Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Ex-media baron Black's fraud conviction set aside
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Ex-media baron Black's fraud conviction set aside
Reuters - 31 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
By James Vicini
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court on Thursday threw into doubt the fraud convictions of former Enron Corp Chief Executive Jeffrey Skilling and ex-media baron Conrad Black, a setback for the U.S. Justice Department in two of the biggest corporate fraud prosecutions of the last decade.
The high court limited the reach of a federal fraud law that Justice Department prosecutors have used in a number of cases alleging public corruption by government officials and fraud by executives like Black and Skilling.
The ruling could make it harder for the administration of President Barack Obama to use the fraud law even as it faces rising public anger and pressure to bring major cases against corporations and top executives for wrongdoing in the wake of the financial crisis.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said the fraud law at issue only covered bribery and kickbacks, and that Skilling's alleged misconduct did not involve a bribe or kickback.
The court also ruled that the convictions of Black and two former colleagues for defrauding shareholders of former newspaper publisher Hollinger International Inc must be reviewed because of flawed jury instructions about the fraud law.
The court stopped short of overturning both convictions, and sent the cases back to lower courts for more proceedings. Both men will remain in prison.
Ginsburg said in Black's case, the lower courts must determine if the jury instruction error was harmless, while in Skilling's case, she said the conspiracy and fraud conviction was flawed, but may not have to be reversed.
The Justice Department would defend the Skilling and Black cases in the lower courts as well as other prior convictions under the law, spokeswoman Tracy Schmaler said.
"While we are disappointed that today's Supreme Court decisions narrowed the honest services statute, we are pleased that the court upheld many of the core provisions that have been used for decades to prosecute corrupt public officials and corporate executives who have breached their duties to their constituents, clients and investors," she said.
The ruling significantly narrows a law "crucial for holding accountable the corporate criminals whose actions did so much to contribute to the current financial crisis which has harmed so many Americans," said Vermont Democratic Senator and Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy.
Skilling and Black had been convicted on other charges besides fraud, and the ruling ensures further legal proceedings to determine the fate of their convictions on all the charges.
Skilling as chief executive led Enron's transformation from a sleepy natural gas pipeline company into a global energy trading powerhouse. He was convicted in 2006.
The case was part of the Justice Department's crackdown early in the decade targeting top executives for their role in corporate fraud and accounting scandals in such companies as Enron and WorldCom.
Skilling is serving a prison sentence of 24 years at a minimum security facility in Littleton, Colorado.
SKILLING 'VERY HAPPY'
Defence lawyer Daniel Petrocelli said Skilling's first statement was an emotional "thank you so much" to the group of lawyers on the telephone line when told of the ruling. "He is very happy," Petrocelli said.
"Our position will be that every count of conviction is undermined because the government relied so prominently on the honest services theory at trial," he said.
Miguel Estrada, Black's attorney, said, "We are obviously pleased that the Supreme Court rejected the government's argument that Conrad Black engaged in honest services fraud."
"We look forward to helping Mr. Black regain his freedom," he added.
The Canadian-born Black, who had been a member of Britain's House of Lords, has been in a U.S. prison since March 2008, when he began serving a 6-1/2-year sentence for fraud and obstruction of justice.
The Supreme Court's ruling stemmed from an appeal by Black after he was found guilty by a jury in Chicago of stealing millions of dollars from Hollinger by fraudulently paying himself bogus fees. Hollinger was once the world's third-largest publisher of English-language newspapers.
In the first part of the Skilling ruling, the high court rejected his argument that his conviction should be overturned completely because his Houston jury had been tainted by prejudice and anger over the energy trader's collapse.
The court said he received a fair trial. Justices John Paul Stevens, Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor dissented from that part of the ruling.
In the second part of the ruling, the court focussed on a law used by Justice Department prosecutors in Skilling's case.
At issue in the case is a 28-word law that the U.S. Congress adopted in 1988 that makes it illegal for public officials and executives to commit fraud by depriving those they work for of the right to "honest services."
His attorneys said Skilling did not breach his honest services duty because he never was dishonest to his employer, he always acted in Enron's interest and prosecutors never showed he personally benefited from his allegedly fraudulent acts.
Ginsburg's opinion struck a middle ground.
She did not go as far as Skilling's lawyers wanted in seeking to get the law declared as unconstitutionally vague.
But she also did not give the Justice Department what it wanted by extending the law from bribes and kickbacks to a third category of conduct -- undisclosed self-dealing by a public official or private employee.
The Supreme Court cases are Jeffrey Skilling v. United States, No. 08-1394 and Black v. United States, No. 08-876.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Burgers, Boeings and bonhomie as Obama meets Medvedev AFP - 20 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 31 minutes ago
Ex-media baron Black's fraud conviction set aside Reuters - 31 minutes ago
U.S. government loses bid to keep oil drilling ban Reuters - 36 minutes ago
After bloodshed, Kyrgyzstan to vote on future Reuters - 40 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Russia to buy 50 Boeing 737s worth four billion dollars
Obama: 'Russia belongs in the WTO'
Second 2010 hurricane forms off Mexico
Longest ever tennis match resumes at Wimbledon
Russia-Belarus gas dispute draws to a close
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Aussie men shoot each other in buttocks 'to see if it hurts'
Disgraced millionaire lobbyist takes pizza job
Nurse in iconic World War II kiss photograph dies
Gulf containment cap reattached, collecting oil: BP
Prince Albert of Monaco announces engagement
More Most Viewed »
Aussie men shoot each other in buttocks 'to see if it hurts'
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 25 June 2010 Still time for Iran nuclear fuel swap
Obama: 'Russia belongs in the WTO'
Paris hosts cyber-shelter for battered bloggers
French 'Hannibal Lecter' gets 30-year jail term
US-TECH Summary
Canada police halt suspicious car near G20 summit site
|
US ambassador to Afghanistan: Time to move on
Second 2010 hurricane forms off Mexico
Fans scramble for Apple's iPhone upgrade
US ambassador to Afghanistan calls for unity
Longest ever tennis match resumes at Wimbledon
Google assessing China's new rule on web mapping
Katy Perry Spends Third Week Atop Billboard Hot 100 With "California Gurls"
Facebook to take on Asian rivals to reach billion user mark
7 Afghan construction workers killed in bombing
Swingers at risk of sexual disease: Dutch study
Suspected Jamaican drug lord faces handover to U.S.
|
Greek police minister escapes bomb
|
French Obama hacker escapes jail
Tech companies seeking business in Syria
Twitter settles privacy charges with U.S
Still time for Iran nuclear fuel swap: think tank
|
China marks anti-drug day with executions: state media
Pakistani court sentences Americans for terrorism
Nokia to use Linux for flagship N-series phones
Israel's Likud backs West Bank settlement growth
Nokia to use Linux for flagship N-series phones
Frenchman who ate cellmate's lung gets 30 years jail
|
Alleged Jamaica drug lord extradited to US: official
Israel's Likud approves West Bank settlement growth
Paraguay into last 16, Kiwis leave with pride
Nike Posts Growth In Q4, Full Year Earnings
Iranian Guards Crossed Into Iraq To Capture US Hikers
Illinois State Police Dismiss First Muslim Chaplain
New Jobless Claims, Continuing Claims Fall More Than Expected
Katy Perry Spends Third Week Atop Billboard Hot 100 With "California Gurls"
Ben Stiller Creating Web Show Starring His Parents
Sino-Canadian ties of 'growing strategic importance': Hu
Ex-media baron Black's fraud conviction set aside
Japan PM kicks off campaign season
Myanmar sees 'dramatic' surge in drug seizures: UN
N.Korea vow to restore honour against Ivory Coast
Debate Heightens About University Of Texas Dorm Named After Klansman
Gucci, Fendi present first children's collection in Florence
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Justin Bieber, Usher To Appear On "20/20" Michael Jackson Special
Oil Spill Cleanup Captain Commits Suicide On Vessel
A Minute With: Taylor Lautner from "Twilight"
Art missing since 1945 on show at German palace
US, EU Sign "Second Stage" Air Transport Agreement
Cuba's Buena Vista Social Club to miss U.S. show
YouTube, now with instant vuvuzela sound
|
Polaroid action nets 12.5 million dollars
Drool-worthy tips on new Paris foodie website
Internet bosses set to approve .xxx for porn sites
|
Bharti to invest 150 million dollars in Zain Zambia
Glastonbury readies for music, mud and Gorillaz
Apple's iPhone 4 makes world debut
Alibaba.com to buy U.S. e-commerce site Vendio
|
Stability back in Vietnam forex market: state bank
New Japan PM to make global debut at Canada summits
A Minute With: Taylor Lautner from Twilight
|
Santana recruits Nas and Daughtry for covers album
|
YouTube, now with instant vuvuzela sound
|
Killers' singer Flowers to debut album in September
|
Cuba's Buena Vista Social Club to miss U.S. show
|
US seeks to reassure allies after McChrystal fired
Bank of England warns of eurozone debt crisis dangers
US Congress approves new Iran sanctions
Burgers, Boeings and bonhomie as Obama meets Medvedev
Will video sites stop filtering content?
U.S. Congress OKs sanctions on Iran's energy, banks
Arrest in N.Ireland over 'Basque separatist probe'
Jamaica turns over alleged drug lord to U.S.
|
Apple's iPhone 4 makes stellar world debut
US lawmakers race to secure Wall Street reforms
Israel offers to let Europe diplomats visit Gaza-official
Gadhafi, Zapatero 'in talks' on next EU-Africa summit
North Korea issues no-sail warning; missile eyed
|
Sony's PlayStation near deal with Hulu: report
Scientists make progress in growing new human lungs
Russia to buy 50 Boeing 737s worth four billion dollars
Australian new PM reassures Obama on Afghanistan
Hong Kong passes historic reforms amid muted protest
|
Venture firm Accel pours 11 million dollars into GetJar
Blackberry maker RIM rings up record smartphone sales
US ambassador to Afghanistan: Time to move on
Obama, Democrats prepare for campaign with iPad, iPhone apps
Alibaba.com to buy U.S. e-commerce site Vendio
Twitter settles with US regulators over privacy breach
Sony's PlayStation near deal with Hulu: report
Stalin statue removed in Georgian home town
|
"Glee" Cast Members Talk UK Tour, Michael Jackson With Jonathan Ross
Police: Calif couple tried to sell baby at Walmart
Hong Kong passes democratic reform package
US, Russia Reiterate Commitment To Bring Peace To Afghanistan
Tibet environmentalist jailed for 15 years: lawyer
President Obama Signs West Virginia Disaster Declaration
Disappointment, pride for fans as NZ bows out
Severe storm shatters largest city in Connecticut
U.S. High Court Rules Honest Service Fraud Law Covers Only Bribery, Kickbacks
Whalewatching worth billions and booming: study
Russian President Gets Taste Of American Food, Calls It Not Healthy
"Harry Potter," "Paranormal Activity" Sequel Trailers To Debut Before "Eclipse"
U.S. Markets Continue Decline As Retailers, Financials Weigh
Palin fund illegal; donors will get money back
S.Korea places 65 firms under restructuring plans
Global Weather-Celsius
Seoul shares fall 0.6 pct on econ jitters
Sony's PlayStation near deal with Hulu: report
|
Taiwan stocks end down 1.5 pct; property slumps
PAKISTAN
China sets strong yuan rate ahead of G20
Will video sites stop filtering content?
|
China's yuan move too soon to judge: Obama
Seoul shares fall 0.6 pct on econ jitters
New Australia PM tells Obama committed to Afghan war
N.Korea issues no-sail warning; missile eyed-paper
From the Bronx to Brooklyn, pianos take over New York
Fans gather for Michael Jackson death anniversary
S.Korea won breaks support line on recovery doubt
Philippines' kidney register to fight trafficking
Taiwan raises rates on NCDs after rate hike
New troubles at Al Gore's Current TV
S.Korea raps 'reckless' N.Korea at war anniversary
N.Korea declares 'no sail' zone off west coast
Channing Tatum attached to sci-fi romance "Ion"
North Korea issues no-sail warning; missile eyed
"Toy Story 3" set to crush Cruise and Sandler movies
Goldman Sachs gets Weinstein films in debt pact
Blue Samurai draft new chapter for Japan
War film "Restrepo" gives ground view of Afghan war
Pubs urged to stock up booze for England vs Germany
Santana recruits Nas and Daughtry for covers album
Toy Story 3 set to crush Cruise and Sandler movies
|
War film Restrepo gives ground view of Afghan war
|
Goldman Sachs gets Weinstein films in debt pact
|
New troubles at Al Gore's Current TV
|
Channing Tatum attached to sci-fi romance Ion
|
Paws for thought: Oscar the bionic cat
Israel marks four years of 'cruel' Shalit captivity
G8 nations to take stock of development needs
|
Amputee cat gets bionic legs
Clijsters reaches Wimbledon fourth round
Kyrgyz troops vote in first stage of referendum
|
Bodies found beheaded in southern Afghanistan
BP shares plunge near 14-year low on liabilities
Pacific Hurricane Darby now a major storm off Mexico
|
Shakira To Release New Fragrance "S"
Former Transit Officer Testifies In Own Murder Trial
Germany calls for bank tax ahead of G20
Hurricanes In Eastern Pacific Ocean Pose No Threat While Forecasters Watch Atlantic Ocean Region
Police find 11 beheaded bodies in Afghan south
|
Are Americans embracing the beautiful game at last?
Drunk Man Found Mile Offshore Floating In Pool Chair
New York's V, W Subway Lines Make Final Runs Friday
Court rules no right to gay marriage in Europe
|
BP says 2.35 billion dollars spent on oil spill
Vatican protests to Belgium over police raids
|
Scientists Implant Functional Lung Tissue In Rats
Milwaukee Teen Dies In Parking Garage Collapse
Red Wine Ingredient May Prevent Blinding Diseases
Indonesia says militants aiming at embassy, police
|
Study: Canadian, U.S. Health Care At The Bottom Among 7 Industrialized Nations
Yemen police, militants clash during raid in Aden
|
Swollen river threatens major city in central China
Stalin statue removed in Georgian home town
|
UN war crimes panel chief 'criticises S.Lanka ban'
Outcry as Hong Kong adopts democratic reforms
Australia's Gillard unlikely to shift foreign policy
Japan sumo gambling scandal highlights yakuza links
Hong Kong passes "historic" reforms amid muted protest
Ambani brothers sign revised gas deal
Oppenheimer sees iPhone 4 sales of 1.5 million on first day
|
Pakistan to monitor Google, others for blasphemy
|
Suicide-hit Foxconn hands over staff dormitories
|
Pakistan stocks flat ahead of fiscal year-end
Asian markets extend losses after Wall Street fall
Man and didgeridoo open Glastonbury music festival
Mizuho Financial announces $9.6 billion share sale
Michael Jackson fans pay tribute to billion dollar man
Oil falls as investors turn pessimistic
Are Americans (finally) embracing the beautiful game?
S.Korea agency to buy $3.7 bln savings bank loans
S.Korean banks select 65 firms for restructuring
Japan fans hold sleepover to mark Jackson death
Michael Jackson fans pay tribute to billion dollar man
|
A Minute With: Taylor Lautner from Twilight
|
Man and didgeridoo open Glastonbury music festival
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights