InfoAnda - Insight: How HP's board presided over a train wreck |

Palestinian state-building drive threatened: U.N., IMF | | 15 September 2011

49-year-old female chimp dies at Toledo Zoo | 19 October 2009

Poet Reid surprise winner of Costa Book of the Year | 27 January 2010

Domestic Violence Charge Against Comedian Robert Schimmel Dropped | 23 May 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Insight: How HP's board presided over a train wreck |

Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Home Business Business Home Economy Technology Media Small Business Green Business Legal Deals Earnings Summits Business Video Markets Markets Home U.S. Markets European Markets Asian Markets Global Market Data Indices M&A Stocks Bonds Currencies Commodities Futures Funds peHUB World World Home U.S. Brazil China Euro Zone Japan Mexico Russia Afghan Journal Africa Journal India Insight Global News Journal Pakistan: Now or Never? World Video Politics Politics Home Front Row Washington Politics Video Technology Technology Home MediaFile Science Tech Video Opinion Opinion Home Chrystia Freeland Felix Salmon Jack Shafer Breakingviews George Chen Bernd Debusmann Gregg Easterbrook James Pethokoukis James Saft John Wasik Christopher Whalen Ian Bremmer Mohamed El-Erian Lawrence Summers The Great Debate Unstructured Finance Newsmaker MuniLand Money Money Home Analyst Research Global Investing MuniLand Reuters Money Alerts Watchlist Portfolio Stock Screener Fund Screener Personal Finance Video Life & Culture Health Sports Arts Faithworld Business Traveler Left Field Entertainment Oddly Enough Lifestyle Video Pictures Pictures Home Reuters Photographers Full Focus Video Article Comments (2) Slideshow Video Sub to voyage to bottom of the sea A Florida company is building a submersible craft made of glass to take visitors to the deepest part of the ocean, the Mariana Trench, nearly 6 miles below the surface. Video Internet diamond business rocks New fashion for online designer stores DNA to link bone fragments with 9/11 victims Follow Reuters Facebook Twitter RSS YouTube Read Particles found to break speed of light 3:26pm EDT HP named Whitman CEO, Apotheker out 4:31pm EDT Failed bill spotlights dysfunction in Congress | 4:49pm EDT UPDATE 1-Particles found to break speed of light 3:09pm EDT Market's 3 percent plunge suggests deepening worry | 4:32pm EDT Discussed 133 Obama to propose $3 trillion in deficit cuts 79 Geithner’s ”succinct” message irks Europeans 72 House unexpectedly defeats spending bill Watched World Bank's Zoellick: "The world is in a danger zone" 11:43am EDT Human skin strengthened with spider silk can stop a bullet Tue, Sep 20 2011 Scarlett's naked pics, Tyler Perry is highest paid Wed, Sep 14 2011 Insight: How HP's board presided over a train wreck Tweet Share this Email Print Related News Is HP competing for "worst board ever" honors? 9:47am EDT HP may oust CEO, hire eBay veteran: source Wed, Sep 21 2011 Wall Street sinks 3 percent after Fed cites economic "risks" Wed, Sep 21 2011 UPDATE 4-HP's board may oust CEO, hire eBay vet -source Wed, Sep 21 2011 UBS chief confident of board support despite trading loss Wed, Sep 21 2011 Analysis & Opinion Counterparties Federal judge gives shareholders green light for say-on-pay suit Related Topics Technology » Hot Stocks » Asian Markets » 1 of 3. Leo Apotheker, CEO of Hewlett-Packard, speaks at a media event in Beijing in this June 29, 2011 file photo. Credit: Reuters/China Daily/Files By Poornima Gupta and Peter Henderson SAN FRANCISCO | Thu Sep 22, 2011 1:36pm EDT SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - To fire one CEO, or even two, may be regarded as misfortune; to fire three looks like carelessness. When Hewlett-Packard Co named Leo Apotheker as its chief executive last year, the majority of the board that hired him had not even met the German executive. That HP's board would appoint a CEO without insisting on an in-person interview with all directors is just one example of what critics say is a pattern of dysfunction behind the meltdown of the technology giant, which traces its roots to the beginning of Silicon Valley itself. The board is expected to name former eBay Inc CEO Meg Whitman to replace Apotheker later on Thursday. It's easy to blame Apotheker, who has cut financial forecasts for three straight quarters, U-turned on key aspects of HP's strategic roadmap, and failed to stem a nearly 50 percent plunge in the company's stock price. But HP's problems go back much further than Apotheker's 11-month tenure. Interviews with insiders, former executives and experts paint a picture of an ever-changing roster of board directors who lacked a good grasp of the company's fundamentals and vacillated over what its business should be. Not only did the full board not meet Apotheker before he was hired, many directors also did not interview Silicon Valley venture capitalist and former software executive Ray Lane, who became HP's chairman at the same time, according to a person familiar with the situation. The board left the interviews to a four-member search committee, the person said, and gave no indication that they understood the tremendous change in strategy it had put under way by choosing two software experts to head HP, the world's largest personal computer maker. Apotheker was previously CEO of German software company SAP AG, where he lasted seven months before resigning abruptly amid customer complaints over software support fee increases. "The company seems to have lost its way. It is sort of trying to commit suicide," said Tom Perkins, co-founder of venture fund Kleiner Perkins and a former HP board member who was also the one-time head of HP's research unit. "How did this happen? This is the fault of the board." The 14-member board will on Thursday wrap up a two-day meeting to try to correct some of its mistakes. It will decide whether to oust Apotheker and examine a host of other strategic issues, according to another source. If he goes, Apotheker would become the third CEO in a row to be ousted at HP. His predecessor Mark Hurd left in scandal after a female contractor accused him of sexual harassment and a board-commissioned investigation found discrepancies in his expense reports. Before Hurd, Carly Fiorina was fired in 2005 in a spat with the board over how to run the company. Then there was Patricia Dunn, chairman of HP before Hurd. She left after facing a criminal probe into authorizing private investigators to impersonate directors and reporters in an investigation into boardroom leaks. Perkins resigned in 2006 over that scandal. "I was trying to think of another company that had tripped up that often in this many years and I found it impossible to come up with another example," said Paul Hodgson, senior research associate at corporate governance advisers GovernanceMetrics International. Hodgson and other experts did point to the many new faces the board has seen, a revolving door that means only four of the 14 directors joined before 2009. Six new directors joined this year alone. While fresh faces can turn around a company in trouble, in this case the board turnover may have contributed to the problems. Institutional knowledge rests primarily with Ann Livermore, who was relieved of her executive duties by Apotheker and promoted to the board after she was passed over for the CEO job. Now she is deliberating the future of the man who beat her. WHO TO BLAME? HP's problems started to brew during the tumultuous reign of Fiorina, but the real flare-up came with Hurd's departure. A buttoned down, numbers-oriented executive known for his financial rigor, Hurd mostly kept directors insulated from the operational complexities of the day-to-day running of the hardware company, sources said. He reinvigorated HP to become the largest tech company by revenue after Fiorina's departure, and he was much favored by the board prior to the eruption of the sexual harassment allegation, even though some members were cowed by his hard edge, the sources said. The messy public brawl in the wake of Hurd's departure last year set the tone of HP coverage for months. Critics of Hurd say he is also to blame for HP's trouble today, arguing that R&D budget cuts stifled innovation. Chairman Lane told Reuters in July that Hurd "burned the furniture to please Wall Street." While cost-cutting and streamlining HP's massive operations made Hurd popular with investors, Hurd also presided over some major acquisitions including 3COM for $2.7 billion and Palm for $1.2 billion. In the ensuing chaos during and after Hurd's departure, Silicon Valley heavyweight Marc Andreessen emerged as a key influential voice on the board, sources said. The board believed HP was in good shape financially and needed an executive who would keep the company running efficiently but bulk up its software business, they said. Enter Apotheker, who was deemed to have the best resume among a three finalists, and Lane, whose candidacy for the chairman role also came through the same recruiting channels used for the CEO search. The search committee of four directors Andreessen, Lawrence Babbio Jr., John Hammergren and Joel Hyatt, focused on finding a CEO and a chairman who could expand HP into new growing markets and beefing up areas where it was weak, like software. Internal candidates were passed over, deemed not ready for the task. STRATEGIC SHIFTS The board rarely understood the strategic implications of the decisions it was constantly asked to make, sources said, adding that some members seemed to go along without much involvement. "There were pockets of smart people asking smart questions. There were pockets of extremely dysfunctional behavior," said one former executive. "There were only a few board members who would get into details." In retrospect the hiring of Apotheker and Lane seemed like a major strategic shift by a board making a calculated bet. While Apotheker began to learn the company he was running, Lane presided over the exit of four directors after discussions with the board on what the chairman called "looking forward" after the "incredible decision to terminate its CEO." Joel Hyatt, John Joyce, Robert Ryan, and Lucille Salhany stepped down voluntarily, Lane said at that time, adding that Hurd's departure had no impact on the decision. But both Hyatt and Joyce were seen as staunch supporters of Hurd during the crisis, and Ryan and Salhany were in charge of the investigation into the sexual harassment allegation against Hurd, which vindicated him, sources said. Whitman and three others joined the board, but failed to stem the flow of bad news or concoct a clear strategy. The board is now considering appointing Whitman interim CEO. "Our conversations with shareholders and investors over the past month revealed a level of exasperation that we have not seen directed at HP or any other company in our universe in our 13 years following the sector," Toni Sacconaghi, an analyst with Sanford Bernstein, wrote in a note published on Thursday. "The potential sudden removal of Apotheker as CEO - and the fact that such Board discussions were once again leaked to the press - are likely to further undermine the Board's already fragile credibility." BUNGLES CONTINUE In recent months, HP has launched, killed, and then decided to bring back its TouchPad tablet. It also said it was considering spinning off the personal computer business - then followed by saying it may also consider keeping it. And after facing criticism that it paid too much for a data storage company called 3PAR, HP decided to pay nearly $12 billion to buy software firm Autonomy, a 60 percent premium over its average stock price the previous month. "The board was a big part of this," another person familiar with the situation said, referring to the software deal. As for the PC business? "They are trying to figure out whether they should or shouldn't. Leo said that himself - maybe they do, maybe they don't," that person said. Recently, Lane abandoned his effort to keep the board quiet and in the background. Last week, he took the CEO's place at an industry conference to defend HP's change in strategy and try to clear the confusion that followed in the market. So far it hasn't worked. Whatever vision it has, the board has not communicated it. HP has declined so far to address Wednesday's reports that its board was considering replacing Apotheker. The company also had no immediate comment when contacted by Reuters for this story. Emails to Lane were not returned. Hurd declined through a representative to comment, as did Fiorina. "Part of the problem here is communication. No one knows anything (among investors)," the person familiar with the Autonomy situation said. The announcement of Apotheker's hiring last year gave no clue to what strategy would be. His speech in March didn't help: the CEO explained that HP was moving into 'the cloud,' which means basing computing services on the Web. Many senior-level executives did not see the path to achieving that goal. COMMUNICATIONS MELTDOWN During his first few months at HP, Apotheker was more interested in holding long-term strategic conversations with his management team and preferred to leave the intricacies of running HP's various businesses and the financials behind them to other executives, one of the sources said. Communication was another issue. "It seems as though everything is being done a little bit on the seat of their pants," said the former HP executive. The most telling example of a communications bungle - before Wednesday - was on August 18. In a rapid-fire series of announcements, HP disclosed acquisition talks with Autonomy; confirmed a deal had been done; said it was considering spinning off its PC business; announced quarterly results that missed forecasts; and said it was killing the TouchPad. The day after the series of announcements, HP shares nose-dived 20 percent, wiping out $16 billion of value in the worst single-day fall since the Black Monday stock market crash of October 1987. "There are boards out there that have made mistakes but they've generally learned from them, eventually. Maybe replacing the board all the time is not the thing to do," said Hodgson of GovernanceMetrics International. He said he would have expected a board of such caliber to avoid so many mistakes. "It doesn't seem to be the case, and it's difficult to come up with an explanation," he said. (Reporting by Poornima Gupta and Peter Henderson in San Francisco, additional reporting by Ben Berkowitz in New York, editing by Tiffany Wu and Claudia Parsons) Technology Hot Stocks Asian Markets Related Quotes and News Company Price Related News Tweet this Link this Share this Digg this Email Reprints We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/ Comments (2) KingofChina wrote: So they hired Whitman? The value of eBay stock has been flat for 5 years thanks to her. She physically assaulted an eBay employee several years back and they paid big bucks to pay the victim off. You call this a good choice? Sep 22, 2011 3:41pm EDT -- Report as abuse 3dayscondor wrote: HP is making another very poor decision by naming Meg Whitman as CEO. She has no experience in running a large technology computer company. Her inadequate management skills were displayed in her failed attempt to become governor. HP board of directors are making disastrous decision that will damage the company. A real sad group of characters. Sep 22, 2011 4:07pm EDT -- Report as abuse See All Comments » Add Your Comment Social Stream (What's this?) Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Back to top Reuters.com Business Markets World Politics Technology Opinion Money Pictures Videos Site Index Legal Bankruptcy Law California Legal New York Legal Securities Law Support & Contact Contact Us Advertise With Us Connect with Reuters Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS Podcast Newsletters Mobile About Privacy Policy Terms of Use Our Flagship financial information platform incorporating Reuters Insider An ultra-low latency infrastructure for electronic trading and data distribution A connected approach to governance, risk and compliance Our next generation legal research platform Our global tax workstation Thomsonreuters.com About Thomson Reuters Investor Relations Careers Contact Us Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Friday, 23 September 2011
Iran's Ahmadinejad attacks West, prompts walk-out |
Struggling Braves barely holding off Cards for NL Wild Card
Season 14 of The Ultimate Fighter opens with 16 fierce preliminary bouts
Radio journalist shot, seriously wounded in Somalia
FDA to phase out over-the-counter asthma inhalers to protect the environment
77 Year old Ukrainian man wins dumpling eating contest then promptly dies
Analysis: U.N. move may help establish Palestinian legal rights |
Mexican president promotes tourism while drug cartel killings continue
Military suicides linked to low levels of Omega-3 fats
Shortest commute in Great Falls, Montana
U.S. stocks tumble on recession news
First time jobless claims drop to 423,000
Bomb at Iraqi pilgrim restaurant kills 4, wounds 17 |
Facebook builds tighter integration with music, TV |
Competitors circle around as Netflix stumbles |
Text, video messaging eyed for emergency calls |
Insight: How HP's board presided over a train wreck |
Clearwire talks capacity with AT&T, Verizon, others |
Silicon Valley flop Color tries to reinvent itself |
Amazon web services puts snag behind it, sees more cloud |
London Olympics to 'strain' mobile networks-mayor |
Americans prefer Modern Family to X Factor |
Jay-Z protege J. Cole preps for music spotlight |
Wizard of Oz ruby slippers up for auction |
Tony Bennett apologizes for 9/11 comments |
Abbas to stake Palestinian claim to state at U.N. |
As sparks fly, Pakistan warns U.S. You will lose an ally |
Frosh choice: Ohio State to start Braxton Miller behind center
President Saleh returns to Yemen amid gunfire, blasts |
Woman fined for wearing face veil to run for president against Sarkozy
Physicists find sub-atomic particles travel faster than light
Triple car bomb explosions kill 6, wound 60 in Russian Dagestan
At least 11 more bodies dumped in Mexican port city |
St. Louis Blues: Mets dispatch Cardinals with ninth inning rally
Fever star Tamika Catchings finally nets WNBA MVP honor
Qantas airlines faces Friday Strike
Libya NTC faces credibility test at Gaddafi strongholds |
Liam the leader: Liam Bond shoots 66 at Austrian Open
PGA rerun: Keegan Bradley, Jason Dufner, one-two at Tour Championship
Zambia's Sata wins presidential race |
At least 13 different countries to be represented at upcoming World Series of Bowling
Chavez in Venezuela says chemo finished successfully |
Thousands riot in south China over land grabs: report |
Sectarian tensions rise in Syria's Homs, 2 killed |
Oracle seeks $1.16 billion from Google in Android case |
Suspected LulzSec hacker arrested in Sony studio breach |
Facebook builds tighter integration with music, TV |
HP names Whitman CEO, Apotheker out |
Alibaba.com shares jump 5% on Silver Lake, DST investment |
Rambus faithful set up verdict vigil |
Competitors circle around as Netflix stumbles |
Lawmakers tell FCC to protect GPS from Falcone |
ZTE plans to roll out 4G handphones in Q2 2012 |
Disgraced pastor Ted Haggard to appear in Wife Swap |
Kiefer Sutherland returns to TV in Fox's Touch |
Bruno Mars' song on Breaking Dawn soundtrack |
British arts world wades into row over Israeli orchestra |
U.S. turns up the heat on Pakistan's spy agency |
Greece says not seeking new way out of crisis |
Amid global outcry, Europeans express dismay at the execution of Troy Davis
Soap Opera "All My Children" ends after 41 year run
Prosecutors show crime scene photos as Knox trial resumes |
Undz.org men underwear sold 100,000 underwear in 3 months!
UK lawyer to start News Corp action in U.S. |
Hooters photog: It's a great job and someone's got to it
Mike Vick full participant at Eagles practice; may play Sunday vs. Giants
Nike sees profits soar
Efforts to reduce child labor on cocoa plantations beginning to pay off
Better food key to malnutrition and obesity
Bahrain police block protest march to capital |
Canadian mom sues sons for financial support
CERN scientists claim to break speed of light
Insight: Haqqani chief says U.S. will suffer if it tries attack |
Alibaba.com boosted by private equity investment |
Nokia more confident on Windows Phone this year |
Bluetooth devices security risks rising: research |
Oracle seeks $1.16 billion from Google in Android case |
Taylor Lautner talks about his newest 'Abduction' |
Elton John in talks to make biopic Rocketman |
Baby rockers land the right punches on debut album |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01