">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
`At the Movies' critics dish it out, take it too
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
`At the Movies' critics dish it out, take it too
By LYNN ELBER,AP Television Writer AP - Friday, February 27
BEVERLY HILLS, Calif. - "At the Movies" critics Ben Mankiewicz and Ben Lyons have been taking it as well as dishing it out since joining the show last fall.
ADVERTISEMENT
That's especially true for Lyons, who's gotten heat from fellow critics and others for hobnobbing with Hollywood insiders and his alleged quest for blurb glory in movie ads. They don't like his reviews much, either.
While everyone's entitled to their opinion, Mankiewicz said, the thumbs-down for his colleague is "just wrong."
"Nobody who meets him is going to doubt that this guy knows a lot about film and is thoughtful about it, is interested and wants to talk about it," he said. "Everything came through this prism of presuming that he's young and didn't know what he was talking about."
Lyons said the attacks are inaccurate but leave him unfazed.
"It hasn't bothered me, hasn't affected me. I'm traveling, working, have a couple different jobs going on. I'm too busy to let it get to me," he said. "I do look at it as I criticize people's work, someone's going to criticize my work."
During lunch in a chic hotel (tuna sandwich for Lyons, chicken soup for Mankiewicz), they're as eager to discuss the Oscars as their show. The pair contrast sharply: Mankiewicz, 41, is low-key and droll, while Lyons, 27, is all boyish enthusiasm.
When Lyons mentions their different opinions of the dysfunctional family drama "Rachel Getting Married," which he declares he "loved," Mankiewicz pulls a face.
"It's not over yet. I think it's 98 hours long and it's just about ready to wrap up," Mankiewicz quips.
Lyons, a Hollywood reporter and film critic for "E! News" and others, and Turner Classic Movies host Mankiewicz started last September on the show distributed by Disney-ABC Domestic Television. They replaced Richard Roeper, who'd been working with guest critics since illness took Roger Ebert off the air in 2006. (Ebert's trademark thumbs up-down is gone, too.)
Lyons and Mankiewicz commute from Los Angeles to Chicago, where the show is produced, for tapings.
Viewership initially dipped, with 1.8 million tuning in compared to the nearly 2.4 million it was averaging last season. But there's been a steady uptick, to 2.3 million viewers in January, according to ratings released by Disney.
Lyons and Mankiewicz say their on-air chemistry still is jelling as they move at a fast clip through films, squeezing in an extra review _ about six total, along with DVD critiques _ in the latest incarnation of the long-running show.
Observers have criticized the revamp as a surrender to lightweight criticism, with Lyons bearing the brunt of the attacks.
"It's kind of mindboggling to me that we're at this point that Ben Lyons basically has become the face of film criticism," said Erik Childress, vice president of the Chicago Film Critics Association.
He was willing to give Lyons a chance but "it seems every week he's out there saying something completely moronic," Childress said, adding that Mankiewicz is trying "to keep the spirit of the show alive."
Scott Johnson, a blogger who founded StopBenLyons.com, said Lyons "seems more interested in kind of playing into what's the latest vehicle for hype and seeing if he can jump on the band wagon rather than being critical and offering an opinion that's going to challenge people."
Lyons takes issue with claims that he's angling to get quoted in movie ads and panders to the industry.
His reviews have been "blurbed" far less than those of other critics, he said. And mingling with Hollywood insiders is helpful as long as he keeps his reviews honest, Lyons said, insisting that he does.
"In the past, it might have hurt the show a bit that (reviewers) were isolated in Chicago. I enjoy the fact that I'm out here in L.A. and I know writers and directors and actors. I'm young and I'm going to be out and social and to meet people and develop genuine friendships with them and understand the (artistic) choices they've made," he said.
Mankiewicz's wry aside: "I'm not young, I'm not social and I don't enjoying going out. But I want to establish that we get along really well."
It's the latest twist in the journey of "At the Movies," which had its roots in a 1975 PBS series with Chicago newspaper critics Ebert and Gene Siskel (who died in 1999) and became the leading national TV forum for film criticism.
Ebert, a Pulitzer Prize winner, and Siskel offered brief but trenchant TV assessments of movies that they analyzed in greater depth and detail in print.
That was then and this is now, Mankiewicz and Lyons said.
"This is a TV show and the notion that only people who qualify to talk about film criticism are people who have written for a newspaper seems silly," Mankiewicz said.
Look at it this way, he adds: Would anyone suggest that NBC anchor Brian Williams write "750 to 2,500 words on the stimulus package before he discusses it on the air?"
That does not signal any less respect for films or those who make them, the pair say, and they produce family history as evidence.
Mankiewicz's grandfather, writer Herman Mankiewicz ("Citizen Kane") and great-uncle, writer-director Joseph Mankiewicz ("All About Eve," "A Letter to Three Wives") both are Oscar winners.
Lyons, whose grandfather was New York Post columnist Leonard Lyons, went to screenings as a child with his dad, critic Jeffrey Lyons, who encouraged his appreciation of classic films.
When it comes to movie criticism, Lyons and Mankiewicz say tradition is giving way to the rising chorus of voices online. That gives them a sharp appreciation of their "high-profile platform," Lyons said.
"Everybody can be a critic but that doesn't mean that everybody takes it seriously or responsibly, and that's something we can do. It's our job, it's what we do and love, so we treat it with the utmost respect."
___
AP Writer Caryn Rousseau in Chicago contributed to this report.
___
On the Net:
http://www.atthemoviestv.com
http://www.rogerebert.com
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle
Heart's Wilson sisters to be honored by music bizReuters - Friday, February 27
Nick nixed: `Idol' chooses 3 more finalistsAP - Friday, February 27
Jonas brothers eye box office crownReuters - Friday, February 27
Antonio Banderas joins Woody Allen pictureReuters - Friday, February 27
Brittany Snow to star in "Gossip Girl" spinoffReuters - Friday, February 27
Most Popular – Entertainment
Viewed
RBS posts record British loss, offloads toxic assets
HIV mutates at high speed to avoid immune system: study
Obama drives reform with 3.55-trillion-dollar budget
Diet, exercise could cut cancer rates by third
Obama seeks new 250 billion bank bailout: report
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 27 February 2009 Britain admits rendition of prisoners from Iraq
| International
|
Stevie Wonder Honored With The Gershwin Prize By President Barack Obama
Holocaust-denying British bishop makes apology
| International
|
Iran slams Obama government at U.N.
| International
|
IAEA urged to impose special inspection on Syria
| International
|
Ex-Serbian president acquitted of Kosovo war crimes
| International
|
Yahoo CFO to leave as company reorganizes
| Technology
|
U.S. Internet firms defend tighter Web management
| Technology
|
Obama budget eyes boost to cybersecurity funds
| Technology
|
JPMorgan To Post Profit As It Cuts More Washington Mutual Jobs
Rare Superman comic to be auctioned online
| Technology
|
Secretary Of State Hillary Clinton Warns Israel Over Gaza Aid Delays
Feb 26 Highlights Of Low Points In U.S. Economy
Ticketmaster CEO amenable to sale of TicketsNow
| Technology
|
Federal Government To Conduct Stress Test On Major U.S. Banks
Chicago Bulls To Visit Obama At White House
Republicans Slam President's 2010 Budget; Say 'Era Of Big Government Is Back'
Spray your tag on West Bank wall -- online
| Technology
|
Congress Eyes More Power For Bankruptcy Judges To Halt Foreclosure Crisis
Update: Obama Sends First Budget To Congress; Calls Proposal 'An Honest Accounting'
First-Time Jobless Claims Rise; Total Claims Now Over 5 Million
Dealers Of Toyota Lexus Top Customer Service Survey
Clint Eastwood thanks France as Cannes pays tribute
| Entertainment
|
Slumdog, Jai Ho! named top Hollywood words
| Entertainment
|
Martin Sheen back in political fray with Echelon Conspiracy
| Entertainment
|
Russian Man Dies After Swallowing Bottle Of Viagra
Chicago Bulls To Visit President Obama At White House
Teenage Pregnancies Up In U.K. For The First Time In 7 Years
Iran eyes Mexico in deepening Latin America ties
Mexico to send more troops to besieged city
| International
|
US, Afghans, Pakistan see 'common threat'
Usher Goes To Washington, D.C., Meets With Politicians About Volunteerism
Palestinians agree to work to form unity govt
Obama drives reform with 3.55-trillion-dollar budget
Iran slams U.S. envoy to U.N.
JPMorgan Chase expect 12,000 job cuts
Iraq, Kuwait hold highest-level talks since Saddam
Oil group Repsol says 2008 profits down 15 pct
US envoy, Netanyahu have 1st meeting on peace
RBS posts record British loss, offloads toxic assets
Kuwait FM on landmark visit to reformed Iraq
US jobless claims hit highest level since 1982
Palestinians agree to form unity govt by end-March
Diet, exercise could cut cancer rates by third
Officers' bodies found after Bangladesh mutiny ends
| International
|
Iraq buries nearly 500 soldiers killed in past wars
GM posts whopping $30.9-bln loss for 2008
China scorns U.S. rights record in tit-for-tat exchange
| International
|
Australia to reveal carbon trading legislation
Afghans protest against foreign troops
| International
|
Australian leader to meet Obama in Washington
China mothers urge reckoning with 1989 bloodshed
| International
|
Obama drives reform with 3.55-trillion-dollar budget
Officials: Obama says Iraq pullout by Aug 2010
Australia on alert as new fires threaten Victoria
| International
|
Climate change: chance for US-China cooperation
Obama budget a blueprint for a changed America
Dutch say Turks, Americans among Schiphol crash dead
| International
|
Tow Truck Bump Sends 2 School Buses Crashing In Arizona Highway, 6 Students Hurt
US will seek to end Iran's nuclear ambition
State Department Issues Mexico Travel Alert
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,251
Indigenous Leaders Call For End To Uranium Mining
Group urges Obama to unilaterally ease Cuba policy
Colorado Newspaper Prints Last Issue After 150-Year Run
Newsday plans to 'end free Web content'
Fannie Mae Posts $25.2 Billion Loss; Seeks $15.2 Billion From Washington
Newsday to charge for website, online cable service
US dispatches envoy for NKorea talks
Teens Charged With Shooting Cop As Part Of Gang Initiation
Facebook turns to democracy to appease users
GM Lost $30.9 Billion In 2008
Pentagon to allow pictures of flag-draped coffins
Yahoo CEO reorganizes company
| Technology
|
New Home Sales Drop To Record Low In January
Facebook lets users comment on new terms of service
EU awaits US data before move on Guantanamo inmates
Wall Street Slips On Housing Data, Health Care Sector
Facebook lets users comment on new terms of service
| Technology
|
Google introduces ads to Google News
Attorney General Holder Says Obama Will Reinstate Assault Weapons Ban
Ticketmaster CEO amenable to sale of TicketsNow
Russia proposes NATO talks on Georgia to ease ties
DoCoMo halts BlackBerry Bold sales due to overheating
| Technology
|
Rare Superman comic to be auctioned online
Newsday to charge for website, online cable service
| Technology
|
Obama budget eyes boost to cybersecurity funds
Finns urged to check Web, curb guns after rampages
U.S. spy agency may get more cybersecurity duties
Thousands flee new Australian fires threat
Bangladesh mutiny ends after tanks enter capital
ASEAN human rights body lacks power to punish
China says military ties 'difficult', urges US action
Aus anti-Asian campaigner Hanson runs for parliament
"Slumdog", "Jai Ho!" named top Hollywood words
Australia to unveil carbon-trading legislation
Watchmen turns superheroics into campy soap opera
| Entertainment
|
'Slumdog' stars welcomed home to India after Oscar glory
SKorea to name new nuclear negotiator with NKorea
Model Gisele Bundchen weds NFL star Tom Brady
| Entertainment
|
China "mothers" urge reckoning with 1989 bloodshed
The Simpsons to clinch television record
| Entertainment
|
Filipinos jailed for Nigeria oil theft are freed
Jonas brothers eye box office crown
| Entertainment
|
Another bird flu patient dies in Vietnam
Kanye West's Radiohead tirade cut from VH1 show
| Entertainment
|
Japan's industrial production falls record amount
Antonio Banderas joins Woody Allen picture
| Entertainment
|
Jonas brothers eye box office crown
Japan's factory output suffers biggest ever drop
Antonio Banderas joins Woody Allen picture
Heart's Wilson sisters to be honored by music biz
| Entertainment
|
Asian emergency fund 'matter of urgency': ASEAN
Brittany Snow to star in "Gossip Girl" spinoff
Korea Hot Stocks
Def Leppard sets tour with Cheap Trick, Poison
| Entertainment
|
An intimate, yet unsentimental 'Our Town' scores
Taiwan dollar weakens past T$35, hits 6-year low
`At the Movies' critics dish it out, take it too
NZ housing confidence rebounds in Q4
NC Symphony recording features Branford Marsalis
South Korean bonds fall as won threatens 11-yr low
Robin Williams heading to B'way for 5 performances
Seoul shares open up but rapidly lose gains
No unanimous agreement reached at Piven hearing
SKorea's Jan current account in the red as exports plunge
CORRECTED: Final Harry Potter film gets release date
S.Korea institutions lose $46 bln foreign assets
On the Net: Sites aim to be TV Guide for the Web
Last-ditch efforts for broad Israel govt collapse
Russian bomber neared Canada before Obama visit
| International
|
I won't join Netanyahu-led Israeli govt: Livni
Grievance Committee Sides With Jeremy Piven On His Abrupt Exit From Broadway
Bishop's apology over Holocaust denial not enough: Vatican
| International
|
Obama plans Iraq pullout by August 2010
Netanyahu fails in last-ditch bid for broad coaliton
World faces last chance to avoid fatal warming: EU
| International
|
US to take $25 billion stake in Citigroup
Russell Simmons To Pay $480,000 Annually In Child Support To Ex-Wife Kimora Lee
Iraqi president meets top Iranian leaders
Sri Lanka rebels boxed in further, army says
| International
|
Lloyds declares £10.8 bln HBOS loss
Obama setting date for Iraq troop pullout
Regional ministers seek donor help for Zimbabwe
| International
|
Artist seeks stars for 'living monument' in London
US, Afghans, Pakistan see 'common threat'
Japan faces deepening recession
Citigroup, US Treasury reach deal on government stake
Israel's Livni-Netanyahu talks end without deal
| International
|
Tibetan monk sets himself on fire: activist group
| International
|
US troops to leave Iraq by end 2011
US soldier dies on combat patrol in Baghdad
US combat troops out of Iraq by Aug 2010: reports
Facebook lets users comment on new terms of service
| Technology
|
US-TECH Summary
Second video of Canadian diplomats abducted in Niger
BlackBerry Bold sales suspended in Japan
U Of Tennessee Planning 777 Job Cuts To Cope With $66.5M Reduction In Funding; Tuition Increases Also Under Consideration
Biden Leads First Meeting Of Obama Middle Class Task Force Friday
US envoy to try to deter NKorea missile launch
Microsoft Files Patent Infringement Lawsuit Against Dutch Firm
California Supreme Court Provides Protection To Whistle Blowers
First Lady Declares 'New Day' In Environmental Policies During EPA Visit
Experts Forecast Near Bottom For Auto Sales
China Responds To U.S. Report On Human Rights Abuses With Counter Accusations
Senate Passes D.C. Voting Rights Bill Despite Amendment Repealing Gun Laws
Bill Tatum, "Voice Of Harlem," Publisher Emeritus Of Amsterdam News, Dies At Age 76 On Vacation In Croatia
Estimated $8.5M In Fortunoff Gift Cards, Merchandise Credit Slips Will Be Honored In Liquidation Sale
Australian firefighters keep blazes under control
U2 album a hit, Bono campaigning a miss: critics
| Entertainment
|
Bangladesh security chief among mutiny dead
Axl Rose says Slash is a cancer
| Entertainment
|
Afghans protest alleges NATO gunshots in mosque
African film festival turns 40 with pride
| Entertainment
|
Malaysian PM: Send Muslim boat people back
Japan's lower house passes fiscal 2009 budget
General: Mass graves found after Bangladesh revolt
Khmer Rouge detention hearing postponed
ASEAN signs trade deal with Australia, N.Zealand
Nissan design seeks to appeal to aging Japan
Police fire tear gas to stop protests in Pakistan
India's Tata Steel Q3 profit down 44%
Troops patrol in Indian Kashmir to prevent protest
India economy slows sharply as global slowdown hits
Sony CEO Stringer tightens grip on power
AirAsia's 'phenomenal' quarter despite loss in Q4
U2 album a hit, Bono campaigning a miss: critics
Japan's lower house passes fiscal 2009 budget
Vietnam's youth 'the future for growth'
Mobile phones more visible in North Korean capital
"Watchmen" turns superheroics into campy soap opera
WRAPUP 3-S.Korea won hits 11-yr low on dollar shortage fears
Heart's Wilson sisters to be honored by music biz
S.Korea banks seek $8 bln from $13 bln govt-led fund
Nick nixed: `Idol' chooses 3 more finalists
Karachi stock exchange closes early due to glitch
Russell Simmons agrees to child support payments
Artist seeks stars for 'living monument' in London
Fourth Sumatran tiger killed in Indonesia: official
European Budget Airline Ryanair Mulling Charging For Toilet Use; Already Charges For Water
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights