">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profiles
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Search
Search:
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profiles
Reuters - Saturday, May 9
By Gina Keating
LOS ANGELES - A U.S. appeals court on Friday reinstated a breach of contract claim against Yahoo Inc by an Oregon woman who said the company failed to remove nude photos and fake profiles posted by her estranged boyfriend after promising to do so.
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on Thursday that Cynthia Barnes could sue Yahoo for agreeing, then failing to stop the "dangerous, cruel, and highly indecent" use of its site by the ex-boyfriend.
"Contract liability here would come not from Yahoo's publishing conduct, but from Yahoo's manifest intention to be legally obligated to do something, which happens to be removal of material from publication," the opinion said.
The appeals court remanded the case to the district court for further action on the state law claim for breach of contract but did not rule on whether the claim was viable.
The appellate decision also affirmed the lower court's dismissal of a claim for negligent undertaking.
Yahoo said in a statement that it was pleased that part of the dismissal stood, and "evaluating the opinion on the remaining claim and looking forward to swift resolution in the district court."
Barnes' attorney Thomas Rask of Kell, Alterman & Runstein LLP in Portland, Oregon, said his client sued only after repeatedly asking Yahoo to remove the profiles, then relying on a promise by a Yahoo employee that they would be taken down.
"What an has to understand is this is not the wild wild West," Rask said. "There has to be some rational logic to it. Don't promise to do something and then not do it."
'BIG IMPLICATIONS'
The ruling could have a "big implications" for Internet companies that enjoy immunity from lawsuits involving user-posted content under the Communications Decency Act , said attorney Jeff Neuburger, co-chair of the Technology, Media and Communications practice group at Proskauer Rose LLP.
Neuburger, who is not involved in the case, said the opinion would prompt him to counsel media clients with Web operations, including social networking and blogging features, to consider some safeguards.
"There are a number of practical implications that flow from this decision, including educating customer service representatives, modifying terms of use and generally making sure that anything that comes from the publisher of the site cannot be viewed as a promise," Neuberger said.
The Yahoo profiles included nude photos of Barnes and her boyfriend taken without her knowledge, her office phone number, email and address and "open solicitations" for sex, the opinion said.
"Before long, men whom Barnes did not know were peppering her office with emails, phone calls, and personal visits, all in the expectation of sex," the opinion said.
Yahoo did not respond to Barnes' requests to remove the profiles until a TV news crew did a story on her situation and called the company for comment, the ruling said.
An employee then told Barnes she would "personally walk the statements over to the division responsible for stopping unauthorized profiles and they would take care of it" -- a pledge that could be construed as a contract, the opinion said.
The profiles were not removed until more than two months later, after Barnes filed the lawsuit, the opinion said.
Yahoo said it would "hotly contest" Barnes allegations at trial, the opinion said.
The case is Barnes v. Yahoo! Inc, CV-05-00926, U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
1 user recommend
Related Articles: Internet Portals & Search Engines
US-TECH SummaryReuters - Saturday, May 9
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profilesReuters - Saturday, May 9
Hackers breach US air traffic control computersAFP - Saturday, May 9
U.S. state AGs looking at Google books dealReuters - Saturday, May 9
Related Articles: Technology
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profilesReuters - Saturday, May 9
Hackers breach US air traffic control computersAFP - Saturday, May 9
U.S. state AGs looking at Google books dealReuters - Saturday, May 9
Google CEO says he expects more government scrutinyReuters - Friday, May 8
Virtual Earth gets 3D Photosynth viewsAFP - Friday, May 8
Related Full Coverage
Internet Portals & Search Engines
Latest development in the online world
All Full Coverage
Most Popular – Technology
Viewed
Stress tests lift uncertainty over US banks
Obese young men have less hope of marriage: study
British store admits it boobed in bra row
Court okays breast removal for transsexual teen: report
Obama budget to slash 'stunning' waste in US
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Saturday, 9 May 2009 Afghan's Karzai demands U.S. halt air strikes: report
| International
|
Ahmadinejad seeks new term as Iran president
| International
|
U.N. says south Sudan tribal violence worrying
| International
|
Scheffer says NATO's doors open to Balkan hopefuls
| International
|
U.S. state AGs looking at Google books deal
| Technology
|
Visionary or plane crazy? Airbus contest to decide
| Technology
|
Australia Shores Up Defense As U.S. Power In Region Wanes
Report: Pelosi Was Briefed About Waterboarding In 2002
Child Welfare Spokesman Gets 24 Years In Prison for Child Porn
U.S. Job Market Shows Sign Of Improvement; Unemployment Rate Raises Concerns
"Inappropriate" Growth of Children Spurs New Rules for Sex Gels
Democrats Give Obama Deadline To Submit "Comprehensive Plan" On Closing Guantanamo
Wal-Mart Agrees to Act To Prevent Future Store Tramplings
Crown Of The Statue Of Liberty To Reopen On Independence Day
Former Homeland Security Sec. Tom Ridge Decides Against Senate Run
Roughly 1,400 Firefighters Battle Growing California Wildlfire
Van Halen confirmed for Guitar Hero
| Entertainment
|
ABBA legends pair up for first new songs in 15 years
| Entertainment
|
KFC cancels free chicken deal after Oprah promo
| Entertainment
|
Runaway Cow Escapes Slaughter, Leads Police On Chase
Borat Star Suffered Serious Burns After Trying To Bleach His Body Hair
Michael Douglas Jokes He Had Knee Surgery So He Can Chase Daughter's Future Boyfriends
Tongue Exercise May Reduce Sleep Apnea, Snoring
Diddy Holds Business Meetings In The Gym
Queen Elizabeth's Racehorse Fails Drug Test
American Tourist Caught Swimming Away From Burmese Opposition Leader's Lakeside Home
World's Oldest Dog Turns 21 With Birthday Party, Cake
University Of Illinois At Chicago Bans Graduation Handshakes As H1N1 Precaution
Volcano Boarding New Extreme Sport
Afghan leader demands air strikes end
Pope to visit mosque in Jordan, address Muslims
| International
|
Pope in Jordan to strengthen Christian-Muslim ties
State Attorney Generals Leary Over Google Books Deal
No need to talk to South, says North Korea
| International
|
Obama administration renews sanctions on Syria
Concert Promoter Admits To "Phony Toni" Braxton Show Scam
Iran court to review U.S. reporter's case
| International
|
Murdoch leads charge to get readers to pay online
Lebanon arrests 5 suspected of spying for Israel
Howard Stern Blasts Porn Star Sasha Grey For "Racist" Comment
Canada reports first flu death as U.S. cases climb
| International
|
Creditors drop opposition to Chrysler bankruptcy plan
Carjackers kill peacekeeper in Sudan's Darfur
Afghan's Karzai demands U.S. halt air strikes: report
| International
|
Kate Winslet Sues U.K. Tabloid For $225K Over Her Workout Regimen
US job losses slow, as unemployment hits new high
South Africa's Zuma to be sworn in as president
| International
|
Turkey pledges renewed EU drive
Apple Approves Nine Inch Nails iPhone Application Without Changes
NIN's Trent Reznor Blasts Prince And Rivers Cuomo In Recent Interview
Canada to appeal court ruling on Guantanamo inmate
| International
|
U.N. experts prepare to investigate war crimes in Gaza
Kiefer Sutherland Charged With Misdemeanor Assault
Lynyrd Skynyrd Bassist Ean Evans Dies From Cancer
Nicolas Cage's "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" Suffers Another Car Accident
AP sources: Gov't sticks with Bush polar bear rule
Beauty Queen May Lose Crown Over Naughty Photos
AT&T to buy some Alltel assets for $2.35 billion
| Technology
|
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profiles
| Technology
|
Calif. wildfire estimate doubled to 8,600 acres
Court reinstates Yahoo lawsuit over fake profiles
Hackers breach US air traffic control computers
Trolleys collide in Boston; 49 people hurt
U.S. state AGs looking at Google books deal
NY man, 61, dies climbing Alaska's Mount McKinley
Russia shows military power in Soviet-style parade
Miss Calif. pageant to address contract violations
Ethics complaint against Palin dismissed
UN chief to travel to Bahrain, Switzerland later this month
4 teens charged with sexual battery of teammate
Armenian, Azeri heads make progress on Karabakh: mediator
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 610
Temporary Czech cabinet sworn in
Man gets more prison time in transgender slaying
Danny Gokey, 'American Idol' crews visit Milwaukee
Jose Carreras announces retirement from opera
| Entertainment
|
Taiwan's ex-leader rushed to hospital: doctor
Myanmar's Suu Kyi 'not in good health': party
Christian Bale forces Terminator rewrite
| Entertainment
|
Sacha Baron Cohen's Bruno is pushin' der limits
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan president sees 'war' against Taliban
Swine flu: Japan, Australia report first cases
Lost teen's emergency calls prove futile
KFC amends free chicken deal after Oprah promo
| Entertainment
|
Japan's first swine flu patients confirmed
Q&A: Turning 60, Billy Joel is happy and contented
| Entertainment
|
Japan confirms first 3 swine flu cases
Rapper offers free Stimulus Package
| Entertainment
|
Sri Lanka troops break more rebel defences: ministry
AFGHAN NOTEBOOK: CIA past shapes Gates' outlook
North Korea says no need to talk to South
Pakistani c.bank buys 43.57 bln rupees of T-bills
EU states seek more time on S.Korea pact-diplomats
EU, China bank on trade to ward off economic slump
Volkswagen, FAW to invest 5bn yuan in China: report
Rapper offers free "Stimulus Package"
Hyundai mulls shift from India on labour woes
'Idol' Kris Allen returns to Ark. hometown, parade
EU agrees to final push in South Korea trade talks
Sacha Baron Cohen's "Bruno" is "pushin' der limits"
Scores die breaking down ships in Asia
KFC amends free chicken deal after Oprah promo
Christian Bale forces "Terminator" rewrite
Hugh Jackman to launch `Wolverine' in Mexico
Fired apprentices diss Joan Rivers
"Star Trek" launched to robust advance screenings
Statue of Liberty's head to open to tourists again
Jose Carreras announces retirement from opera
Militia must stay out of election: Iran reformer
Iran court to review U.S. reporter's case
Gunships, planes strike Pakistan Taliban in Swat
| International
|
Geithner's warning on speed of economic recovery
Medvedev says Russia will rebuff agression
| International
|
Pope calls for Christian-Muslim harmony
| International
|
Zuma sworn in as South African president
| International
|
Georgia opposition seeks meeting with president
| International
|
No plans to abolish Turkey's rural militia: minister
| International
|
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood dismisses Obama speech
| International
|
Nations gather for oceans talks in Indonesia
Berlusconi says riding high despite divorce coverage
| International
|
Competing demands on health overhaul from groups
Peel and weep: Stamps costing 2 cents more Monday
Leahy to return Citigroup donation
Microsoft says EU may boost Google dominance: report
Cleanup begins after Midwest storms killed 5
GOP: Closing Guantanamo prison threatens security
Obama: Send me credit card legislation this month
Gay marriage effort stalls in heavily Catholic RI
Hollywood writer John Furia Jr. dies at age 79
Microsoft says EU may boost Google dominance: report
| Technology
|
Food stamp rule frustrates police in North Dakota
Maldives holds multiparty parliamentary elections
Gunships and planes strike Pakistan Taliban
Pakistan: Up to 55 Taliban killed in northwest
U.S. drone attack kills at least five in Pakistan
Report: China mine owners hide death of 6 workers
Malaysia frees terror suspects, Indian activists
Australia reports first case of swine flu
Rights group: Sri Lanka shelling hospitals
Indian PM: Outsourcing helps US companies
Japan nuke plant restarts two years after quake
Sri Lanka troops kill 35 Tigers: military
Amy Winehouse cuts short comeback gig in Caribbean
Language of Jesus keeps memories alive in Israel
Miss Calif. pageant to address contract violations
Andy Samberg hosts special on 'SNL' short films
Nations gather for oceans talks in Indonesia
Beyonce Says She Was So Fat As A Child That Her Family Used To Help Her Fasten Her Clothes
Man Shoplifts Clothes, Then Applies For Job At Same Store
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights