Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Heaping plates nullify Thanksgiving calorie cuts
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Heaping plates nullify Thanksgiving calorie cuts
By MICHAEL HILL,Associated Press Writer -
2 hours 1 minute ago
Send
IM Story
Print
Good news this Thanksgiving: Compared to 50 years ago, some staples of the Turkey Day table have fewer calories.
The bad news? It probably won't matter because most Americans will eat too much anyway.
While Americans are notorious for cranking up the calories and portions compared to a generation or so ago, small changes in the nation's diet seem to have buffered Thanksgiving dinner from some _ but not all _ of our bigger-better mentality.
To find out just what has changed about America's official gut-busting dinner, The Associated Press asked Cornell University's Food and Brand Lab to analyze recipes from the 1950s and compare them to contemporary versions.
Previous studies of non-Thanksgiving recipes by lab director Brian Wansink had found that calorie counts for many classic cookbook recipes have ballooned by nearly 40 percent during the past 70 years.
But Thanksgiving staples didn't follow that trend.
Calorie counts for five of the eight recipes tested actually dropped by almost a third when comparing 1956 Better Homes and Gardens recipes to the 2006 edition of the "Better Homes and Gardens New Cookbook," changes Wansink attributed partly to the use of lower-calorie ingredients, such as low-fat milk instead of cream. Surprisingly, some serving sizes went down over the decades too.
Per-serving calorie counts dropped an average of 102 calories for green beans with almonds, stuffing, mashed potatoes, candied sweet potatoes and pumpkin pie. They went up 26 calories for rolls and were essentially unchanged for corn and candied carrots.
That puts the total calorie count for a contemporary Thanksgiving dinner of those eight fixings, plus a turkey drumstick, at 2,057 calories. The tally for 1956 was 2,539, according to Cornell researcher Laura Smith.
But those numbers are accurate only if you eat proper serving sizes. And when was the last time you carefully measured out 6 ounces of candied sweet potatoes or called it a day after just one roll? Especially on Thanksgiving.
Wansink's research repeatedly has shown that controlling portions is not something Americans today are skilled at.
"There might be a little less butter put in the dressing or there might be fewer marshmallows on the sweet potatoes," he says. "But where you end up messing with them, you end up serving up a lot more than your grandfather served himself."
Meals served at home have followed the same trend as restaurant and packaged food portions _ more, more, more.
Even the plates on which Thanksgiving is served have grown since a generation ago (by more than a third according to Wansink's studies). By today's sensibilities, older china sets seem more fitting for tapas than Turkey Day.
And Wansink's research has shown a link between larger plates and larger portions. Put simply, a little lump of mashed potatoes can look awfully lonely on a foot-wide plate. The same dynamic works with wine consumption. Today's bigger glasses get bigger pours.
Wansink added that even in cases where recipes are about the same size, today's families are smaller. That means more per person.
Even the turkeys are bigger. Today's big-breasted birds on average are 10 pounds heavier at slaughter compared to 1950, according to federal data. Recipes from the '50s actually included roasting instructions for 5-pound birds. Good luck finding one that small today.
Joan Salge Blake, a nutrition professor at Boston University and spokeswoman for the American Dietetic Association, thinks the tradition-bound nature of the Thanksgiving meal probably played a role in keeping the recipe calorie counts down.
"These are Grandma's recipes," which are less likely to change over generations, she says.
Nancy Hopkins, deputy editor of food and entertaining for Better Homes and Gardens, isn't surprised by Wansink's findings. She says her company has responded to consumers who increasingly ask for healthier options, including for Thanksgiving.
To see a real calorie spike, all you have to do is compare Thanksgiving today to 1621, the year of the feast that inspired the holiday.
The menu enjoyed by the settlers and their Wampanoag guests _ commonly knows now as the Pilgrims and Indians _ is lost to history. But the limited clues available point to tables loaded with venison and wildfowl, according to Kathleen Wall, colonial foodways culinarian at Plimoth Plantation at Plymouth, Mass. Other dishes may have included lobster, mussels, boiled greens and pumpkins.
But forget the fancy sides.
The Pilgrims probably had no potatoes in 1621, and if they had butter and sugar, it came over on the Mayflower the year before. There was no dough, so no pies. They may have eaten cranberries, but not as a sweetened sauce. The birds probably were stuffed with little more than quartered onions and parsley, Wall said.
The likely calorie count? A settler who gave thanks with a turkey drumstick, some lobster, boiled spinach and stewed pumpkin washed down by water _ sorry, no beer or wine yet _ probably only ingested about 550 calories.
No fancy, fatty stuff for the settlers who came over on the Mayflower. Salge jokes "they would have sunk the ship."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
UK begins inquiry on Iraq war AP - 2 hours 38 minutes ago
Big Bang atom smasher sends beams in 2 directions AP - 2 hours 49 minutes ago
October sales gains lift hopes for housing market AP - 2 hours 55 minutes ago
French aid workers kidnapped in Centr.Africa: diplomat AFP - 2 hours 55 minutes ago
CO2 curve ticks upward as key climate talks loom AP - 2 hours 59 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Gold hits record high 1,174 dollars
Atom-smasher aims sharp increase in power next year
Tax credits fuel 10 percent surge in US home sales
Atlantis astronauts begin third and last spacewalk
U2 to headline Glastonbury festival
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Antarctic ice loss vaster, faster than thought: study
BA warns cabin crew over strike: report
Harnessing the power of salt, Norway tries osmotic power
Crisis forcing hard-up Spaniards to sell their hair
US economy will 'bounce back': Indian PM
More Most Viewed »
Alcohol helps cut heart disease risk for men: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 24 November 2009 Iraq vote in fresh doubt as new bill faces veto
Five dead in Italian transport plane crash: military
Atom-smasher aims sharp increase in power next year
Eight soldiers dead in Russia munitions blast: ministry
Gold hits record high 1,174 dollars
Tweets or bleats? Tool measures importance on Twitter
Israel-Hamas prisoner swap deal near
British police to compensate De Menezes family
Britain surveys cost of devastating floods
Brazil: World should engage, not isolate Iran
U2 to headline Glastonbury festival
UN climate chief expects 'specific' deal
Iran's Ahmadinejad on controversial trip to Brazil
Atlantis astronauts begin final spacewalk
Israel, Hamas near swap of prisoners for soldier
Saudi Arabia seeks to curb flu and stop protest at haj
| International
|
Amended Iraqi election law still angers Sunnis
Israel has history of uneven prisoner swap deals
Russia says new blast at arms depot kills 8
| International
|
Iranian official in fake degree scandal dies
No deal yet on Shalit prisoner swap: Israeli PM
Iraq parl't passes new vote law, veto unresolved
Jail broken iPhones vulnerable to new virus
| Technology
|
Google buying display advertising startup
| Technology
|
Official: China mine that exploded was too crowded
Hundreds protest trash incinerator plans in China
Pentagon: Fort Hood review due Jan. 15
China activist who spoke out on quake gets 3 years
Obama to honor young inventors at science fair
Taiwan's dwindling birth rate causes concern
4 US service members die in Afghan attacks
Clinton says Iraqi election might be delayed
Smartphone growth to continue strong in 2010
| Technology
|
Jackson's doctor returns to work at Houston clinic
India test-fires medium-range missile
China families protest mine disaster; toll hits 104
Feds find association between drywall, corrosion
Pakistan's army attacks militants in northwest
Program to help truckers attracts drug smugglers
Oldest Mt. Everest climber celebrates recognition
Attack on election convoy kills 21 Filipinos
Palin arrives at Fort Bragg to a crowd of hundreds
Hundreds mourn Mich. boy allegedly slain by father
Pipe-cutting led to radiation at Pa. nuke plant
Heaping plates nullify Thanksgiving calorie cuts
China tells banks to control lending
Thai court charges banking scandal suspect Saxena
Pakistani stocks end lower; rupee weakens
Hong Kong bans ex-CLSA banker from finance jobs
Susan Boyle set for biggest UK album of 2009: HMV
| Entertainment
|
Macau plans Michael Jackson shrine to house iconic glove
| Entertainment
|
Fox says will make profit with sci-fi epic Avatar
| Entertainment
|
Rolling Stone Italy names Berlusconi 2009 rock star
| Entertainment
|
U2 to headline UK's Glastonbury Festival
| Entertainment
|
Darwin book found on shelf worth up to $100,000
| Entertainment
|
Gunmen fire on Americans' home in Indonesia
British TV star Susan Boyle's album goes on sale
Fox CEO wants US to join France on Internet piracy
Michael Jackson's doctor says others gave him propofol
| Entertainment
|
Lebanon to host European film festival from Thursday
Bizarre candidates kick off Philippine election race
LA committee to review Jackson memorial costs
EPA Sets National Rules On Construction Site Soil Runoff
Brad Pitt's production company enters "Dark Void"
Six-Term Rep. Dennis Moore To Announce Retirement
Adam Lambert ready to shake up pop world with CD
NYC Tavern Offering 100 Proof Vodka Turkey
Dispute Over NYC Subway Seat Ends Badly When Pest Control Worker Kills Homeless Man
Michael Jackson 'Opus' book offers rare images
MA Attorney General Still Ahead In Race For Ted Kennedy's Seat
Facebook May Have Triggered Redhead Beating Incidents
U2 to headline Glastonbury festival
Amnesty International Urges Obama to Address Human Rights In India
To millions, Oprah's not a megastar, just a BFF
BART Facing Questions Again With Officer's Use Of Force During Arrest
Three Mile Island Leak Not Serious
9/11 Suspects To Plead Not Guilty During New York Trial
Belgian pleads guilty in U.S. jet parts sale to Iran
KLM flies world's first "passenger flight on biofuel"
Hong Kong man, three others jailed for spam scheme
Philippines imposes emergency rule after massacre
| International
|
Afghan governor warns Dutch over pullout: report
HP quarterly net profit up 14 percent
US-TECH Summary
Belgian pleads guilty in U.S. jet parts sale to Iran
| International
|
"Jail broken" iPhones hacked by new virus
Gold hits record high 1,174 dollars
Peacekeepers should prepare to leave Darfur
Philippines declares emergency in parts of south
| International
|
Gartner forecasts 2.8 percent growth in PC sales in 2009
Congo warlords in the dock at Hague court
| International
|
TV: Israel proposing 10-month settlement freeze
Google buying display ad startup Teracent
Tajikistan fails to curb abuse of women: Amnesty
| International
|
Few US firms ready for workforce disruption: survey
Peacekeepers should prepare to leave Darfur: Sudan
| International
|
Jordan king dissolves parliament, calls election
| International
|
HP quarterly net profit up 14 percent
Iran shuts newspaper for Baha'i photo: media
| International
|
'Day of Outrage' takes stand against violence
Philippines declares emergency after 24 killed
Goodbye jobs, hello mom and dad, say young adults
Trial of Khmer Rouge prison chief in final stage
Poll: Americans conflicted over health overhaul
Microsoft, News Corp weigh Web pact: source
| Technology
|
Opposition debate Australian carbon reduction laws
White House braces for tough sell on Afghan policy
AT&T offers pay by day, week, month data options
| Technology
|
Philippines declares emergency after 24 killed
Obama meets with top advisers on Afghan policy
Overnight star Susan Boyle focus of TV special
China blast mine 'overcrowded': safety official
Alleged Hawaii spy found competent to stand trial
Philippines imposes emergency rule after massacre
Lawmaker defends RI Rep Kennedy in Communion flap
Australian PM urges parliament to approve carbon cuts
Eight charged in U.S. for Somali war recruiting
Somali-US youth told jihad would be 'fun'
Renowned Chinese translator Yang Xianyi dies
Former Thai Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej dies
SKorea pledges to double aid to Africa
China planning agency OKs Shanghai Disney project
SKorean trade chief urges US to move on agreement
SKorea pledges to double aid to Africa
Coal-burning China invests in methane capture
China Eastern Airlines teams up with Alibaba
Adam Lambert's sexually-charged act draws complaints
| Entertainment
|
NZ inflation expectations jump sharply-RBNZ survey
S.Korea turned net creditor as of end-Sept -c.bank
New Moon final weekend box office hits $142.8 million
| Entertainment
|
Woman found 25 hours after Indonesia ferry sank
Korea Hot Stocks
Frost honored, Britain wins 5 International Emmys
| Entertainment
|
S.Korean bonds down on data jitters
Seoul shares inch up; Woori slips after block deal
Man pleads innocent to taping Erin Andrews nude
| Entertainment
|
The real Alice in Wonderland's book up for auction
| Entertainment
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Frost honored, Britain wins 5 International Emmys
Britain wins 5 International Emmys; 1st for Brazil
Final episode of TLC's 'Jon & Kate Plus 8' airs
Sarah Palin's book tour hits NC's Fort Bragg
AP source: Palin book sells big in first week
Title fight unites boxers of different faiths
War deprives Yemeni elite of choicest chew
Chief guilty of 3 counts in Parker-Broderick case
Vampire sequel 'New Moon' feasts on box office
Spain police detain 30 in Basque raids: report
Google to digitise Iraq Museum archives: CEO
DR Congo war crimes trial begins at The Hague
Britain begins long-awaited Iraq war probe
Iran says needs guarantees to ship nuclear fuel
| International
|
Shalit prisoner swap 'very close:' Israeli minister
Netanyahu says Hamas prisoner deal might not happen
| International
|
AIDS death toll passes 25 mln: UNAIDS
Netanyahu says Hamas prisoner deal might not happen
Twitter eyes acquisitions, sees making money in 2010
Magnitude 6.8 quake recorded near Tonga
| International
|
GM has paid back Opel loans to Germany: Merkel
Iran said ready for uranium exchange on its soil
'Comfort food' relieves stress: Australian study
Microsoft, News Corp weigh Web pact: source
Iraq national vote unlikely in January: official
| International
|
HIV kills 25 million, infects 60 million: UNAIDS
China executes two for tainted milk scandal
| International
|
Japan finance minister urges BoJ on deflation
Google documents Iraqi museum treasures
Soldiers kill 18 militants in Pakistan Khyber area
| International
|
WHO probing drug resistant swine flu
| International
|
Mankind using Earth's resources at alarming rate
Yemen conflict inflaming Saudi-Iranian rivalry
Hague prosecutor accuses Congo warlords
| International
|
KRouge trial prosecutors want Duch jailed
Police arresting people just for the DNA
| International
|
Israeli aircraft strike arms operations in Gaza
Obama meets war cabinet on Afghanistan
Sri Lankan opposition party to support war hero
India probe blames mosque attack on Hindu leaders
Twitter eyes acquisitions, sees making money in 2010
| Technology
|
Thai Cabinet invokes security law ahead of protest
Obama hosts Indian prime minister
Jail broken iPhones hacked by new virus
| Technology
|
Khmer Rouge prosecutors seek jail term for Duch
Sparkling reindeer-dung jewelry sells at Ill. zoo
Opposition backs Australian carbon reduction bill
China executes pair over tainted milk scandal
Former Thai Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej dies
SPIN METER: Legislation inflation grips GOP
Space agencies argue over delayed launch
SC legislators begin Sanford impeachment hearings
Sri Lankan navy seizes 100 illegal migrants
Atlanta cops, shaken community try to make amends
NYC police promote head of 9/11 trial security
Pro-Kremlin group slams Uzbek war memorial removal
Astronauts rest up after 3 spacewalks
Ailing Japan Airlines to receive emergency loans
Nokia says it will cut 220 R&D jobs in Japan
Pakistan's PSO to import 3.5 mln T diesel from Kuwait
S.Korea BOK grew warier on economy in Oct
Rock-star wife details drug mayhem in new book
| Entertainment
|
China shares fall on economic policy uncertainty
Regis Philbin taking leave of absence for surgery
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea c.bank to set inflation target on Nov 26
Japan's Hitachi to build rail car plant in Britain
French first lady Bruni to act for Woody Allen
China backs writers in fight against Google Books
Japan finance minister urges BoJ to tackle deflation
Overnight star Susan Boyle focus of TV special
Britain tops Emmy awards list, Brazil gets first
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights