InfoAnda - Medi-dramas give patients 'unrealistic expectations'

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

EU urges G20 to act to avoid currency war | 29 October 2010
Scientists stumped as bee population declines further | 29 March 2010
Poll shows Australian government heading for poll defeat | | 7 August 2010

Hacker gets 20 years for U.S. payment card theft | 26 March 2010

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Medi-dramas give patients 'unrealistic expectations'

Yahoo! My Yahoo! Mail Yahoo! Search Search: Sign InNew User? Sign Up News Home - Help Navigation Primary Navigation Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Top Stories Most Popular Secondary Navigation Asia Pacific World Search Search: Medi-dramas give patients 'unrealistic expectations' AFP - Friday, September 4 WASHINGTON (AFP) - - People love watching television doctors working miracles on patients with mystery ailments or devastating injuries but these medi-dramas are feeding patients unrealistic expectations, experts warn. ADVERTISEMENT Viewers glued to weekly instalments of fictional doctors ordering batteries of diagnostic tests and unorthodox medical treatments can be forgiven for believing that rafts of examinations and aggressive interventions are the norm. But US experts said hospitals are unable to provide the cure-all solutions found on programs like the rabidly popular "House", starring British actor Hugh Laurie as the maverick medical genius Doctor Gregory House. Research also suggests aggressively treating some ailments can do more harm than good, they said. "The shows do tend to be very activist, very interventionist, very aggressive with their care... because action is more interesting," said Andrew Holtz, a medical journalist and author of a book on "House." "You get the pressure to have aggressive medical intervention that almost always works and that's just unrealistic." Not only does such treatment often fail to work, Holtz noted, but sometimes it can have side effects that outweigh the benefits. "People don't see that on television," he said, adding that medical dramas contribute to a false conviction that any ailment can be cured. "People have the belief that if you search hard enough, if you spend enough money, if you find the right doctor, you can get that rescue, that breakthrough, and those things just don't really happen in the real world." Medical professionals often provide the background material that television writers use to script the unusual illnesses that afflict their unfortunate characters. Allan Hamilton, a script consultant for the popular medical drama "Grey's Anatomy," is also the chairman of the surgery department at the University of Arizona Health Services Center. "They'll say 'we need a disease that looks like a person's going to die, but then there's this one thing that tips them off that they need to do further diagnostic tests.' Or 'we want a patient who is doing really well and everyone's really happy and then something goes dreadfully wrong,'" he said. "I always joke with the writers, you know, 'this wouldn't really happen or that wouldn't really happen' and then they turn around to me and say 'yeah, but this is Hollywood, anything can happen.'" As a medical professional, Hamilton is wary of the effects that depicting experimental treatments can have on viewers. "Are we going to suddenly raise people's expectations?... You do worry about that. People see this and there's a question in their mind, 'well are there people like that that we could find... is there a House that could fix me?'" Sandra Buffington, director of the University of Southern California's Hollywood, Health and Society program, argues that the power of medical dramas is one should that can be harnessed to educate. Her program receives funding from the US government's Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and organizations like the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to help television writers develop accurate health stories. "When the drama is compelling, the viewer is completely transported," Buffington said. "They forget their surroundings, they're completely in the story, they see the characters as family and friends, almost as loved ones.... They are much more receptive and open to learning." Buffington's program has worked with shows including "Grey's Anatomy" and "ER," but had one of its greatest successes with a storyline about an HIV-positive character on the daytime soap opera "The Bold and Beautiful" that featured information about an HIV/AIDS information hotline. "The highest peak in callers all year was, we got 5,313 calls in a single day, was the day that Tony told his fiancee Kristen that he was HIV positive." Buffington acknowledges that the "huge" impact of medical dramas is just as powerful, even when storylines are unrealistic or just plain wrong. "That's why we're in business, because so much of this information is inaccurate or may be outdated." For Holtz, the most misleading health information on television comes not from medical dramas, but advertisements for prescription medications. "Television ads are some of the most crisp and concise storytelling that exists," he said. "They tell this story that if you come, if you get our product, you will have a life that's full of sunshine and butterflies and romps in the grass. It's just purely fantasy." Email Story IM Story Printable View Blog This Sign in to recommend this article » 0 users recommend Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle Fox adds on-air tweets to `Fringe' rerunsAP - 2 hours 1 minute ago Robbie Williams charts route back to the topAFP - 2 hours 20 minutes ago Nicolas Cage plays unhinged cop in Bad LieutenantReuters - Saturday, September 5 Cast and creators recall the birth of 'Avenue Q'AP - Saturday, September 5 Guest: Michael Jackson funeral touching, emotionalAP - Saturday, September 5 Enlarge Photo US experts say hospitals are unable to provide the cure-all solutions found on programs like the rabidly popular "House", starring British actor Hugh Laurie (pictured in 2007) as the maverick medical genius Doctor Gregory House. Most Popular – Entertainment Viewed Poignant final farewell as Jackson laid to rest World heading for climate 'abyss': UN chief First baby born from new egg-screening technique BP unveils 'giant' oil discovery in Gulf of Mexico Chappaquiddick 'haunts me,' Kennedy said View Complete List » Search: Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Top Stories Most Popular Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Community - Intellectual Property Rights Policy - Help

Other News on Friday, 4 September 2009
Iraq accuses Syria of harboring armed groups
Outspoken Arctic Sea ship commentator flees Russia
US-TECH Summary
Chappaquiddick 'haunts me,' Kennedy said
Israeli team working to decipher ancient texts
Another blogger held in Vietnam: diplomat
French documentarian killed in El Salvador
EU leaders want binding G20 finance rules, sanctions
Millions in Australia lose international Internet link
US, Europe set to exit recession: OECD
Israel: pictures of St. Mary as terrorist removed
Iran's list of approved Cabinet ministers
Sprint to release Android phone in October
Iran's new key Cabinet ministers
Sprint backs Hero, the latest HTC Android phone
Building of new West Bank housing drops
Nokia seeking developers' help in Apple rivalry
Music videos return to YouTube after licensing deal
U.N.'s Ban raises alleged killings with Sri Lanka aide | International |
Virtual detectives stalk in-game spammers
Walkman outsells iPod in Japan: survey
Website says to carry bin Laden present to Muslims | International |
EU reveals probe into Oracle bid
Body handed over in Iraq confirmed as British hostage | International |
Nokia seeking developers' help in Apple rivalry
Walkman outsells iPod in Japan: survey
US cuts aid to Honduras in support of ex-leader
Security assigned to watch guards at Kabul embassy
Embracing social media, photo sites stay in the game | Technology |
Hundreds of feral animals found at California home
Australia open to military exercises with China: PM
Stray bullet kills student walking Atlanta campus
Biden defends stimulus plan
Parents held after lead poisoning protest in China: police
Biden: Obama health plan to be bold, contentious
Terror mastermind likely hiding in Java: Indonesia anti-terror chief
Schwarzenegger gets firsthand look at fire ruins
'Fresh protests' in China's Xinjiang
Del. dad pleads guilty in international kidnapping
CDC study: Swine flu deaths higher in older kids
Swiss, Chinese unveil new swine flu vaccines
Dealers should get 'Clunkers' money by Sept. 30
2 crashes in 1 day claim boy's grandfathers in Pa.
Japan wonders if new leaders have economic vision
NATO: 2 US service members killed in bomb attack
Syringe attacks spark new protest in Chinese city
Army: 11 killed in spate of violence in Thai south
Tensions brewing between Japan Inc. and new govt
Japan's Dainippon Sumitomo to buy US drugmaker Sepracor
Trade ministers put Doha deal in sight
Thai police push tax charges against Philip Morris
Study: Bigeye tuna stocks in Pacific under threat
Korea's KNHC bond to be sold at UST+265 bps -source
Happiness sequel revisits family misery | Entertainment |
Just a Minute With: Audrina Patridge on Sorority Row | Entertainment |
Fox business TV to simulcast Don Imus radio show | Entertainment |
Radiohead singer releasing solo single this month | Entertainment |
Fox Business Network to simulcast Imus
AP source: 'SNL' adds 2 performers for fall season
Artists protest Tel Aviv focus at Toronto film fest | Entertainment |
Carrie Underwood rushes new single to YouTube | Entertainment |
Madonna visits Jordan's Petra ruins
SAfricans target roots of anti-foreigner anger
Black Eyed Peas, Peal Jam shine on singles chart | Entertainment |
Tornatore in nostalgic mood with lengthy homage | Entertainment |
Indonesian quake leaves 57 dead, dozens missing
Spain forecasts 10 percent drop in foreign tourists
Madonna concert leaves Bulgaria facing pitch battle
No Impact Man charts U.S. couple's climate fight | Entertainment |
New novel, new movies in works for writer Sparks
`Life During Wartime' quasi-sequel to `Happiness'
Movie remake for McCarthy's bleak novel "The Road"
Top 15 programs on cable networks for Aug. 24-30
Not enough Facebook friends? Buy them
US must stay in Afghanistan to defeat Al-Qaeda: chiefs
Gangs are the heart of violent crime in Salvador, Central America
Google's China head to leave company: source
North Korea says in last stage of enriching uranium | International |
Poignant final farewell as Jackson laid to rest
Five years on, 334 balloons mark Beslan tragedy
Blast after Afghan air strike, scores feared killed | International |
Sony throws down the 3D gauntlet with new TV
Iran assembly approves most of hard-line Cabinet
Canada seeks to overturn South Africa refugee ruling | International |
Netanyahu to allow new Israeli settler homes: aide | International |
World heading for climate 'abyss': UN chief
EU's Barroso vows 'ambitious' Europe in new term
U.S. appeals court stays Microsoft Word injunction
Iraqi deputy minister arrested in corruption sting
Russia orders new search for journalist's killers
La Presse publisher threatens to close Quebec daily
ECB chief upbeat on economic recovery
Four dead in bomb blast at south Iraq mosque
Taiwan drops annual U.N. bid as China relations warm | International |
Apple iPod updates expected, Jobs show uncertain
Unrest flares in far-west Chinese city | International |
Iran gets first woman minister as MPs back Ahmadinejad list
Iraq PM asks for U.N. inquiry into Baghdad bombings | International |
Doubts raised as former leader gets key Japan role | International |
FTC urges privacy policy for Google books
Facebook members who buy 'friends' could be banished
Sprint, HTC to release Android phone in October
Hurricane Jimena kills one in northern Mexico | International |
Fire on Air India flight put out, passengers safe | International |
Sony throws down the 3D gauntlet with new TV
NKorea says in final stage of uranium enrichment
Dalai Lama says 'always ready to go back to Tibet'
Deadly Jimena claims first victim in Mexico
Apple iPod updates expected, Jobs show uncertain | Technology |
China seeks to quell unrest in far-west city
FTC urges privacy policy for Google books | Technology |
Indonesian quake kills 57, leaves dozens missing
Google's China head to leave company: source | Technology |
10,000 Chinese protest series of needle stabbings
Jaycee kidnapper raped 14-year-old in 1972: police
U.S. appeals court stays Microsoft Word injunction | Technology |
Spacewalk performed despite approaching space junk
North Korea says in final phase of uranium enrichment
Hawaii gov: Budget woes may prompt 'restructuring'
Zheng rallies to reach third round at US Open
Ancient skeleton found with gun under Mass. shed
LA blaze ruled arson, homicide probe launched
NKorea says at final phase of uranium enrichment: Yonhap
Feds: Calif. water crisis isn't Washington's fault
Philly basketball court shooting kills 1, wounds 1
G20 to debate tough action on bankers' bonuses
Taiwan dollar flat as exporter deals meet c.bank
S.Korean bonds steady before auction, rate vote
Japan wonders if new leaders have economic vision
Korea Hot Stocks
Seoul shares open up;muted reaction to N.Korea news
NZ new car registrations fall in August
Dainippon of Japan acquires US drug maker Sepracor
Bullock comedy "Steve" knows little about humor
Indonesia quake toll at 59, search ongoing
Michael Jackson laid to rest, surrounded by stars | Entertainment |
Telluride unveils festival films, Oscar looms | Entertainment |
Mourners gather for Michael Jackson funeral
Kimchi brings health and beauty, enthusiasts say
Berlusconi docu in spotlight at Venice fest | Entertainment |
Russell Crowe challenges columnist to bike duel
Bullock comedy Steve knows little about humor | Entertainment |
Just a Minute With: Audrina Patridge on Sorority Row | Entertainment |
Rapper gets 75 years for fatal NJ robbery
Judge questions whether Salinger harmed by spin-off | Entertainment |
It's a boy for Idina Menzel and Taye Diggs
Telluride unveils festival films, Oscar looms
Barrymore to host skating event in Detroit area
CORRECTED: Artists protest Tel Aviv focus at Toronto film fest
Camera turns on 'Videocrat' Berlusconi at Venice
Aides: Israel to build new houses in settlements
4 suicide bombers detained in Chechnya: official
IMF chief sees global recovery, urges exit strategies
Up to 90 killed as NATO hits Afghan fuel trucks
Nifty and stylish is aim at Berlin gizmo fair
Indonesia quake landslide attracts voyeurs | International |
Israel to approve hundreds of new settler homes
Iran leader helped secure backing for government: MP | International |
BP warned UK of risk in delayed Libya prisoner deal | International |
H1N1 has killed 2,837, but not more serious: WHO | International |
UNHCR urges China grant access to Myanmar refugees | International |
Nifty and stylish is aim at Berlin gizmo fair | Technology |
Samsung: LED TV sales to grow at least five fold in '10 | Technology |
China police break up angry crowds near party HQ
Indonesian quake toll at 63, dozens still missing
Bomb in south Thailand kills policeman, wounds 12
Texas DNA exonerees find prosperity after prison
Philippines: Talks with communist rebels postponed
Indonesia quake landslide attracts voyeurs
Ex-POW hopes German cellar holds his pilot's wings
Thaksin supporters to mark Thai coup anniversary
North Korea says uranium program near completion
The Nation's Weather
Former soldier to be sentenced in rape, murders
Indonesia quake toll rises to 63, dozens missing
Guest: Many wept during Jackson's Calif. funeral
Japan's new leader backs fiscal regulation
Obama speech to students sparks new controversy
Health care lobbyists target returning Congress
NATO airstrike in Afghanistan kills up to 90
Kennedy's death impacts Wall Street reform effort
Rio Tinto suspends iron ore talks with China
US trade chief sees hope on global trade talks
Nicolas Cage plays unhinged cop in Bad Lieutenant
Cast and creators recall the birth of 'Avenue Q'
Warner Bros. poised to take summer box-office crown | Entertainment |
Philippine inflation down to 0.1 percent in August
Warner Bros. poised to take summer box-office crown
Stars, family honor Michael Jackson at funeral
Japan shares lower ahead of US employment data
China shares rise on rumors of IPO slowdown
S.Korea curbs home loans, rate rise looms
Kashmiris relishing drop in violence
Nicolas Cage plays unhinged cop in Bad Lieutenant | Entertainment |
Artists protest Tel Aviv focus at Toronto film fest | Entertainment |
Medi-dramas give patients 'unrealistic expectations'
Google China president steps down
Fitch may cut Taiwan rating over typhoon costs
Official: 115 die of malnutrition in Indonesia
Pakistani stocks close on year high; rupee weakens
Car-crazy Dubai gears up for first Gulf metro
Venice documentary attacks Berlusconi media empire
Welcome to Montreal Beach, new river surf capital
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01