Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
As US begins Afghan surge, Canada plans its exit
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
As US begins Afghan surge, Canada plans its exit
By ERIC TALMADGE,Associated Press Writer -
Sunday, February 7
Send
IM Story
Print
KHADAN, Afghanistan – By the crack of dawn, the Royal Canadian Dragoons' armor was in position, fanned out across a dusty vineyard for Operation Tazi to secure a key land route into Kandahar from the Taliban.
It was a mission the Canadians have done countless times before in other Afghan places. But, this time, they weren't officially running the show. The local police chief was, and he wasn't there yet.
"You have to work on Afghanistan time," Master Cpl. Jason Dunnett, 27, of Oshawa, Ontario, said after the soldiers were issued their orders and briefed on what to expect. "We'll go when they are ready."
For Canada, Afghanistan has been a long slog.
Fighting its bloodiest conflict since the Korean War, Canada has paid a heavy price _ 139 Canadian troops have died. With about 2,800 soldiers in the country, the third-largest contingent in the U.S.-led coalition, the Canadians have taken more casualties, proportionately, than any other.
But by the end of next year, they will be gone.
After four years of often-intense combat since moving down to Kandahar, the spiritual center of the Taliban, Canadian military planners are now fine-tuning their exit strategy, bringing the Afghans in as closely as possible to ensure that their hard-fought progress doesn't evaporate after they leave.
"We are killing insurgents with our right hand, and killing the insurgency with our left," said Capt. Jade Watson, a planning officer for the Canadian Battle Group in Kandahar. "We can offer a future. The insurgents can only offer a past."
Even as new U.S. troops are flowing in to begin their surge, however, the Canadians have learned that progress can vanish as easily as footprints in the sand.
Their departure will be deeply felt. The Afghan police and army, who will be called upon to fill the gap, are understaffed and poorly trained. Their ranks are riddled with corruption, and they are often not respected or trusted by the Afghan people.
Out in the field, the shift toward winning hearts and minds _ and giving local forces as big a role as possible _ is striking, but problematic.
About three-quarters of the way through the Khadan compound search, the police chief, Shir Shah, said he had seen enough. A village woman had died, a grave was being dug, and he didn't want to disrupt village life any further.
So the Canadians pulled back.
No weapons caches, explosives or suspected insurgents were found. No doors were kicked in, and the primary intelligence gleaned was about what the villagers needed _ well pumps, and perhaps a school.
"We would have liked to see more, but it is his call," said Maj. Mark Popov, the commander of the reconnaissance squadron behind the operation. "The Canadian combat mission is ending. I don't have a crystal ball. But it's not all about fighting. You can't kill your way to victory."
Shah, meanwhile, was encouraged by what his 30 Afghan National Police officers had accomplished.
"There are some bad guys here, but mostly they are receptive to us," he said through an interpreter. "This isn't the Russians all over again. The Canadians are here to help, to build roads and schools. Most people appreciate that."
Though overshadowed by the Americans and British, Canada has played a crucial role in southern Afghanistan.
A key trade route to Iran, India and Pakistan, Kandahar is where the Taliban was born in the early 1990s. A city of 800,000, its population is mainly ethnic Pashtun, the same as the Taliban. And as the coalition shifts its strategy to securing population centers, Kandahar has come even more into focus.
Though it had in the past concentrated more on peacekeeping operations abroad, Canada's choice to do the heavy lifting in Kandahar was deliberate.
After staking out a place near the relative quiet of Kabul in 2002, Canada decided its military was ready and able to do more. Kandahar, violent and insecure, was the perfect proving ground.
But the troops have faced huge obstacles.
Only about 500 are actually part of the infantry battle group that is at the center of the mission. That has left the Canadians spread dangerously thin.
"There are times when I just don't have enough people to do the number of patrols I would like," said Popov, who goes by the name Major Mark when dealing with local officials because he doesn't want them to associate him with the Russians who invaded Afghanistan in 1979 and stayed for 10 years.
That equation is now changing.
The surge in U.S. and other coalition troops will concentrate on Kandahar and neighboring Helmand province because they must be stabilized if counterinsurgency is to move forward.
The Canadians here welcome the help.
"It's all good news," said Lt. Col. Simon Bernard of Task Force Kandahar. "The U.S. tsunami is coming. We talk a lot about the surge of troops, but it is also a civilian surge. The bottleneck will be the Afghan capacity to handle all the resources coming in."
Bernard said maintaining momentum over the next four months will be key.
The safety bubble in and around Kandahar _ strategists call it the rings of stability and security _ is easily popped.
Just before Operation Tazi got under way, an insurgent rocket hit inside Kandahar Air Field, injuring eight Romanian and Bulgarian soldiers. Though rocket attacks are common and often ineffective, the blast was jarring _ about 22,000 coalition troops and civilians work out of British-run Kandahar Air Field, the busiest single-runway military airfield in the world.
From the Canadian perspective, the U.S. surge also has its risks.
Bernard said the fresh flow of U.S. troops will be a bigger target for insurgents. Increased skirmishes and bombings could _ at least initially _ burst the perception of safety among the local population that is essential for development projects to make headway.
"We are at a tipping point," Bernard said. "One of our concerns in long-term planning is that we see a seamless transition to the U.S. or whomever takes over."
But even if the fragile pockets of security hold, it is not certain that the progress Canada has made _ particularly in development and reconstruction projects _ will have a lasting effect.
Sheila Fraser, Canada's auditor general, said during a recent visit to the Canadian troops in Kandahar that the Canadian departure could leave a void.
"One of my questions is what are the political consequences of the decision to withdraw, who is going to take care of the projects that the Canadians are now doing," Fraser said. "These aren't things that can be done in a few months. Who is going to continue this?"
The Canadians are deeply involved in a dam project, are building schools, clinics and developing irrigation. At the outset of Operation Tazi, an officer was designated to seek out village elders and ask them what their village needed most _ a practice which is typical of the Canadian presence.
President Barack Obama has said the U.S. also plans to begin its own withdrawal by July 2011, adding a further sense of urgency to getting the Afghans themselves to take a leadership role.
"2010 will be a pivotal year for Afghanistan," said Canadian Ambassador William Crosby. "I can't predict what the place will be like 18 months from now. My focus over the next 18 months is to deliver on Canadian promises."
Still, he said Canada's decision to set a date for the end of combat involvement was a good one.
"It takes away the argument that we are an occupying force. It sends a good message to Afghans that we are here to help, but we are not going to be here forever."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Laos 'moving toward' Hmong access: US diplomat AFP - Sunday, February 7
43 held in raid on alleged Philippine communists AFP - Sunday, February 7
US missionary freed by NKorea starts journey home AP - Sunday, February 7
As US begins Afghan surge, Canada plans its exit AP - Sunday, February 7
US missionary in China after North Korea release AFP - Sunday, February 7
News Search
Top Stories
G7 preoccupied with eurozone debt, China 'bubble'
US urges EU assembly not to block bank data deal
JPMorgan's chief reaps 16-million-dollar bonus
Jackson doctor to be charged Monday: prosecutors
Mixed report shows US loses 20,000 jobs, unemployment dips
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
JPMorgan's chief reaps 16-million-dollar bonus
Mixed report shows US loses 20,000 jobs, unemployment dips
Jackson doctor to be charged Monday: prosecutors
BAE to pay 450 million dollars in fraud fines
Fury heats up after new AIG bonuses
More Most Viewed »
Fury heats up after new AIG bonuses
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Sunday, 7 February 2010 Hamas backtracks on apology over harming civilians
Ukraine braces for tense presidential polls
Ethiopia gets Microsoft software in Amharic
U.S., Germany say Iran not ready for nuclear deal
G7 preoccupied with eurozone debt, China 'bubble'
Iraq group says it has kidnapped U.S. contractor
|
Militant video shows abducted American in Iraq
Philippine automated vote system 'almost perfect': officials
French aid worker released 3 months after Chad kidnap
US-TECH Summary
Lebanon locates black boxes from doomed jet
Iran's police vow no tolerance towards protesters
Abbas awaits U.S. clarification over peace talks offer
|
Amazon reshelves Macmillan titles but not e-books
China's Xinjiang restores access to 27 websites
S. California storm brings mudslides, flooding
Obama seeks to rally glum Dems amid GOP challenges
'Snowmageddon' blankets Mid-Atlantic in heavy snow
Laos 'moving toward' Hmong access: US diplomat
Blizzard paralyzes U.S. mid-Atlantic
43 held in raid on alleged Philippine communists
Shiite group kidnaps US contractor in Iraq: video
New Orleans votes amid Carnival, Super Bowl hoopla
US missionary freed by NKorea starts journey home
Amazon reshelves Macmillan titles but not e-books
|
Conn. police official threatens reporter, resigns
As US begins Afghan surge, Canada plans its exit
Obama: Parties need to cooperate on major issues
Afghan police patrol kills 7 civilians
No paper for you! Hawaii uses less, saves money
China official heads to North Korea
Obama calls capital's blizzard `Snowmageddon'
Nissan to slash production at Spanish plant
New accidents add to Toyota Prius doubts: Japanese media
Japanese ask: Is US backlash behind Toyota woes?
Rihanna, Mark Sanchez raise money for charities
Rob Lowe's a traveling Indianapolis Colts fan
Kidnappers free Red Cross worker held in Darfur
US publishers smile again as Kindle rivals emerge
Iranian Nobel winner calls for protests
Ukraine vote as tensions high in close-run election
|
Afghans flee ahead of major anti-Taliban offensive
Police seize 1.5 tonnes of explosives in ETA Portugal cache
Mudslide kills 11 people in rain-sodden Mexico
|
Iraqi court pushed to rule on banned candidates
Afghan police commander arrested in bomb ring
|
Israeli, Saudi handshake settles seating spat
Black boxes from Ethiopian jet crash found off Lebanon
Six shot dead in Mexico disco in likely drug attack
|
Philippine campaign starts as race tightens
|
Shuttle aims for pre-dawn launch as clouds move in
New Orleans elects first white mayor in 32 years
Strong earthquake hits off Japan's southern coast
Former Chinese police chief's gang trial ends
AP: More migration has meant more economic stress
Reports: Malaysia finds drugs in Iranians' luggage
House fire in Warwick, RI, kills 5, including baby
Amazon reshelves Macmillan titles but not e-books
|
Taiwan to seek more arms despite improved China ties
Palin calls Obama budget 'immoral'
Thousands of dinosaur footprints uncovered in China
Palin: Obama administration mishandling terrorism
Chinese envoy meets North Korean officials
Palin says Obama policies to be short-lived
Pakistan's 'third gender' seek greater rights
Japan balks at $2 billion bill to host US troops
China jails man 13 years for running porn Web site
Trial of top China official accused of mob links ends
South Korea talks down possible Europe impact
Open skies, budget travel: Asian airlines soar
Karachi violence blow to Pakistan economy
Afghan insecurity pushes gold price up, business down
Marlene Dietrich to star on Berlin 'Walk of Fame'
G7 to continue stimulus until global economy on track
PayPal halts certain payment transactions in India
G7 vows to continue stimulus policies
'Worst is over' for food inflation, says India's PM
Vietnam tackles US in first WTO case: official media
Aceh reconstruction offers hope for Haiti
Karina Smirnoff and others party on Super Bowl eve
Diehard Thaksin loyalist paints rural Thailand red
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Revellers don masks for Venice Carnival
Injured Leonard Cohen delays tour by six months
Seoul launches 'floating island'
Controversial film acclaimed abroad but unseen by Syrians
Marlene Dietrich to star on Berlin 'Walk of Fame'
Iran ratchets up atom work despite sanctions threat
Iran ratchets up atom work despite sanctions threat
|
Poor weather delays US shuttle launch
Defiant Ahmadinejad orders higher uranium enrichment
Britain's Mandelson attacks EU on banking reform
Yemen arrests embassy bomb threat suspect
|
US shuttle Endeavour launch delayed
Iran says arrests people hired by CIA
|
Iraq Shi'ite leaders vow Baath purge as furore grows
Lebanon recovers crashed Ethiopian jet's data box
Iran says to start work on 20 percent nuclear fuel
NATO should be global security forum: Rasmussen
|
US troops detain Afghan police chief: official, NATO
HRW says Israel 'failed' to probe Gaza war crimes
Israeli forces arrest two foreigners in West Bank
|
Incumbent declared winner in flawed Nigeria poll
|
Taliban dig in for big assault, say Afghan villagers
|
Lebanon recovers crashed Ethiopian jet's data box
|
Iraq panel reinstates election ban amid Shi'ite ire
|
Arrests of 43 suspected Filipino rebels questioned
Nepal vice president reinstated after language row
Indian govt hails test of nuclear-capable missile
Afghanistan's NATO head: Military push needs gov't
Australia mourns lives lost in wildfires 1 year on
NATO arrests Afghan cop accused in roadside bombs
Chinese envoy meets NKoreans amid nuclear talk bid
The nation's weather
Court martial looms for S.Lanka's defeated candidate: report
Super Bowl Sunday at the White House
Australia marks anniversary of deadly firestorm
US east coast digs out after record blizzad
Activists, Japanese whalers clash in Antarctic waters
US shuttle Endeavor ready for new space mission
New Zealand house prices rise in January
China economy to grow 10 percent in 2010: think tank
Taiwan fin firms have $1.1 bln exposure to 3 European nations
All eyes on Ellen in American Idol judge debut
|
British jazz legend John Dankworth dies at 82
|
Jazz musician Sir John Dankworth dead at 82
US 'cavemen' seek raw truth
Horror witch-hunts target low-caste women in Nepal
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights