Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Star Wars fans seem angered by 3D release plans
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Email
Print
Reprints
Read
Factbox: Islamist militant attacks in Europe
29 Sep 2010
Yuan slips; China signals displeasure over US bill
29 Sep 2010
China says U.S. yuan bill could harm ties
|
3:39am EDT
About 1 in 4 Q2 home sales a foreclosure: report
12:13am EDT
Gym culture not working out for the French
28 Sep 2010
Shared
McDonald's may drop health insurance: report
29 Sep 2010
Doping-Cyclist Contador suspended for "adverse finding"
29 Sep 2010
Buffett and Jay-Z trade tips in Forbes interview
22 Sep 2010
U.S. systemic risk council set to meet Oct. 1
15 Sep 2010
Factbox: Islamist militant attacks in Europe
29 Sep 2010
Watched
Red faces over top model gaff
Tue, Sep 28 2010
Mexican mayor stoned to death
Tue, Sep 28 2010
Glowing new fluorescent angelfish
Sun, Sep 26 2010
"Star Wars" fans seem angered by 3D release plans
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related News
"Stars Wars" blasts back into theaters in 3D
Wed, Sep 29 2010
Related Topics
Fashion »
Entertainment »
Zagat Power Lunches »
Film »
A man dressed as Star Wars character Darth Vader poses for photographers at the ''Star Wars: Where Science Meets Imagination'' exhibition at the Powerhouse Museum in Sydney in this December 3, 2008 file photo.
Credit: Reuters/Daniel Munoz
By Jay A. Fernandez and Borys Kit
Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:25am EDT
LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - Like a lightsaber to the midsection, reactions to news that George Lucas is planning to rerelease 3D versions of the "Star Wars" sextet have been swift and, more often than not, deadly.
But when the Force actually is with them, will fans be able to stay away?
For every "I'll be first in line," there are another 20-30 Web comments along the lines of "SW is just a machine now," "I'll stay away in droves," "Lucas is beating a dead horse" or "Never have I seen something so amazing be systematically destroyed."
Lucas and Fox plan to rerelease the "Star Wars" franchise in state-of-the-art 3D conversions beginning in 2012 with one film annually led by the much-mocked prequels. That means the original "Star Wars" and its two sequels won't start rolling out until 2015.
The rolling theatrical releases inevitably would set up 3D DVD versions that would facilitate the ultimate home-viewing experience once 3D-capable televisions have become fixtures in four to six years.
A specific date for the first release, "The Phantom Menace," has not been announced, but sources said Fox and Lucas are looking at a mid-February launch.
On paper, the news should be every fanboy's dream. The groundbreaking nature and scope of Lucas's original trilogy, launched in 1977, have practically begged for a 3D treatment to match its ambitions. But for many of the die-hards, that starship has long since sailed.
A lot has happened in the three decades between the theatrical release of "Return of the Jedi" in 1983 and what will be the first of the new 3D versions. For one thing, Lucas made three other movies in the saga, which were almost universally panned. He also has already done several rereleases and recuts of the original trilogy that updated the effects and added new or deleted footage in ways that many found sacrilegious (see: the widespread "Han Shot First" campaign, or Alexandre O. Philippe's documentary "The People vs. George Lucas," which had its world premiere at SXSW this year).
For those with a negative view of the post-1983 "Star Wars" output, the idea of yet another iteration -- especially using a conversion process many have found lacking in recent releases such as "Clash of the Titans" and "The Last Airbender" -- is cause for great despair.
"People are just too down on conversions," said Jeremy Smith, West Coast editor of Ain't It Cool News. "It doesn't even matter what the film is -- with the exception of animation. The conversations have gone from 'F--- conversion' to 'George Lucas is a money-grubbing whatever.'
"There has been some enthusiasm for the new development. A lot of parents, who grew up during the original fever, are excited for their kids (and grandkids) to see the original films in the theater. And some just can't get enough "Star Wars," no matter what the reservations.
For those on the fence, their loyalty remains partially intact but devoted only to the original trilogy. (NotMalcolmRee'sd comment on Ain't It Cool News is typical: "i will not sit thru the prequels again even in 10 dimensions.")
Many wish Lucas would do something new rather than keep futzing with the existing movies -- even make a seventh film in the series or a whole new trilogy with new characters, in 3D or otherwise. But in the absence of that, just how many fans would be willing to bypass the chance to see what Lucas would do with 3D?
"My gut feeling is that it will do well, on the level of what the '97 releases did," Smith said. "They'll get the die-hards out, they'll get people taking their kids. These kids are as into 'Star Wars' as their parents. And kids don't have the hatred toward 'Star Wars' as people in my generation."
The 1997 "special edition" rereleases of "Star Wars," "The Empire Strikes Back" and "Return of the Jedi" grossed $138 million, $68 million and $45 million, respectively. Notable is the decline in interest as the trilogy progresses (most loyalists place the first two as the only genuine classics), with the second trilogy -- the prequels -- drawing limitless derision despite having grossed more during release.
Returns on a 3D rerelease of "Phantom Menace," the first scheduled, are likely to be significantly less than a 3D rerelease of "Star Wars" or "Empire" and thus a questionable test case for future conversions.
Fashion
Entertainment
Zagat Power Lunches
Film
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 30 September 2010 Iran puts off Bushehr plant launch to early 2011
US-TECH Summary
Indonesia lifts tsunami warning after 7.2 quake
|
U.S. envoy sees Netanyahu in bid to save talks
Europe hands France ultimatum in Roma row
E-books may spur more kids to read-study
U.S. judge grants bond to man in Afghan murder case
|
Workers swarm Europe's streets in anti-cuts protests
NATO confirms senior al-Qaida commander killed
TED conference wants ads worth spreading
Lost letters add a twist to DNA breakthrough
Study: Americans Drinking More Now Than in 1990s
Hitmen kill Mexican mayors as drugs war intensifies
|
FIFA track transfers with new online system
Companies sue Air France, Martinair for price fixing: lawyer
U.S. targets eight Iranian officials over abuses
|
WTO calls on US to cut farm subsidies
DHS Exercise Tests U.S. Response To Cyberattack
Final results give Chavez slim Venezuela vote win
|
Man Takes DJ's Bet, Tattoos Station's Logo On His Forehead
Boeing Gets $19Million Contract From U.S. Navy
Washington Post, NY Times, Gannett invest in news aggregator
China Airline Orders 4 Boeing Jets Worth $1.1 Billion
US, China to resume military contacts: Pentagon
Enbridge Restarts Michigan Pipeline Two Months After Oil Spill
Samsung to provide 3D TVs to Britain's Virgin Media
Italy's Berlusconi wins confidence vote
|
"Let Me In," "Case 39, "Chain Letter" Mark Horror-Filled October In Theaters
India's ID scheme launched in tribal village
HP Gets Floridas $20M Early Education Plan
Medvedev worries Japan with islands visit plan
Vietnam arrests three over porn websites: reports
NATO: No Genuine Negotiations Yet, Taliban Reconciliation Talks In Embryonic Stage
Japanese smokers stocking up before price hike
Kohls Opens 21 Stores, Adds 4,000 Jobs
Fearing holy site unrest, India bans bulk texting
Philippines launches online disaster hotspots map
U.S. appeals court allows stem cell funds to continue
Singapore's Lee hospitalized with infection
U.S. senator wants Afghanistan funds inspector fired
E-books may spur more kids to read-study
Dell pitches open system in data center offering
|
Bankers battle for Lehman souvenirs at London auction
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
E-books may spur more kids to read-study
|
Samsung to provide 3D TVs to Britain's Virgin Media
Leonard Cohen cancels Hawaii show, adds 3 dates
Director Arthur Penn dies at age 88
Indonesia cancels tsunami alert after major quake
Tony Danza turns teacher for TV show
Major 7.2 quake hits eastern Indonesia: USGS
'Bonnie and Clyde' director Arthur Penn dies
Indonesia lifts tsunami warning after 7.2 quake
Cross-dressing meets boy-girl duos on Paris catwalks
Family saga to represent Italy at Oscars
Russian ministry confirms ban on art for Louvre
Women activists in Jerusalem hail lifting of modesty barrier
Obama, US House target China over currency
China wins WTO backing in chicken fight with US
Travelers cancel JAL flights amid Japan-China row
Snooki takes romance from hot tub to book world
|
Fact or fiction? Facebook film the latest truth tale
|
Goldman Sachs to reduce stake in China's ICBC
Michael Caine says might retire at 80
|
Director Arthur Penn dies at age 88
|
Pakistan raises interest rate by 0.5 percent
Britney Spears praises Glee tribute
|
Renault-Nissan open to GM tie-up: Ghosn
Tony Danza turns teacher for TV show
|
Chinese sales help Porsche set new record: company
Leonard Cohen cancels Hawaii show, adds 3 dates
|
FACTBOX-Pakistan's c.bank ups key rate by 50 bps to 13.5 pct
Foreign soldier killed in south Afghanistan: NATO
Al-Qaeda plot to attack European cities uncovered
Special report: How Dubai got serious
|
Nintendo 3DS delay casts gloom over games giant
Pakistan officials accuse NATO of chopper killings
Italy's Berlusconi survives confidence vote
Anglo Irish Bank bailout hits 29.3 bln euros
North Korea's leader-in-waiting goes on show
|
Republicans scuttle net neutrality bill: Waxman
ADHD down to genes not poor parenting, says study
Warlords taint Afghan peace council: analysts
Spanish police detain three ETA suspects, seize explosives
Mosque verdict keeps India on security tenterhooks
|
Lawmakers decry US failure to stop 'jihadi websites'
US orders sanctions against Iran officials for rights abuses
Congress Hears Pentagon Plans For Improving Financial Accountability
Italy's Berlusconi wins vote of confidence
Pakistan says 3 soldiers killed in NATO strike
|
Melissa Rycroft To Host Fall Baby Shower On Nickelodeon's ParentsConnect.com
Taliban reject claims of Afghan peace approaches
China releases 3 Japanese but isle dispute lingers
|
US cyber exercise providing valuable lessons: officials
France unveils toughest budget in 50 years
Suicide After College Roommate Livestreams Gay Sexual Act Online
Coordinated militant attack plot disrupted: sources
|
Ashton Kutcher Is Popchips' President Of Pop Culture For Ad Campaign
Berlusconi gets rival's support in key vote
U.N. rights body backs critique of Gaza flotilla raid
Diller bearish on future of Ask.com
Spike TV "Scream" Awards To Feature "Scream 4" Footage, "Back To The Future" Reunion
Pentagon: China, U.S. Military Relations Back On Track
EU to launch proceedings against France over Roma
NATO confirms senior al-Qaida commander killed
U.S. Sanctions 8 Iranians Over Human Rights Violations
Dell pitches open system in data center offering
Stocks Dip Despite Energy Sector Rally
Could women play a bigger role in Islamic finance?
|
China Pledges to Balance Trade as U.S. House Prepares Tariff Vote
Investment a success story in Iraqi Kurdistan
|
US-TECH Summary
Nokia says starts shipping flagship N8 model
S.Lanka president confirms jail for ex-army chief
Three Japanese held in China released: state media
China releases 3 Japanese but isle dispute lingers
Christopher Plummer joins "Dragon Tattoo"
Mosque verdict keeps India on security tenterhooks
Senator wants Afghanistan funds inspector fired
Nigerian culture thrives 50 yrs after independence
Quake rocks Samoa on tsunami anniversary
North Korea's US 'trophy' ship is tourist site
Nokia says starts shipping flagship N8 model
|
Two Koreas hold first military talks since 2008
Turkish man convicted of assault in N.Zealand
DR Congo children turn to acrobatics to survive
Facebook and Skype exploring partnership: report
|
Nintendo 3DS delay casts gloom over games giant
|
Japan defence chief eyes China talks
Camel-crazy UAE use cutting-edge breeding technology
LG and Microsoft team-up in cloud computing
|
Aussie Power seeks IndyCar season crown
Oliver Stone: What helped pay for "Wall Street 2"
Bruce Willis spies a good time in "Red"
Mobile Web usage jumped in August: Opera
|
James Cameron gets close look at Canada's oil sands
E-books may spur more kids to read: study
|
Jerry Lee Lewis' 40 minute set unites generations
Republicans scuttle net neutrality bill: Waxman
|
Judge dismisses 2 charges in Anna Nicole drug trial
China: US bill on yuan would violate WTO rules
Japan to withdraw from Iran oil project: reports
Seoul shares move sideways; airlines gain
Korea NPS to invest $1 billion in Asian property
RPT-SCENARIOS-Taiwan central bank seen hiking rates again
Japan factory output slips 0.3 percent in August
South Korea bonds rise on weak factory output data
Seoul shares open up; techs continue gains
Moody's maintains NZ's Aaa stable outlook
Star Wars fans seem angered by 3D release plans
|
Fact or fiction? Facebook film the latest truth tale
|
Nokia says starts shipping flagship N8 model
Jon Stewart says rallies satirical, not political
|
Judge dismisses 2 charges in Anna Nicole drug trial
|
Christopher Plummer joins Dragon Tattoo
|
Oliver Stone: What helped pay for Wall Street 2
|
Bruce Willis spies a good time in Red
|
Afghan opium output drops 50 percent: UN
Germany tries woman in Baader-Meinhof murder
US, Euro diplomats strive to save Mideast talks
Pakistan stops NATO supplies entering Afghanistan
Technip Gets Two Hydrogen Plant Contracts
Pakistan halts NATO supplies after border attack
|
U.S. Funds $1 Billion For Anti-Greenhouse Gas Facility
Congress Passes Stopgap To Fund Government; Goes On Recess
US-TECH Summary
Car bomber in south Afghanistan kills 3 civilians
France says Niger hostage images offer hope
|
Kurdish rebels to extend ceasefire by one month
|
FTC Slams Juice Maker For Unproven Health Claims
Nokia says starts shipping flagship N8 model
Quito international airport shuts during unrest
|
Snooki To Publish Her First Novel
LG and Microsoft team-up in cloud computing
Taliban reject Karzai's peace council as failed
|
Feds Urge Parents Not To Put Babies In Sleep Positioners
Myanmar to free Suu Kyi days after election: officials
"DWTS" Producers Don't Think Judge Bruno Tonioli Should Apologize To Michael Bolton
Doctors Successfully Use Less Chemo To Treat Common Childhood Cancer
Dutch government pact cuts budget and bans burqa
|
North Korea publishes first photo of heir apparent
Denmark Tops List Of Best Countries To Do Business
Italy's Northern League ramps up anti-Rome rhetoric
|
Indian Ayodhya holy site to be divided: lawyer
Stuxnet 'cyber superweapon' moves to China
Oscar-nominated actor Tony Curtis dies: report
North Korea's leader-in-waiting goes on show
US and Europe toil to save Israel-Palestinian peace talks
Actor Tony Curtis dies: US media
Pakistan halts NATO supplies after border attack
Indian court rules disputed holy site to be divided
Thai PM has final say on Viktor Bout extradition
China warns US bill on yuan could hurt trade ties
Japanese climbers missing in Nepal: official
Over 60 to be charged in Zeus Trojan cybercrime
|
Pakistani rupee at record low; stocks flat
Pakistan's forex reserves jump to record $16.79 bln
India boasts record 69 billionaires: Forbes
Berlin Wall shooting video game angers victims' relatives
|
Bomb blast injures one in Indonesia: police
Philippine officials concerned over strong currency
Nintendo shares tumble on 3DS player delay
S.Korea c.bank contacts offshore dealers on won-official
India's Satyam shares slide 9% as losses announced
AIG sells two Japanese units to Prudential Financial
Taiwan c.bank raises rates to 1.5 pct
Japan's Panasonic develops robot hair-washer
Oscar-nominated actor Tony Curtis dies
|
Berlin Wall shooting video game angers victims' relatives
CNN's Anderson Cooper eyes daytime talk show
|
Mobile Web usage jumped in August: Opera
LG and Microsoft team-up in cloud computing
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights