Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Hillary movie puts campaign finance limits at risk
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Hillary movie puts campaign finance limits at risk
By JESSE J. HOLLAND and MARK SHERMAN,Associated Press Writers AP - Sunday, September 6
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court appears poised to wipe away limits on campaign spending by corporations and labor unions in time for next year's congressional elections in a case that began as a dispute over a movie about Hillary Rodham Clinton.
ADVERTISEMENT
The justices return to the bench Sept. 9 _ nearly a month early _ to consider whether to overrule two earlier decisions that restrict how and when corporations and unions can take part in federal campaigns. Laws that impose similar limits in 24 states also are threatened.
The court first heard arguments in March in the case of whether "Hillary: The Movie," a scathingly critical look at Clinton's presidential ambitions, could be regulated as a campaign ad. The emphasis has shifted away from the 90-minute film.
Now the justices could decide whether corporations and unions should be treated differently from individuals when it comes to campaign spending. Restrictions on corporations have been around for more than 100 years; limits on unions date from the 1940s.
Deep corporate and labor pockets and the potential for corruption "amply justify treating corporate and union expenditures differently from those by individuals and ideological nonprofit groups," argued Sens. John McCain, R-Ariz., and Russ Feingold, D-Wis., and other sponsors of a major campaign finance law who don't want any significant change to the restrictions.
But former Solicitor General Theodore Olson, who six years ago defended the campaign finance provision he now is challenging, said the limits are strangling corporate and union freedom to speak out.
"Why is it easier to dance naked, burn a flag or wear a T-shirt profanely opposing the draft," Olson said at a Federalist Society event in July, "than it is to advocate the election or defeat of a president? That cannot be right."
Wednesday's unusual session _ the court only rarely orders a case to be reargued _ also will be the first to include the newest justice, Sonia Sotomayor. In August, the 55-year-old New Yorker became the court's first Hispanic and third female justice ever.
It also will be the first argument for Solicitor General Elena Kagan, a finalist for the high court seat that went to Sotomayor. Yet another former solicitor general, Seth Waxman, is representing McCain and Feingold in an effort to preserve the 2003 provision that tightened limits on ads paid for by corporations and unions and broadcast close to an election.
Kagan, defending the law on the government's behalf, and Waxman will face skeptical conservative-leaning justices, who appear to hold the upper hand on this issue. The court's liberals generally have voted to uphold campaign finance laws. Sotomayor's ascension to the court did not change its ideological balance, giving opponents of the current campaign finance laws hope this court will strike them down.
The court could have decided the case narrowly following arguments on March 24. Instead, on the last day they met before their summer break, the justices said they would consider overruling part of their 2003 decision that upheld major portions of the McCain-Feingold law as well as a 1990 decision that upheld limits on corporate spending in elections.
Three justices on the court now _ Anthony Kennedy, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas _ already have signed minority opinions that advocated striking down both laws as unconstitutional restrictions on speech. Since the 2003 decision, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito have joined the court. Both have questioned the validity of campaign finance laws, but have not yet gone as far as their three conservative-leaning colleagues.
Roberts and Alito made clear during the original arguments how much they worried about the control the campaign finance laws give government over political speech.
"If Wal-Mart airs an advertisement that says, `We have candidate action figures for sale, come buy them,' that counts as an electioneering communication?" Roberts asked government lawyer Malcolm Stewart.
"If it's aired in the right place at the right time, that would be covered," Stewart said.
Stewart later added that campaign finance laws could be applied to mediums such as books and e-books. "That's pretty incredible," Alito said. "You think that if a book was published, a campaign biography that was the functional equivalent of express advocacy, that could be banned?"
Olson picked up on Alito's incredulity in his brief to the court. "Enough is enough. When the government of the United States of America claims the authority to ban books because of their political speech, something has gone terribly wrong and it is as sure a sign as any that a return to first principles is in order," he said.
Olson is representing Citizens United, a conservative not-for-profit group that wanted to air ads for the anti-Clinton movie and distribute it through video-on-demand services on local cable systems during the 2008 Democratic primary campaign.
But federal courts said the movie looked and sounded like a long campaign ad, and therefore should be regulated like one.
The justices could have decided the case on narrow grounds this year, saying for example that movies aired on-demand are exempt from campaign finance laws.
The call for new arguments to address the broader limits on corporate and union spending makes supporters of those laws nervous.
"This has the potential to unleash massive corporate spending," said Democracy 21 president Fred Wertheimer, a longtime proponent of limiting money in politics. "It would be a disaster for democracy."
___
The case is Citizens United v. FEC, 08-205.
___
On the Net:
"Hillary: The Movie": http://www.hillarythemovie.com
Federal Election Commission: http://www.fec.gov
Background on the case: http://tinyurl.com/cfltxp
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Sightseeing boat sinks in Macedonian lake; 15 deadAP - 50 minutes ago
UK-World SummaryReuters - 1 hour 42 minutes ago
Fire no longer threatening LA-area communitiesAP - 1 hour 43 minutes ago
Obama adviser Van Jones resigns amid controversyAP - 2 hours 54 minutes ago
Mexico catches suspect in border incursion, deathsAP - 2 hours 58 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Appetite spells three wolves' doom in Switzerland
Poignant final farewell as Jackson laid to rest
US unemployment hits 9.7%, job losses narrow further
First baby born from new egg-screening technique
Chappaquiddick 'haunts me,' Kennedy said
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Sunday, 6 September 2009 Turkey's FM sure of eventual EU membership despite critics
No room for complacency on economy, IMF chief warns
Iran's Mousavi defiant after MPs back Ahmadinejad
Iran's Mousavi defiant after MPs back Ahmadinejad
| International
|
US sees global growth but 'challenges' ahead
Iran's Mousavi vows to fight poll 'fraud'
Marches for, against Chavez in divided Venezuela
| International
|
Woman's case reflects prisoners' treatment in Iran
Holy city twist: Arabs moving into Jewish areas
Russia says N. Caucasus rebels shot: report
| International
|
Twenty-five killed in south Sudan fighting
Mexico nabs suspected killer of 17 rehab patients
| International
|
Suspects released in Sarkozy death threats probe
| International
|
US, SKorea in top-level talks on NKorean nuclear programme
US general: Afghan civilians wounded at bomb site
Top official in China's volatile Urumqi sacked
After 8-year delay, VA program hopes to help vets
Transgender activist runs for mayor of Idaho town
China sacks top officials over Xinjiang unrest
Okada to be Japan's new foreign minister: Hatoyama
China boycotts opening of Taiwan-hosted games
NY mom charged after posing kids with guns
City leader sacked over China protests
US general inspects Afghan tanker airstrike site
'Terror' witness can sue senior Bush official: US court
US terror suspect fails to show in Pakistan court
Missing boy found alive, hidden at grandma's home
Pilot injured in Teterboro, NJ, crash dies
Recession hits nest eggs; US promotes ways to save
Obama's back-to-school message is responsibility
India promises $10 bln bond purchase: IMF
Chinatrust offers $2.4 bln for AIG Taiwan unit-source
Debts closing in on photographer Annie Leibovitz
'Accident' defies Hong Kong thriller genre
Austrian family seeks return of painting sold to Hitler: report
Calif. house owned by Groucho Marx for sale
German cineaste Herzog to teach 'guerrilla filmmaking'
Herzog screens 2 Golden Lion contenders
Michael Moore brings capitalist lovefest to Venice
Filmmaker Herzog is up against himself in Venice
US-Russia deal on Afghan flights takes effect
Anti-nuclear protest march against German U-turn
Ex-Google China chief to fund Chinese tech start-ups
Calm returns to China's Urumqi after officials sacked
| International
|
Astronauts conduct final spacewalk of Discovery mission
Vietnam frees blogger ahead of Australia visit
IEDs wreak havoc among foreign forces in Afghanistan
U.S. seeks clarity from North Korea on uranium
| International
|
US general promises Afghans inquiry into NATO air strike
Mexico nabs suspected killer of 17 rehab patients
| International
|
Six South Koreans missing in river near border
| International
|
Ex-Google China chief to fund Chinese tech start-ups
| Technology
|
Vietnam frees blogger ahead of Australia visit
| Technology
|
Obama adviser Van Jones resigns amid controversy
Malaysia Muslim protest derails Hindu temple plan
Magnitude-4.0 quake shakes Central Coast of Calif.
Call for firm action in China's restive Xinjiang
Hillary movie puts campaign finance limits at risk
3 killed, 880 people rescued from Philippine ferry
INSIDE WASHINGTON: A lawmaker's long reach
Vietnam reports 3rd swine flu death
Airplane trade ruling comes in era of bailouts
Vietnam police release detained blogger
U.S. seeks clarity from North Korea on uranium
For many, Labor Day just another stressful day
Dem negotiator: Time here for health care action
Myanmar's ethnic challenges in elections: analysts
Health care effort could depend on Maine's Snowe
Six South Koreans missing in river near border
Hong Kong reports 11th swine flu death
Top official in volatile Chinese city sacked
Crews dodge flying corks in Wyo. wine truck fire
US kidnapper Garrido told mum victim was his daughter
McDonald's takes McCurry to court again in Malaysia
G20 leaders left to-do list ahead of summit
SKorean TV giants tout differing technologies
Nokia strikes back against 'smart' rivals
India's budget airlines leave rivals in vapour stream
Apple's iPhone launch in China no easy task: experts
Hand gel on menu as Madrid restaurant fights swine flu
AIG sells asset management unit for $500 million
Suzuki Motor to build new auto plant in India: report
Weather presenters grapple with uncertain climate
Twilight life of Malaysia's Muslim transsexuals
'Sopranos' actor Imperioli directs first film
Moore pulls no punches in 'Capitalism: A Love Story'
Suspect released in probe of French filmmaker's death
In economic crisis, SAfrica designers practice 'chic-onomics'
Israel will approve new settlement homes: minister
New revelations add twist to ex-French PM's trial
Hundreds rescued from sinking ferry in Philippines
| International
|
British business chiefs upbeat about economy
Karzai inches toward Afghan poll win
| International
|
Israel to approve settlement expansion: minister
Israeli Cabinet backs new West Bank construction
Chevron awaits verdict in environmental damage case
Israel affirms plans to approve more settler homes
UK denies putting Libya first in IRA victims' row
| International
|
Israel PM to OK 100s of new settlements: minister
Kuwait to keep Citigroup, Merrill Lynch stakes: report
Israel affirms plans to approve more settler homes
| International
|
Yemen rebels deny breaking truce
| International
|
Iran says develops stealth missile interceptor system
| International
|
Mother comes out against Dutch girl's solo sail
| International
|
Police, poll protesters clash in Gabon's oil hub
| International
|
Fire no longer threatening LA-area communities
Former Australia PM Howard home from hospital stay
Workers find Bay Bridge crack; Shutdown could last
Okada to be next Japan foreign minister, media say
Obama's environmental adviser resigns: report
Philippine troops kill 4 communist rebels in south
Palestinians 'seriously considering' one-state
Nine dead as Philippines ferry sinks
China's Urumqi still edgy after officials sacked
Hundreds rescued from sinking ferry in Philippines
NKorea produces part 2 of Kim Jong Il documentary
Japanese prince, 1st male heir in decades, turns 3
3 policemen found shot in head in Pakistan
Lehman investors in Hong Kong protest central bank
US eyes recovery year after near financial meltdown
Michael Jackson glove fetches $49,000 in Australia
"Capitalism is evil," says new Michael Moore film
Michael Jackson's glove auctioned in Australia
Capitalism is evil, says new Michael Moore film
| Entertainment
|
US libraries hit back over challenges to kids books
Michael Jackson glove fetches $49,000 in Australia
| Entertainment
|
Roma kids discover the power of school
Lasseter sees more chance for animation at Oscars
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights