Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Europe seen needing regulation on Internet access
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Analysis: Europe seen needing regulation on Internet access
Reuters - Thursday, December 23
Send
IM Story
Print
LONDON - Europe's confidence that it need not follow the United States in adopting rules to ensure fair Internet access may be short-lived, as competition between mobile operators and service providers like Skype intensifies.
A debate over net neutrality -- the principle that all Internet traffic be treated equally -- has been heating up in the United States for years but has so far generated little public concern in Europe.
At stake is the ability of Internet service providers to ration access to their networks, allowing them to manage congestion but running the risk they will favor their own services or those who pay more, restricting consumer choice.
The U.S. communications regulator on Tuesday adopted rules that banned high-speed Internet service providers from blocking lawful traffic but allowed them to "reasonably" manage their networks.
In Europe, telecoms operators such as Deutsche Telekom, France Telecom or Telefonica -- former state monopolies which typically have close relationships with national governments -- still have the upper hand.
The European Commission has so far refrained from legislating to avert a looming conflict with the likes of Skype, Google or Facebook, which offer virtually free voice communications and messaging, striking at the heart of the carriers' business.
But Internet service providers -- mainly telcos in Europe -- already actively manage traffic to make it more efficient, and the potential to do more to protect their own services or earn extra revenues may be too much to resist.
"Mobile operators will be sorely tempted to do all they can to block the competition and stop them from cannibalizing their revenue streams," says Bengt Nordstrom, chief executive of Nordic telecoms consultancy Northstream.
"While operators have dodged the net neutrality bullet for now, they can expect further intrusion from the European Commission in the not-too-distant future," says Nordstrom, who predicts such intervention will come in 2012.
JUST ALGORITHMS
Europe's competitive environment is different from that in the United States, with fiercer rivalry among more mobile carriers operating in smaller markets, and a less-developed cable infrastructure.
This has led some to argue that the need for legislation in Europe is far less, as competition between ISPs allows customers to easily switch to an alternative provider if they are not getting the services they want.
At the same time, the operators argue they need and deserve help to upgrade their networks, which have begun to creak under the weight of traffic generated by services like Google-owned YouTube, Facebook and the BBC iPlayer.
"What is evident is that Internet search engines use our networks without paying for it. That's real luck for them and a disgrace for us," Telefonica Chairman Cesar Alierta said this year. "We do everything. I mean, they just have algorithms."
Bernstein analysts wrote in a recent research note: "In Europe, unlike the U.S., the net neutrality debate can, and we think will, be cast not as a battle for free speech but instead as a battle between aggressive over-reaching, freeriding U.S. content companies and homegrown European infrastructure providers ."
They said their stock preferences to play this state of affairs was for European telcos and U.S. cable operators.
Vodafone Deutsche Telekom, France Telecom, Telefonica and Telecom Italia have all complained about Google, Facebook and Apple using their networks to deliver services without contributing to network investments.
So far the European Union has taken a wait-and-see attitude, having directed national governments to ensure ISPs adopt non-discriminatory and transparent policies -- something they will have to put into practice by May 2011.
Meantime, it is consulting to determine whether traffic-management tools deployed by ISPs constitute a problem.
"There is cognitive dissonance. The service providers say we're not doing any of this, the likes of Skype say their services are being throttled," says one senior EU official. "It's clear that you have to be vigilant about these issues."
POWER BALANCE
Who holds the balance of power in the delicate relationship between the telcos and the content providers is "the $64,000 question," according to Andrew Bud, founder and chief strategy officer of mobile transmission and billing firm mBlox.
"That power balance is continually shifting," said Bud, who has long argued companies that want to push their content and services through networks to consumers should pay. He sees Europe as past the need for a net-neutrality debate.
"I can see events accelerating toward a new consensus," he said, citing most recently a speech by British Communications Minister Ed Vaizey in which he said it might make sense for content providers to pay for differing levels of service.
Northstream's Nordstrom reckons that consolidation in the trillion-dollar telecoms industry will pick up pace, changing the status quo, and predicts that European regulators will step in to legislate in 2012.
He points to carriers' past reluctance to self-regulate in the case of roaming charges for making mobile calls abroad -- costs that were eventually slashed by the EU -- saying operators tended to exploit favorable conditions for as long as possible.
"Nothing happened until regulation came, and now it's data. Operators are rather waiting to be regulated and trying to leverage the situation as much as they can," he says. "There's a lot of money to be made before regulation comes in."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 33 minutes ago
Skype hit by outage, says investigating Reuters - 33 minutes ago
Google buys New York office building AFP - 1 hour 8 minutes ago
Apple drops WikiLeaks app, Google keeps it Reuters - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
Activision wants to add Electronic Arts to lawsuit Reuters - 2 hours 36 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Oil jumps to highest levels since 2008
Indonesia's dragons draw tourists to 'Jurassic' islands
Time Magazine honors AFP photographer
US third quarter GDP growth revised higher
British economy suffers growth downgrades
More Top Stories »
Related Full Coverage
Internet Portals & Search EnginesLatest development in the online world
All Full Coverage »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Fears grow of euro-style debt crisis in US states
Zsa Zsa Gabor's husband glues own eye shut
US gets tough on shark fins
Lunar eclipse makes memorable solstice
'World's first' glasses-free 3D TV hits Japan
More Most Viewed »
NASA finds new form of life... on Earth
Defiant Obama defends tax cuts, eyes 2012
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 23 December 2010 Thousands of Italian students take to the streets
Iranian whipped in public for drinking alcohol
France charges Hutu rebel over 1994 Rwanda genocide: source
Ministers' gaffes show tensions in British coalition
|
Time Magazine honors AFP photographer
US third quarter GDP growth revised higher
British economy suffers growth downgrades
Russian paper to air WikiLeaks corruption material
|
Italian students march against education law
|
Sony to buy back chip plant from Toshiba: report
Motorola Mobility buys cloud storage firm Zecter
Pro-Kremlin group luring youth with spy luster
|
Sex hotel scandal is first for Brazil's next government
|
Salvadoran sentenced to 30 years for Cuba bombings
|
Dubai's DP World sells $1.5 bln Australian stake
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Japan slams officials over whale meat gifts
Sofia Coppola looks at Hollywood life in "Somewhere"
Indian opposition rally on graft pressures government
Chinese film to star Hollywood's Bale
Warm Russian, Indian ties outlive Cold War
Apple drops WikiLeaks app, Google keeps it
|
Pakistan and Iran jockey for influence after bombings
Protests on last day of China envoy's Taiwan visit
Skype hit by outage, says investigating
|
Lottery spreads Christmas cheer in Spain
Taiwan, US to resume trade talks after 3-year gap
Beatles 'Abbey Road' crossing given heritage status
China bans random mixing of foreign words with Chinese
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates up; rupee weakens
Baidu's face to Facebook talks ignore chime of wedding bells
Robert Gates is Man of Year at MTV college network
Teradata to buy cloud software firm Aprimo for $525 million
|
Jennifer Hudson "Feeling Good" about weight loss
Chinese film to star Hollywood's Bale
Sony launches subscription music streaming service
Beatles' Abbey Road crossing wins protected status
Sofia Coppola looks at Hollywood life in Somewhere
|
Julie Andrews, Dolly Parton win lifetime Grammys
|
Michael Jackson album fails to top pop chart
|
Live from the jury box, it's Steve Martin!
|
Analysis: Europe seen needing regulation on Internet access
German publisher Springer unveils iPad-only project
Pakistani IT firm's app tops Blackberry list
News
British gov't hit by fresh revelations of dissent
European airports race to clear Christmas backlog
South Korea holds drill, North lobs only insults
|
Thai rangers killed in rebel ambush
|
U.S. Senate approves nuclear arms treaty with Russia
World Bank cuts Ivorian financing as crisis deepens
|
Venezuela opposition slams coup d'etat by Chavez
|
U.S. military to allow gays, but rules will take time
Former Argentine dictator Videla jailed for life
|
News
U.S. Senate likely to pass START treaty Wednesday
Mexico leftist mayor rules out alliances in 2012
|
Draft on settlements ready for U.N.: Palestinians
|
News
Rovi to buy Sonic for $720 million, widens digital
|
News
Mobile security firm Lookout raises $19.5 million
|
Lille Christmas champions, 10-man PSG hit by Hadji double
Oil jumps to highest levels since 2008
Sony in talks to buy back Toshiba chip line: source
|
Indonesia's dragons draw tourists to 'Jurassic' islands
News
South Korea holds drill, North lobs only insults
News
S.Korea starts new drill as N.Korea raps 'warmongers'
Outage takes out Skype, recovery taking hours
Thai rangers killed in rebel ambush
Google buys New York office building
Bollywood hopes animation is a draw for audiences
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Australia apology to Indian doctor over terror charge
Apple drops WikiLeaks app, Google keeps it
David Schwimmer's violent film "Trust" loses ratings appeal
Obama to welcome China's Hu Jintao January 19
Activision wants to add Electronic Arts to lawsuit
Specialty films off to strong start at box office
Japan hails US-Russia new arms control treaty
"Despicable Me" tops DVD sales chart
Taylor Swift returns to No. 1 on U.S. album chart
|
Sony in talks to buy back Toshiba chip line: source
S.Korea, China in consultations over boat sinking
Foo Fighters play new songs at secret L.A. show
Officials order new safety measures for Spider-Man
|
5.4 magnitude quake shakes Indonesia, no tsunami threat
Christian Bale to star in Chinese massacre film
Motorola Mobility buys cloud storage firm Zecter
Foo Fighters play new songs at secret L.A. show
|
Taylor Swift returns to No. 1 on U.S. album chart
Craigslist pulls all adult services ads: state official
Christian Bale to star in Chinese massacre film
|
"Gulliver's Travels" relies too much on effects
Teradata to buy cloud software firm Aprimo for $525 million
Country Strong a Nashville nightmare
|
Officials order new safety measures for "Spider-Man"
Sony in talks to buy back Toshiba chip line: source
Specialty films off to strong start at box office
|
Bush memoir speeds past 2 million sales level
David Schwimmer's violent film Trust loses ratings appeal
|
Despicable Me tops DVD sales chart
|
Gulliver's Travels relies too much on effects
|
S.Korea to import 4 mln T grains directly by 2020
Seoul shares end flat, Samsung Electronics eases
Taiwan to issue T$185 bln in govt bonds in Q1 2011
Taiwan sells 30-year govt bonds at 2.2030 pct yield
S.Korea c.bank cuts SME credit facility ceiling
US challenges Chinese wind power subsidies at WTO
Seoul shares take breather, Samsung Electronics down
NZ economy unexpectedly shrinks, delay in rate hikes seen
Korea Hot Stocks-POSCO down on earnings worries
NPS to entrust $87 bln to outside fund houses next yr
Police check all Rome embassies after explosions
|
Russian Duma could ratify START within days
|
News
China speeds plans to launch aircraft carrier: sources
|
Would-be PM Soro calls for ICC mission to I.Coast
Lib Dems say UK coalition safe after paper sting
|
U.S. confirms embassy hit in Ivory Coast violence
Five detained Belarus candidates may face charges
|
Russian Duma could ratify START within days
Man detained near George W. Bush's home
Thai film board splats gay-themed movie
News
Global Weather-Celsius
News
News
News
Beijing's top 10 hangout spots in 2010
News
Five million Britons to shop online on Xmas Day
|
Micron sees lower NAND chip pricing
|
Asia Fuel Oil- Taiwan Formosa offers 55,000T, January
Pakistani stocks end down; rupee firms, o/n rates flat
Pakistan's forex reserves fall to $16.39 bln
Taiwan regulator meets AIG CEO on Nan Shan sale
Taiwan: buyers of insurers must fund future business
Cold weather, Christmas demand fuels oil prices
China pledges support to eurozone countries
News
SK Energy to sell $2.4 bln stake in Brazil unit
AIG may unveil buyer for Taiwan unit next week: report
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights