Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Special Report
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Special Report - A prince, a sultan, diamonds and a lawsuit
Reuters - Friday, November 5
Send
IM Story
Print
By Mark Hosenball
WASHINGTON - Prince Jefri Bolkiah and his brother, the Sultan of Brunei, have at long last reconciled, but their epic feud involving diamonds, fast cars, luxurious homes and billions of dollars generated a treasure trove of legal documents.
Whether evidence from the earlier cases can be used by defence lawyers is a key issue in a lawsuit filed by Jefri against two of his former advisers, Reuters has learned.
One of the world's richest men, Jefri is expected to face vigorous grilling when he gives rare public testimony later this month in New York. His lawsuit charges that two of his personal lawyers enriched themselves through "fraud," "breach of contract" and "criminal enterprise."
But the prince's protracted legal wrangling with his brother may come back to haunt him. On behalf of the sultan, the state of Brunei had accused Jefri of misappropriating some $40 billion.
In a court filing this week, which was reviewed by Reuters, defence attorneys said Brunei authorities spent nearly a decade raising questions about "Prince Jefri's integrity and credibility in court proceedings around the world." The lawyers argue that they should be able to use material from previous court cases related to Jefri's diamond-encrusted lifestyle and prodigious spending to question him under oath.
In response, lawyers for Jefri and Brunei authorities, who once sued the prince for allegedly misappropriating official assets but are backing him in the New York case, have asked the judge to exclude evidence from earlier litigation.
Whatever latitude the judge allows, lawyers on both sides acknowledge that when he testifies, Jefri is likely to face tough questioning. His credibility will be the "central issue" in the trial, said Mark Cymrot, a lawyer for the prince's former advisers.
Jefri's answers could also shed light on one of history's most spectacular fraternal squabbles, whose reverberations extended far beyond tiny Brunei, the secretive oil-rich state located on the island of Borneo in Southeast Asia.
HIDDEN DIAMOND CACHE?
Defence lawyers say they hope to cross-examine Jefri, brother of Brunei's ultra-rich ruler, Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah, about an especially delicate subject: an alleged secret hoard of diamonds worth more than $1 billion.
In June this year, lawyers for the Brunei Investment Authority , official custodian of the Sultanate's vast oil wealth, told a British judge that Jefri had a "history of concealment and dissipation of assets." The BIA said that despite his denials, it believed Jefri "may still be in possession of some valuable diamonds."
The BIA lawyers sent the letter to the judge a few weeks after acquiring a sworn statement from a retired diamond dealer who claimed to have eavesdropped on -- and to have secretly recorded -- conversations among alleged acquaintances of Jefri who are in the diamond trade. According to the affidavit, the Prince's acquaintances allegedly talked about how Jefri might want to raise some quick cash by selling off some of his secret diamond stash -- or even sending them to Israel to be cut up.
One alleged acquaintance of the prince who the retired dealer's affidavit says was involved in such discussions was Edward Asprey, a former executive of Asprey's, an exclusive London jeweller that Jefri once owned. In an e-mail to Reuters, Asprey insisted that the affidavit, on the one hand, contained information which had been "obtained illegally," but on the other, was "full of inaccuracies, conjecture and assumptions." He declined to point out any specific flaws in the document's account.
Over the years, Prince Jefri has issued repeated denials that he misappropriated any Brunei funds or secreted assets. People close to Jefri insist that whatever diamonds the prince once had were surrendered to Brunei authorities two or three years ago.
Geoffrey S. Stewart, a U.S. lawyer who represents Jefri, said neither the prince nor his legal team would have any comment on the latest twists in the story or the forthcoming civil trial in New York. Legal sources directly involved in the case said that BIA believed the allegations in the diamond dealer's affidavit were not substantiated.
A legal source close to the BIA said that even though Jefri had indeed surrendered some diamonds to Brunei authorities, the investment agency's lawyers had not withdrawn their letter to the Judge suggesting Jefri might still have a secret diamond cache. If Jefri does have such a secret hoard, the source said, it likely is well-hidden.
A spokesman for the BIA declined comment beyond asserting that they were confident about winning the lawsuit.
TEN YEARS OF LITIGATION
In court rulings and filings over more than a decade, judges in Britain and lawyers for the BIA repeatedly accused Jefri, who was long estranged from his brother the Sultan, of misusing Brunei's official funds and then offering explanations or excuses for his behaviour which were not credible.
Over the last year, Jefri and the Sultan have made up, according to several people familiar with the brothers' affairs. One source said that Jefri is presently living in a luxury hotel in Brunei; another source said that the Sultan had recently made a large, vacant palace available for Jefri to move into.
Despite the purported reconciliation, many loose ends in the case remain unresolved. In particular, legal proceedings related to the recovery of assets held by Jefri and associates -- including members of his family -- are still underway.
Given the enormous wealth involved, it was probably inevitable that the feud would spark a tsunami of litigation that, over the years, has ensnared attorneys, solicitors, barristers and judges from the isles of Borneo, to Britain to Manhattan.
According to a November 2007 ruling by Britain's Privy Council, Jefri served as chairman of the BIA between July 1983 and July 1998. An investigation by the accounting firm Arthur Anderson subsequently found that over that period, "special transfers" totalling around $40 billion were made from BIA accounts. The auditors said that around $14.8 billion of that sum had been paid to or used on behalf of Prince Jefri, about $8 billion had been transferred to the Sultan's accounts, about $3.8 billion had been used by the Brunei government, and the remaining $13.8 billion couldn't be traced.
The Privy Council, a committee of British law lords acting as Brunei's Supreme Court, noted that Jefri did not deny that he had received "very substantial" sums from the BIA and that some of this money was used to buy properties, artworks, cars, airplanes and jewellery. But the judges noted that Jefri rejected charges that his use of the money amounted to misappropriation. He told them that he was running the BIA on the authority of his brother, the Sultan, and "at all times had the authority to make the respective transactions."
"SIMPLY INCREDIBLE" CLAIMS
In the wake of the discovery of the $40 billion hole in the BIA's wallet, lawyers for the authority and the Sultan launched a worldwide treasure hunt to recover Jefri's assets. In 2000, Jefri signed a settlement with the BIA, in which he agreed to turn over at least 40 properties in England, two properties in Paris and 11 properties in the United States, including two well-known luxury hotels, the Bel Air of Los Angeles and the Palace Hotel on New York's Madison Ave.
But according to the 2007 Privy Council ruling, instead of surrendering his ownership in the American hotels and a handful of other expensive properties, including a building in Paris' historic Place Vendome, Jefri procrastinated. He said that under an oral agreement he struck with his brother allowing him to maintain a "suitable lifestyle," he was allowed to hold onto the properties.
The Privy Council judges caustically rejected Jefri's story about the oral agreement, declaring in their ruling that the Prince's claims were "factually implausible," "simply incredible," "had no substance whatsoever," were "devoid of weight" and were "hopeless."
In a January 2008 affidavit submitted to Britain's high court, Lindsay Marr, a lawyer for the BIA, alleged that Jefri had continued to withhold information about the location of all his assets, calling this the "result of a cynical, persistent and deliberate design."
With a touch of sarcasm, Delaware Judge Leo Strine noted in a May 2008 ruling that despite the BIA's allegations that Jefri had misappropriated nearly $15 billion, the prince never faced criminal prosecution. "This could have been because his brother, the Sultan, still cared for him. It could have also been ... that Jefri had authority for everything he did from his brother, and had misappropriated funds for the Sultan's use as well. But for whatever the reason, Jefri escaped a long term in the jailhouse."
A footnote in the judge's ruling said that while Jefri had surrendered "over 600 properties, over 2000 cars, over 100 paintings, 5 boats and 9 aircraft to the BIA, he still retained billions of dollars in assets in other holdings."
In June 2008, Britain's high-court scheduled a hearing on whether Jefri was in contempt of court for his alleged failure to disclose the existence of secret bank accounts from which money continued to have been drained. But shortly before the hearing, Jefri, who had lived for years in a luxurious London mansion, left the country. The judge in the case issued a bench warrant for the Prince's arrest, which according to a person involved in the legal proceedings, remains in force today. "These proceedings are criminal in nature ... If he were to set foot in Britain, he would be arrested," the legal source told Reuters.
Lawyers close to the dispute say that despite Jefri's flight from Britain before the contempt of court hearing, by 2008 the BIA had begun to recover many, though not all, of the assets which Brunei authorities believed the Prince had acquired with misappropriated oil wealth -- including the New York and Los Angeles luxury hotels.
BROTHERLY RECONCILIATION
This apparently helped to pave the way for a reconciliation between Jefri and his brother the Sultan. After five years in exile, the Prince went back to his homeland just over a year ago; the local Borneo Bulletin marked his return by publishing a picture of Jefri attending prayers at a local mosque with the Sultan and other members of their family.
Given his turbulent recent legal history and the warrant outstanding against him in Britain, Jefri's appearance as a witness in any Western legal proceeding, such as his current lawsuit against his former personal lawyers, might seem risky. But the reconciliation between Jefri and the Sultan appears to have tempered Jefri's reluctance to appear personally in court.
In 2007 and then again a year ago, Jefri travelled to New York to give depositions in the lawsuit. The trial is scheduled to begin November 8 before a state judge in Manhattan.
In the New York case, Jefri and some of the same lawyers who once pursued him and his assets around the world have teamed up to sue Thomas Derbyshire and Faith Zaman, two British barristers who Jefri hired in 2004 to supervise his ownership of the Palace Hotel in New York and the Hotel Bel Air in California. The Brunei government claims that the two former advisers illegally diverted $6 million from the Palace hotel and other properties. Derbyshire and Zaman, who deny any wrongdoing, have counter-sued Jefri and his brother, claiming they are being framed by the Prince and the Sultan.
Central to the case against the two lawyers is an allegation by Prince Jefri that he never gave Derbyshire and Zaman authorization to use the funds they allegedly diverted. New York state Judge Ira Gammerman, who is presiding in the case, will have to decide how much to allow Jefri's reputation to be put on trial along with that of the people he is suing.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Zimbabwe arrests diamond magnates for fraud AFP - Friday, November 5
US Republicans vow to battle Obama AFP - 18 minutes ago
At least 20 dead in Costa Rica mudslide AFP - 19 minutes ago
Record drugs haul seized from US-Mexico border tunnel AFP - 1 hour 2 minutes ago
Gbagbo and Ouattara set for duel in Ivory Coast AFP - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Atom smasher ventures deeper into 'new frontier'
ECB, Britain hold rates steady as Fed pumps up funds
Rolls-Royce recommends engine checks after A380 incident
Serbian leader apologises at Croatia massacre site
Norway best for the good life: UN report
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Be fit, have fewer colds: study
Toddler survives seven-floor fall in France
Germany unveils new 'psychic' octopus -- and he's French
Fed resumes massive spending to spur recovery
Google 'Street View' broke Data Protection Act
More Most Viewed »
Time, like all good things, may come to an end: study
Alcohol more harmful than heroin, crack cocaine: study
Toddler survives seven-floor fall in France
Spectacular unknown species found in Amazon
Iranian chocolate thief 'to have hand chopped off'
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 5 November 2010 WikiLeaks founder tells US to open up on Iraq war
Rolls-Royce recommends engine checks after A380 incident
Israel's Barak stung by "idiot" insult
US-TECH Summary
Deutsche Telekom results underscore iPhone effect
Palestinians to give U.S. peace effort more time
|
NATO: Service member killed in eastern Afghanistan
Greek police intercept French embassy parcel bomb
Samsung sees selling 40 million smartphones in 2011: report
Atom smasher ventures deeper into 'new frontier'
Pakistan to walk tightrope on Afghan peace
ECB, Britain hold rates steady as Fed pumps up funds
Haiti evacuation effort stalls as storm closes in
|
Few Americans using location-based services: Pew study
Qaeda's Zawahri urges revenge over jailed scientist
|
Gunman Opens Fire in Palm Bay Hospital
Serbian leader apologises at Croatia massacre site
EU wants to give people power to vanish from Internet
Florida's Governor-Elect Unveils Transition Team
Norway best for the good life: UN report
U.S. Worker Productivity Increases
China's Hu signs deals, discusses G20 with Sarkozy
|
Sri Lanka to publish pictures of accused porn actors
Study: Lung Cancer Deaths Reduced If At Risk Screened By CT
Weather delays Discovery space shuttle launch: NASA
Well-known Vietnam blog hacked: founder
Food Network Launches New Foodie App
Privacy Group Sues To Stop Use Of Airport Body Scanners
Syria Internet law threatens online freedom
Minnesota Mom Ordered to Pay $1.5M for Illegally Downloading 24 Songs
Jambox a boombox for the smart gadget era
U.S.-Mexico Drug Tunnel Found, 40 Tons Of Marijuana Seized
Dane Cook To Release Greatest Hits Double Disc "I Did My Best"
Bomb defused with minutes to spare
FDA Confirms Listeria In Texas Celery Plant
China, France sign major energy, aviation deals
US embassy accused of spying in Norway, Oslo demands answers
Oracle CEO Ellison to testify Monday in SAP trial
Europe tests cyber defences against hackers
Al-Qaeda bomb in British airport was 'minutes from blast'
Samsung sees selling 40 million smartphones in 2011: report
Special Report
WikiLeaks urges U.S. to fully examine abuses
Oracle CEO Ellison to testify Monday in SAP trial
|
Samsung sees selling 40 million smartphones in 2011: report
|
China and France sign 20 billion dollars in trade deals
Nations must address economic imbalances: APEC draft
Cambodia, China announce 1.6billion dollar deal: officials
Nissan quarterly profit surges, raises forecast
LG Chem, Samsung Total to up naphtha cracking capacity
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates end up; rupee firmer
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $16.96 bln
BRIEF-Cambodian mobile firm CamGSM gets $591 mln funding
Qantas jumbo makes emergency landing in Singapore
Ex-teen idol David Cassidy arrested for drunk driving
|
Rapper Lil Wayne released from NY jail
|
Danny Boyle puts human touch into 127 Hours
|
A Minute With: Downey Jr, Galifianakis on Due Date
|
Ke$ha debuts at No. 1 on U.S. singles chart
|
Sirius XM mum on Howard Stern contract talks
|
Iran nuclear program on "explosive" path
BBC journalists' strike 'knocks flagship shows off air'
Cuba says all 68 on board died in plane crash
|
NATO: 3 service members killed in Afghanistan
Asia-Pacific governments chip away at Internet freedom
Charter plane crashes in Pakistan, no survivors
|
World's oldest axe found in Australia
Death toll from Indonesia volcano doubles overnight
|
NASA comet fly-by yields rare images from deep space
Tribes Suit Says Solar Power Farm Threatens Habitat Of Revered Desert Lizard
Qantas says A380 engine failure may be design issue
|
Dell switching off BlackBerry, onto own smartphone
Beyoncé's "I Am... World Tour" Concert Becomes ABC Thanksgiving Night Special
Oracle may aim to claim billions more from SAP
Six Americans killed in Mexico's drug war city
|
LimeWire Ordered To Be Shut Down
Western Digital looking at digital home for growth
Apple To Increase Music Preview To 90 Seconds On iTunes Store
Iraq parliament session pressures Iraqiya bloc
|
Update: Palm Bay Hospital Shooter Found Dead
US cooking magazine under fire for lifting article
Feds $600 Billion Economic Stimulus Plan Drives Stocks Up
Military proxies prepare to sweep rare Myanmar poll
|
Activision profit tops Street, shares rise
NASA Using Cloud Computing For Mars Rover Project
Wikileaks founder may seek Swiss asylum: interview
Japan investigating China collision video
|
Activision Blizzard net profit more than triples
Tropical Storm Tomas soaks Haitian tent camps
|
Indonesian volcano kills 35 in latest blast: hospital
1.5-million-dollar verdict in US music piracy case
Indonesian soldiers stand trial over torture video
China's Hu gives France G20 backing, signs deals
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
Video of China-Japan ship collision leaked on YouTube
Malaysian coalition claims key by-election wins
Legal appeal sent to UN for jailed Nobel winner
Medvedev plans 'active' role in Japan APEC summit
China pressures European governments over Nobel
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Death toll from Indonesian volcano climbs to 56
Family says newly crowned oldest woman is 115
Nearing 70, Ephron loves writing essays on age
Dell switching off BlackBerry, onto own smartphone
|
Danny Boyle puts human touch into "127 Hours"
A Minute With: Downey Jr, Galifianakis on "Due Date"
BBC apologizes to Geldof for aid-for-weapons story
Western Digital looking at digital home for growth
|
World's first Ferrari theme park opens in Abu Dhabi
Ex-teen idol David Cassidy arrested for drunk driving
Seoul shares open up; tech issues rise
Ke$ha debuts at No. 1 on U.S. singles chart
China, France sign big contracts, unite for G20
Activision profit tops Street, shares rise
|
Indonesian soldiers stand trial over torture video
Erupting Indonesian volcano kills 58
Indonesia's volcano death toll doubles overnight
Microsoft's Xbox 360 motion sensor Kinect hits stores
U.S.-Mexico Drug Tunnel Found, 40 Tons Of Marijuana Seized
Nova Scotia Couple Spends Entire $11.2 Million Lottery Prize Money In 4 Months
Official: Mumbai plane lands with suspicious cargo
Robot Astronaut Debuts, Joins Last Flight Of Discovery
NCAA Sees First Transgender Athlete In College Basketball Player
New Michael Jackson album gets December release
|
Aretha Franklin cancels all shows for six months
|
Eight Lady Gagas to enter Madame Tussauds worldwide
|
Megamind cartoon eyes mega-debut at box office
|
Nearing 70, Ephron loves writing essays on age
|
RBS bank plunges back into loss
Three Russian pilots kidnapped in Darfur
Qantas aircraft makes emergency landing in Singapore
|
Georgia 'busts Russian spy ring', outrages Moscow
Another Foxconn worker dies at south China plant
2 NATO service members killed in south Afghanistan
RBS plunges into red with third quarter loss
Afghans turn to Pakistan for medical treatment
Foxconn worker plunges to death at China plant: report
Britain urges action over extremist U.S. website
|
BofA and Citigroup testing iPhone for corporate email: report
NASA Ohio Facility Locked Down On Report Of Shots Fired
Officials Warning Consumers To Avoid Bravo Farms Dutch Style Gouda Cheese
Iraqi al Qaeda group predicts more bloody days
|
BLS: Employers Added 151,000 Jobs In October
NASA Spacecraft Snaps Closest Images of Comet Hartley 2
Georgia says breaks up Russian spy network
|
New Michael Jackson album gets December release
Republican Concedes Washington Race To Sen. Murray
North Korea says still wants to help in ship probe
|
Michigan Bans Alcoholic Energy Drink Four Loko
FDA Approves Cymbalta For Back Pain
E. Coli Outbreak Linked To Costco Cheese
Michigan Bans Alcohol Drinks Containing Caffeine
Suicide attack at Pakistan mosque kills 61
Concerns at US trade proposal as APEC meets
White House, Pentagon Deny $200 mln Price Tag, 34 Warships Escort For Asian Trip
Another Foxconn worker falls to death in China
Mosque bombing in Pakistan kills at least 50
Charter plane crash kills 21 in Pakistan
Western Digital looking at digital home for growth
|
Japan investigating China collision video
BofA and Citigroup testing iPhone for corporate email: report
|
Nepalese boy, 9, training to climb Everest
Cisco CEO comments key to igniting stock gains
|
Divas set to dominate MTV Europe Music Awards
Another Foxconn worker dies at south China plant
|
Portugal's doleful fado seeks place on UN heritage list
Italy longs for its heyday on 'La Dolce Vita' anniversary
"Megamind" cartoon eyes mega-debut at box office
Bank of Japan keeps rate near zero
New Michael Jackson album gets December release
Snubbed Haiti presidential candidate Wyclef releases new disc
Disney's Shanghai theme park takes step forward
Charter plane crash kills 21 in Pakistan
US stimulus rings Asian alarm bells
China rejects targets to ease trade imbalances
Rebounding Toyota posts $3.6 bln profit
Pakistani c.bank buys 9.7 bln rupees of govt paper
S.Korea T-bond futures slide on FX inspection fear
Japan to closely watch US monetary policy: FM
Seoul shares slip 0.2 pct on autos; techs bounce
Divas set to dominate MTV Europe Music Awards
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights