Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Small business lobby joins challenge to health law
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Small business lobby joins challenge to health law
By RICARDO ALONSOZALDIVAR,Associated Press Writer -
1 hour 3 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
WASHINGTON – The nation's most influential small business lobby is joining a court challenge to President Barack Obama's health care overhaul, arguing that Americans cannot be required under the Constitution to obtain insurance coverage.
The National Federation of Independent Business will announce Friday it is joining a federal lawsuit filed in Florida by 20 state attorneys general and governors, NFIB President Dan Danner said in an interview. All but one of the state officials are Republicans, and the case coincides with an election year.
NFIB's involvement ensures that constitutional arguments for overturning the health care law _ even if they fail to sway federal judges _ will be extensively aired in the fall campaigns. With 350,000 members, the group boasts a far-reaching network of local activists.
Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum, a leader of the legal challenge and a GOP candidate for governor, said he has "received a lot of strong response and reaction in support when I have spoken of this subject. I think voters as a whole are concerned."
A groundswell of opposition to the law from small business owners prompted NFIB's decision to join the court challenge, said Karen Harned, a senior lawyer for the group. "The second the law was signed, NFIB was hearing from its members: 'What are you all going to do about this?'," said Harned. "So we hunkered down. We looked around. This state attorneys general lawsuit made the most sense for us. It's the only one that has a national presence."
The health care law, passed by a Congress divided on partisan lines, puts the nation on a path to coverage for all. One of its pillars is the requirement that most Americans carry health insurance _ through an employer, a government program, or by buying their own policy.
The mandate is effective in 2014, when new competitive insurance markets open for business. Insurers will then be required to take all applicants, no longer allowed to turn away those in poor health. The government will offer tax credits to help middle-class households pay premiums. And Medicaid will be expanded to cover millions more low-income people.
Individuals who refuse to get health insurance will be hit with a tax penalty, although exceptions are allowed for financial hardship and religious reasons. Businesses will also be required to contribute to the cost of their workers' health insurance, but companies with fewer than 50 employees are exempt.
The Obama administration argues that the coverage requirements rest on a solid constitutional foundation: the power of Congress to regulate interstate commerce.
But critics say that does not give government the right to direct individuals to purchase a specific good or service.
The new law allows government "to regulate you just because you exist," said Danner. "If you can regulate this, where do you stop? Do you tell people, 'We are going to mandate that everybody exercise?' We think this is an overreach by the government. It goes too far, and threatens individual freedom."
The administration counters that a decision to opt out of health insurance is not merely a matter of personal choice. It has consequences for others, since uninsured people will get sick, or have accidents, and someone must pay for their care if they can't afford it.
"Individual decisions to forgo insurance coverage, in the aggregate, substantially affect interstate commerce by shifting costs to health care providers and the public," Justice Department said this week in legal papers filed in a similar lawsuit in Michigan.
People who remain uninsured by choice "have not opted out of health care; they are not passive bystanders divorced from the health care market," the government continued. "They have made a choice regarding the method of payment for the services they expect to receive, no less 'active' than a decision to pay by credit card rather than by check."
Legal scholars are divided over prospects for the case. Many _ but not all _ expect the administration to prevail.
Timothy Jost, a professor at Washington and Lee University law school in Virginia, said:
"These are not really legal cases _ they are political statements."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Ransom paid to free British tanker: EU mission AFP - 17 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 31 minutes ago
Iran seen improving higher atom enrichment: diplomats Reuters - 32 minutes ago
Oil extends losses on eurozone debt, supply glut AFP - 37 minutes ago
Toyota to suspend production at Thai plant: spokeswoman AFP - 50 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
EU's Barroso calls on G20 to agree bank levy
Portugal announces more austerity measures
Boy survivor of Libya air crash 'stable but confused'
Asia steps into Cannes spotlight
New British coalition holds first cabinet meeting
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Boy survivor of Libya air crash 'stable but confused'
Portugal announces more austerity measures
Pope rallies priests as crowds flock to Fatima
Asia steps into Cannes spotlight
More Most Viewed »
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Aliens may exist but contact would hurt: Hawking
Lack of sleep linked to early death: study
UN fears 'irreversible' damage to natural environment
Freddie Mac asks for fresh 10.6 billion dollar bailout
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 14 May 2010 U.S. sees "good progress" in Iran sanctions talks
Europe slams Facebook's privacy settings
Three Moscow metro 'attacks planners' killed
Iraq's shaky power grid bombed 22 times in a month
Iceland volcanic ash sells like hot cakes on Internet
U.S. sees good progress in Iran sanctions talks
|
EU's Barroso calls on G20 to agree bank levy
Three Moscow metro bombing 'organisers' killed
Latvian police release 'Robin Hood' hacker amid protests
Twitter takes to the airwaves, at least in Spain
Drugstore Halts Sale Of Genetic Test Kits Amid FDA Probe
Adobe fires another shot in war with Apple
Dad On Trial For Branding Kids Like Cattle; Sons Defend Him
Greece's woes a chance to bury Turk-Greek rivalry?
|
Former Music Teachers Pleads Guilty To Sex With Student
Lula visit may be last shot on Iran engagement: U.S.
|
Illnesses From Tainted Lettuce Hit Fourth State
Pope urges Portuguese to oppose gay marriage law
|
New Jobless Claims Fall Less Than Expected, Continuing Claims Rise
Entangled Gray Whale Freed In California
Athens' prison bomb causes damage but no injuries
|
Eminem Tops Billboard Hot 100 Chart With "Not Afraid"
Kate Hudson Named New Face Of Almay Cosmetics
Donald Trump Defends Miss USAs New Sultry Image
Two arrested in FBI raids over Times Square bomb plot
1 person killed in clashes in Thai capital
Karzai in poignant visit to US military cemetery
Cut the political jargon, urges China's vice president
Thailand puts 17 provinces under emergency decree
BP readies new bid to contain Gulf of Mexico spill
Red shirt military adviser wounded in Thai capital
'Several' FBI raids over Times Square bomb plot
Kyrgyz protesters seize regional gov't offices
China police chief vows to strike at school attackers
14 US troops receive German medals for bravery
Rogue Thai general aiding Red Shirts shot in head
US, China talk human rights after hiatus
Facebook to hold staff meeting on privacy
|
15 die as truck touches high-voltage wire in India
Gameworld: Free games lure new players including women, elderly
|
Sony aims for 5-fold jump in profit but lags consensus
|
China invests $1.2 billion in Canadian oil sands firm
Reclusive Bhutan sees economic growth halve: World Bank
Sharp to produce LED backlights for LCD TVs: report
|
Berlusconi blasted in quake film at Cannes
Gulf nations drill for film
Fashion fights for red carpet at Cannes festival
Avatar's James Cameron says 3D renaissance has arrived
Bond baddie brings burlesque film to Cannes
Dad On Trial For Branding Kids Like Cattle; Sons Defend Him
A Minute With: Vanessa Redgrave and "Letters to Juliet"
Physicist Points Out 99-Year-Old Dictionary Error
Los Angeles City Council Boycotts Everything Arizona
Pakistani Student Arrested, Charged For Coming To U.S. Embassy In Chile With Traces Of Explosive
Boys aged 10 And 11, Go On Trial For Rape Of 8-Year Old Girl
Seven students, Teacher Hacked To Death At China Kindergarten; Killer Commits Suicide
Snoopy Prison Break Unsuccessful
Michael Jackson's children become web stars after leaks
|
Breakfast At Tiffanys Authors House Sells For $18M
Military Signal Jams, Controls Garage Doors
Brazilian Gisele Bundchen world's top earning model
|
Obama, Medvedev discuss "progress" on Iran sanctions
Thai troops advance on red shirt protest checkpoint
|
US-TECH Summary
Sony shares slide 7 percent after forecast falls short
Gameworld: Free games lure new players including women, elderly
Police detain wife of top Mexican drug lord: report
|
First Lady Launches Chefs Move to Schools Program
Afghan protesters say NATO killed 11 civilians
|
ITC to take up Apple's complaints against Kodak
Burlington Vermont Diocese Settles 28 Molestation Lawsuits For $20 Million
"Kids Bowl Free" Fights Summer Boredom
Facebook to hold staff meeting on privacy
Okinawans angry as Japan PM flipflops on U.S. base
|
Obama Announces New Posts For Administrative Posts
China's Wen says social tensions behind school killings
|
FBI Successful In Major Gang Crackdown In NYC With Narcotics Trafficking Crimes
Sharp to produce LED backlights for LCD TVs: report
Nigeria's ruling party chairman resigns: State radio
|
Babysitter Who Left Toddler Home Alone To Drink Charged With DUI
Kyrgyz government supporters retake Osh administration
|
Biden Excercises Phone Diplomacy Domestically, Internationally
Somali pirates release UK-flagged chemical tanker
|
Hammond Man Charged With Post-Katrina Defraud
Sony shares slide 7 percent after forecast falls short
Philippines' Aquino has long wait for official win
|
Cardiac Procedure Found To Lessen Risk of Alzheimer's Disease, Stroke
Timeline of events in Thailand's political crisis
Small business lobby joins challenge to health law
U.S. Markets Finish Lower As Financials Weigh Heavily
Kyrgyz gov't supporters try to retake offices
3 Pakistanis arrested in Times Square bomb probe
Hong Kong cabbie jailed for driving high
Neighbors thought China attacker was a good man
Protesters say NATO attack killed Afghan civilians
China kindergarten attacker psychotic, suicidal
Video game sales plunge in April: NPD
|
Thai protesters set fire to police bus
Gameworld: Free games lure new players including women, elderly
|
Thai protesters set fire to military vehicles
Sony shares slide 7 percent after forecast falls short
|
US engineer held in China released without charge
ITC to take up Apple's complaints against Kodak
|
SKorea: Economy can withstand NKorea tensions
Seoul shares end flat; autos, defensives help
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Pakistani c.bank sells 19 bln rupees of T-bills
"Twilight" co-stars begin tough contract talks
Toyota to halt output at one of its Thai plants
"Bruno" lawsuit adds Jonah Hill, Jay Roach
PAKISTAN
Early Cannes films are the polar opposite
Offshore holdings NZ govt debt falls in April
"Chuck," "V" renewed for next season
Seoul shares end flat; autos, POSCO help
"Iron Man 2" set to outpace "Robin Hood"
Korea Resources sells $300 mln 5-yr bond
Lindsey Vonn finds acting scarier than speed
S.Korea won trims falls on export deals, stocks
S.Korean bonds rebound early, mood still cautious
Long-running show "Law & Order" canceled: reports
NBC gets social in Web-based viewership push
Brazilian Gisele Bundchen world's top earning model
Iron Man 2 set to outpace Robin Hood
|
Twilight co-stars begin tough contract talks
|
Brazilian Gisele Bundchen world's top earning model
|
Long-running show Law & Order canceled: reports
|
Bruno lawsuit adds Jonah Hill, Jay Roach
|
NBC gets social in Web-based viewership push
|
Early Cannes films are the polar opposite
|
Chuck, V renewed for next season
|
At 101, Portuguese director gets benefit of doubt
|
Iran seen improving higher atom enrichment: diplomats
No fraud found after Iraq election recount
|
Global ad industry eyes boost from mobile devices
Russia to sell Syria warplanes, air defense systems
|
U.N. seeks torture probes in Syria, Yemen, Jordan
|
Bus accident electrocutes 28 wedding guests in India
|
Prominent white South African anti-apartheid campaigner dies
|
Italy bribery scandal widens, casts pall on government
|
Suspected Pink Panther jewel robber held in Rome
|
UK's Cameron says coalition will defy doubters
|
China sentences to death 4 robbers of old tombs
No threat in vehicle spotted in NYC's Union Square
Protesters say NATO attack killed Afghan civilians
Police uncover plot to kill Indonesia's president
Aquino: No oath before Philippine chief justice
Clashes in Kyrgyzstan kill 1, injure more than 30
Pakistani Taliban say America will "burn"
Red Cross shuts offices in southwest Pakistan
28 die as bus touches high-voltage wire in India
Video game sales plunge in April: NPD
|
Tivo win vacated by appeals court; rehearing ordered
|
Bangkok battle: Troops fire on rioting protesters
Global ad industry eyes boost from mobile devices
|
Samsung to unveil chip spending plan Monday
|
Hauppauge soars on launch of TV streaming app for Apple products
|
Pakistani stocks flat; o/n rates down; rupee weaker
Japan's Shinsei and Aozora Banks scrap merger plan
Mizuho, Sumitomo Mitsui return to annual profit
Hong Kong records 4th straight quarter of growth
US Transport Sec wraps up train tour in China
Mizuho swings to $2.6B profit on economic recovery
Italian satirist takes aim at Berlusconi at Cannes
NTT profit falls as 1-off gains lifted prior year
Indonesian police uncover plot to kill president
S.Korea utilities find alternatives to costly Australia coal
Indonesian militants targeted foreigners, President
Oliver back on Wall Street with bank crisis drama
SKorea: Economy can withstand NKorea tensions
At 101, Portuguese director gets benefit of doubt
S.Korea finmin willing to review need to be at cbank meetings
"Avatar" star goes back to future in "Quartermain"
Oliver back on Wall Street with bank crisis drama
|
Michael Jackson's children become Web stars after leaks
|
Italian satirist takes aim at Berlusconi at Cannes
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights