Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
'IMF' for Europe a distracting sideshow: experts
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Photos
Sitemap
'IMF' for Europe a distracting sideshow: experts
AFP - Wednesday, March 10
Send
IM Story
Print
A man looks at a poster showing the Slovak edition of the euro. Talk of a European version of the International Monetary Fund to rescue errant EU states is little more than a distracting sideshow, analysts and a key central banker say.
FRANKFURT (AFP) - – Talk of a European version of the International Monetary Fund to rescue errant EU states is little more than a distracting sideshow, analysts and a key central banker say.
Rather than creating new institutions, the European Union (EU) should make the present framework of its currency union more credible, German central bank chief Axel Weber said Tuesday.
"Any other discussion is a sideshow which will distract from the necessary [fiscal] consolidation," Weber told the central bank's annual press conference.
UniCredit chief economist Marco Annunziata was equally skeptical about the idea of a European Monetary Fund (EMF).
"An EMF would be nothing else than an admission of failure, an explicit recognition that not only the SGP (EU Stability and Growth Pact) cannot enforce fiscal discipline but also that the eurozone would be unable to design any new mechanism able to enforce fiscal discipline," he told AFP.
As the global economic slump deepened in 2008, Brussels temporarily eased fiscal rules to allow governments to spend more on support for their struggling economies.
The result was swollen public deficits, increased debt and countries including Greece in such dire straits that financial markets turned on them. That in turn threatened the cohesion and credibility of the entire eurozone.
Sound national finances -- a public deficit of less than three percent of gross domestic product and debt of less than 60 percent of GDP -- were set as the bedrock of the European project.
The current pact for curbing annual deficits and compounded debt levels for EU countries is widely seen as a failure: 20 out of 27 members have breached the deficit limits.
In Germany, Europe's biggest economy and a staunch defender of fiscal rectitude, leading politicians have floated the idea of an EMF.
Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble raised the idea of a new body in comments to a German Sunday newspaper, Welt am Sonntag.
Germany has consistently refused to give aid to Greece for fear of sending the wrong signal and encouraging laxity elsewhere.
And on Tuesday German Chancellor Angela Merkel stressed that EMF plans would only work if strengthened "sanctions" were included to penalise wayward spenders.
"There must be sanctions," she said of plans due to be outlined to the European Commission by the EU's economic and monetary affairs commissioner Olli Rehn in Strasbourg, France.
According to German media reports, Berlin envisages the enforced suspension of European financial aid as well as the withdrawal of EU decision-making voting rights.
Merkel said plans for an EMF were being formulated to combat "situations of last resort." They should not be perceived as an instrument that weakened the existing framework, she said.
Royal Bank of Scotland senior European economist Nick Matthews said the European Monetary Union "is at a crossroads, its sustainability will be a function of how fiscal policies are coordinated in the future."
But some analysts have forecast that tighter rules would involve intrusive oversight of countries' fiscal management and strict sanctions, two notions that have been strongly resisted in the past.
"There seems to be no other option than removing fiscal sovereignty of member countries," Matthews warned.
"The idea of an EMF should be seen in this context, i.e., as part of a set of ideas currently being discussed to reform EMU institutions," he added.
The EMF idea goes to the heart of how the eurozone will develop, given efforts by some to make current rules tighter. Others however want politicians to have more influence over monetary policy.
Some economists underscore the danger of allowing EU states to draw comfort from the idea that they can get help in a crisis.
"It would create severe moral hazard," by relieving pressure on governments because they would count on aid from peers if trouble arose, Barclays Capital economist Thorsten Polleit told AFP.
Polleit also felt it would fuel inflation because the money would come from more government bond issues, which the ECB would be pressured to underwrite at least indirectly by printing more money.
Annunziata said an EMF would simply reproduce the IMF mechanism "under a new acronym - and it would need to be funded, whereas the IMF already is.
"Definitely a step backwards, not forward," he concluded.
But Deutsche Bank counterpart Gilles Moec said the idea "would go much further than the SGP in creating credible incentives for fiscal discipline."
Moec said an EMF would require countries with large deficits and debt to pay more into the fund. Beneficiaries would have to meet tough conditions, just as borrowers from the IMF have to, he added.
The proposal was first floated by Deutsche Bank's chief economist Thomas Mayer and another economist, Daniel Gros.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
News Search
Top Stories
'IMF' for Europe a distracting sideshow: experts
Greek PM: Obama 'positive' on speculator battle
Researchers back cancer-fighting properties of papaya
WHO unveils landmark anti-malaria measures
Greece heads for further general strike
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
N.Korea says ready for dialogue and war with US
World's biggest oil trader ends supplies to Iran: company
Chile quake moved entire city 3 meters to west: study
Researchers back cancer-fighting properties of papaya
HIV among newborns could be 'eradicated by 2015'
More Most Viewed »
Chile quake moved Earth's axis, shortened days: scientist
Experts confirm asteroid wiped out the dinosaurs
Florida killer whale to stay in park after deadly attack
Common weed-killer chemically castrates frogs: study
Australia police search anti-whaler ship at Japan request
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 10 March 2010 Israel okays settlement homes as Mideast talks resume
Seven held in Ireland over Swedish cartoonist 'plot': police
Dell cuts 10 percent of staff at Taiwan R&D centre: report
Baghdad holds key as Iraq awaits initial vote results
Cisco unveils system for super-fast Internet
Kenyan-flagged fishing boat hijacked off Somalia
Clinton says elections key to Haiti stability
|
WHO unveils landmark anti-malaria measures
U.S. considers some free wireless broadband service
Princess Caroline's German husband fined for assault
Two NATO soldiers killed in eastern Afghanistan
|
Greece heads for further general strike
Cindy Crawford blackmailer jailed in Germany
Vatican says wrong to single out Church over abuse
|
Crash Victim: God Sent Angels To Rescue Me
Greek public, private sector clash over austerity
|
Microsoft Researcher Wins Prestigious Computing Award
Dick's Sporting Goods Swings To Q4 Profit, Tops Estimates
U.S. apologizes to Libya for dismissive comments
|
OK Go Announce Spring Tour Dates
U.S. Airlines Improve On-Time Performance In January
Correspondents Share Close Encounters Of War Kind
Oklahoma Twister Destroys 5 Houses, Downs Power Lines
Edgar Wayburn, Conservationist, Dies At 103
Family of slain U.S. activist sues Israel
|
Hawaiians Unharmed After Jolt By 4.4-Magnitude Quake
N.Ireland backs transfer of key powers despite row
Survey: Only 16 Percent Of Americans Confident In Ability To Retire
Bangladesh urged to repair destroyed embankments
Thailand imposes tough security law for Thaksin protests
Gates walks town that was a 'no-go zone' weeks ago
Skater's gaffe highlights politics of China sports
Russia urges Sweden to extradite Chechen bandits
|
China tries microblogging top political event
Japanese bug to wage war on weeds in Britain
China rejects reform calls but rhetoric softens
China endorses Copenhagen climate accord
China accuses Dalai Lama as Tibet anniversary looms
Belfast votes in favor of police, justice transfer
|
Japan lifts lid on Cold War nuclear pacts with US
Malaysia eyes growth in palm oil exports for 2010
India's Tata Motors shares slide on Daimler's exit
Officials: Bali bombing mastermind may be dead
Cisco says new router 12 times faster than rivals'
|
NFL signs mobile phone deal with Verizon Wireless
|
U.S. considers some free wireless broadband service
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Lindsay Lohan sues over "milkaholic" E*Trade ad
Russians face backlash in India's Goa
Power symbol wins NY condom design contest
Tobacco group's art collection fetches record price
Sony to roll out 3D TVs in Japan in June
A stitch in time while doing time in Britain
Shows with gays could lose Florida tax credit
NY seeks 'fat tax' on sodas to fight rising US obesity
Cliff Richard turns to jazz to mark 70th birthday
Accused Letterman extortionist pleads guilty
|
Israeli general says "all options" needed on Iran
UK PM Brown warns of bumpy economic road ahead
|
"Logorama" duo take aim at "Ghost Recon" videogame
Snow snarls traffic, strands thousands in southern Europe
Biden condemns new Israel settlement plan
MySpace readies site overhaul to rekindle growth
UK's Miliband urges push for Afghan peace deal
|
U.S. raises concern about Iranian "dictatorship"
Freak snowfalls strand 6,000 on Franco-Spanish border
LG Elec launches Android-based smartphone
A third of world's jailed journalists in Iran
Bomber's death deals fresh blow to Indonesia militants
|
'IMF' for Europe a distracting sideshow: experts
U.S. weighing China Internet censorship case
Israeli general says all options needed on Iran
|
US lawmakers seek action on Internet freedom
Hackers target freshly uncovered Internet Explorer hole
Greek PM: Obama 'positive' on speculator battle
Belgian newspaper issues 3D edition
Researchers back cancer-fighting properties of papaya
Abu Dhabi is future base for News Corp: Murdoch
U.N. sees no security vacuum as U.S. troops exit Haiti
|
LG Elec launches Android-based smartphone
India's Congress faces turmoil over women's bill
|
U.S. kept Britain in dark over torture: ex spy chief
|
Obama Seeks More Small Business Loans for Low-Income Communities
Chinese group files complaint over faulty HP laptops
|
PETA Pulls High-Flying Stunt; Seahttp://newsbahn.com/?rm=edit;type=Article;id=10024265#World Pushes Back
MySpace readies site overhaul to rekindle growth
|
EPA Administrator Jackson Predicts Congress Passing Cap-Trade Bill
Cisco Unveils New Router, Said To Have Triple The Capacity
U.S. weighing China Internet censorship case
|
Hong Kong killer of Thai visitor gets life term
U.S. Markets Post Modest Gains Despite Sell Off In Commodity Stocks
St Jude Researchers Investigate Role Of Nutrition On Dengue Fever
Logorama duo take aim at Ghost Recon videogame
|
Report: NKorea to replace top diplomat in Geneva
Pennsylvania Woman Known As "Jihad Jane" Indicted On Terrorism Charges
Indonesian leader vows to hunt terrorists
Bride-To-Be Calls In Backup In Bridal Shop Dispute
'JihadJane' recruited for Europe, SAsia terror attacks: US
32 killed in series of road crashes in Philippines
Study Finds Abused Children Likely To Suffer Gastrointestinal Ailments
Clinton, Preval urge quick Haiti elections
Bali bombing suspect killed: Indonesia president
Woman Survives Gator Chomp On Park Trail
Aung San Suu Kyi to be barred from party and polls
Cable group wants U.S. FCC to end fee disputes
|
China to boost food safety measures after scandal
Indonesia confirms Bali bomber killed
Haitians wary of US military reduction
US 'JihadJane' arrested for terror recruiting
Biden slams Israel settlement plan
Indonesia, Australia pledge on people smuggling
LG Elec launches Android-based smartphone
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Bigelow's Oscars will change Hollywood, slowly
Japan machinery orders fall in January
Cathay Pacific returns to full-year profit
China auto sales reach 1.2 million in February
Hollywood buzzing as Oscars catwalk begins
China February exports jump 45.7 percent
S.Korea seen buying dlrs to check won -traders
John Krasinski joins "Something" romantic comedies
Simon & Garfunkel begin Canada trek next month
De Niro signs up to play football icon Lombardi
Rapper DMX arrested for violating probation
Accused Letterman extortionist pleads guilty
Bigelow's Oscars will change Hollywood, slowly
China exports rebound extends into February
PAKISTAN
Number of US millionaires up 16 percent in 2009: study
US Iraq commander likes 'Hurt Locker'
Soaring China home prices thwart ordinary buyers
Korea Hot Stocks
Men likelier than women to enjoy sex in old age
De Niro set to portray coaching legend Vince Lombardi
Japan machinery orders fall 3.7 percent in January
Indonesia, Australia agree on asylum seeker plan
Officials: Bali bombing mastermind may be dead
Bride-To-Be Calls In Backup In Bridal Shop Dispute
Dozen 17th,18th Century Shipwrecks Found In Baltic Sea
Correspondents Share Close Encounters Of War Kind
Argentinean Grandma To Face Charges For Growing Two Marijuana Plants
Bigelow's Oscars will change Hollywood, slowly
|
Accused Letterman extortionist pleads guilty
|
De Niro signs up to play football icon Lombardi
|
Charlie Sheen returning to work next Tuesday
|
Rapper DMX arrested for violating probation
|
John Krasinski joins Something romantic comedies
|
Simon & Garfunkel begin Canada trek next month
|
US-TECH Summary
Iran's Ahmadinejad in Afghanistan, Gates departs
Google opens virtual shop for business software
Retaliation fears stalk Nigeria city after clashes
|
Car bomb kills five in eastern Afghanistan: police
UN chief 'condemns' Israeli settlement plan
Chinese group file complaint over faulty HP laptops
Suicide attack kills NATO soldiers in Afghanistan
Chavez trusts God and nature in power crisis
|
Disney Ends Give A Day, Get A Day Promo
Obama effect boosts Nobel Peace Prize nominations
|
Ahmadinejad, Gates trade barbs in Afghanistan
|
Gunmen kill 6 in Western aid agency raid in Pakistan
|
Chinese group file complaint over faulty HP laptops
Libya accepts U.S. apology over diplomatic row
|
Head of Egypt's al-Azhar dies in Saudi Arabia: report
|
Gunmen storm US charity in Pakistan, killing 6
Japan baby-robot teaches parenting skills
British ex-spy chief accuses US of hiding torture
New Caledonia taps Australia for reef protection
Security tight in Tibet on uprising anniversary
Tibet security tight for anniversary: residents
"Lost Boy" Haim Found Dead From Drug Overdose
Gourmet diners 'may spell extinction' for sea turtle
Polls Find Rubio In Nearly Insurmountable Lead For Senate
Disney Ends Give A Day, Get A Day Promo
'Miracle' baby elephant cheats death in birth
Man Pleads Guilty To Kiss Causing Airport Security Breach
IBM, universities target easy-to-use cellphones
|
"Last Tree" Not Payment Enough To Keep Man Out Of Jail
Gates checks out Afghan army training exercises
Trade Chief Kirk Notes Google-China Tug Of War, Commits On Doha Round
Members Of Right-To-Die Group Indicted
Gabourey Sidibe Lands Showtime "The Big C" Gig
Study: Obesity Associated With Higher Risk Of Death From Colon Cancer
Researchers Discover Men Die Sooner, But Remain Sexually Active Longer Than Women
Pakistani o/n rates lower; rupee, stocks flat
China's exporters fret over labour shortage
GM Daewoo vows to return to black this year
AIG could learn fate of Taiwan unit deal soon
Philippine exports fastest rise in 15 years
China World Cup mascot factory defends itself
Bold new Gaza play skewers Fatah and Hamas
FACTBOX-S.Korea policymakers' comments on economy, policy
At evolution exhibit, US creationists are unswayed
Curious whales give boost to Mexican fishermen
Charlie Sheen returning to work next Tuesday
Corey Haim dies of overdose
|
Phantom sequel a shadow of the original
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights