Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Oscar contenders vie for underdog status
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Palin star of controversial Tea Party
03 Feb 2010
Dutch court will hear case against far-right MP
03 Feb 2010
Vegetative patient "talks" using brain waves
03 Feb 2010
Obama vows to get tough with China on currency
| Video
1:08am EST
UPDATE 1-US defends interrogation of airplane bomb suspect
03 Feb 2010
Dutch court will hear case against far-right MP
03 Feb 2010
Vegetative patient "talks" using brain waves
03 Feb 2010
Monster to pay $225 million for Yahoo's HotJobs site
03 Feb 2010
Marathon Garyville work on track for Q1 completion
02 Feb 2010
Australia's "Down Under" band rapped for plagiarism
1:10am EST
Academy Awards
And the nominees are...
The nominations have been announced for this year's Academy Awards, including 10 for best picture. Here's a look at the top contenders. Full Article
Factbox: List of Oscar nominations
Sandra Bullock poised for first Oscar
10 Oscar nominees, but who’s counting?
Slideshow: Oscar contenders
Oscar contenders vie for underdog status
Stephen Galloway
Wed Feb 3, 2010 11:01pm EST
Related News
Historic German studio celebrates record Oscar run
Wed, Feb 3 2010
Oscars producer wants ceremony to be less "stuffy"
Wed, Feb 3 2010
Nominees could boost Oscar's TV ratings
Tue, Feb 2 2010
Exes, couples among Oscar nominees
Tue, Feb 2 2010
Oscar snubs "Avatar's" motion-capture actors
Tue, Feb 2 2010
LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - Is "Avatar" truly the underdog?
Entertainment | Film
That's the way Fox co-chairman Tom Rothman saw the best picture race last month in an interview with the New York Times -- and that was before "Avatar" lost to "The Hurt Locker" at the producers and directors guild awards in recent weeks.
The reality, though, is more complicated. Typically, the movie with the most Oscar nominations is the front-runner for best picture, and here "Avatar" and "Locker" are tied with nine apiece. That gives each an edge over the other eight nominees in this year's supersized category.
But which, if either, will win? What follows is an analysis of some of the factors that might determine the winner.
1. PREVIOUS AWARDS
As recently as early December, "Avatar" wasn't even being discussed as an Oscar movie. The picture hadn't screened for critics; a 25-minute preview at Comic-Con and another 15-minute clip that played in Imax theaters nationwide had drawn mixed responses. If anything, "Up in the Air" was looking like the favorite -- then "Avatar" started to roll out.
The Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. saw it and loved it; trade reviews were raves; and the first major press screening ended in applause. As critics followed with near-unanimous praise and the film began breaking box office records, "Avatar" emerged as the front-runner.
"The Hurt Locker" stole its thunder at the Critics Choice Awards on January 15, taking the directing and best picture prizes. But "Avatar" rebounded two days later at the Golden Globes, winning those races.
Six days later, the Screen Actors Guild Awards gave its ensemble prize to "Inglourious Basterds," but the following day the Producers Guild of America -- which has accurately forecast the Oscar winner six of the past 10 years -- opted for "Hurt Locker." The Directors Guild of America last Saturday gave its top award to Kathryn Bigelow for "The Hurt Locker."
So are the DGA and the PGA the best litmus tests? Maybe. The DGA has been right all but twice during the past decade -- though SAG and the Globes have the same success rate as the PGA, accurate six out of 10 times, and they didn't go with "Locker."
2. AGE
The average Academy member is 57.7 years old.
That number doesn't come from the Academy itself, but from a statistical sample culled by The Hollywood Reporter. (We randomly selected 500 of the Academy's 5,777 voting members, searched public databases to find their ages and averaged them out.)
Most insiders believe the average Academy member is quite a bit older than the average WGA, DGA and SAG member -- especially the latter, given that SAG's large membership includes a host of young actors who have not yet made their mark.
What's unclear is how age will factor in the race. In the foreign-language category, age has often been cited as the reason the Academy has leaned away from cutting-edge pictures like Romania's Palme d'Or winner "4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days" or movies from European masters like Pedro Almodovar. But will it affect the best picture nominees?
One producer argues yes, noting that the older voters will want a more substantive, issue-oriented film like "Locker," rather than a four-quadrant crowd-pleaser like "Avatar." But another Academy member counters that older members are more likely to appreciate the latter's craft and scope.
The Academy's older-skewing membership in the past has been held responsible for such middlebrow winners as "Dances With Wolves" and "Gandhi." By contrast, the Academy's attempt to broaden its membership in recent years has led it to favor such non-blockbuster movies as "Crash" and "No Country for Old Men." Overall, insiders believe older voters will favor "Locker" or possibly "Up in the Air," both of which deal with pressing issues without an action movie structure.
3. MEMBERSHIP
Of the Academy's 5,777 voting members, 1,205 are actors. And actors historically have voted for actor-oriented films. That's why a movie like "Driving Miss Daisy" beat "Born on the Fourth of July," "My Left Foot," "Dead Poets Society" and "Field of Dreams" for best picture at the 62nd Oscars in 1990. Most insiders believe that actors will veer away from the CGI-heavy "Avatar" and toward "Up in the Air," "Locker" or "Basterds."
To counter this, before the nominations, Fox ran ads touting the work of the actors in "Avatar." Highly praised as her performance has been, Zoe Saldana was always a long shot to get nominated for best actress -- and indeed she wasn't. But the ads subtly reminded voters that "Avatar" was an actors' film and not just a VFX showcase. The good news for "Avatar" is that actors are just one branch of the Academy.
Often overlooked is its hefty base of technicians. After producers and executives (who make up the second- and third-largest Academy branches), the next largest is the sound branch, which includes 405 members. Add them to the 279 members of the visual effects branch and that's a hefty bunch of technicians who might reasonably be inclined toward "Avatar."
4. VOTING SYSTEM
It is quite possible that the movie with the most votes for best picture will go on to lose the race. That's because, when it comes to best picture, the Academy uses a preferential voting system -- the same system it uses in almost all categories when it comes to choosing the nominees. (Curiously, the Academy doesn't use that system in determining winners in any category except best picture.) What this means is that long-standing notions about why certain films win may prove false.
Now, the old fear of "splitting" votes is baseless. In the past, insiders speculated that a movie like "Chariots of Fire" won the Oscar in 1982 because voters were torn between two other best picture nominees, "Atlantic City" and "Reds," dividing their votes between them and allowing "Chariots" to win. Not this time. Under the current system, several rounds of vote-counting take place. If your first choice were "Atlantic City" and your second choice were "Reds," and "Atlantic City" got the least votes, in round two your "Atlantic" vote would turn into a vote for "Reds." That process continues through several rounds, until one movie crosses the winner's line.
Because of this, being the No. 1 choice of a passionate group of voters is no longer enough. Unless one picture clears 51% of the votes in the first round, it will have to count on being placed No. 2 or No. 3 on members' ballots in order to win. There was speculation after the PGA vote that "Avatar" might have received the most votes in the opening round, but failed to get enough No. 2 votes to become the winner.
Will this voting system favor "Avatar" or "Locker?" Many insiders argue that it could work in "Locker's" favor, with "Locker" potentially picking up a disproportionate amount of No. 2 votes from "Up in the Air" or "Inglourious Basterds," as those films fall by the wayside. But that theory only holds water if you believe that "Avatar" is the kind of galvanizing picture that will cause voters to either mark it as their No. 1 choice or express ambivalence with a much lower ranking.
5. OTHER NOMINATIONS
No film in the past decade has won best picture that hasn't also been nominated for either original or adapted screenplay. And only two movies in the past decade have won best picture without having any actors nominated ("Slumdog Millionaire" in 2009 and "Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" in 2004).
Both factors are strikes against "Avatar." Few expected it to earn any acting nominations, but given that the WGA singled out its screenplay, insiders were surprised when it failed to pick up a writing Oscar nomination -- which means that less than 20% of the 382 members of the Academy's writing branch believed it was nomination-worthy. Those historical trends favor "Locker," which drew an acting nomination for Jeremy Renner. Still, Cameron can take comfort: The last best picture winner not to get a screenplay nomination was -- guess what -- "Titanic" in 1998.
Entertainment
Film
More from Reuters
Toyota sees $2 billion hit from recall problems
TOKYO/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Toyota Motor Corp expects costs and lost sales from its largest ever safety recall to total $2 billion for the year to March, but raised its outlook after posting its strongest operating profit in six quarters. | Video
Shell profits collapse on weak refining, natgas
Obama vows to get tough with China on currency
| Video
Health spending to get bigger share of economy
Sony posts first profit in five quarters, lifts outlook
Pfizer sees strong growth in China
» More Top News
A frosty welcome for G7
Break out the dog sleds. Canada's decision to host the G7 in the frostbitten Arctic has speculators wondering if the meeting is still relevant. Full Article
Canada hopes to refresh G7
Forex, financial reform on the agenda
U.S. to G7: Austerity will come
Economy
She's the star of the Tea Party
The first national Tea Party convention is set to kick off amid in-fighting and criticism. Can Sarah Palin transform the movement into a political machine? Full Article
Sarah Palin's got Ohio on her mind
Tea Party "warriors" take aim at Florida
Tea party target: Its own convention
Politics
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 4 February 2010 Italy's prime minister links Gaza war to Holocaust
EU places Greece under tough budget scrutiny
Italian developer takes down iMussolini application from store
Scientists 'grow' edible insects in Costa Rica
Iran leader's nuclear comments surprise West
Egypt: 2 editors punished for dealing with Israel
Gunslinger reflex helps save lives: UK research
Iraq court delays ban on hundreds of candidates
Indian mobiles fall silent over tower dispute
West offers skeptical reaction to Iran nuke plan
Jackson doctor 'ready to surrender to police'
Nokia says it has more than one million navigation clients
Suicide attack on Shiite pilgrims kills 23 in Iraq
Hynix executive, others, held over alleged Samsung theft
Bill Clinton to coordinate Haiti aid efforts
|
US debt to hit ceiling by end February: Treasury
US-TECH Summary
Yugoslav partisan who saved Jews in Holocaust dies
Hamas hosts Fatah leader for unity talks
|
Comcast profit up on Internet, phone subscribers
Barred Iraq candidates allowed to stand: official
Iran government survival hinges on nuclear issue: Israel
|
Uproar in Brazil over huge Amazon dam plan
Hamas gives U.N. response to Gaza war crimes report
Newly independent AOL reports profit
China welcomes foreign Internet firms: minister
European states keep Swiss bank secrecy under siege
|
AOL posts profit, but subscribers dwindle
Ukraine PM cries foul days before presidential poll
|
Berlusconi in Bethlehem: Wall? What wall?
|
Hynix executive, others, held over alleged Samsung theft
Nokia says it has more than one million navigation clients
Syrian FM: US has nominated ambassador to Damascus
Asia bolsters defences as West feels pinch: IISS
A look at the 2010 Cadillac SRX
NKorean-flagged Libyan ship hijacked off Yemen: EU
Scandal-plagued Baltimore mayor says goodbye
China to beef up security in restive Xinjiang
Judge drops charges against 1 in 1975 AIM slaying
Japan political kingmaker to avoid indictment: reports
Some House Dems oppose plan for jobs tax credit
Judge dismisses suit filed by Alamo followers
Malaysian police probe PM's aide over race remarks
Oracle database can be hacked remotely: researcher
|
Prelim delayed for alleged unruly passenger in Pa.
US Senate condemns hacking of Google in China
US sees 'spike' in Vietnam human rights issues
Court: Man can't sue prosecutor over terror case
Obama to meet Dalai Lama despite Chinese warnings
Ohio teen told police he raped woman along road
Pakistan school bombing kills US soldiers, children
Marines brace for new push in southern Afghanistan
Argentina has Hollywood in its 'Eyes' after Oscar nod
Taiwan carmaker touts new luxury sedan in China
Worst movies of all time led by Clooney's "Batman"
President Hu says China must change economic model
US 'disappointed' by limits on Japan auto incentives
New Zealand virgin auctions herself for tuition
Soros: US, China key to world financial regulation
Up a favorite in quality Oscar race for animation
|
Toyota hit by over 100 Prius brake complaints
Leif Garrett arrested for heroin possession
|
Sharp swings to profit in third quarter
Asia stocks up on Wall Street rise
Executives get down and dirty in Undercover Boss
|
Sphinx-lined alley hints at wealth of Egypt's lost empires
Argentina has Hollywood in its 'Eyes' after Oscar nod
"Hair" back in Serbia after 40 years, minus nudity
Austria welcomes Oscar "hat-trick"
Jamaican scholar, choreographer dies in US at 76
UK model Katie Price weds cage-fighter boyfriend
Haiti charity single reworks REM's 'Everybody Hurts'
List of top 15 cable shows in Nielsen ratings
Worst movies of all time led by Clooney's "Batman"
Hamas wants talks with US, Europe: Haniya
Ukraine candidate accuses rival of 'swimming in mud'
Bomb in Pakistan kills 3 U.S. soldiers, 3 children
|
Google, NSA may team up over cyberattacks: report
Fury heats up after new AIG bonuses
Samsung aims to treble smartphone sales in 2010
Pakistani scientist guilty in US servicemen attacks
Inspectors 'failed to check runway' before Concorde crash
In new term, Bernanke calls for Fed to stay independent
Netezza teams up with NEC to battle Oracle
Netanyahu hopes for talks with Palestinians in weeks
New technique helps search for another Earth
Iran leader's nuclear comments surprise West
Video game makers look for 2010 turnaround
Kremlin body proposes radical makeover for Russia
Monster gobbles HotJobs for 225 million dollars
Netanyahu: Peace talks could resume in weeks
Afghans want to be farmers, not fighters, says U.S.
|
Cisco quarterly profit up 23 percent
Israel pushing Middle East to war: Syria's Assad
|
Iraq court lifts ban on hundreds of candidates
RIM device development holds promise, analyst says
Mideast peace talks will resume in 'coming weeks': Netanyahu
Oracle database can be hacked remotely: researcher
2009 videogame sales dip eight percent in Britain, Japan, US
Iran says it launches satellite rocket
Iran sends rocket with animal menagerie into space
Samsung aims to treble smartphone sales in 2010
Samsung aims to treble smartphone sales in 2010
|
Hong Kong tycoons' wealth soars: Forbes
Google, NSA may team up over cyberattacks: report
|
Lurid testimony at Anwar trial closed to public
Video game makers look for 2010 turnaround
|
Netezza teams up with NEC to battle Oracle
|
1 year on, China stays silent on missing lawyer
RIM device development holds promise, analyst says
|
N.Korea eases curbs on markets amid anger: Seoul
Obama nears end of Uighur Guantanamo nightmare
Philanthropist Evelyn Haas dies at age 92
Pa. woman convicted in pierced kittens case
Men at Work ripped off 'Kookaburra' riff: Aus court
Australia blocks Iran shipments over weapons fears: PM
Hollywood studios lose landmark Internet download battle
Gunman kills self in Ill. store, no others injured
Obama vows to get tougher on China trade
Motivational speaker charged in sweat lodge deaths
2 charged with Indonesia maid's murder in Malaysia
Prius brakes questioned; Toyota probe expands
'Bling ring' burglar says not guilty of LA thefts
Senate report: 'Dirty money' still entering US
Brown getting Kennedy's seat, but not his desk
Toyota posts $1.7B profit, raises annual forecast
Seoul shares rise on autos; banks, retailers fall
GM says China sales nearly double in January
Oscar contenders vie for underdog status
|
AA gives high flyers helicopter ride to Narita
Lady Antebellum set to crush Lil Wayne on U.S. chart
|
SKorean, US firms embroiled in chip espionage case
Who can afford Howard Stern?
|
Jay-Z sues lender over loan for NYC property
|
Lady Antebellum set to crush Lil Wayne on U.S. chart
PAKISTAN
Hollywood loses landmark copyright case in Australia
|
Report: China investing $956M with UK's Apax
Balloon flown over highest peak in the Americas
S.Korea firm wins three billion dollar Iraq deal
Seoul shares turn down on banks; autos advance
HBO renews Big Love for fifth season
|
Obama vows to get tougher on China trade
Who can afford Howard Stern?
R&B singer Jill Scott sued by record label
|
Source: Jackson's doc to be arraigned Friday
Oscar contenders vie for underdog status
Scattered Palestinian protests reflect a fractured struggle
Stewart tells O'Reilly he's voice of sanity on Fox
Israeli Oscar nominee "Ajami" admirable, but dark
HBO renews "Big Love" for fifth season
Giacometti sculpture smashes auction world record: Sotheby's
Pakistan arrests 30 suspects in U.S. forces attack
|
Ukraine's Tymoshenko street protests
US teen blogging nosedives
New scan 'reads mind' of brain-damaged patient
Discussing Iran sanctions hinders diplomacy: China
|
Foreign food aid trickles into Haiti's black market
|
Assad will lose power if Syria goes to war: Israel
Shell fourth-quarter profit dives 75%
IMF chief says may quit early; eyes French politics?
|
Israel mulls indirect talks with Palestinians
Hopes rise for N.Ireland solution as leader returns
India offers official talks with Pakistan
|
New US export strategy eyes Asia
Iraq condemns lifting candidate ban, MPs to meet
|
Exclave's 10,000-strong protest rocks Russian politics
|
Israel envisages indirect talks with Palestinians
|
New Iraqi media rules raise specter of muzzled past
|
Threat of new Orange protests raises Ukraine tension
|
Obama aunt due in court over Kenya deportation: report
Cops: NY driver used mannequin in car pool lane
Suu Kyi, brother in court over house dispute
Trump annoyed with park weddings next to golf club
NKorea eases market crackdown amid economic woes
70-year-old jailed after crashing into Nev. casino
Thai plan to return Karen to Myanmar draws protest
Stakes high for Calif. in health care reform
Lurid evidence in Malaysia opposition leader trial
Family of Pakistan scientist slam US guilty verdict
Indonesian Muslim leaders slam horror movie
Mass. certifies GOP's Brown as Kennedy successor
Security bloc considers adding Iran, Pakistan
Obama begins full day at National Prayer Breakfast
Pakistan arrests 30 suspects in U.S. forces attack
Sumo's 'bad boy' Asashoryu to retire
House faces tough vote on $1.9 trillion more debt
2 gangsters sentenced to death in China
Discussing Iran sanctions hinders diplomacy
SKorean, US firms embroiled in chip espionage case
Sony quarterly profit surges to $861 million
Pakistani o/n rates up; rupee eases; stocks higher
China launches WTO complaint against EU shoe levy
Debt-laden Dubai says new off-shore oil field found
Toyota weighs on Tokyo stocks
Hollywood loses key battle over illegal downloads
Hollywood loses landmark copyright case in Australia
HSBC to open in S.Lanka former war zone
Sony books $870mln quarterly profit
Japan's Hitachi back to profit in December quarter
China rejects Obama pressure over currency
New art auction record may not be end, say experts
|
Hollywood loses key battle over illegal downloads
T.O., Ochocinco start Super parties on South Beach
Web-based mystery romance lures indie producer
Web-based mystery romance lures indie producer
|
Sparks fly as Bollywood, cricket and politics collide
India's book restorers: saving the past for the future
Hollywood loses landmark copyright case in Australia
James Cameron hints at Avatar sequel
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights