record in 2010
Harry Potter plagiarism case dismissed in U.S.
|
Celeb tweets make impact on top stories in 2010
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights