Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Microsoft loses Word appeal, will adjust program
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (5)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Banks with political ties got bailouts, study shows
21 Dec 2009
Obama may delay vacation over healthcare
11:29am EST
Iran's Ahmadinejad dismisses West's year-end deadline
3:14pm EST
Drug tests awaited on Brittany Murphy death
| Video
21 Dec 2009
Nestle made misleading drink health claims: FDA
11:13am EST
Banks with political ties got bailouts, study shows
21 Dec 2009
U.S. mortgage industry grapples with new disclosures
7:58am EST
The brain may feel other people's pain
21 Dec 2009
Japanese man takes video game character as wife
20 Dec 2009
Iran's Ahmadinejad dismisses West's year-end deadline
3:14pm EST
Pictures
Pictures of the year: Technology
A look at the year's best science and technology photos. Slideshow
Microsoft loses Word appeal, will adjust program
SEATTLE
Tue Dec 22, 2009 2:28pm EST
Related News
China orders Microsoft to halt some Windows sales
Wed, Nov 18 2009
Judges in Microsoft-i4i case question damages
Thu, Sep 24 2009
U.S. appeals court stays Microsoft Word injunction
Thu, Sep 3 2009
SEATTLE (Reuters) - Microsoft Corp said on Tuesday it will tweak its Word application to remove a feature judged to be a breach of patent, ensuring that it will be able to continue selling one of its most widely used programs.
Technology
The world's largest software company made the announcement shortly after a U.S. court of appeals upheld a $290 million jury verdict against it for infringing a patent held by a small Canadian software firm.
The court also affirmed an injunction that prevents Microsoft from selling versions of its Word program which contain the offending software, set to take effect January 11, 2010. Older versions of Word are not affected.
Microsoft said it is taking steps to remove the feature from Microsoft Word 2007 and Microsoft Office 2007 put on sale from that date.
The disputed patent feature relates to the use of XML, or extensible markup language, used for manipulating text, in the 2007 versions of Word. Microsoft described it on Tuesday as a "little-used feature".
However, Microsoft did not rule out further appeals.
"While we are moving quickly to address the injunction issue, we are also considering our legal options," said Kevin Kutz, a Microsoft spokesman. He said that could include a request for a rehearing by a full panel of judges at the appeals court, or a request for a review by the U.S. Supreme Court.
I4i, the Toronto-based software company which owns the infringed patent, welcomed Tuesday's ruling.
"I4i is especially pleased with the court's decision to uphold the injunction, an important step in protecting the property rights of small inventors," said Michel Vulpe, founder and co-inventor of i4i, in a statement.
END OF CASE IN SIGHT
The ruling -- by the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which handles many patent and trademark cases -- may signal the end-game of a long-running dispute between Microsoft and Toronto-based i4i Ltd.
On August 12, a jury in a federal U.S. district court in Texas ruled in favor of i4i against Microsoft, for infringing the XML patent in the 2003 and 2007 versions of Word.
The jury slapped more than $290 million in damages on Microsoft and the court granted i4i's motion for an injunction preventing Microsoft from selling versions of Word that contain the disputed patent technology.
That injunction was stayed while Microsoft appealed the case with the Court of Appeals, but will now go into effect on January 11.
Microsoft shares were up 0.9 percent at $30.79 on Nasdaq.
The case is: i4i Limited Partnership and Infrastructures for Information Inc v. Microsoft Corp, an appeal from the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas in case no. 07-CV-113.
(Reporting by Bill Rigby, editing by Matthew Lewis and Gerald E. McCormick)
Technology
Comments
See All Comments (5) | Post Comment
Dec 22, 2009
Hooray for the little guy… Large companies need to remember that innovation often springs-forth from small companies, and pay for that innovation!
Handicapper
Report As Abusive
Dec 22, 2009
Remember that GM is guru to MS.
Love Bill Gates, but sharks have been eating minnows with out a fishing license.
Lower OS price and be fair, is all.
bobby99
BOBBY99
Report As Abusive
Dec 22, 2009
Remember that GM is guru to MS.
Love Bill Gates, but sharks have been eating minnows with out a fishing license.
Lower OS price and be fair, is all.
bobby99
BOBBY99
Report As Abusive
Dec 22, 2009
Microsoft…. King of the Pirates
qualsdad
Report As Abusive
Dec 22, 2009
i4i’s XML product “x4o” depends on Microsoft Word. Check it out on their website at i4i.com. It seems i4i is really a parasite on Microsoft in this case. While Microsoft also engages in questionable business practices, it’s hard to argue in favor of i4i here either.
This is especially if you take into account that the technology in question involves the encoding of data in the program itself — which 99% of all users don’t care about, and wouldn’t affect the sales of i4i’s product anyway.
The painful truth is i4i is simply looking to take advantage of the U.S. patent system to get rich. In this case, the defendant was Microsoft, but in the next case they could go after anybody who has written a program which they can show utilizes their method for encoding data, even if it doesn’t do anything remotely similar to their own products (and wouldn’t be a threat to their business).
That’s the glory of the software patent, they don’t usually do what patents are supposed to do — they’re often just a device to get rich at the expense of some other person’s work.
spizzbool
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (5)
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Microsoft loses Word appeal, will adjust program
SEATTLE (Reuters) - Microsoft Corp said on Tuesday it will tweak its Word application to remove a feature judged to be a breach of patent, ensuring that it will be able to continue selling one of its most widely used programs.
Mexican relatives die in likely revenge attack
U.S. military defends pregnancy punishment in Iraq
U.S. home sales bolster economic growth prospects
Health bill clears second Senate hurdle
| Video
"Youth Depression" hard on retailers
» More Top News
Health reform inches closer
Democrats are on the verge of passing landmark legislation by Christmas, with only one more hurdle remaining. Full Article | Video
Winners and losers in Senate health bill
Follow healthcare stocks
Healthcare Reform
Are you pregant? Sir! No, Sir!
There are some 115,000 U.S. troops in Iraq -- and one commander wants to make sure his soldiers don't multiply. Full Article
U.N. urges patience in Iraq progress
Is Afghanistan harder than Iraq?
Politics
© Copyright 2009 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
ECVJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 23 December 2009 Ahmadinejad dismisses US deadline for nuclear deal
Grounded European flights add to travel woes
Demjanjuk trial hears of Nazi death camp horrors
|
Former Bush adviser named Obama 'cyber czar'
Iran militia attack pro-reform cleric home-website
Iran militia attack pro-reform cleric's home: website
|
US third-quarter growth revised down to 2.2 percent
Serbia makes 'historic' EU bid
China issues new rules on Internet domain names
British priest defends urging people to shoplift
Iran: Border spat with Iraq was misunderstanding
Mexican relatives die in likely revenge attack
|
Greece relieved by mild credit rating cut
Jail term cut for man in Briton's murder in Italy
|
Serbia officially submits EU membership application
Israel passes demands in prisoner swap to Hamas
Polls darken German economic outlook
French ruling party plans bill on broad burqa ban
|
Egypt says no steel Gaza wall despite Hamas fears
|
Egypt court upholds 4-year sentence for blogger
|
Court slams Bosnia for barring Jews, Roma from office
U.S. military defends pregnancy punishment in Iraq
|
Microsoft loses Word appeal, will adjust program
|
CBS and Walt Disney may join Apple TV venture: report
|
Montana man charged with 7th DUI
Northern Hemisphere Under Icy Grip Of Old Man Winter; Travel Delays, Severe Weather To Continue
Poll finds drop in public concern about swine flu
Teacher Runs Half Marathon Backward
Unclaimed corpses push up urban morgue body counts
Hong Kong democracy activists take a gamble
Survey: Mississippi Most Religious State
Boy, 2, dies after being bitten by family dog
New Rule Requires Airlines To Limit Tarmac Delay To 3 Hours
Pakistani court orders 2 men's noses, ears cut off
Ala. House Dem defects to GOP over policy concerns
More Americans Staying Home For Holidays
World's Best Santa weaves Hong Kong magic
FBI assisted authorities in Jackson probes
Woman Shot In Mall Parking Lot Carjacking
AZ activist agrees to community service, not jail
Teen suicide bomber kills three in Pakistan
Pa. man's belt stops bullet shot through car
Karzai orders investigation into cousin's slaying
Palin E-mail Hacker To Go On Trial
'Stripper-Mobile' Plans Nationwide Tour
China denies aid package, Uighur expulsions linked
No Senate Run Next Year For America's Mayor
Fears Thailand will deport 4,000 Hmong to Laos
SKorea to repatriate 7 NKorean fishermen
Ga. centenarian voter lauded by Obama dies at 107
Century-Old Obama Honoree Dies
Protesters burn flag as Taiwan and China sign deals
China expands Internet controls
Taiwan jobless rate down in November
Chinese-led group initials deal for Iraq oil field
France urges mutual respect with China after spat
Snoopy named top dog in U.S. pop culture
|
Pete Doherty charged with heroin possession
|
Coroner looking into Brittany Murphy leak
Taylor Swift, Beyonce to perform at Grammy Awards
|
Rage Against the Machine humbles Simon Cowell
Gehry-designed theater set for 2012 opening in NYC
Pete Doherty charged with heroin possession
Arnold Stang, actor known for nerdy roles, dies
Rolling Stone's Wood gets British police warning
`Survivor' winner: Quitting job for show a gamble
Medieval `mourners' to leave France for US tour
At Jersey shore, thumbs down for 'Jersey Shore'
Britain's Christmas parties hit by recession
US reacts cautiously to new Afghanistan cabinet
Drug gang revenge attack kills Mexico marine's family
|
US-TECH Summary
OPEC warns of weak recovery for oil market
Saudi says 73 soldiers slain in war on Yemen rebels
US third-quarter growth revised down to 2.2 percent
Shoppers were online, not at malls, last weekend
Ronnie Wood Cautioned Over Girlfriend's Assault
Cleveland Entertaiment Shareholders Awarded $1.8 Million In Lawsuit Over Meat Loaf Album
U.S. military defends pregnancy punishment in Iraq
Honduras' Zelaya stuck in embassy for Christmas
|
Israel passes demands in prisoner swap to Hamas
Colombia says rebels murder kidnapped governor
|
Israel wants Shalit freed, but not at "any price"
NATO will 'stay the course' in Afghanistan: chief
Philippines declares holiday truce with Maoist rebels
|
U.N. council set to slap sanctions on Eritrea
|
Argentine judge asks China arrests over Falun Gong
|
Japan wants more time for US base decision: State Department
Pakistan to release 100 Indian fishermen
Brazil court rules for US father in custody feud
Rumbling Philippine volcano shoots huge ash column
Top SC prosecutor, others probing health care deal
Drug test row could doom Pacquiao-Mayweather fight
WWII sinking of Australian hospital ship 'unclear'
Outage cripples BlackBerry Americas network
|
Guinea junta should be 'held to account': US
Microsoft loses Word appeal, will adjust program
|
Hanoi's 'tube' dwellers vow to stay in ancient quarter
Del. police: Pediatrician sexually abused patients
Leading China dissident goes on trial
Dems, White House predict success on health care
Shoppers were online, not at malls, last weekend
|
APNewsBreak: LA monsignor called before grand jury
SKorea repatriates 7 NKorean fishermen
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,370
China executes another gang boss in crackdown
Holiday storm could snarl travel in West, Midwest
China opens trial of leading dissident Liu Xiaobo
Yellowstone bison conservation program in limbo
Ex-Mich. teacher convicted of having sex with boy
Seoul shares gain 0.4 pct helped by exporters
PAKISTAN
China hits back after EU extends shoe taxes
Vietnam set for middle income status: World Bank
Seoul apartment prices up 23.7 pct in 9 mths -govt
Korea Hot Stocks
Seoul shares rise on tech exporters; banks lag
Hollywood's domestic box office tops $10 billion
US says copyright piracy in China still 'high'
Taiwan dollar flat; dealers watch exporters
Japan markets closed for holiday
Oscar campaigning gets downsized
|
Simon Cowell will leave American Idol: report
|
FBI's Michael Jackson files reveal stalker details
|
Aerosmith singer Steven Tyler back in rehab
|
Oscar campaigning gets downsized
DVD industry down, but not downbeat
|
Christmas becomes a battleground in some US towns
Rapper Kid Cudi held at gunpoint by LAPD
|
Department Of Agriculture Sued Over Logging In Alaska Forest
Sri Lanka's tsunami recovery dogged by graft, delays
Rapper T.I. released from prison early
|
Higher Home Sales, Dollar Perk Up Stocks
Ricky Gervais brings animated TV comedy to U.S.
|
High Unemployment To Remain As Jobless Re-enter Job Market
Atlanta rapper T.I. released from Arkansas prison
Rapper T.I. released from prison early
Bill Cosby named Marian Anderson Award winner
'Mister Ed' actress Connie Hines dies at age 79
Ricky Gervais brings animated TV comedy to US
Hollywood's domestic box office tops $10 billion
Simon Cowell will leave "American Idol": report
35437282898562626475892888
Iraqi police: Gunmen storm checkpoint, kill 4
Controlling the TV with a wave of the hand
Iran forces clash with cleric's mourners: websites
|
Iran forces clash with cleric's mourners
Oil prices rise before US inventory data
Philippine volcano rumbles, eruption seen soon
|
Pakistan orders security for media after attack
|
Iran police 'clash with mourners, 50 arrested'
Two killed in bid to foil execution in Iran: report
|
Palestinians say Bethlehem wall spoils Christmas
|
Iran police 'clash with Montazeri mourners'
Iraq chases many for corruption, catches few
|
Iran security forces clash with protesters in Isfahan
Afghan senator killed at police checkpoint
Harassed Nestle halts Zimbabwe operations
|
Navies too stretched on piracy in Indian Ocean: UK
|
Plane slips off UK runway, two killed in bus crash
|
Afghan member of parliament killed by police
Frozen lake leads to tragedy for California family
Pakistan Taliban say fighters going to Afghanistan
US warns Iran to meet nuclear deadline
Weapons-carrying cargo plane headed for Sri Lanka
Balloon Boy parents face sentencing in Colorado
Weapons-carrying plane headed for Sri Lanka
Pain before gain in health care overhaul
Verdict for Chinese dissident due Friday
Abortion looms as possible health bill deal killer
Thailand firm on returning 4,000 Hmong to Laos
People 'fleeing for their lives' in Australian fires
SKorea repatriates 7 NKorean fishermen
Shooting leaves 2 Wash. deputies badly hurt
Japan emperor turns 76, concerned over financial crisis
Flight misses Jamaica runway; no injuries reported
China steps up reform of pension system: govt
AP NewsAlert
S.Korea bonds rebound, but foreigners keep selling
China negotiator: Taiwan trade pact "long process"
Taiwan unveils Asia's biggest solar plant: govt
Ex-HSBC executive jailed in Hong Kong over bribe
Russia to deliver 20 MiG fighters to Myanmar: report
Hyundai Motor workers vote on deal to avoid strike
New Zealand economy grows at snail pace in Q3
Two killed in Indonesia building collapse
Golden Globes party circuit requires some planning
|
Sherlock takes on Avatar at holiday box office
|
"Sherlock" takes on "Avatar" at holiday box office
'The Christmas Song' turns 65
Golden Globes party circuit requires some planning
DVD industry down, but not downbeat
Rapper Kid Cudi held at gunpoint by LAPD
Reports: Aerosmith's Tyler enters rehab
Terrorist attack feared after Jackson arrest
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights