Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
How the poor can get poorer, and be OK about that
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Slideshow
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
China PLA officers urge economic punch against U.S.
09 Feb 2010
Senate jobs bill extends Medicare payment rates -text
09 Feb 2010
Moscow says U.S. missile shield aimed at Russia
09 Feb 2010
Euro trims gains, awaits details of Greece rescue
| Video
09 Feb 2010
Honda expands airbag recall as more Toyotas probed
| Video
09 Feb 2010
China PLA officers urge economic punch against U.S.
09 Feb 2010
Study toasts beer as being good for your bones
09 Feb 2010
Google Gmail tweak challenges Facebook, Twitter
09 Feb 2010
Age of mother affects child's autism risk: study
08 Feb 2010
Haiti PM: rebuilding could take 10 years
09 Feb 2010
How the poor can get poorer, and be OK about that
Nerijus Adomaitis and Patrick Lannin
Tue Feb 9, 2010 9:17pm EST
<
1 / 4
>
View Full Size
VILNIUS/RIGA (Reuters) - Moody's upgraded the outlook for Lithuania's debt rating recently, but that means nothing to people like Lijandra Garniene.
World
Sitting in a cramped one-room apartment in Vilnius, the mother of four, a former shop assistant in what was one of Europe's fastest-growing economies, remembers weeping in despair the first time she had to ask for a charity food parcel for her family. Her children are aged between 2 and 13.
"I could not actually say it -- I started to cry. They understood," Garniene, 32, told Reuters. "I was not ashamed -- but I felt so sad that I cannot earn enough myself to buy food for the children, but I had to ask for it."
As financial markets panic about the risks to the euro from laxer governments in southern Europe, the northern Baltic states are already in tight fiscal bandages as they experience Europe's most severe recession.
And the Baltic countries show how, with a passive, compliant population, the medicine of austerity goes down.
Economists say the worst may be over for the Baltics, but the human cost has been high: unemployment in Latvia is now the highest in the European Union -- at 22.8 percent in December 2009. Estonia has the third highest, after Spain, Lithuania the fourth.
Even if some kind of recovery is on the way, it would need to be a very high tide to lift the boats of people like Garniene or, in Latvia to the north, Valentina Pankova, who works in the laundry of an old people's home near Riga, the capital.
She earns just 100 lats a month, or just over $200, on a government scheme to help the unemployed.
As an unenviable crown from the crisis, Latvia set a world record by losing more than 24 percent of its economy in just two years -- a sharper contraction than America's during the Great Depression, according to U.S. analyst Mark Weisbrot of the Washington-based Center for Economic and Policy Research.
Describing Latvia's economic policy response as "19th-century-brutal" in a column in The Guardian last month, he argued its people are suffering under political pressure from other European governments keen to shore up their own banks.
He saw this as a factor behind the Balts' decision to make cuts rather than devalue their currencies and kick-start growth.
"A devaluation in Latvia could trigger the same result in Lithuania, Estonia, and Bulgaria, and increase defaults on the bad loans that these banks made during bubble years throughout the region," he wrote.
So far, those people who remain in the former Soviet states have been rigorously stoic, apart from an isolated outburst of protest in Latvia in January 2009. Many Balts are emigrating in search of work or aging quietly at home, so those who stay tend to remember Soviet days when they stood in line for anything.
"It's just as well that in many shops there are all sorts of discounts," said Pankova, 54. "You go into the shop, you choose cheaper things."
STABLE?
Moody's said on February 4 it sees less downside risk to Lithuania's 'BBB' investment grade bond rating, citing the country's tough budget measures in the wake of the crisis.
"The turnaround has come quicker than anyone had dared hope for," European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) chief economist Erik Berglof told Swedish newspaper Dagens Industri about the Baltic states and east Europe.
"The Baltic states have a very difficult job in front of them with significant risks. But the situation has stabilized."
Despite its crisis, Estonia is on course to adopt the euro in 2011 thanks to a conservative fiscal policy. Lithuania is now even forecasting economic growth in 2010.
But governments in the region, which in the boom was pumped up to double-digit rates of growth by cheap credits from Nordic banks, may yet face pressures to come up with ways to stop people falling into poverty.
"We would not be able to survive physically without these food packages," the Lithuanian mother Garniene said of the aid she gets from Catholic charity Caritas. Her husband Sigitas lost his job as a construction worker when the property market collapsed. The family gets a total 2,000 litas ($835) a month, about a third of what they earned during the boom years.
Latvia is the only European Union country outside Romania to carry a "junk" bond rating. Its government has created a "100 lat" scheme, giving people work at a set wage of 100 lats.
"It is the absolute minimum," said Pankova, adding she was lucky she had no family to support and her flat -- with few modern comforts -- is relatively cheap to run.
HOLDING THE PEG
Even if a hoped-for moderate recovery materializes in 2011, the Baltic economies remain fragile at best -- Latvia's is still shrinking. The speed of a recovery will determine when Nordic banks like Swedbank and SEB -- the region's major financial players -- begin to cut their loan losses.
Latvia had to make its spending cuts to secure a 7.5 billion euro bailout from the International Monetary Fund and EU.
It needed that because, like Estonia and Lithuania, it decided to keep its currency pegged to the euro. Some economists, including Paul Krugman, a Nobel laureate in 2008, said devaluation would have brought a quicker recovery.
"It makes no sense to continue to shrink the Latvian economy, with no end in sight to the recession, simply to maintain the pegged exchange rate," agreed Weisbrot. "Argentina tried this from 1998-2002, also suffering its worst recession ever and pushing 42 percent of its households into poverty."
The Baltic governments and central banks argued devaluation -- which would be a 'nuclear' option for faltering euro zone members -- would cause more harm than good, due mainly to high levels of debt in euros run up during the boom.
As a result, Latvia is set to see a 2009 fall in economic activity of 18 percent and Estonia around 14 percent. Lithuania has reported a drop of 15 percent.
That's visible on one of Riga's main shopping streets, Krisjana Barona street, peppered with "to let" signs and sales signs advertising "50 percent off" or even "70 percent discounts."
OUT OF MIND?
But by and large you don't see the poverty in the Baltic capitals, where the streets still buzz with activity, and popular cafes and restaurants are often full.
It's the suburbs that can show most how property and construction, shops, restaurants and car dealers have been really hit.
At the Saliena property project just outside Riga, sales director Barny Edis points to empty, unsold houses. The ground is still muddy; pipes and construction material have been left lying around. Evidence of the past boom is down the road, where 200 houses that did sell are still occupied.
"It is tough. It's been tough for me, it's been tough for my family, but what doesn't kill you makes you stronger," said Edis, a Briton who brought his wife and two children to Latvia in 2007, just before the property bubble burst.
His company now has 46 houses remaining. Sixteen are completed and six have sold, but another 30 stand unfinished.
He said the company was selling one house a month, compared with four or five a month two or three years ago. He expects the market to pick up around October or November, or early 2011.
Other projects had similar problems: one developer built two tower blocks but abandoned the third half-built, leaving a naked skeleton of concrete and iron bars pointing to the sky.
OPPORTUNITY KNOCKS
As Latvians turn downmarket in their shopping habits, some businesses are, of course, capturing the opportunities: Guntars Lasis is selling goods from bankrupt companies.
In premises which used to house a menswear shop -- it went bankrupt -- he sells a hodge-podge of items including children's winter wear from upmarket Swedish company Polarn O. Pyret, stationery items, some furniture and other odds and ends.
"Lots of people come, many people show an interest and buy a lot," said Lasis. The crisis could be felt in many spheres, he said: people had to realize that to find a job they had to bring down their expectations of how much they could earn.
While entrepreneurs like Lasis can be found the world over, it is hard to envision many people in countries like Greece putting up as stoically with such austerity -- its farmers are already protesting, and strikes are planned.
(Editing by Sara Ledwith)
World
More from Reuters
Honda expands airbag recall as more Toyotas probed
TOKYO/DETROIT (Reuters) - Honda Motor Co said it would recall another 440,000 cars around the world for faulty airbags as rival Toyota Motor Corp faced further probes over its largest-ever safety crisis. | Video
Nikkei rises 0.3 percent as hopes of Greece aid plan help
ArcelorMittal sees little improvement in first quarter
BHP beats forecasts, cautious on China demand
European governments agree to help Greece: source
Second big snowstorm slams East Coast
» More Top News
Analysis:
China's boom may lead to bust
The housing market is becoming the investment of choice for the Chinese, which is making policymakers very nervous. Full Article
Will China hit back at U.S. over Taiwan?
China exporters shrug off yuan issue
China
Avoiding "another Greece"
Don't count on the euro zone growing anytime soon. Getting into the single-currency club will be tougher than ever. Full Article
Failing on reform could haunt euro zone
Should the rest of Europe be worried?
Roubini: Greece aid a good step
Felix Salmon: When Germany bails out Greece
Global Markets
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 10 February 2010 Barroso team wins approval from EU parliament
EA in the red for 12th quarter in a row
Opel unveils turnaround plan, 8,300 jobs slashed
Pilot error behind Ethiopian jet crash
China PLA officers urge economic punch against U.S.
|
Google adding status updates to Gmail
India's software exports face protectionism
Sudan, Chad agree "definitive end" to proxy wars
Pitt, Jolie sue British paper over split claims
China to crack down on online gambling
Afghan avalanches kill 24, up to 40 missing: govt
British PM to face Iraq inquiry in early March
Life imitates art in Oscar-nominated Israeli film
Italy says Iranian militia attacked its embassy
|
Russian tycoon says ex-spy murder claim outrageous
|
Israel urges "crippling" sanctions now against Iran
Google tweaks Gmail to challenge Facebook, Twitter
|
Too early for decision on Myanmar election, says Suu Kyi
Clinton asked to intervene in Haiti kidnap case
China calls for new checks amid milk scare
GOP wary of pitfalls in Obama's health care summit
Taiwan insists submarines, jets still on arms agenda
Newark airport breach suspect pleads not guilty
State Farm says it warned NHTSA on Toyota in 2007
China officers urge economic punch against U.S.
Snowstorms force US House to scrap work week
Colourful Philippine election season kicks off
ATF blames Texas church fires on serial arsonist
China gives 5 years to activist who probed quake
LAPD: Arrest made in killings of anti-gang worker
White House hastens concert to beat snow
US Army closes in on targeted southern Afghan town
Toyota announces mass hybrid vehicle recall
Death of Kerrigan's father is ruled a homicide
Cambodia wants World Court to rule on Thai border
Investigators: acceleration problem not resolved
India halts genetically modified eggplant release
Hollywood names up for Olivier theater awards
Japan Airlines rejects Delta, stays with American
S.Korean creditors offer Kumho 326 million dollar loan
Ma says China trade pact crucial to Taiwan
Malaysia's Maybank Q2 profit up 35 percent
Thai Airways plans to lease 15 new aircraft
Upbeat Nissan now expects full-year profit
Perez Hilton, Black Eyed Peas manager settle suit
Japanese plane seat maker admits falsifying safety data
Angelina Jolie visits quake-hit Haiti
|
Sarkozy senior exhibits paintings in Budapest
Renault to open dealership network in India
China's NetEase reapplies for 'World of Warcraft' licence
Auto sales surged 50 percent last month in India
Louis Gossett Jr. fighting prostate cancer
|
Indian police vow extra security for new Bollywood film
Singapore welcomes 9.7 million visitors in 2009
US allows Cambodia to reschedule $317 mln debt
DeGeneres says Cowell is `meaner than I thought'
India mulls anti-honour killings law
Study: Pop culture helps Indonesia fight terrorism
Bad liquor kills 8 on Indonesia's Java island
Strawberries offer lifeline for Romania's rust belt
Record Super Bowl telecast tops M*A*S*H record
|
Trailblazing Uzbek photographer goes on trial for slander
Einstein's first wife's kin wants her reburied in Serbia
UN forecasts 'stable' Afghan opium crop
US-TECH Summary
Greek gov't workers strike amid reports of European lifeline
Obama warns of swift sanctions against Iran
Tune in, turn off, iPod generation finds perfect haven
Obama says world moving quickly on Iran sanctions
Google Gmail tweak challenges Facebook, Twitter
Haiti secure after quake, but escapees a concern: U.N.
|
Nigerian VP assumes office as acting president
|
US Marines gear up for major Afghan assault
Japan PM sees new reform minister lifting support
|
Disney CEO seduced by iPad
Google Maps climbs to Olympic peaks
NY Times editor rejects call to remove Jerusalem bureau chief
How the poor can get poorer, and be OK about that
|
Coroner confirms 2 Mexican children died in rains
Google Gmail tweak challenges Facebook, Twitter
|
Discovery Channel: 'Deadliest Catch' captain dies
Second big snowstorm slams U.S. East Coast
Tune in, turn off, iPod generation finds perfect haven
|
China jails young man for joining political party
China high court stresses 'mercy' in death penalty
Changes proposed in how psychiatrists diagnose
Malaysia: Anwar sodomy judge mulls stepping down
US denies defense crisis with Russia
Google enters fray in Thai-Cambodia border dispute
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
LA-area foothills under mudslide threat
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
City vehicles strike 2 in San Francisco accidents
Damage to homes near Conn. power plant is assessed
AP NewsAlert
Anwar defence accuses Malaysia trial judge of lies
Fresh snow misery hits eastern US
Sri Lanka set for snap election
Myanmar court sentences US man to 3 years prison
As 'Avatar' conquers, Fox also eyes local releases
Hollywood sign gets makeover for fundraising drive
China to curb maverick steelmaking as costs rise
Seoul shares end flat; banks, commods rise
Taiwan sells T$40 bln bonds at 1.95 pct yield
Ellen finds Simon a challenge on Idol
|
China exports show trade recovery on track
Disney aims to shorten big-screen run for Alice
|
Cruise takes on Mission: Impossible IV
|
Toyota starts fixing Priuses recalled in Japan
Baidu's rosy outlook after Google China quit threat
Lil Wayne sentencing postponed, says goodbye to fans
|
Philippines exports surge in December
PAKISTAN
White Stripes objects to Air Force Reserve ad
|
Honda airbag problem, 437,763 vehicles recalled
Discovery Channel: 'Deadliest Catch' captain dies
Hollywood sign gets makeover for fundraising drive
|
S.Korea Dec money supply growth hits 13-mth high
Disney aims to shorten big-screen run for "Alice"
Academy streamlines process for Oscar winners
|
As 'Avatar' conquers, Fox also eyes local releases
Vampire author Anne Rice set to release video book
Fans delighted by DeGeneres' 'Idol' debut
Vancouver's poor
Academy streamlines process for Oscar winners
White House rings with sound of emancipation, protest
Cashing in on Mandela, 20 years after freedom
Hollywood sign gets makeover for fundraising drive
Lebanon backs Hezbollah against Israel
Yanukovych wins Ukraine vote by 3.5%: results
Pakistan has credible information Mehsud dead
|
Iran says makes arrests before revolution day rally
|
Penguin future looks perkier with marine zone: study
Global mobile broadband spending seen up to $72 billion
Iran says nuclear fuel swap remains an option
Autopsy Results Rule Jackson's Death Homicide
Afghanistan says ready if thousands flee assault
|
Australian study supports gastric surgery for obese teens
Reuters photographer says reborn after freed by U.S.
Opera says to introduce faster browser for iPhone
Greek union marches to challenge austerity plan
|
Australian govt websites face censorship protest
Lady Antebellum Debut At #1 On Billboard Albums Chart With "Need You Now"
More than 150 killed in Afghan avalanches
|
Afghan avalanche toll hits 160: official
"Avatar" Officially Surpasses "Titanic" As The Highest Grossing U.S. Film Of All-Time
Clashes erupt in Sri Lanka over general's arrest
|
Somali clashes kill 24, thousands flee capital
|
Oscar Noms For "Avatar" Translate To Increased Business For Fandango
Israeli warplanes bomb southern Gaza
UK government forced to disclose U.S. torture allegations
|
Afghan avalanches kill 165, rescue underway
"Avatar," "The Hurt Locker" Lead Oscar Nominations
Iran rewards Basij militia with political clout
Yanukovich tells Ukraine rival to quit as premier
|
UNODC sees further drop in Afghan opium production
Sprint loss narrows but revenue misses expectations
|
UN envoy in North Korea to spur nuke talks
Emblaze says Microsoft, Apple infringe its patents
|
Global mobile broadband spending seen up to $72 billion
|
Officials: Afghan avalanches kill 157 people
Opera says to introduce faster browser for iPhone
|
Soldier detained over teen's death in Kashmir
Obama to meet with black leaders on the economy
Security tight as Myanmar workers strike in Yangon
Unflattering Pre-Photoshopped Pics Of Madonna Surface On Internet Blogs
Space shuttle Endeavour pulls in at space station
Cross-examination begins for serial murder suspect
Jennifer Aniston Says Gerard Butler's "A Fun Guy" To Work With
Pakistan has "credible information" Mehsud dead
AP sources: FAA eyes hefty fines for American
Clinton Campaign Office Hostage-Taker On The Lam
NZ teen kidnaps puppy to save it from euthanasia
Obama, Palin trade telling jibes over crib sheets
Illinois Wakes Up To Rare Earthquake
Gov't fitness efforts haven't stemmed kid obesity
Pakistani army helicopter crashes, 2 feared dead
Generation 2 Worldwide and "ChildESIGNS" Drop Side Crib Brands Recalled; Three Infant Deaths Reported
Pakistan: Taliban leader's reported death credible
Psychiatric Group Proposes Changes To Mental Disorder Categories
PROMISES, PROMISES: War widows' futile fight
Aussie wheat board trial starts over Iraq payments
Innovage LLC Recalls Discovery Kids Lamps Due to Fire and Burn Hazards
Lil Wayne's Prison Stint Delayed By Dental Appointment
Anonymous Businesses Put Up Billboard Ad With George W. Bush's Image
MS Less Likely In Those Whose Pregnant Mothers Drank Milk
Rio Tinto employees to stand trial in China
Report: Rio Tinto employees to stand trial
Honda airbag fault fuels Japan's auto woes
Pakistani o/n rates rise; rupee weakens; stocks down
Stan Lee gives himself a role in Super Seven
|
KOREA MARKETS-Some players seek insurance as doves reign
Taiwan to end ban on LCD, chip investment in China
Steel giant ArcelorMittal posts profit
For defense team, singer's fame may pose challenge
Indonesia hotel bombing suspect goes on trial
Japan machinery orders jump 20 percent in December
Indonesian said "God is great" as hotels attacked
Conference takes on "What the world needs now"
Toshiba plans for new chip factory: report
South Korea jobless rate jumps to nine-year high
Hard times in Gaza fill ranks of Hamas police
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Stan Lee gives himself a role in "Super Seven"
Chopped-off heads and other Paris treasures on show
Riot Erupts at Saudi Girls' School
Anonymous Businesses Put Up Billboard Ad With George W. Bush's Image
Google Challenges Facebook, Twitter With Gmail 'Buzz'
American Airlines Charging For Blankets On Domestic, Some International Flights
Tiger Woods & Rosie O'Donnell Make For Least Desirable Valentines According To New Survey
O'Hare Wants To Use Cemetery For Runway Expansion
British Girls Becoming Pregnant At Age Ten
North Korean Government Releases Detained United States Missionary; Robert Parks Back Home
Angry Army Father Arrested After Allegedly Waterboarding 4-Year-Old Daughter
Ohio Strip Club Raises Funds For Haiti With Lap Dances For Charity
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights