Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Obama's Afghan plan represents high-stakes gamble
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Obama's Afghan plan represents high-stakes gamble
By ROBERT H. REID and CHRIS BRUMMITT,Associated Press Writers -
Thursday, December 3
Send
IM Story
Print
KABUL – President Barack Obama is holding an uncertain hand in his high-stakes gamble in the fight against Islamic extremism in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Weak partners in both countries, doubts about the speed of building up Afghan security forces and allies reluctant to commit themselves wholeheartedly to the battle all raise questions about the strategy.
If all goes well, U.S. troops can begin heading home in July 2011, Obama said. The White House says Obama set this date to make sure Afghan President Hamid Karzai's government knows it has limited time to reform itself and take charge of security.
Yet nearly every step presents difficult challenges _ problems that festered over eight years of international neglect after the Bush administration shifted its attention from Afghanistan to Iraq once the U.S.-led invasion of 2001 had ousted the Taliban from power.
The threefold plan, unveiled Tuesday during a speech at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, New York, calls for:
_ Sending 30,000 U.S. reinforcements to reverse the Taliban's momentum and bolster Afghanistan's security forces within 18 months.
_ An accelerated program to boost the notoriously weak and corrupt Afghan government.
_ Partnership with Pakistan, where many al-Qaida figures including Osama bin Laden are believed hiding.
The NATO chief says America's European partners will contribute more than 5,000 new troops to the international force in Afghanistan, which currently consists of 70,000 U.S. troops and about 30,000 other NATO-led personnel. Nevertheless, most of the pledges have come in small numbers. European powers like France praised Obama's speech but remained silent on offering new troops.
Even with greater support, both Afghanistan and Pakistan are led by weak governments that lack the political power to meet some of America's goals.
Key to a quick exit are the Afghan army and police. Afghan officials themselves question whether 18 months is enough time for a complete handoff to security forces _ whose combat capabilities are reduced by a primitive system for supplying troops with food, fuel and ammunition without NATO's help.
There are differences within the U.S. leadership itself over how large a force Afghanistan needs.
Current plans call for boosting Afghan forces to 134,000 army soldiers and 96,800 police by next October. The Afghan army currently numbers about 95,000 with another 93,000 police.
The top U.S. commander, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, has recommended 240,000 soldiers and 160,000 policemen _ a target he said would take at least four years to meet. The White House has not embraced the higher numbers _ in part because of concern about the costs.
Afghan officials believe a 134,000-member army is too small and expressed doubt that the country's soldiers and police would be ready to defend the country in only 18 months.
Training individual soldiers is only part of the challenge. Turning them into an effective, integrated fighting force is another.
Of the 90 Afghan army battalions, the U.S. military considers only one in three capable of fighting without NATO support. An estimated 90 percent of the recruits can't read or write when they join the army, making it difficult to operate complex military operations that require written orders and reports.
"The police are taking money from both sides _ the government and the Taliban," said Ghulam Haider Hamidi, the mayor of the southern city of Kandahar. "When we have this kind of police and military, the Afghan problem won't be solved in 20 years."
Equally challenging is dealing with the governments of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Each is critical to success, and each presents unique and nearly intractable problems.
With Afghanistan, the goal is to rid the government of corruption, including links to drug trafficking, and to bolster its ability to deliver services to its citizens _ a necessary step to win popular support. Training enough civil servants to run a government extending from Kabul to remote villages and towns nationwide will take time and resources.
Salaries are so low _ $60 a month for many district administrators _ that the government has trouble attracting talented people who won't take bribes.
In Pakistan, the challenge of building an effective partnership has been dogged by a spike in anti-Americanism led by elements of the security forces and increasing doubts over the stability of the weak, civilian government.
Since 2001, the U.S. has given the Pakistani army billions of dollars to try to get it to fight Islamic militants along the Afghan border. Starting last year, the U.S. began a sustained program of covert missile strikes against militant targets close to the border.
The results have been mixed. Militancy has spread throughout the northwest and is slowly creeping into the nuclear-armed country's heartland. Stung by the rise in attacks, the military has moved forcefully over the last year into several regions close to the Afghan border.
While the army has taken on the Pakistan Taliban, it has failed to go after Afghan Taliban leaders who base their operations in the lawless border region.
Many Western officials and analysts believe Pakistan is playing off both sides _ accepting U.S. funds to crack down on Pakistani militants while tolerating the Afghan Taliban in the expectation that the radical movement will take power in Afghanistan once the Americans withdraw.
Shaun Gregory, an expert on Pakistani security at the University of Bradford in Britain, said the Pakistanis will take note of Obama's pledge to start bringing U.S. troops home from Afghanistan in July 2011.
"The Pakistanis are smart enough to read the signals coming out of Washington," Gregory said. "It seems to me that the army's longer-term strategy of broadly backing the Afghan Taliban is paying off now. They have their tails up."
Over the last year, a succession of U.S. officials has traveled to Islamabad to stress that Washington is looking for a long-term relationship with Pakistan, not only one focused on the war against militants. But the stinging reaction to the centerpiece policy of that effort _ a $7.5 billion aid program _ was a reminder of the difficulties it faces.
The army, angry at strings attached to part of the aid that called for more civilian oversight into its affairs, criticized the government. So did large sections of the media and opposition, using it as a stick to beat President Asif Ali Zardari, who is backed by the U.S. but is desperately unpopular at home.
Last month, Zardari was forced to abandon an effort to get parliament to approve a decree issued in 2007 by his predecessor, Pervez Musharraf, granting him and thousands of others immunity from a host of corruption and criminal charges. The end of the amnesty last weekend has now raised the possibility of legal challenges to Zardari's rule.
"Pakistan has never faced a terrorist quagmire as it has faced in the recent years, and combatting terrorism requires political and economic stability," said Ishtiaq Ahmad, professor of international relations. "A political crisis is the last thing that we can afford at this stage."
Well aware of America's problems, the Afghan Taliban scoffed at Obama's plan, saying it would only lead to more American casualties.
"Throughout the history of Afghanistan, the Afghans have not been subjugated through deceits, ploys ... and military might of the foreigners," the Taliban said in a statement released in English. "Therefore, the reinforcement of the American troops and other tactics will not have impact."
___
Reid reported from Kabul, Brummitt from Islamabad. Associated Press Writer Deb Riechmann contributed to this report from Kabul.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
American, partners offer $1.1B to Japan Airlines AP - 1 hour 8 minutes ago
Vietnam's restrictions threaten progress: donors AFP - 1 hour 52 minutes ago
Troops surround Filipino massacre clan targets: army AFP - 2 hours 13 minutes ago
Vietnam finds mass grave of communist soldiers AP - 2 hours 15 minutes ago
Victims of Bhopal gas tragedy demand cleanup AP - 2 hours 17 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Comcast to announce NBC Universal deal: source
ECB seen signalling easing of crisis measures
Bank of America to repay $45 billion to US
Toxic chemicals found in a third of children's toys: study
Fed sees signs of improving job market, overall economy
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Dubai and Abu Dhabi markets plunge on debt woes
WHO changes HIV treatment advice
Dubai World to restructure parts of group including Nakheel
Trade ministers disagree on WTO Doha talks
Early intervention aids children with autism: study
More Most Viewed »
Global stocks mixed amid Dubai debt crisis
Tiny magnetic discs could kill cancer cells: study
Mankind using Earth's resources at alarming rate
Alcohol helps cut heart disease risk for men: study
Dubai blackout over debt plans to hit Gulf markets
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 3 December 2009
Iran whistleblower died from drug-laced salad
German Nazi guard trial postponed by illness: court
EA sees fewer game titles
Polanski to be bailed Friday: Swiss official
Europe agrees to cross-border financial oversight
Iran won't talk to West on nuclear program
US private sector sheds more jobs than expected
Online spending up five percent on Cyber Monday: comScore
Sperm genes could explain why women live longer
Another Iraq election law veto looms amid impasse
Google offers online news compromise
Dell to sell Polish plant to Taiwan's Foxconn
Three out of 10 Christmas lights unsafe: EU
NATO says allies will help US surge in Afghanistan
Three arrested for online 'ginger-bashing'
NATO chief urges allies to fill Afghan shortfallNATO chief urges allies to fill Afghan shortfall
Nokia predicts rebound of global mobile phone sales in 2010
Israel strips more Palestinians of Jerusalem status
Avoid flirty patients on Facebook, doctors told
Former PM's brother punches reporter
Yahoo expands integration with Facebook
Nokia predicts rebound of global mobile phone sales in 2010
Gays and transsexuals can't enter heaven: cardinal
| International
|
Google offers online news compromise
| Technology
|
Marines hold hearing for officer on Iraq deaths
Geithner says $700B bailout program will end soon
Suicide bomber kills one in Pakistan navy HQ attack
EA sees fewer game titles
| Technology
|
Report: 2,600 bodies found in Kashmir graves
Web retail a bright spot in tepid U.S. holiday season
| Technology
|
Blackwater founder Prince feels thrown under bus
Suicide bomber kills 1 at navy complex in Pakistan
New stem cell lines approved for tax-paid research
EU to give more funding to Khmer Rouge tribunal
Orszag: Health care efficiencies may take decades
World Bank to loan India $1 billion to clean up Ganges
Ohio suspect's old home searched for more bodies
Australia's carbon-trading legislation fails
No Australia poll in wake of climate law defeat
NY teen guilty of hate crime in Ecuadorean's death
A look at the 2010 Buick LaCrosse
FDIC: Poor, minorities struggle to access banks
US commander: Offer Taliban chance to end fight
Japanese painter Hirayama dies at 79
2 Chinese tourists die in Thai boating accident
Lamy warns March breakthrough needed for 2010 Doha deal
World Bank to help clean India's Ganges
Cambodia set to build 1st stock market
Experts: Harper's 1st visit to China to thaw ties
Japan premier, BOJ chief agree to fight deflation
Activists: Despair in NKorea over currency change
Japan PM, central bank vow joint effort on economy
Gold strikes record high above $1,217 an ounce
Pakistani stocks end higher; rupee weakens
Susan Boyle makes smash debut on U.S. album charts
| Entertainment
|
Japan's 'modern geisha' to form labour union
Swiss say Roman Polanski house arrest to begin Friday
| Entertainment
|
Actress Meredith Baxter says she's a lesbian
| Entertainment
|
Susan Boyle album debuts at No.1 in U.S. charts
Simon Cowell gambling on Internet Vegas talent show
| Entertainment
|
Real Madrid to launch lingerie line
Walters' 'Fascinating People' include Jackson kids
More Privacy Features To Be Added To Facebook
Croatian conductor Vjekoslav Sutej dies aged 58
Former University Of Miami Spokesperson Sentenced For Child Porn
Man Of Color Misreads 'No Color's' Sign
Swiss say Roman Polanski house arrest to begin Friday
Boy Survives Sliding Glass Door Accident, Has Arm Re-Attached
Defamation lawsuit against Dixie Chicks dismissed
Man Fondles Teen; Says Checking For Breast Cancer
Foot, Bloody Clothes Found In Missing Boy's Backyard
McChrystal Gives Full Support For New Afghan Strategy; GOP Warns Against Timelines
Strike forces Paris museums to close
Former Editor, Reporter Sue NY Post For Racism, Sexism
Longtime Tennessee Congressman, John Tanner To Retire
Swiss to place Polanski under house arrest Friday
Susan Boyle makes chart history with No.1 debut
Man Who Killed Family Members At Thanksgiving Dinner Was Invited By Father
Indonesia bans "war crimes" film Balibo
What Did Jesus Do? Christ Kicked Out Of Court
Man Of Color Misreads 'No Color's' Sign
Entire Police Force In Maguindanao Relieved As Part Of Massacre Probe
US-TECH Summary
Man Fondles Teen; Says Checking For Breast Cancer
1 In 2 Australian Adults Feel It's Okay For Children To Drink
Remains, Coffin Of German Billionaire Found In Hungary
Texas Inmate Escapes Custody During Transfer
Saudis Clamp Down On 'Cross Dressers'
Animal Aliyah: Jewish Immigration To The Holy Land Extends To Pets
"America's Toughest Sheriff" Heckled Off Stage At Journalism Forum By Singing Protestors
New EU foreign policy chief faces MEP critics
Israeli police arrest settler leader in West Bank
Honduran Congress votes against Zelaya's return
| International
|
Washington Times firing 370 employees, Miami Herald 24
Iran frees five detained British yachtsmen
Comcast to announce NBC Universal deal: source
NATO allies face U.S. pressure on Afghan troops
| International
|
US seeks to reassure Pakistan in fight against extremists
ECB seen signalling easing of crisis measures
Rebel S.Ossetia frees two Georgian teens, jails two others
Susan Boyle Scores Biggest Debut Week Of The Year On Billboard Albums Chart
Islamists claim Russian train bombing
Former Miss Argentina Dies Of Cosmetic Surgery
Bank of America to repay $45 billion to US
U.S. court jails Mexico drug kingpin for 27 years
| International
|
MySpace hopes high as launches music site in UK
James Woods Settles Negligence Case With Hospital
Karzai welcomes US timeline, Taliban escalate war
More Venezuelan private banks targeted: Chavez
| International
|
Officials: Iraq likely to postpone election
Iran to enrich uranium to higher level
Japan party threatens to leave government over U.S. base
| International
|
Jennifer Lopez's Ex-Husband Barred From Releasing Private Videos
Toxic chemicals found in a third of children's toys: study
Tiger Woods Escapes Criminal Charge, To Pay $164 Fine Over One-Car Crash
Microsoft revamps Bing online maps
Fed sees signs of improving job market, overall economy
Anthony Michael Hall Won't Be Charged Over Row With Ex-Girlfriend
Six injured in South Korean explosion
| International
|
Cisco, Juniper gear vulnerable to hacking: U.S. govt
Elisabeth Hasselbeck Sued Again By Same Author
Redbox talking with video game makers
Actor Patrick Swayze Honored With Scholarship
BBC Suspends Production Company For "Faked" Scenes On Reality Shows
Russia recession likely to dominate Putin phone-in
| International
|
Pete Doherty May Be Questioned Over A Murder Case
EBay and Craigslist battle heads to court
Struggling media will need government help: US congressman
Judge rejects Amazon bid to scrap Google pact
Nokia predicts rebound of global mobile phone sales in 2010
India's "death factory" leaves toxic legacy 25 years on
Six injured in South Korean explosion
More unidentified bodies surface at Ill. cemetery
Court: Mass criminal immigration hearings unlawful
One dead in S.Korea weapons blast: ministry
Fort Hood suspect charged with attempted murder
Judge won't end order targeting voter intimidation
Australian PM shrugs off climate bill defeat
University turns iPhones into musical instruments
| Technology
|
60 hurt in S.Korea defence institute blast: Yonhap
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,367
EBay and Craigslist battle heads to court
| Technology
|
China busts huge crystal meth gang: report
NYC tree lighting ushers in tourist season
Obama's Afghan plan represents high-stakes gamble
New Mexico man arrested in infant daughter's death
New Zealand PM to attend Copenhagen climate summit
Bhopal protests on 25th anniversary of toxic leak
Army officer, relatives sentenced in bribery plot
Evidence blocked arrest of imam with Fort Hood tie
MySpace hopes high as launches music site in UK
| Technology
|
S.Korea says N.Korea seeks to buy time to make nukes
Redbox talking with video game makers
| Technology
|
Judge rejects Amazon bid to scrap Google pact
| Technology
|
Cisco, Juniper gear vulnerable to hacking: U.S. govt
| Technology
|
Seoul shares rise 1.5 pct; LG Elec, shipyards gain
Trading in China's SAIC suspended
Delta sticks to offer to JAL for alliance
NZ commodity prices surge in November-survey
Seoul shares rise; refiners fall, shipyards gain
Peugeot to take control of Mitsubishi: report
S.Korea LPG firms face record $579 million fine
Seoul shares open 0.4 pct higher; refiners down
Beijing to hike water price to fight shortage: report
Beyonce leads Grammys, Taylor Swift close behind
Urban League Says TARP Funds Could Create 3 Million Jobs
Beyonce leads Grammys, Taylor Swift close behind
| Entertainment
|
Jackson kids among most fascinating of 2009
| Entertainment
|
MySpace Music debuts in Britain
Stricker urges Woods to air more of his private turmoil
| Entertainment
|
Holiday Spending For 2009 Assisted By Cyber Monday Up Over Last Year
Sundance lifts curtain on 2010 competition films
| Entertainment
|
Sprint Gives Government Easy Access To GPS Tracking Data
Taylor Swift inks Comcast video-on-demand deal
| Entertainment
|
Sundance festival shines light on Bhutto, Afghanistan
Four plead not guilty to celebrity burglaries
| Entertainment
|
CEO of Country Music Association leaving
Taylor Swift inks Comcast video-on-demand deal
Top 10 most-watched shows of the decade
| Entertainment
|
Jackson kids among "most fascinating" of 2009
"True Blood" casts vampire, werewolf
Arcade Fire plots spring tour
| Entertainment
|
Jack Cooke, bandmate of Ralph Stanley, dead at 72
Sundance lifts curtain on 2010 competition films
Top 10 most-watched shows of the decade
US says Afghan pullout date not fixed
Syria says Iran bus blast an accident, 3 dead
Siemens reports quarterly loss of 1 bln euros
University turns iPhones into musical instruments
McChrystal tells Afghans U.S. not leaving yet
| International
|
Europe's growth out of recession confirmed
Syria blast was 'not terrorist act': minister
EU navy arrests 13 pirates off Oman
Putin tells Russians he's here to stay
| International
|
Suicide bomber kills three Somali government ministers
| International
|
Putin accuses US of hindering Russia's WTO bid
Iraq election decision postponed until Sunday
| International
|
Russia police find bomb near train station: reports
| International
|
Israel think-tank warns EU off Swedish proposal
| International
|
Syria bus blast kills 3, terrorism ruled out
Italy to send reinforcements to Afghanistan
Pakistan kills 15 militants in restive northwest
| International
|
Serbia raids homes of suspected Mladic helpers
| International
|
China announces more death sentences for Xinjiang riot
| International
|
Philippine media may seek U.N. role in massacre probe
| International
|
PM Gilani does not think bin Laden in Pakistan
Sri Lanka group counts war casualties
How the poll on digital abuse was conducted
Turkmen leader pardons nearly 4,000 prisoners
Google CEO says not to blame for news media woes
| Technology
|
Poll finds sexting common among young people
Nepal ministers gather for Everest meeting
Bhopal protests on 25th anniversary of gas leak
Blessed are the conservative in Bible translation
A comparison of Bible verse interpretations
Obama to host jobs summit
Pakistanis kill 15 militants in northwest clashes
The nation's weather
Tests suggest 5 women raped in Philippine massacre
Analysis: Afghanistan pullout date not definite
China 'sentences five to death' over Urumqi riots
N.Korea military on guard against unrest: reports
Obama rejoining economic debate with jobs summit
2 tons of snakes, tortoises seized in Cambodia
Pentagon e-mails suggest distrust over ally Canada
EADS India JV proposal rejected: Indian partner
UAE bank chief says market overreacted to Dubai
Peugeot Citroen, Mitsubishi in parternship talks
Jackson film not part of Sony's new 3-D vision
Activists: Despair in N.Korea over currency change
Ronnie Wood arrested on suspicion of assault
| Entertainment
|
ANA, Continental, United to merge key routes: report
Tiger Woods admits transgressions, apologizes
| Entertainment
|
South Korea plans 2010 Incheon Int'l Airport IPO
World Bank chief talks up Asia role in recovery
Japan manufacturers' capital spend down 40 percent
ABC cancels Adam Lambert's Kimmel performance
| Entertainment
|
Indonesian journalists to defy 'Balibo' ban
`Twilight,' `Sopranos' stars bound for Sundance
Globalisation clouds vision of Israel's Negev desert
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
ABC cancels Adam Lambert's "Kimmel" performance
Couture must juggle the creative with the commercial
Legendary Bollywood singer given France's top award
Chopin's homeland, a magnet for Asian musical talent
Dance's Twyla Tharp gives lessons in collaboration
Beyonce tops Grammy nominations with 10 nods
Musicians overjoyed at Grammy nominations
Son Attacks Father For Loud Snoring
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights