">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Obama debating Cheney is a plus for GOP
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Analysis: Obama debating Cheney is a plus for GOP
By WALTER R. MEARS,AP Special Correspondent AP - Saturday, May 23
CHAPEL HILL, N.C. - In political debate, the side that keeps its arguments simple and repeats them again and again is likely to gain the advantage. It is an easier sale, especially when the topic is as scary as terrorism.
ADVERTISEMENT
That's how Republicans got the edge in the dispute over President Barack Obama's planned closing of the Guantanamo Bay prison. And it put former Vice President Dick Cheney on a separate but almost equal platform with the president of the United States, which is a plus any time the party out of power can manage it.
Their back-to-back speeches on Thursday gave Cheney "a lot of credibility" and put Obama on the defensive, said Republican pollster David Winston.
"From a political standpoint, I think Cheney wins on points," said GOP strategist Rich Galen. Long-term, the former vice president's premier role may have a downside for the Republicans, given his 25 percent approval rating and his status as the most unpopular top figure in an unpopular administration. But Galen said that at this point, "It's either Cheney or who else. There's no who else, so you take Cheney."
In the Guantanamo argument, Obama's critics didn't worry about legalities, court decisions or complexities. They invented an argument about letting terrorists move next door to Americans.
Although no one had ever suggested such a thing, it worked, and the Democratic Senate voted overwhelmingly to deny Obama an $80 million appropriation to close the prison camp by eight months from now, as he had promised. Now Democratic leaders are saying that if Obama will come up with a plan on what to do with the prisoners _ there are about 240 of them _ they might agree.
He said he's working on it, but it isn't easy. If it were, the place might already have been shut, since former President George W. Bush said that he wanted to close it but 2008 wasn't the right time.
"We're cleaning up something that is, quite simply, a mess," Obama said. He said the prison Bush ordered opened in 2002 has left prisoners in legal limbo, flooded the government with legal challenges and distracted officials who should be spending their time dealing with potential threats.
"There are no neat and easy answers here," he said. "I wish there were." He said the issues are too complicated for absolutes or rigid ideology. So instead of scrapping everything the Bush administration did, he is adapting some of it, notably the use of military commissions to try terrorist suspects, to bring them "in line with the rule of law."
To which Cheney, in his own terrorism speech minutes after Obama's, said there's no place "for some kind of middle ground" on the issue. "Half measures keep you half exposed," he said. "You cannot keep just some nuclear-armed terrorists out of the United States; you must keep every nuclear-armed terrorist out."
There's no disputing that. But conjuring nuclear terrorists serves his argument that it is all or nothing, with no room for "sensible compromise" or "splitting differences," in Cheney's words.
Even debating the issues is wrong in Cheney's view. "The terrorists see just what they were hoping for _ our unity gone, our resolve shaken, our leaders distracted," he said.
And not only over Guantanamo, but also over the interrogation tactics Cheney calls enhanced and Obama calls torture.
"Torture was never permitted," Cheney repeated. But waterboarding and other methods certainly sound torturous. Cheney dismissed that issue as "contrived indignation and phony moralizing." He also said that hard-line questioning produced information that "prevented the violent death of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of innocent people."
No proof, but he said that is because it's in classified memos Obama hasn't released. That is said to be under review. Still, in an information sieve like Washington, it is hard to conceive that information involving hundreds of thousands of lives saved would not have been leaked by now.
Cheney argues that closing Guantanamo will make America less safe and that in promising to do it, Obama and his allies are trying to cozy up to European opinion. Cheney's administration wanted it shut at some point, and so did Sen. John McCain, the Republican presidential nominee who now says it can't be done without a plan on what to do with the inmates.
It was, as Obama said, opened without a plan on what to do with the prisoners except lock them up. Bush did it by presidential order; there was no discussion or legislation involved, and in 2006 the Supreme Court overruled the system by which the administration planned to try prisoners. At one point, Guantanamo held up to 750 inmates. The new president noted that more than 525 prisoners were released under the Bush administration, before he took office and ordered the place closed.
"Rather than keeping us safer, the prison at Guantanamo has weakened American national security," Obama said. "It is a rallying cry for our enemies. It sets back the willingness of our allies to work with us in fighting an enemy that operates in scores of countries."
That's complicated. Republicans are still keeping it simple.
"Guantanamo has worked very well," said Sen. Mitch McConnell, the GOP leader. "I'm not sure this is broken and needs fixing."
And certainly not if it will mean bringing prisoners to the United States to be tried and imprisoned if convicted.
"Republicans oppose releasing these terrorists or importing them into our local communities," said Rep. John Boehner, the House Republican leader.
Obviously, but nobody has proposed either.
Obama said trying to scare people won't protect them. "And we will be ill-served by some of the fear-mongering that emerges whenever we discuss this issue."
But for the present, it serves the political purposes of his opponents.
___
EDITOR'S NOTE _ Walter R. Mears reported on politics and government for The Associated Press for more than 45 years. He is retired and lives in Chapel Hill, N.C.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Israeli troops kill 2 militants in Gaza clashAP - Saturday, May 23
GMAC receives $7.5 billion in new Treasury aidAP - Friday, May 22
Florida's BankUnited fails, will cost FDIC $4.9BAP - Friday, May 22
Ex-soldier gets life in prison for Iraqi slayingsAP - Saturday, May 23
Today in History - May 22AP - Friday, May 22
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Obama signs credit card reforms
Vitamin D boosts brain power in middle-aged men
Smokers duped by light cigarettes: US court
Popular cereal is a drug, US food watchdog says
Chavez nationalizes iron, steel companies
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Saturday, 23 May 2009 Afghan leader welcomes Obama's Guantanamo vow
British economy at weakest for 30 years
Rafsanjani urges Iranians to vote in poll
Ahmadinejad slams rivals' detente policy with West
| International
|
Germany prefers Canada's Magna bid for Opel
Moderate earthquake rocks central Mexico
| International
|
Iraqis unhappy about life for U.S. rape soldier
Domestic Violence Charge Against Comedian Robert Schimmel Dropped
Atlantis return delayed until Saturday
Woman Who Attacked Simon Cowell's Ex Says She Was Just Avenging Paula Abdul
Biden links U.S. aid to Lebanon vote outcome
Heath Ledger's Last Unfinished Film Screened At Cannes
WHO chief says world should prepare for severe flu
| International
|
Turkish Cypriots pessimistic on unification talks
Wannabe Actress Sues Talent Agency For Sexual Assault
Canada court finds Rwandan guilty of war crimes
| International
|
Natalie Cole's Sister Dies After Her Own Successful Kidney Surgery
Fighting kills at least 45 in Somali capital
| International
|
Ban seeks U.N. access to Sri Lanka refugee camps
| International
|
Handwritten Poem Falsely Thought To Be Written By Bob Dylan
Michael Jackson To Wait One Week Before Treating Alleged Skin Cancer
Kate Walsh's Soon-To-Be Ex-Husband Wants ABC Network President To Testify In Divorce
Robert Pattinson Raises $80,000 To Kiss Two Teenage Girls
Woman Pleads Not Guilty To Attacking Simon Cowell's Ex-Girlfriend Terri Seymour
Tech companies look for deals as values fall
| Technology
|
Probation for McCain volunteer in fake Pa. attack
Facebook and Twitter hunt for revenue
| Technology
|
China stock regulator issues new draft IPO rules
Goldman Sachs unit to buy Universal Studios Japan
Ga. father gets 100 years for poisoning kids' soup
Toddler buys earthmover in online auction
US to assess Lebanon aid in light of vote: Biden
Defiant Obama slams Bush's Guantanamo 'mess'
China cracks down on insider trading
S.Korea court calls for Ssangyong self-rescue plan
Asia Crude-Taiwan's CPC seeks July condensate
Indonesia's air force struggles to maintain fleet
Bruce Springsteen to close Giants Stadium
Cannes celebrity AIDS gig hit by credit crisis
Smokie Norful talks about his balancing act
Close call in Cannes as prison drama edges ahead
| Entertainment
|
Clinton's sax sold at auction for AIDS research
France plays film card for tourism at Cannes
Jessica Biel's cutting wit does not come Easy
| Entertainment
|
Heath Ledger's final bow at Cannes
Bruce Springsteen to bid farewell to Giants Stadium
| Entertainment
|
Trout Fishing music duo pens children's book
`Keyboard Cat' phenomenon spreads on Web, TV
Syria sees Israeli talks offer useless without Golan
Caracas to pay $1.05 bln for Banco de Venezuela
Ex-South Korea leader Roh dead, aide says suicide
| International
|
Iran reformists hope for high election turnout
Online classified use soaring in US: Pew survey
U.N.'s Ban visits Sri Lankan displaced persons camp
| International
|
Obama signs credit card reforms
Belarus leader blasts Russia for reneging on pacts
Cuba's cyberwar intensifies
Ahmadinejad slams rivals' detente policy with West
Germany prefers Magna for Opel, decision next week
Gisele Bundchen And Tom Brady Reportedly Expecting First Child
Indonesian Muslim clerics frown at Facebook
AP Interview: Iraqi top cop expects more attacks
Smokers duped by light cigarettes: US court
Israeli troops kill 2 militants in Gaza clash
Magazine appeals Singapore defamation ruling
Two killed in Nepal blast as PM vote nears
| International
|
Biden links U.S. aid to Lebanon vote outcome
NKorea launches Internet mobile phone service: state media
Taciturn Armstrong sparks Twitter media boycott
Rebels rush to Mogadishu, residents fear more bloodshed
| International
|
Japan woos Pacific island leaders
News
'Subtle, sneaky' swine flu could hit poor nations: WHO
GM says it received 4 bln dlrs more from US Treasury
Australia fined but avoid ban for Davis Cup boycott
Barbados names gov't offices for US attorney gen
Car bomb kills 10, wounds 70 in Pakistan
Liberty U. pulls plug on campus Democratic club
Russian group mulls Facebook investment: report
| Technology
|
Malaysian govt wins latest battle in war over Perak
Wash. state has first death under new suicide law
Japan woos Pacific island leaders
University Relents After Banning Campus Dem Club
Search continues in Alaska for missing climber
Pakistani troops encircle Taliban base, Swat town
Leader defends group in spotlight in chemo dispute
Illinois Meatpacker Recalls 96,000 Pounds Of Ground Beef Linked To E. Coli Infections
UN official calls for Sri Lanka reconciliation
Pancreatic Cancer Patient Dies From Assisted Suicide In Washington State
Utah man charged in beating of pregnant teenager
Seattle Widower Shot For Holding Son Hostage
Suu Kyi proclaims innocence in Myanmar court
New trial for Ill. inmate who claimed police abuse
Groups Sue Feds To Protect Columbia Gorge Flowers
Sri Lanka dismiss threat of war crimes charges
Wall Street Posts Modest Loss On Late Sell-Off
NY man denies killing reputed dealer at Harvard
Hairspray Bacteria, No-Buzz Bean Among Top New Species
Barbour to travel to Iowa and New Hampshire
After Defeating A Resolution To Probe Her Claims, Pelosi Refuses CIA Questions In Briefing
At Naval Academy, Obama Promises To Send Graduates Into Harm's Way Only When Necessary
Biden Arrives In Lebanon Ahead Of Key Parliamentary Elections
IBM sets up 'innovation center' in Vietnam
S.Korea to tackle EU on trade pact, climate talks
'Spider-Man' director shocked at death of actress Gordon
Deposition: Paris Hilton is a promotion machine
Lee Solters, publicist for Sinatra & others, dies
Brit actor Vinnie Jones acquitted in SD bar fight
Hollywood lands in DC for 'Museum' premiere
Brazil fashion show to push for racial inclusion
Carol Cole, sister of Natalie Cole, dead at 64
Idol winner Kris wants respect, Adam eyes stardom
| Entertainment
|
'The Sims' return with more personality quirks
Boom sets off nonstop party from Black Eyed Peas
| Entertainment
|
`Idol' runner-up Lambert ready to put music first
Linkin Park crosses New Divide for Transformers
| Entertainment
|
Statue of Liberty has plenty on her mind
Q&A: Jarvis Cocker delves Further into rock
| Entertainment
|
Clay Aiken sounds off on `American Idol,' Lambert
John Fogerty revisits Blue Ridge Rangers
| Entertainment
|
Oak Ridge Boys get Back to basics
| Entertainment
|
Spoleto Festival USA opens in tough economic times
Brazil fashion show agrees to black model quota
Clarification: Cole undergoes kidney transplant
In decaying downtown, Johannesburg repairs forgotten organ
Timing not right for deal with Taliban: US
Celebrations as Germany turns 60
Russian firm offers to invest in Facebook: report
NATO soldier killed in Afghanistan: alliance
Anger mounts in Britain at fresh MP expense claims
Pakistani troops fight Taliban in Swat's main town
| International
|
Iraq PM slams law pardoning mainly Sunni prisoners
| International
|
Weather permitting, Atlantis plans to land Saturday
Israel government too extreme to make peace: Syria's Assad
| International
|
Health chiefs warn against 'sneaky' flu virus
India's finance minister Mukherjee vows to protect economy
| International
|
U.S., Afghan forces kill 60 in drug raid: military
| International
|
Madagascar rivals agree crisis breakthrough: U.N.
| International
|
Moderate communist elected Nepal's new PM
| International
|
Japan pledges $528m climate aid to Pacific Islands
S.Korea's ex-president dead, suicide note found
Weather permitting, Atlantis shuttle to land
Sri Lanka health ministry probes war zone doctors
US to resume migration talks with Cuba
Communist rebels kill 3 soldiers in Philippines
Analysis: CIA's Panetta tries to thread the needle
Australian floods kill man, displace 10,000
Troops kill 60 rebels, make largest Afghan drugs bust
Two dead, 14 injured in Nepal church blast: police
US makes overture to Cuba on legal immigration
Death toll hits 7 in Pakistan blast near cinema
Prosecutors: Peterson offered $25K for hit on wife
Taliban driven from road but still in hills
SKorea, EU agree to push for early conclusion of FTA
Senate vote not last word on Guantanamo
UN chief witnesses Sri Lanka refugee despair
South Korea-EU trade deal eyed for 2nd half of '09
Analysis: Obama debating Cheney is a plus for GOP
UN chief visits Sri Lanka war refugees
Vietnam inflation slows to 5.58 pct in May: govt
Pakistani c.bank buys 42.05 bln rupees of T-bills
SKorea, EU call for early conclusion of FTA
Vietnam's inflation eases to 5.58 percent in May
Lush images, audience walk-outs as Cannes winds up
| Entertainment
|
NY's Times Square prepares for pedestrian future
Porn publisher Larry Flynt sued by brother
Venezuela music program flourishes as global model
NY man denies killing reputed dealer at Harvard
Sutherland, McCollough resolve differences
Allen, Lambert ready to launch music careers
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights