Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Divided you will fail, Loach warns Palestinians
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
World
Divided you will fail, Loach warns Palestinians
AFP - Thursday, January 13
Send
IM Story
Print
RAMALLAH, Palestinian Territories (AFP) - – British film director Ken Loach brought a message of warning to the Palestinians on his first visit to the occupied territories: if you are divided you will fail.
The 74-year-old filmmaker and veteran social activist arrived in the West Bank on Tuesday to attend a screening of his award-winning drama "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" which depicts the Irish struggle for independence from Britain in the 1920s and the ensuing civil war.
Hundreds of Palestinians packed into Ramallah's Cultural Palace to watch the film, which won the Palme D'Or at Cannes in 2006 but was subjected to fierce criticism when it was released in Britain.
The film, which contains some harrowing scenes of brutality, follows the story of two brothers caught up in the fight against the British occupation, but who are eventually ripped apart by bitterly opposing views on the Anglo-Irish treaty of 1921.
What really struck a chord with the audience was the fact the conflict had two levels to it: the fight against the occupation, and the internal struggles which ended up splitting the Republican movement.
"We just thought you might find it interesting," the softly spoken director told the audience with a wry smile.
"It's exactly like Hamas and Fatah," whispered one member of the audience as the film drew to its bloody and tragic conclusion, clearly surprised by the obvious parallels between the splits among the Irish Republicans and those of the Palestinian factions.
Brooding tensions between Hamas and Fatah, both of whom have different views on ending the occupation, have simmered for years but erupted into deadly violence in 2007 when the Islamists forced their secular rivals out of Gaza, effectively splitting the Palestinian territories in half.
"The experience from Ireland is: if you are divided, you will fail," Loach told the audience, which broke into applause as he stepped onto the stage.
"There is that big struggle between the ultimate prize and what you think you can achieve at that moment."
An unassuming yet deeply committed social activist, who is known for his bitter-sweet pictures focusing on social reality such as "Kes" (1969) and "Land and Freedom" (1995), Loach has taken a central role in the campaign for a cultural boycott of Israel.
In 2009, Loach withdrew his film "Looking for Eric" from the Melbourne film festival in protest over Israel's sponsorship of another filmmaker, and several months earlier, he took a similar stance at the Edinburgh film festival.
"We just have to chip away at the boycott and make certain that Israel becomes a pariah -- and encourage the boycott of trade," he said.
"It is not the time to be silent... to write journalism or make films that ignore reality," said Loach. "It's the presence of justice that we need to see in this land."
Asked about his first impression of the Palestinian territories, Loach said it was shock at the towering reality of the vast separation barrier Israel is building across the West Bank.
"Nothing prepares you for the shock of seeing the wall," he told AFP. "The reality of it is so brutal and harsh and so illegal that it made us feel angry."
Loach's remarks appeared to reflect a deep pessimism about the prospect for meaningful change in the Middle East.
"There is a very simple lesson we learned from Ireland: don't trust the word of the ruling class," he said to a wave of applause as he described the 1921 Anglo-Irish treaty as a "cynical" attempt to keep the British Empire intact.
"What they were determined to do was... to prevent the people from being genuine participants in their own future," he said.
A similar situation was being played out in the Middle East, where economic and political control was at stake, he said.
"What people face here is an economic reality where the big powers, principally the Americans, want to keep control of the region and they have people who do that for them in Israel. That's the realpolitik."
Loach called current attempts to negotiate an end to the occupation as "phoney" and "fraudulent" and said they were unlikely to lead anywhere until the parties agreed to apply international law.
"We are approaching the whole thing in the wrong way. There is clearly no intention by the Israeli government to act legally, and there is no pressure for that from the States," he told AFP.
"How long can the world ignore the Geneva Convention? At some point, it has to end."
Ultimately, it would be up to the United Nations, which he believes is the only body that could actually enforce change.
"It's their job to uphold the law and face down the Americans," he said."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 1 hour 7 minutes ago
David Nelson of "Ozzie and Harriet" TV family dies Reuters - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
John Travolta and Kelly Preston show off new baby Reuters - 1 hour 27 minutes ago
Russia bans Cinderella over 'political message': report AFP - Thursday, January 13
Divided you will fail, Loach warns Palestinians AFP - Thursday, January 13
News Search
Top Stories
Portugal claims success in bond sale
EU launches new era of tighter economic governance
Lebanon's unity government collapses
EU divided over debt crisis fund boost
Haitians grieve on quake anniversary
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Falling blackbirds baffle Arkansas officials
Hasta la Vista: Arnie quits as California governor
Goldman deal 'values Facebook at $50 billion'
Spain lotto winner nearly loses millions by tossing tickets
Brazil's 2010 trade surplus lowest in 8 years: official
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 13 January 2011 Hezbollah, allies quit Lebanese goverment
UK confidence in online shopping rattled by snow: poll
Hezbollah forces Lebanon government collapse
Portugal claims success in bond sale
EU launches new era of tighter economic governance
Fujitsu unveils 'world's first' glasses-free 3D PC
Lebanon's unity government collapses
Attacks in Afghanistan kill 5 NATO troops
EU divided over debt crisis fund boost
NATO: 5 service members killed in Afghanistan
Haitians grieve on quake anniversary
At least 127 dead as rains pummel Brazil regions
|
Gaza militants say to halt rocket fire at Israel
|
Qatar restore pride with China victory
Five more killed in Tunisia clashes: witnesses
|
China bans German pork, egg imports
China says stealth jet test flight not a threat
|
Biden tells Pakistan: 'We are not the enemy of Islam'
Djeparov fires Uzbeks towards Asian Cup quarters
Divided you will fail, Loach warns Palestinians
Crew under pressure to land Kaczynski plane: Russia
|
Two Thais in Cambodia court on spying charges
Russian spy Anna Chapman to host TV show
U.N. says Gbagbo-backers loot food convoy in Abidjan
|
N. Korea reopens border hotline with S. Korea
Book tells inspiring tale behind King's Speech film
U.S. Vice President Biden warns against Pakistan extremism
England win thriller to set T20 record
Geithner urges China reform ahead of Hu visit
Nvidia shares surge 12 percent, extend rally
|
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee firms; o/n rates flat
IBM, Samsung to jointly develop chip technology
|
Clearwire shares rise on hopes of funding deal
|
Activist manager sells Cisco shares on rights concerns
|
Wikipedia, 10 years old, targets India for growth
|
Demand Media moves ahead with $112.5 million IPO
|
Toyota to make lithium batteries for hybrids: Nikkei
|
John Travolta and Kelly Preston show off new baby
|
Seth Rogen, Jay Chou dish on new Green Hornet
|
German firm develops Internet eraser for photos
David Nelson of Ozzie and Harriet TV family dies
|
Ten years on, Wikipedia eyes a better world
US-TECH Summary
Clearwire shares rise on hopes of funding deal
News Corp., Apple to unveil 'The Daily' next week
Demand Media moves ahead with $112.5 million IPO
Lebanon plunged into uncertainty as government falls
Spain faces first big debt test of 2011
Brisbane avoids worst in floods but sees years of rebuilding
|
YouTube mobile video viewing tops 200 mln a day
Hezbollah and allies resign, toppling Lebanon government
Lebanon plunged into uncertainty as government falls
|
Prince Harry eyes North Pole trek
PC sales growth slows in fourth quarter: Gartner
Afghan police: Explosion reported in Jalalabad
Hezbollah forces Lebanon govt collapse
Ivory Coast army seals off pro-Ouattara area, bars U.N.
|
Russia blames Polish pressure for Kaczynski crash
Investors bet on Nvidia's new mobile chips
U.S. agencies believe Iran's nuclear efforts have slowed
Haitians recall 2010 quake hell as death toll upped
|
PC shipment growth lackluster in Q4
World Bank sees 2008 risks for global economy
Taylor Swift Scores Lowest-Selling #1 Album On The Billboard Albums Chart With "Speak Now"
2010 ties 2005 for warmest year on record: US
Egypt Christians clash with police over shooting
Google turns Android smartphones into interpreters
U.S. agencies believe Iran's nuclear efforts have slowed
|
Global economy to slow in 2011: World Bank
Philippine floods, landslides kill 42
|
Citing rights failings, firm divests Cisco holdings
Gaza militants say to halt rocket fire at Israel
Blackpool pile on agony for Liverpool in Premier League
Mobile airwaves seen key to U.S. competitiveness
Special Report: Vietnam capitalist roaders follow China's trail
|
Palestinian fails in bid to win control of settlement
Ultimate Software looks at selling itself: sources
A Kuwaiti PM in first Iraq visit since war
Winter brings fiery killer into Afghan homes
|
Wikipedia, 10 years old, targets India
At least 270 dead in Brazil floods
|
IBM, Samsung to jointly develop chip technology
Japan PM to tap fiscal hawk in new line-up: report
|
N. Korea must act to defuse tensions: Gates
Bob Geldof is keynote speaker at South by Southwest
Brisbane a 'war zone' as huge flood smashes city
Edward Furlong scraps trip after latest arrest
Japan PM to tap fiscal hawk in new line-up
Imam criticised for NY mosque embarks on U.S. speaking tour
N. Korea's uranium for making bombs: South
Obama leads mourning of Arizona shooting victims
Factbox
Brisbane avoids worst in floods, sees years of rebuilding
Obama visits wounded U.S. Congresswoman Giffords
Hard times make way for fuller-figured lingerie
China says shares U.S. goals on Korea as hotline reopens
Texan builds artful, green homes out of trash
News Corp says looking at spinout or sale of MySpace
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Biden in Baghdad to meet Maliki: WHouse
Brisbane flood peaks well below expected high: officials
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
Investors bet on Nvidia's new mobile chips
|
Showtime cable network passes on "Kennedys"
Australia rebuilding task 'of postwar proportions'
Disruptive Arizona suspect axed from online group
Bob Geldof is keynote speaker at South by Southwest
Mobile airwaves seen key to U.S. competitiveness
|
US 'not the enemy of Islam' says Biden
Edward Furlong scraps trip after latest arrest
World Bank says China has room for more rate hikes
PC shipment growth lackluster in Q4
|
S. Korea raises key rate, moves against inflation
Taiwan capital to levy 'luxury residence' tax
Ultimate Software looks at selling itself: sources
|
Carmakers target inland China to maintain growth
Seoul shares end down amid options expiry
HIGHLIGHTS-Bank of Korea chief's comments at news conference
Japan PM taps fiscal hawk in cabinet shake-up
India's Infosys reports 14.1% net profit rise
Tyler Perry nabs 19 NAACP Image Award nominations
WRAPUP 1-S.Korea steps up inflation battle, raises rates
"Green Hornet" never reaches top speed
Pakistan
Obama Visits Hospital, Meets With Injured And Families
Conan feels liberated after year of tumult
The Game Scores Huge Ratings For BET
Katie Holmes new face of Ann Taylor clothing
"The Big Bang Theory" Renewed For Three More Years
The need of the hour is return of sanity, remembering that we are one"
Chinas stealth jet fighter sends signal about its military power
Facebook paid $8.5 million for fb.com domain
Somber mood as Tucson prepares to welcome President Obama
Study: Energy drinks don't lessen effects of alcohol
AP, Fairey copyright case involving Obama's image dismissed
Principal at NYC prep school fired over affair with 18-year-old ex-student
Conan feels liberated after year of tumult
|
Edward Furlong scraps trip after latest arrest
|
Green Hornet never reaches top speed
|
Tyler Perry nabs 19 NAACP Image Award nominations
|
Showtime cable network passes on Kennedys
|
Bob Geldof is keynote speaker at South by Southwest
|
Three actors exit Law & Order: Los Angeles series
|
Book tells inspiring tale behind King's Speech film
|
David Nelson of Ozzie and Harriet TV family dies
|
British health tech startups seek US foothold
Lebanon in political turmoil as govt collapses
Spotify, Shazam tie up on finding and buying music
Ship carrying acid overturns in Germany: police
Analysis: a year after China retreat, Google plots new growth
RIM gives India access but not to secure e-mails
Violent clashes spread to centre of Tunisian capital
|
Prize-winning Korean director shoots iPhone film
Iran's nuclear sites tour proposal flounders
|
News Corp says looking at spinout or sale of MySpace
Gates warns on North Korea, eyes Japan ties
|
U.S. and European officials warn Belarus after crackdown
|
In France, far right seizes on Muslim street prayers
|
Iran's nuclear sites tour proposal flounders
Japan boss: Asian Cup like Champions League
Cambodian court grants bail to 2 Thais
More foreign film shooting in Thailand expected
ANALYSIS: Leadership a vexing issue for Thailand's opposition party
Analysis: A year after China retreat, Google plots new growth
|
US envoy blasts China, India on WTO talks progress
Rain washes out tennis at Kooyong Classic
Pakistani stocks end on 31-mth high; rupee flat
AT&T to take Q4 $2.7 billion charge on accounting change
|
RIM gives India access but not to secure e-mails
|
Pakistan's forex reserves fall to $17.09 bln
Ultimate Software says no current plans for sale
|
BlackBerry announces answer to India security fear
MTS estimates 2010 Russia handset sales rose 25 percent
|
POSCO posts sharp drop in profit
Prize-winning Korean director shoots iPhone film
|
Police halt body recovery at N. Zealand mine
South Korea steps up inflation battle, raises rates
Frenchman held in Indonesia over drugs: official
Prize-winning Korean director shoots iPhone film
China's Li into Sydney tennis final
Troubled Indonesia budget airline halts operations
Lady Gaga, Miranda Lambert, Eminem To Perform On The Grammys
Judge says Homeland Security can keep scanned image secrets
Study: Antibiotics best treatment for toddlers with ear infections
Snow covers 71 percent of U.S.
AIG to sell Taiwan business for $2.16 billion
California man charged with threatening Washington congressman
Prize-winning Korean director shoots iPhone film
|
Nude housekeeper on trial for stabbing client to death
Space observatory finds smallest Earth-like planet outside solar system
Japan firm launches mirror thermometer for detecting flu
Laos opens first stock exchange
Cuba registering first lung cancer vaccine in South America
Seattle 'superhero' attacked over the weekend, thugs break his nose
Its a Bird, Its a Shark, Its a Mossad Spy
Saudi court sentences woman to 3 years for torturing, mutilating Indonesian maid
Forget gossip: Facebook will not shut down March 15
'Butt dial' sends SWAT team to school
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights