Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
US Bordeaux prices at risk of 'bloodbath', experts say
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
US Bordeaux prices at risk of 'bloodbath', experts say
AFP - Sunday, November 8
Send
IM Story
Print
US importer Diageo Chateau & Estate Wines (DC&E), a subsidiary of the British drinks giant Diageo, has abandoned Bordeaux wine after 35 years, aggressively liquidating its warehouse stock on an already shaky market.
BORDEAUX, France (AFP) - – Even as Chateau Lafite leads a surge for Bordeaux vintners in Asia, US retail prices for the same wines have skidded below wholesale cost as a major importer dumps stocks worth tens of millions of dollars.
US importer Diageo Chateau & Estate Wines (DC&E), a subsidiary of the British drinks giant Diageo, has abandoned Bordeaux wine after 35 years, aggressively liquidating its warehouse stock on an already shaky market.
Speaking to AFP, a source within DC&E, who asked to remain anonymous, blamed "enormous stocks" of unsold Bordeaux for their exodus. "It's all about making money. The margins are getting thinner each year and Americans are trading down."
DC&E's turbulent withdrawal, which has heated up in recent weeks, is having a "huge impact on the market," Chris Adams, chief executive of Manhattan retailer Sherry Lehmann, told AFP.
For many years, DC&E was the largest US buyer of Bordeaux, and amassed a colossal cellar. Now famous labels such as Lafite, Haut Brion and Lynch Bages are being offered to American retailers at discounts of up to 50 percent.
"I have 5.5 million dollars' worth of First Growths in my warehouse that I cannot sell, because I'll be 50 percent more expensive than Chateau & Estate," said Guillaume Touton, owner of Monsieur Touton Selection, the New York importer with annual sales of over 100 million dollars.
"A major Mexican importer sent trucks to New York to pick up inventory, because it was 25-percent cheaper to buy it from Chateau & Estate," he said
"No one else can sell their wine. We don't know how long the scenario will last," said Geoff Labitzke, Corporate V.P. of Fine Wine for Youngs Market Company, a California-based wholesaler with annual revenues topping one billion dollars.
The timing is particularly bad.
The economic crisis crippled Bordeaux wine sales and "the exchange rate is killing us," chorused several wine merchants.
But Adams came to DC&E's defence. "They're exiting the market - and trying to find the correct market price." He said the discount prices "reflect the level of demand for the 2005 and 2006."
But there is a benefit for wine lovers suffering like consumers in general from the downturn. "In general we are passing a lot of the discounts on to consumers," he said.
Today Sherry Lehmann retails Chateau Lafite 2006 at 495 dollars (334 euros) per bottle. Wholesalers bought the same wine two years ago for 310 euros per bottle, shipping, taxes and broker fees not included. Connoisseurs can pick up "vintage of the century" Lafite 2005 for 9,900 dollars (6,674 euros) a case. Just six weeks ago, a New York Sotheby's auction sold the same wine for 14,520 dollars (9,789 euros) a case.
The pricing problems for Bordeaux are not new, nor entirely the fault of DC&E's defection or the economy. Prices soared between 1982 and 2005 under the combined pressure from Asia, speculators and Robert Parker's faithful legions.
The problem was exacerbated according to Labitzke, because Costco and DC&E bought huge allocations and hoarded the wine, creating "an artificial level of implied demand from the US -- the wine estates set their prices based on this perceived demand."
Touton agreed. "Chateaux have admitted to me that they had had steady growth for the last 15-20 years because of (DC&E). DC&E was part banker, part Santa Claus. Well, Santa Claus is gone now."
The bubble burst when vintners badly miscalculated the prices for the 2006 and 2007 vintages. Consumers fled. Wholesalers and retailers cancelled orders. And companies like DC&E were left financing overpriced wine.
Aquitaine Wine Company's Harvard-educated CFO Margaret Calvet likened the situation to the classic business school case study, tulip mania.
At the end of 16th century, the world was crazy for tulips. They were coveted as the ultimate luxury good. They were sold on futures. Prices climbed to dizzying heights until buyers would no longer follow. The price no longer had any relation to the flower's intrinsic value. In 1637, tulip prices crashed, never to recover.
"There is a price ceiling for every wine on the planet," concurred Labitzke. "Beyond that ceiling, the consumer will not pay."
Bordeaux and its partners are, naturally, hoping to avoid the fate of tulips.
Brokers and merchants are pressuring vintners to resist the temptation to raise prices on the excellent 2009 vintage. And some merchants have moved to stench the flow of discounted wine on the market as well as replenish their own stock from someone willing to lose 50 cents on the dollar.
Pierre-Antoine Casteja, CEO of Joanne, a 125-million-euro wine merchant firm with a six-million-bottle cellar, confirmed in an email to AFP that he had bought stock from DC&E.
Meanwhile, Adams raised the spectre many vintners fear.
"There are a lot of retailers in America where Diageo was their supplier for Bordeaux wine." The retailers will continue to stock their shelves, but will it have Bordeaux on the label? "When you pull a bottle off the shelf, another bottle replaces it. You don't get back that shelf space," said Adams.
Casteja has already moved decisively to fill the distribution void with his recent purchases. "The stock already in NY will remain there to be sold by the organisation we have established there."
In the meantime, Bordeaux and its partners in America are bracing themselves for DC&E's imminent sale of the 2007 vintage. In separate interviews with AFP, four wine executives predicted a "bloodbath."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Jimmy Cobb still 'Kind of Blue' after 50 years AFP - Monday, November 9
Kosher comics prove hit with Israel's Haredi Jews AFP - Sunday, November 8
Football fever transforms 'Carmen' in SAfrica AFP - Sunday, November 8
Shakespeare's MacBeth meets Africa in Botswana's opera AFP - Sunday, November 8
Hopper: All's 'good right now' despite cancer AP - Sunday, November 8
News Search
Top Stories
Japan eyes solar station in space
Advertisers face resistance to on-line tracking
IMF says stimulus needed to aid 'nascent' recovery
Obama to push lawmakers on health care vote
Opel chief quits after GM decides to keep European unit
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Gold price hits record after 'Sri Lanka purchase'
US grieves after Muslim doctor kills 13 on army base
Obesity causes 100,000 US cancers every year: study
Opel chief quits after GM decides to keep European unit
10 percent jobless rate adds to pressure on Obama
More Most Viewed »
Somali centenarian weds 17-year-old
Mobile phone giant Nokia sues Apple over patents
Fibre may keep asthma, diabetes at bay, study finds
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Sunday, 8 November 2009 Two Britons Win $149 Million Lottery Jackpot
Escaped Circus Elephant Sideswipes Car
The Sky Is Falling: Mysterious Ice Chunks Hit Chicago Home
Japanese Gangster Opens Fire On Three Debt Collectors, Then Commits Suicide
New Mom Sarah Jessica Parker Relishes The Smell Of Dirty Diapers
Dartmouth Scientist Uses Modern Technology To Authenticate Iconic Oswald Photo
Atlanta Man Rescues One Dog, Ends Up With Ten
Iran to reject UN-brokered nuclear plan: leading MP
G20 wants 'ambitious' Copenhagen talks
G20 'agrees timetable' for monitoring economic policy
Obama to push lawmakers on health care vote
Lebanon's Hariri set to form government with Hezbollah
Honduran rivals signal new bid to solve crisis
| International
|
Study shows high cost of German reunification: report
| International
|
Iran releases 3 journalists jailed during rallies
British man provides photo for his own wanted poster
| International
|
Shortage of military therapists creates strain
China PM reaches out to Muslims in Cairo speech
Fort victims had different reasons for enlisting
To defang Taliban, some look to private schools
Pelosi: Obama visit inspired Democrats
Thousands throng Indian town for Dalai Lama visit
George W. Bush visits Fort Hood, wounded soldiers
Lawyer: Fla. office shooting suspect mentally ill
Afghan ministry: NATO strike kills Afghan soldiers
France asks Sri Lanka to end emergency laws
Another attack leaves US Muslims fearing backlash
Japan urges Myanmar to release Suu Kyi before poll
Ministry: NATO airstrike kills Afghan soldiers
Colo. man who threatened Obama makes weapons plea
Japan to increase aid to Myanmar: PM
Navy ship built with WTC steel goes into service
Prized mushroom collection returns to China
Muslim leader had troubling talks with suspect
Pohang beat Al Ittihad to win AFC Champions League
Obama to push lawmakers on health care vote
Police: LA celebrity burglaries led by 19-year-old
A Prophet nominated for six European film awards
| Entertainment
|
Sri Lanka buying gold 'to diversify reserves'
Police: LA celebrity burglaries led by 19-year-old
Advertisers face resistance to on-line tracking
In eastern Europe, people pine for socialism
| International
|
Advertisers face resistance to on-line tracking
IMF says stimulus needed to aid 'nascent' recovery
"Modern Warfare 2" strikes on Tuesday
Iran releases 3 journalists jailed during rallies
Award-winning Cuban blogger says she was beaten, detained
Dalai Lama begins visit to disputed India state
| International
|
Brazil blackouts result of cyber hacking: report
Families hold Rio memorial for doomed Air France flight
Market attack in NW Pakistan kills at least 8
| International
|
Yushchenko to blame for Russia-Ukraine spat: Medvedev
Saudi Arabia says regains area seized by Yemen rebels
| International
|
Haiti's new prime minister wins confirmation
| International
|
China's Wen seeks to boost blossoming Africa ties
| International
|
House Roll Call: How they voted on abortion issue
Dalai Lama visits town near Tibet, angering China
Market attack in NW Pakistan kills at least 8
Clinton leaves for Europe, Asia
Japanese FM says no base deal during Obama visit
House passes health care bill on close vote
Funeral services held for slain New Mexico nun
Police: Suicide bomb in northwest Pakistan kills 8
Report: NKorea's Kim Jong Il fires top TV official
US ship built from twin tower steel commissioned
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
US is helping Guyana track terror suspect: US official
Malaysia to charge Japanese woman over drug haul
House passes resolution honoring Fort Hood victims
Deans's joy as rugby slam bid starts with England win
Japanese protest over US base before Obama visit
U.S. House approves sweeping healthcare overhaul
Obama wraps up Afghan review, eyes final options
China's new Nasdaq-style board sees wild start
India's fast-growing telecom sector hits trouble
iPhone disappoints in China launch: analysts
SKorean workers march against labour law plan
Chinese premier: Africa trade push is 'selfless'
An east German stockbroker wrestles with his fate
Taiwan breeders see big profits in rare shrimps
Nepal emerges as 'poacher's paradise'
Hopper: All's 'good right now' despite cancer
Guests for the Sunday TV news shows
Japanese cellist wins world's top competition
Swiss less wary of foreigners than a decade ago: survey
Pope a fan of sports -- but not doping athletes
"A Prophet" nominated for six European film awards
Nabokov's unfinished -- and unburned -- novel reappears
Taiwan court to scrap 'unfair' law on prostitutes
European Court Ruling Against Classroom Crucifix Stirs Italy, Prompts Appeal
Netanyahu's Washington trip clouded by Abbas threat
Japan eyes solar station in space
Saudis claim gains from Yemen rebels
NATO, Afghanistan probe deadly 'friendly' strike
Thousands in West Bank urge Abbas not to quit
| International
|
Russia must keep promise to supply missiles: Iran
| International
|
17 rebels killed in Afghan battle: ministry
China to boost aid to Africa as ties blossom
| International
|
War support flagging as Britain remembers fallen
Hurricane Ida strengthens, 42 dead in Salvador
| International
|
Women fight new battle in Iraq's insurgent corner
| International
|
Congolese forces arrest 100 over police deaths
| International
|
AP NewsAlert
Police: 1 killed, 3 injured in shooting near Vail
Dalai Lama visits Indian state disputed by China
China to boost aid to Africa as ties blossom
Chinese premier pledges funds, aid to Africa
Murder case a glimpse into stresses of caretaking
Thaksin to visit Cambodia this week: PM
Malaysian lawmakers put marriages on line in oath
Fuel convoy hit in eastern Afghanistan
British soldier killed in southern Afghanistan
Jimmy Cobb still 'Kind of Blue' after 50 years
Communist consumer goods make comeback
US Bordeaux prices at risk of 'bloodbath', experts say
Kosher comics prove hit with Israel's Haredi Jews
India PM invites world to invest in economy
Football fever transforms 'Carmen' in SAfrica
Shakespeare's MacBeth meets Africa in Botswana's opera
Indian PM hopes for 7 percent growth next year
Taiwan, China to sign financial agreement: report
Nobel laureate says global crisis a chance to change
Hundreds join anti-corruption rally in Indonesia
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights