InfoAnda - Alison Frankel: Fly ruling is not a free pass for aggregators |

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

Ben Silverman's Electus unveils shows, one for MTV | | 13 April 2010
High-tech cheaters jailed in China | Technology | | 4 April 2009
Wright, Burnett join forces for CBS drama | 29 September 2009

UN chief visits Sri Lankan war refugees | 24 May 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Alison Frankel: Fly ruling is not a free pass for aggregators |

Edition: U.S. Article Comments (0) Follow Reuters Facebook Twitter RSS YouTube Read Inmate in jail with Anthony lost child to drowning 1:33am EDT Israel asks Apple to remove intifada phone app 21 Jun 2011 Roger Ebert defends Tweet about "Jackass" star 21 Jun 2011 UPDATE 1-LulzSec's ambition grows, targets secret govt data 21 Jun 2011 California lawmakers denied pay until budget resolved 21 Jun 2011 Discussed 48 Weiner tells friends he will resign: NY Times 48 IMF cuts U.S. growth forecast, warns of crisis 46 Ron Paul wins 2012 Republican straw poll in New Orleans Watched Hefner's revenge; Ryan Reynolds stops traffic Fri, Jun 17 2011 Airbus A380 damaged at Paris Air Show Mon, Jun 20 2011 Grim cigarette labels aim to curb smoking Mon, Jun 20 2011 Alison Frankel: Fly ruling is not a free pass for aggregators Tweet Share this Email Print Related News Wal-Mart wins Supreme Court sex-bias ruling Mon, Jun 20 2011 Wall Street loses appeal on "hot news" lawsuit Mon, Jun 20 2011 UPDATE 5-Wall St loses appeal on 'hot news' lawsuit Mon, Jun 20 2011 Dow, S&P end sixth losing week - is seventh on tap? Fri, Jun 10 2011 Analysis & Opinion The Bank of Japan’s ill-advised “1% rule” How Oracle told the world it wants billions from Google Related Topics Technology » Media » A worker carries out maintenance in a branch of Barclays bank in central London February 15, 2011. Credit: Reuters/Paul Hackett By Alison Frankel NEW YORK | Tue Jun 21, 2011 5:20pm EDT NEW YORK (Reuters) - On its face, Monday's ruling by the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Barclays v. Theflyonthewall.com seems like a win for the folks who republish the news. The Second Circuit, in an 88-page ruling, found that a financial news website called Theflyonthewall.com had not engaged in "hot news" misappropriation when it ran headlines about stock recommendations by Barclays, Bank of America's Merrill Lynch unit, and Morgan Stanley. (The rarely-invoked hot news doctrine provides copyright holders a cause of action outside of copyright law.) As Jonathan Stempel reported for Reuters, that's undoubtedly a loss for the banks and their lawyers at Weil, Gotshal & Manges, who had won a lower-court injunction by arguing that the banks were losing trading commissions as a result of Fly's misappropriation. The ruling is great news for Fly, which no longer has to fear a bar on its reporting of analyst recommendations, and for Fly's longtime counsel, Glenn Ostrager of Ostrager Chong Flaherty & Broitman. Google and Twitter also claimed victory. The companies had supported Fly with a joint amicus brief, and their lawyer, Kathleen Sullivan of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan told The New York Times that the Second Circuit's ruling "acknowledges the reality of new media," she said. "It's a great decision for the free flow of information in the new media age." Perhaps. But the Second Circuit's decision is certainly not a free pass for aggregators to appropriate headlines and blurbs from journalism companies without fear of liability for misappropriation. The Second Circuit opinion leaves the hot news doctrine in place. And, more importantly, it pays great heed to the craft of reporting and breaking news -- which is exactly what you'd expect in a decision written by Judge Robert Sack, a onetime media lawyer who represented Dow Jones and Times Mirror when he was in private practice at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher. The majority opinion draws a distinction between making news and breaking it. When a bank issues a stock recommendation, the Second Circuit found, the fact of that recommendation is news. Theflyonthewall.com doesn't have the right to republish the underlying analysis that led to the recommendation; Fly actually conceded copyright infringement for cribbing from analysts' reports before the case reached the Second Circuit. But according to the Second Circuit, Fly has the right to uncover and report on the fact that a bank has issued a stock recommendation, even if Fly's reporting means the bank loses commission revenue. " is collecting, collating, and disseminating factual information -- that facts that firms and others in the securities business have made recommendations with respect the value of and the wisdom of purchasing or selling securities -- and attributing the information to its source," Judge Sack wrote. "The firms are making the news; Fly, despite the firms' understandable desire to protect their business model, is breaking it." The appellate panel credited Fly with working hard to find out about the stock recommendations, not simply "free-riding" on the work done by the banks. "Approximately half of Fly's 28 employees are involved the collection of the firms' recommendations and production of the newsfeed on which the summaries of the recommendations are posted," the opinion said. "Fly is reporting the financial news -- factual information on the firms' recommendations -- through a substantial organizational effort." The same principle guided the 1997 Second Circuit panel that established a test for hot news liability in NBA v. Motorola, in which the appeals court determined that Motorola's basketball score-reporting service didn't violate the NBA's rights to information about its games. Manhattan federal district court judge Denise Cote applied the five-prong NBA test in deciding the Fly case in the trial court, finding (among other things) that Fly was free-riding on the banks' work, in direct competition with them. In her appellate court minority opinion, Judge Reena Raggi found that Fly doesn't compete directly with the banks, so it's not liable for hot news misappropriation under the NBA test. In the majority opinion, Sack engaged in some confusing discussion of the NBA test and ended up concluding that the five-part test isn't established law. That might appear to be a benefit to news aggregators, except that the majority's analysis of the Fly facts hews very closely to the NBA court's examination of free-riding (which, in turn, built upon a 1918 U.S. Supreme Court decision called International News Service v. Associated Press, in which INS illegally cribbed AP headlines and passed them off as its own). The appellate court's ultimate finding is that Fly engaged in its own reporting to find out about the banks' recommendations. It didn't simply capitalize on the banks' work. OTC talked Tuesday with the lawyer who won the NBA case -- and also represented a group of 13 media companies appearing as amici in the Fly appeal. Andrew Deutsch of DLA Piper said the Second Circuit ruling won't put a crimp in news organizations' rights when it comes to suing Internet operations that crib their headlines. "Hot news remains available," he said. "I don't think this case affects the rights of original news gatherers to bring claims against aggregators ... says Fly is a reporter, and the hot news doctrine protects reporters." The Second Circuit's apparent repudiation of the test for hot news liability, Deutsch added, is "interesting to lawyers," but not really important in light of the court's free-riding analysis. "The classic hot news scenario hasn't changed a bit," he said. (On The Case called and e-mailed Google counsel Sullivan of Quinn Emanuel but didn't hear back.) So why haven't any news organizations like those Deutsch represents gone after aggregators for hot-news misappropriation? Deutsch said there have been threats of such suits, but they've been averted when aggregators (including Google, in a dispute with a French news service) agreed to take out licenses to the news organization's content. "There's still never been a case in which a real aggregator was sued for hot news misappropriation," Deutsch said. "But in my view, it's entirely possible." -- Alison Frankel blogs for Thomson Reuters News & Insight (newsandinsight.com). The views that she expresses are her own. -- (Reporting by Alison Frankel; Editing by Eileen Daspin) Technology Media Related Quotes and News Company Price Related News Tweet this Link this Share this Digg this Email Reprints We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/ Comments (0) Be the first to comment on reuters.com. Add yours using the box above. Social Stream (What's this?) © Copyright 2011 Thomson Reuters Editorial Editions: Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom United States Reuters Contact Us Advertise With Us Help Journalism Handbook Archive Site Index Video Index Reader Feedback Mobile Newsletters RSS Podcasts Widgets Your View Analyst Research Thomson Reuters Copyright Disclaimer Privacy Professional Products Professional Products Support Financial Products About Thomson Reuters Careers Online Products Acquisitions Monthly Buyouts Venture Capital Journal International Financing Review Project Finance International PEhub.com PE Week FindLaw Super Lawyers Attorney Rating Service Reuters on Facebook Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Wednesday, 22 June 2011
Metra train hits, kills 2 men in Chicago
Pakistani militants plant bomb on schoolgirl for suicide mission
Nick Lachey, Vanessa Minnillo to televise wedding
Gannett to lay off 700 employees
Israel's Netanyahu reaches out to Turkey: official |
Rory McIlroy: what's next for the U.S. Open champion?
Gaddafi, Italy blast NATO over deadly air strike
FDA unveils new cigarette packaging labels
Iran says U.S. hikers to be tried on July 31: lawyer |
Bangladesh turns around from secularism to Islamic constitution
U.N. assembly approves second term for U.N. chief Ban |
Italy launches anti-fraud crackdown against Chinese businesses in Prato
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood expels presidential hopeful |
Scotland Yard arrests British teen hacker
Analysis: New Internet rules will spawn battle for dots |
New round of cyber attacks heightens focus on FBI |
UK teenager arrested in global hacking probe |
Israel asks Apple to remove intifada phone app |
Micron, Hynix say Rambus played dirty in PC chips |
Gaddafi rockets dent sense of security in Misrata |
Sectarian violence erupts for second night in Northern Ireland |
India and Pakistan aim to nudge peace process forward |
Mexico captures La Familia drug boss |
Russian plane crash toll rises to 45 with boy's death |
WNBA: Zellous drops season-best 19 points as Fever burn Mystics
Pakistani support for military action against militants drops: poll |
James Blunt Upsets Fans...and Isn't Apologizing
Japan seeks to extend parliament, PM clings to post |
Greek PM Papandreou survives confidence vote
JPMorgan agrees to pay $153.6 million settlement in fraud case
LPGA Championship starts run of three majors in six weeks
Ford to expand in-vehicle smartphone connectivity |
President Obama to address the nation on Wednesday regarding Afghanistan troop withdrawl
Bowling ball manufacturers battle for bragging rights in June 25 event
Struggling Nokia revamps ops, reels in Navteq |
Japan, U.S. reset relocation deadline for Okinawa air base, troops
AT&T eyes Q1 2012 approval for T-Mobile merger |
Tracy Morgan apologizes to Kevin Rogers and Gay Community
Senate Hearing Witnesses Urge Quick Action on Cybersecurity
Yahoo, Alibaba, Softbank say making progress on resolving Alipay |
RIM jumps on job cut reports, takeover talk |
Australia unveils cybercrime laws to combat global threat |
Adobe sees weakness in Europe, shares dip |
Alison Frankel: Fly ruling is not a free pass for aggregators |
Roger Ebert defends Tweet about Jackass star |
Producer linked to Tupac attack faces drug charges |
Aretha Franklin fractures toe but continues tour |
U.S. official in Sanaa, al-Qaeda militants flee prison |
Bahrain opposition figures handed life sent |
Postal Service stops pension fund payments
Analysis: Lebanon's Hezbollah may fight Israel to relieve Syria |
Bangladesh: Food prices up; poverty down
Syria scorns EU criticism, says it sows chaos |
Resurgent Twins knock out Bumgarner with eight-run first inning, crush Giants
Versace teams up with H&M for affordable collection
Five million Pakistanis at risk from floods, says U.N. |
Four dead, dozens hurt in attacks on Iraqi police |
Tar Heels receive Notice of Allegations from NCAA; nine major violations possible
China frees dissident artist Ai Weiwei: report |
Sacramento woman arrested for microwaving baby to death
Britney Spears fights off "Terminator" paparazzi, references "Thriller" in new video
Special Report: Europe's other crisis |
Virgin Atlantic pilots vote to strike over lack of pay increase
Agreement near? NFL, players to meet in Boston area Wednesday
Muslim Brotherhood walks democratic path with caution
Samsung won't get peek at unreleased iPhone: ruling |
Apple plans faster iPhone for September: report |
Hulu weighs sale options after approach: source |
China says no cyber warfare between it, U.S. |
Brazil government latest victim of hacker attack |
Shazam raises $32 million to expand music, TV services |
Isis plans mobile payments launch in Austin |
China frees dissident artist Ai Weiwei: report |
Rowling set to unveil new Harry Potter venture |
Clooney political drama to open Venice film festival |
U2, Coldplay, Beyonce lead line-up at Glastonbury |
Galliano to tell trial he lost it on booze & drugs |
Just A Minute With: Woody Allen on nostalgia, scandal |
Roger Ebert defends Tweet about Jackass star |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph	VPN on MacOSX	BlogMeter 1.01