">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Mental health courts increase despite debate
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Mental health courts increase despite debate
By DENA POTTER,Associated Press Writer AP - Wednesday, May 6
NORFOLK, Va. - When the judge calls her name the lady pops up, slipping on her long, red jacket and floppy hat as she approaches the bench.
ADVERTISEMENT
"Taking your medicine?" the judge asks.
"My prescription ran out."
"Are you keeping your appointments?" he follows.
After some excuses and a promise to see her psychiatrist, Norfolk Circuit Judge Charles Poston shoots back, this time more punisher than nurturer: "Don't let me hear that you've been missing doctors' appointments anymore or I'll put you somewhere where you can't miss them."
The exchange is similar to dozens of others each Tuesday afternoon in Poston's courtroom and in hundreds of other mental health courts nationwide. Similar to drug courts, mental health courts work to place the severely depressed, paranoid and delusional into treatment instead of behind bars.
Even as the courts have ballooned from only a handful a decade ago to more than 250, experts and lawmakers remain divided on whether they are the most appropriate way to manage mentally ill people who land in trouble with the law.
Some mental health advocates fear the courts lead to greater criminalization and stigma for the mentally ill. They don't like that the courts use criminal sanctions to coerce treatment or that criminal offenders can jump the line to get community-based treatment before others.
"Despite good intentions, the mental health courts don't address the root problem, which is getting services to people before crisis hits," said Andrew Penn, a staff attorney for the Washington-based Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law. "You shouldn't have to wait until you wind up in court to get those services."
Other groups, like the National Alliance on Mental Illness, support the courts as a way to help the mentally ill instead of punishing them while increasing public safety and cutting down on the money needed to incarcerate the same offenders over and over.
Poston, whose court started in 2004 and is the only one in Virginia, said he's "certainly not an evangelist," because something that works in Norfolk may not work elsewhere. But he said the people are already in court, so "we might as well help them."
Following the move to deinstitutionalize the mentally ill 50 years ago, many individuals did not get the help they needed in the community and wound up getting into trouble. Over time, the nation's prisons and jails became surrogate psychiatric hospitals.
Today, there are more severely mentally ill people in the Los Angeles County Jail than there are in any psychiatric hospital in the U.S. Studies have found that mentally ill offenders stay in jail longer, return often and cost more to house than regular inmates.
Legislative efforts to create or expand mental health courts in Virginia and other states have failed in recent years over concerns about funding and a reluctance to turn judges into social workers.
This year, bills were introduced in Virginia, Oregon, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Indiana to authorize more mental health courts, but so far they have not advanced. Similar efforts in Massachusetts and New Jersey failed in recent years, while Illinois passed authorizing legislation in 2007.
Only a handful of states _ Kansas, Massachusetts, Mississippi, the Dakotas, Wisconsin and Wyoming _ do not have mental health courts.
In Virginia, a bill to expand the courts failed because some lawmakers felt judges should not be paid to "baby-sit" drug addicts or the mentally ill.
"I don't want to pay a judge $160,000 to $175,000 a year to do a social issue when that's not what their job is," said Del. Johnny S. Joannou, a Democrat.
In most parts of the country, judges _ not legislators _ have been the driving force behind mental health courts.
Ohio Supreme Court Justice Evelyn Stratton took a leading role in expanding that state's mental health courts _ there are 40 either operational or being planned _ and has worked to do the same nationwide.
Stratton said the courts really are just a docket management tool, and that judges have inherent authority to control their own dockets. She said putting it in law could do more harm than good.
"All this is so new that to legislate it now when we're still experimenting and growing and trying to invent the wheel would just not be productive," she said.
There is no national court model. Some take only misdemeanors, while others are for felonies. Some have 25 participants and meet monthly, while others see hundreds of participants each week.
Those with psychiatric problems can volunteer to complete the program of close supervision by mental health and law enforcement officials and regular meetings with the judge instead of jail time. They undergo regular drug screenings and can spend days or weeks in jail for slipping up. Often their charges are dismissed if they successfully complete the program.
On court day, talk centers around new jobs, bad relationships, dirty drug tests and new beginnings. Poston's first words to participants often go something like, "What's going on in your life?"
Most of the courts rely primarily on local funding, while some receive federal grants. Some states, like Nevada, devote millions to the courts each year.
Sheila Leslie, a Nevada legislator who also works with the state's specialty courts, says the mental health courts give offenders a chance to succeed.
"Of course you don't have 100 percent success," she said. "Of course there are issues and some people go to prison, but we literally have saved lives."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Related Articles: World
Obama seeks larger, pricier consumer commissionAP - 2 hours 19 minutes ago
Autopsy: NJ boat's captain had used marijuanaAP - 2 hours 27 minutes ago
Stocks dip as Bernanke gives guarded outlookAP - 59 minutes ago
Gates says U.S. to persist with Iran overturesReuters - 2 hours 46 minutes ago
No ransom demand, no motive in SoCal abductionAP - 2 hours 48 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
US banks may need more funds
Court okays breast removal for transsexual teen: report
Kenyan women to sex-starve men -- for politics
Swine flu in decline: Mexico
Brain abnormality found in autistic tots: report
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Tuesday, 5 May 2009 Panama's president-elect to push U.S. trade deal
| International
|
North Korea cool to resuming nuclear talks
| International
|
Karzai registers for election, running mate criticized
| International
|
Iran shells Iraqi Kurdistan village
| International
|
U.N. talks on troubled nuclear arms pact show split
| International
|
Fight against pirates also needed ashore: U.S. Navy
| International
|
BlackBerry Curve seen better than iPhone
| Technology
|
RIM plans next-gen Storm as it eyes untapped market
| Technology
|
EU hearing on Microsoft antitrust case in June
| Technology
|
Duff McKagan a rock 'n' roll renaissance man
| Entertainment
|
Twilight and Slumdog top MTV Movie nods
| Entertainment
|
NBC rolls out 6 new shows in bid to rescue ratings
| Entertainment
|
Madeleine McCann will be found, parents tell Oprah
| Entertainment
|
Angels & Demons director sees Vatican meddling
| Entertainment
|
Flu-hit Mexico plans recovery
| International
|
Turkish wedding attack kills 45
Turkish wedding attack kills 44 in blood feud
| International
|
Spanish judge to probe Gaza air raid
Nepal parties try to form government after Maoists quit
| International
|
Netanyahu says ready for peace talks right away
| International
|
Iran supreme leader rebukes president over powers
NY Times postpones threat to close Boston Globe
U.N. to press Israel on Lebanon border village
Karzai registers for election, running mate criticized
| International
|
Brain abnormality found in autistic tots: report
Israel dispatches envoys to soften hawkish image
Fiat boss touts plans for new car giant
Karzai registers for Afghan vote with warlord
Creditors object to Chrysler deal, setting up fight
Climate change 'cultural genocide' for Aborigines
Iraq's Maliki in Paris seeking investment
Israel's Peres omits mention of Palestinian state
FTC looks at Google-Apple board ties: report
| Technology
|
Bigger Kindle e-reader may not be a newspaper fix
| Technology
|
Struggling US newspapers look to e-readers
Police: Proof is in the pudding in Pa. burglaries
California judge blunts Internet false advertising law
| Technology
|
High-tech start-ups training academy to open
Pa. museum may allow DNA test of Lincoln's blood
Bernanke likely to give less dour take on economy
Michelin steers iPhone users to fine dining
EU hearing on Microsoft antitrust case in June
| Technology
|
Authorities seek SoCal tot reported kidnapped
Bigger Kindle e-reader may not be a newspaper fix
Hudson River to be site of Macy's July 4 fireworks
Basque parliament to elect Socialist leader
HP, RIM form Blackberry alliance
Child advocate wants octuplet guardian appointed
Blackberry Curve tops iPhone in first quarter: NPD
US, Israel at odds on Iran, Palestinians
Berlusconi snaps back in melodramatic divorce battle
SKorea and US forge deal to fight cyber attacks
Students back at NYC school after swine flu scare
Mass. police get burned as 4,000 teens flood beach
NY Times postpones threat to close Boston Globe
EU hearing on Microsoft antitrust case in June
Cowboys assistant coach set for surgery
Cat Stevens to Coldplay: It sure sounds like my song
| Entertainment
|
TV announcer Ed McMahon settles malpractice case
| Entertainment
|
Outlaw Ned Kelly's descendants demand his remains
Wolverine weekend box office nudged lower
| Entertainment
|
Australia detains boatload of suspected refugees
Director Polanski will not attend U.S. court hearing
| Entertainment
|
Woody Allen objects to Farrow, Soon-Yi as witnesses
| Entertainment
|
Report: NKorea operating cyber warfare unit
Nicolas Cage car stunt goes wrong in Times Square
| Entertainment
|
Australian, UK WWI dead to get military funeral
Faster-paced Da Vinci Code sequel premieres in Rome
| Entertainment
|
Typhoon death toll in Philippines climbs to 25
Nepal in turmoil, Maoists threaten street protests
China plans to emulate success of Korean women
Mexico lashes out against Chinese quarantine
Pakistan peace deal under fire amid attacks
Nepal's prime minister resigns amid power struggle
NZ commodity export prices rise in April-survey
NZ new car registrations slide in April
Taiwanese tycoon challenges Buffett's investment
Indians scramble for world's cheapest car
China economic boost helps stock market rally
US, Japan press China on computer rules
Indian stocks up 6.4 pct on global recovery hopes
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Cormac McCarthy receives PEN award
"Wolverine" weekend box office nudged lower
Faster-paced "Da Vinci Code" sequel premieres in Rome
Cat Stevens to Coldplay: It sure sounds like my song
Indonesia anti-corruption chief arrested in murder
NBC takes its medicine: New nurse, paramedic shows
Nicolas Cage car stunt goes wrong in Times Square
`Twilight,' `Slumdog' lead MTV award nominees
Polanski won't appear at LA court hearing
'Wolverine' a howling success at box office
Georgia accuses Russia over foiled rebellion
| International
|
Gates says U.S. to persist with Iran overtures
Residents flee Pakistan's Swat as truce collapses
| International
|
Iranian president to meet Palestinians in Syria
Merkel recalls brutal Communism at Stasi prison
| International
|
Israel angered over 'biased' UN report on Gaza war
Spain could open second Guantanamo torture probe
| International
|
UN refugee body: Security improved in Iraq's south
Arrest of top activists shakes Zimbabwe unity deal
China to stage 50,000-troop military drill: report
| International
|
Iran court to hear U.S. reporter's appeal
Fiat's grand plans hit resistance
Gates says U.S. to persist with Iran overtures
| International
|
Hopefuls sign up for Iranian election
Adidas net profit sinks 97% in first quarter
Around 30 reported killed in Afghan clashes
U.S. presses new Israeli government to back two-state solution
| International
|
Swiss bank UBS issues corporate credit warning
Netanyahu ready for peace talks
US banks may need more funds
Greek court rules first same-sex weddings invalid
| International
|
Jimmy Fallon takes top Webby award
| Technology
|
EU issues consumer online rights, lists action ideas
| Technology
|
Former Fla. House Speaker will seek US Senate seat
US anti-trust inquiry into Google, Apple
Mass. man charged in family plot keeps guilty plea
Car crashes into eatery in NY movie stunt; 2 hurt
Vivendi CEO Levy to chair Activision Blizzard
White House to seek input on education law
Bigger Kindle e-reader may not be a newspaper fix
| Technology
|
California judge blunts Internet false advertising law
Vivendi CEO Levy to chair Activision Blizzard
| Technology
|
US reporter's appeal to be heard next week in Iran
Georgia troops mutiny, govt accuses Russia
On May 5, Mexican dominance irks other Latinos
Pregnancy may help Briton avoid firing squad: Laos
Iran to hear appeal soon for jailed US reporter
Laid-off Mo. factory worker, 65, trains to be cop
Mental health courts increase despite debate
Taos events mark 'Easy Rider' anniversary, '60s
A year on, 'number two' view still dogs Medvedev
Conservatives tipped for EU vote win
Police: Homemade liquor kills 15 in eastern India
Star Trek aims to stun fans
| Entertainment
|
Sri Lanka says rebel leader trapped
Friends give Tilda Swinton alcoholic inspiration
| Entertainment
|
Two Koreas prepare further Kaesong estate talks
Billy Elliot leads race for Tony Award
| Entertainment
|
SKorea finds first Asia case of person-to-person flu
Fans beam about new Star Trek: online poll
| Entertainment
|
Mexicans leave China quarantine on chartered plane
Jimmy Fallon takes top Webby award
| Entertainment
|
Search for US poet in Japan to be scaled down
Plane arrives for Mexicans held in quarantine
Koreas consulting over new round of official talks
China reject latest US report on religious freedom
ADB chief sees signs of Chinese recovery
Philippine inflation dips to 4.8 percent in April
Pakistani share market edgy over fighting in NW
China shares hit 9-month high on rebound hopes
Philippine inflation slows to 4.8 pct
Asian lender under scrutiny after capital boost
An Obama bump for lucky novelist
China's Hainan Airlines halves Embraer jets order
Friends give Tilda Swinton alcoholic inspiration
Malaysia's ex-PM made adviser to national airline
Rihanna returns to red carpet at New York gala
Bangladesh remittances up despite global recession
White Stripes drummer Meg White to wed this year
'Idol' finalist Lambert impresses rocker Slash
GM says China sales set new record in April
Superstore chain looks to `make' hits
Pine makes maiden voyage as `Trek' Captain Kirk
`Angels & Demons' premieres in Rome with Tom Hanks
Israel's Hebrew Catholics keep the faith
Australia may pay for obesity surgery: report
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights