Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Sniffing out the fakes: perfume world battles smell-alikes
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
World
Sniffing out the fakes: perfume world battles smell-alikes
AFP - Monday, November 15
Send
IM Story
Print
Sniffing out the fakes: perfume world battles smell-alikes
PARIS (AFP) - – Kenzo Flower or Coco Chanel? Take your pick among dozens of fragrances, copied for a fraction of the price. This is the promise made by a growing army of "smell-alike" perfumers -- and they have the law on their side.
Like the rest of the luxury industry, perfumers are under assault from imitators set on cashing in on their brand image, and sites that openly claim to copy top fragrances are flourishing on the Internet.
One British site -- Perfume Parlour -- offers perfume oils with the "same top, heart and base notes as the designer perfumes available from the high street stores" -- for around one-tenth of the price tag.
While there may be little market for a designer handbag without designer logo, consumers who buy knock-off designer scents don't parade the bottles in public -- making the copies harder to sniff out.
And unless the copycats infringe on a brand's trademark, for instance by copying a bottle shape or logo, perfumers are powerless to stop them in court.
"Everyone agrees that copying a painting is breaking the law, but copying a perfume is not, according to much of the judicial world," says Jean-Pierre Houri, the president of the International Fragrance Association whose members represent 90 percent of the eight-billion-dollar global industry.
To protect itself from copycats, perfumers have traditionally relied on secrecy -- keeping their precious formulae under tight wraps.
While in theory perfumers can patent the composition of a perfume, the great majority choose not to, precisely because it would require them to reveal their formulae.
Perfume Parlour says it currently uses a process called gas liquid chromatography to analyse the chemical make-up of designer scents and distill its own imitation oils.
If its recipes were freely available, the perfume industry argues, there would be no stopping the counterfeiters, who would only have to tweak a few details to escape the law.
That is why the industry is troubled by the growing pressure it faces to disclose its formulae, in the interests of consumer health and safety.
Under a right-to-know bill proposed this year in California, the industry would be required to reveal the precise compounds used in its perfumes. The California bill is currently stalled, but IFRA believes it is only a matter of time before similar rules are enacted around the world.
"We are caught between a rock and a hard place," Houri told AFP. "The right-to-know movement is a deep social trend. But confidentiality is fundamental as long as we cannot protect our creations."
IFRA recently published a list of all the fragrance materials used by its members worldwide -- running to some 3,000 entries -- but that is currently as far as the industry is willing to go.
Fine fragrance is in the eye of the storm, but the same problem faces industrial users of perfume -- the shampoo and laundry powder makers who make up 75 percent of the market and for whom fragrance is a key marketing asset.
For Allan McRitchie, a British perfumer and marketing consultant, "we have to find whatever way we can to protect that intellectual property."
Currently, he says, you can write court cases around technologies used to deliver a perfume, around new novel materials, or even secondary benefits such as anti-bacterial properties.
"But a lot of perfumes don't fall into these categories."
For many in the fragrance world, the answer is to convince the courts and regulators that perfume is an art form -- and its creations, the scents themselves, therefore eligible for copyright protection.
Courts around the world have ruled in recent years that perfumery involves only technical know-how, not art.
But IFRA is leading the charge: last month it filed a report with a French appeals court in a case pitting L'Oreal against a perfume maker, making the case for classifying perfumes as works of art. The ruling is due in December.
On the political front, IFRA is inviting a European lawmaker to tour a Paris laboratory this month to see perfumers' work up close, with a view to setting up workshops for parliament members next year.
As a perfumer for the Japanese giant Takasago International, which supplies scents to top fine fragrance, cosmetics and consumer product brands, Laurence Fanuel believes "scents are like stories".
Flowers, essences and chemicals are fused into a complex potion to trigger a flood of pleasure, emotions and memories: when Fanuel creates a new perfume, there is no doubt in her mind what she is doing.
"If art can be defined as a combination of elements that excite the senses, trigger emotions and stimulate thoughts -- why isn't perfumery classified as an art form?" asks the Paris-based perfumer.
To create a new scent she draws inspiration from other art forms, natural scents such as those given off while cooking, from her own past experiences and from "a passion for mixing unexpected things".
She also sees clear links with other arts: just as a film can "overdose" on a particular light technique or colour, a perfumer can overdose on a scent to create a "signature", and dress the fragrance up around it.
"And if you say perfume is an art, you will be able to protect it like any other art form."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 1 hour 59 minutes ago
Online viewers still loving regular TV, poll shows Reuters - 1 hour 59 minutes ago
Film on climate change bad boy says 'Cool It' over panic AFP - 2 hours 20 minutes ago
Jane Lynch says no Muppets role for her Reuters - Monday, November 15
Singer Jessica Simpson to marry again Reuters - Monday, November 15
News Search
Top Stories
Muslim pilgrims pour into Mina as the hajj begins
Nobel laureate backs US 'easy money' policy
In Afghan south, US troops turn from battle to building
Sushi wars: fight looms over bluefin tuna
Binladin group wins $7.2 bln Jeddah contract
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Travolta jets home as wife goes into labour
Property bubble fears weigh on Spanish recovery
'Naked' airport scanners may be 'dangerous'
Binladin group wins $7.2 bln Jeddah contract
Muslim pilgrims pour into Mina as the hajj begins
More Most Viewed »
Alcohol more harmful than heroin, crack cocaine: study
Toddler survives seven-floor fall in France
Spectacular unknown species found in Amazon
EU fines 11 airlines 800 million euros for air cargo cartel
Be fit, have fewer colds: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 15 November 2010 Military exercises carried out near nuclear sites
Sarkozy to announce new French government at 1915 GMT
Israeli government seen accepting new settlement freeze
|
Iran detains 5 lawyers on security charges
Hundreds protest in Moscow against journalist attacks
Binladin group wins $7.2 bln Jeddah contract
Iraqi MPs salvage power-sharing pact after walk-out
Five NATO troops killed as Afghanistan violence soars
|
Berlusconi clings on as crunch week looms
Israeli government seen accepting new settlement freeze
Sudan independence vote chief slams foreign donors
|
Irish bailout talk reaches fever pitch
Iran 'holds defence drills' at nuclear plants
Man Tries To Run Over Girlfriend When She Says No To Proposal
World's largest pilgrimage underway as hajj begins
Iraq violence kills eight
Socialists lead in Greek regional vote, low turnout
|
NATO: 5 service members killed in Afghanistan
Haiti cholera toll tops 900 with six provinces affected
|
Afghanistan: 3 NATO service members killed
Cuban political prisoner who refused exile is freed
|
North-south tensions threaten Sudan's Darfur: U.N.
|
Japan PM sees pain ahead as trade barriers come down
Malaysia plans sex education for six year olds
Hollywood honours filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard
Clashes in Bangladesh amid opposition strike
Indonesians trickle home as volcano toll nears 250
Mt Merapi remains on alert, refugee banned from returning home
Hollywood honours filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard
Indonesia's flag carrier suffers $616,000 in losses due to Merapi eruptions
Japan, Peru reach agreement on free trade deal
Man fined $38,000 for cigarette smuggling
Macau celebrates first-ever Asian Games gold
US and Asia Pacific nations plan trade pact by 2012
Megamind tops box offices for second week
|
Two more NATO soldiers killed in Afghanistan
Germany's Merkel rallies party as crunch year looms
Five Canadians, two Mexicans dead in Cancun resort explosion
|
SAP expects its co-CEO to testify in Oracle case
US dismay at Karzai's military reduction call
British couple freed by pirates 'happy to be alive'
Muslim pilgrims pour into Mina as the hajj begins
Toll from Afghan clash rises to five, worst in six months
|
US-TECH Summary
Nobel laureate backs US 'easy money' policy
Somalia most at risk from terror attacks: study
Israeli government seen accepting new settlement freeze
Volatile mix of politics and crime plagues Karachi
|
In Afghan south, US troops turn from battle to building
Karzai wants US to reduce military operations: report
Sarkozy appoints right-wing cabinet with eye on 2012
Sushi wars: fight looms over bluefin tuna
Sudan independence vote chief slams foreign donors
Lax Egypt border lets Hamas rearm
Sarkozy names a new more right-wing French cabinet
Qantas 747 returns to Sydney, A380s stay grounded
|
North-south tensions threaten Sudan's Darfur
Lebanon arrests preacher who praised 9/11 hijackers
Honorary Oscars for film legends Coppola, Godard
Ex-N.Z TV host slams race row apology to India
Adam Scott hangs on to win Singapore Open
Mexico hotel blast kills Canadian tourists, staff
Brad Pitt company vies to film Chile miner saga: report
Long wait for justice over Philippine massacre
Petraeus: Karzai comments hurt war effort
Chinese supercomputer named world's fastest
Pacquiao's trainer issues challenge to Mayweather
Britain to introduce happiness index: report
Number of NKorean defectors to SKorea tops 20,000
S.Korea, Peru ink free trade agreement
Sniffing out the fakes: perfume world battles smell-alikes
Myanmar's Suu Kyi, newly free, calls for talks
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Japan's economy expands in Q3, but risks remain
Jane Lynch says no Muppets role for her
New Zealand aiming to contain kiwifruit disease
French cuisine eyes UNESCO heritage spot
S.Korea Oct bank lendings rise to multi-mth highs
SAP expects its co-CEO to testify in Oracle case
|
In Greece's fallow fields, solar energy stirs
Singer Jessica Simpson to marry again
TEXT-S&P Korea's Hyundai Steel rated BBB-, outlook stable
Handel's 'Alcina' storms Vienna State Opera
Seoul shares end flat; banks, techs lend support
Yahoo India looking for more language partners-head
|
'Megamind' keeps box office gold
S.Korea Citi bond index bid may be dropped
Korea Hot Stocks
Venice residents protest 'theme park' city
S.Korea bonds eye auctions, unfazed by Citi index news
Indonesians ignore volcano threat to go home
NZ Q3 retail sales up on tax; no rates pressure
Man Tries To Run Over Girlfriend When She Says No To Proposal
Singer Jessica Simpson to marry again
|
Jane Lynch says no Muppets role for her
|
Online viewers still loving regular TV, poll shows
|
Swedish imports make their mark in Hollywood
|
Megamind tops box offices for second week
|
No let-up in Afghan violence ahead of NATO summit
Save the world from climate change -- by computer
Myanmar people overjoyed but worry about Suu Kyi
|
Japan's MUFG to buy 3.8 billion pounds of RBS assets
No let-up in Afghan violence ahead of NATO summit
Taiwan NSB gets half million cyber attacks a month
South Sudanese register for independence vote
Eyeing Iran, Israel slates missile shield for 2015
|
Congress Reconvenes For "Lame-Duck" Session On Bush Tax Cuts
Iraq violence kills five
Yahoo India looking for more language partners
Three Fort Carson Soldiers Arrested In Marijuna Dispensary Break-In
Obama Confident Republicans Getting Ready For Compromise
India opposition vows to block reform bills over scandal
|
"The Game" Cast Members Furious At BET Network Over Talent Fee Issue
US envoy denies exit strategy for Afghanistan
Study: Moderate Drinking Good For Male Bypass Surgery Survivors
NATO sees no alternative to Afghan operations
|
Karzai call for less troops frustrates US general
Obama Hopeful Of Middle East Peace Talks Resumption
NATO to stress global role despite Afghan bruising
|
Kitajima flops at A.Games, China goldrush steams on
Vitamin D Deficiency Doubles Stroke Risk In Whites
NATO: 2 more service members die in Afghan attack
Tateishi stuns Kitajima in A.Games 100m breaststroke
Sleep Problems Linked With Inflammation
Guinea misses deadline for poll result
|
Twelve dead in Shanghai high-rise fire
Pakistan PM urges donors for patience on reforms
Indonesian graft suspect 'bribed his way out of jail 68 times'
A tale of 'nasi goreng'
Indonesian lawmakers urge govt to declare Myanmar election undemocratic
Pamela Anderson in Indian reality TV show
'America's Most Wanted' to debut in Asia
Pakistan filmmakers dream of post-Taliban renaissance
Guide pony helps blind Muslim woman go to US college
Google urges U.S. to challenge China Internet curbs
|
Secular Tel Aviv gets its very own 'messiah'
Indonesia 'should review' Myanmar's elections
Motorola eyes split into two in January
|
Broom-wielding quidditch players sweep New York
Pakistan struggle in SA Test after Amla, Kallis tons
Online viewers still loving regular TV, poll shows
Google and Facebook rivalry takes centerstage
|
Film on climate change bad boy says 'Cool It' over panic
AMD joins Intel-led MeeGo smartphone project
|
Nicaragua, Costa Rica urged to pull back in Google map spat
|
Network congestion lifts home 3G station market
|
EMC to buy data storage firm Isilon for $2.25 billion
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights