Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Lax Indian rules still problem after Satyam fraud
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Lax Indian rules still problem after Satyam fraud
By ERIKA KINETZ,AP Business Writer -
1 hour 26 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
MUMBAI, India – One year after the founder of Satyam Computer Services made an astonishing confession to the largest fraud in Indian corporate history, many say that what really sets R. Ramalinga Raju apart is not his malfeasance, but the fact that he got caught.
"To think there aren't other companies that dabble in less than forthright practices, to believe that other companies are not doing this kind of thing is naive," said Sharmila Gopinath, research manager at Hong Kong's Asian Corporate Governance Association.
The group released a 55-page white paper on Indian corporate governance Tuesday, which suggests that many of the conditions that helped facilitate Raju's $2.5 billion fraud still exist, despite efforts to reform.
The Satyam scandal stunned India and raised questions abroad about the risks of investing in a country where improvements in regulations and corporate governance haven't kept pace with its rapid rise in economic and financial clout. With creaking infrastructure and a fast-growing population, India more than ever needs reputable markets to attract and channel private investment capital.
The report draws on the views of more than a dozen foreign institutional investors, like the California Public Employees' Retirement System, auditors, like KPMG, and law firms, like White & Case.
Their chief complaint? Controlling shareholders have too much power, a situation with roots in Indian culture and the nation's corporate regulations.
"The balance of power between the promoters and other shareholders is out of kilter," said Jamie Allen, the group's secretary general.
If that relationship isn't better calibrated, he said, foreign institutional investors _ who poured $17.5 billion into Indian equities last year _ could lose confidence in India's nascent capital markets. Some, he said, already have.
Many Indian businesses are rooted in old family empires run by men who are happy to take money from public shareholders but loathe to cede control. As a result, minority shareholders and independent directors often have little real power. That, plus inadequate regulation and lax oversight, means controlling shareholders can often manipulate a public company for their personal profit, critics say.
"India is undergoing a generational transformation," said Nishith Desai, one of Mumbai's best-known corporate lawyers. "Twenty or 30 years ago, India was very feudalistic, full of black money, bad practices, and no accountability."
Punitive tax rates of up to 97.5 percent in the late 1970s encouraged corporate sleight of hand. "Everybody did business in the black. You were not accountable to anybody. You showed poor results and false losses. You cheated the government, employees and shareholders," he said.
Economic liberalization in the early '90s _ and corporate tax rates that plummeted to 34 percent _ began to change that culture, but, he added: "Some of the old habits and legacy continue."
"The founders of a company forever thought they are the proprietors," Desai said. "They don't want to be answerable to outsiders. They've yet to understand the value good governance brings to a company."
ACGA argues that the best way to fix the problem is to empower institutional investors. It was, after all, a rare revolt by minority shareholders _ who objected to Raju's plan to drain Satyam's cash reserves to buy two property companies run by his sons _ that brought Satyam down.
Today, Raju and nine others, including two auditors from Price Waterhouse, face charges including criminal conspiracy, cheating and forgery at a court in southern India.
Weak voting rights and poor disclosure rules hinder the ability of institutional investors to play watchdog, ACGA says.
Voting by show of hands, the norm in India, gives every investor one vote, irrespective of the number of shares he or she owns. Proxies for foreign investors aren't allowed to vote by hand count or speak at shareholder meetings under Indian law.
Poor disclosure rules mean investors don't necessarily know what a company's holdings are and give controlling shareholders scope to abuse corporate linkages by, for example, overpaying for the assets of a private company they also own.
Satyam is a case in point.
Government investigators say Satyam executives started over 300 companies to invest in real estate and agriculture, buying over 1,000 properties with fraudulently acquired funds.
Those activities dragged the company far from its core software services business. But because Indian companies aren't required to disclose such corporate linkages, shareholders didn't find out how far Satyam had strayed _ and how close they were to owning a property company rather than an IT company _ until long after the fraud came to light.
Weak audits also don't help, ACGA says. They argue that India's auditing industry is too fragmented and needs an independent regulator.
Auditors also complain of getting such a run-around from Indian banks that they can't independently validate bank statements and invoices in time to meet audit deadlines, Gopinath said.
"Accounting firms started sending people to banks and having them sit there and hound people until they get what they want," she said. "If you don't validate things yourself, the likelihood of getting conned is quite high."
To be sure, not all companies are bad. Infosys, notably, has a stellar reputation, and ACGA says the top 50 to 100 Indian companies _ of which Satyam was one _ have generally good governance.
Indian regulators did implement some reforms in the wake of the Satyam scandal.
The Securities and Exchange Board of India in February 2009 mandated greater disclosure of the holdings of controlling shareholders and any pledging of those shares.
The regulator may also mandate the publication of balance sheets twice a year instead of once a year, which could help fill in holes and inconsistencies found in the unaudited quarterly reports of many Indian companies.
In December, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs published a new set of voluntary corporate governance guidelines, designed to improve board oversight and auditor independence and create a whistleblowing mechanism.
But ACGA says those measures aren't enough, and some worry that perversely, Raju's stunning fall may make it harder to root out fraudsters, who will now likely work harder to evade detection.
Raju, Gopinath said, was a victim mostly of bad timing. "If he'd waited, nobody would have known," she said. "Nobody would have been the wiser."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Universal Studios resort in SKorea to open in 2014 AP - 31 minutes ago
Google probing possible inside help on attack Reuters - 48 minutes ago
Japan Airlines bankruptcy filing expected Tuesday AP - 52 minutes ago
China shares end up slightly, c.bank move caps gains Reuters - 58 minutes ago
Nikkei falls 0.8 pct as stronger yen hits exporters Reuters - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Prince William arrives in Australia
Venezuela seizes three banks, orders two closed
Kraft set to take over Cadbury after sweetened offer
Babies pulled from the Haitian rubble
Obama's first State of the Union address set for January 27
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Surrounded by thieves, father digs for precious US visa
Obama surprises Michelle with birthday dinner
Saab drivers hit the road to support car brand
Wall Street sell-off hits Asian shares
Toyota to double global hybrid output: report
More Most Viewed »
Beat the blues by going to bed early: study
Huge tomb found at Egypt's Saqqara pyramid
Woman who saved Anne Frank's diary dead at 100
Scientists praise Obama as Doomsday clock reset
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 19 January 2010 Iran opposition urges protests on Revolution day
Ukraine hospital blast leaves 7 dead, 17 missing: officials
Google pledges cooperation with German competition probe
Wall Street sell-off hits Asian shares
Israeli PM holds historic joint cabinet meeting in Berlin
Yanukovich leads Tymoshenko in Ukraine polls
Iran hails UN indecision over further sanctions
US-TECH Summary
British tourist, several Egyptians killed in storms
Turkey blocking 3,700 websites, reform needed: OSCE
Movie Critic Roger Ebert Blasts Rush Limbaugh, Says He Should Be Horse-Whipped
UK High Court rules for Nokia vs IPCom
Iraq instructs lawyers to take on Blackwater cases
Germany warns Iran it faces new sanctions
|
Gunmen kill 5 people at Baghdad aid office
ASML Q4 order book seen to signal tech rebound
Turk who shot Pope John Paul released from prison
Toronto 18 bomb plotter gets 12 years
|
Handset market recovery in focus after weak 2009
Iraq instructs lawyers to take on Blackwater cases
|
Moderate quake rocks Guatemala, Salvador; no damage
|
Iraqis authorize government to sue Blackwater
Somali pirates free oil tanker for record ransom
|
Iran city prosecutor assassinated: report
|
Israel and Vatican negotiating over holy sites
UK High Court rules for Nokia vs IPCom
Major attacks in Afghanistan's capital
Taliban militants attack Afghan capital; 12 killed
Obama joins honors for slain civil rights leader
Lending a hand: Ways the Obamas have helped out
US soldier born in Haiti asks to leave Afghanistan
Apple to host event January 27, tablet expected
|
Civil rights icon King remembered in hometown
Thai Cabinet replacements take oath of office
Sanctions 'must end' before nuclear talks: N.Korea
5 people shot to death in southeast Texas
Exxon tanker loses power at Prince William Sound
US man in Cambodia arrested on child porn charge
Calif. woman killed in Colo. heli-skiing accident
Militants kill anti-Taliban militiaman in Pakistan
FDA debates tougher cancer warning on tanning beds
Nepal hands over detained Tibetans to UN agency
Analysis: Campaign traits carry over to presidency
Rare bird's breeding ground found in Afghanistan
Montana governor does it his own way
FBI reviews cases where flawed evidence used
Japan Airlines deal talks 'going well': KLM
Golden Globes shines with TV audience boost
Stead, Pinkney win top children's book awards
Singer Billy Bragg to stop paying taxes over bank bonuses
Morocco's Berbers get their own TV channel
Golden Globe parties full of celebs, booze, rain
Country music hitmaker Carl Smith dies at 82
Cancer-stricken actor Dennis Hopper divorcing wife
|
Singer Billy Bragg to stop paying taxes over bank bonuses
|
Avatar passes $500 million at U.S. box office
|
Midwives, Economists Forecast Baby Boom In U.K.
British Physicists Tie Light In Knots
U.K. Retailer Launches Gift List Registry For Newly Divorced People
Bangladeshi Farmers Can Open Bank Account With Only 14 Cents
Duck Hunters Trigger False Alarm At Texas Nuke Weapons Assembly Plant
Kabul on high alert after brazen Taliban strikes
Juncker bids to revamp eurozone governance
Haiti aid picks up, doctors fear disease risk
|
LCD makers set for strong first half after Q4 slowdown
Prince William arrives in Australia
Venezuela seizes three banks, orders two closed
Pro-Russia rivals face-off in Ukraine presidential run-off
Afghan troops vital cog in anti-Taliban surge
Apple tablet computer expected at January 27 event
Kraft set to take over Cadbury after sweetened offer
Taliban reconciliation unlikely: Gates
In a first, Obama 'tweets' visit to aid center for Haiti
Babies pulled from the Haitian rubble
Jawbone makes talk pretty and smart
Obama's first State of the Union address set for January 27
Pakistani 'Al Qaeda' scientist trial begins in NY
Gates praises India restraint after Mumbai attacks
|
Turkey should 'reform or abolish' Internet law: OSCE
Defiant Obama defends first White House year
Surrounded by thieves, father digs for precious US visa
Sony to sign deal with Simon Cowell: report
Apple to host event January 27, tablet expected
|
Prince William lands in Australia for 3-day visit
LCD makers set for strong first half after Q4 slowdown
|
Taiwan to consider canceling Haitian debt
Life sentence for ex-China Supreme Court justice
Obama to seek $1.35 billion more for education
Gates calls for closer defense ties to India
US, Japan mark 50 years since security pact signed
Report: More men get economic boost from marriage
Extreme cold affects millions in northwest China
Report: FBI illegally collected phone records
Bodies of China peacekeepers lost in Haiti return
Some evacuations lifted in Calif. as storm tapers
Taiwan-China likely to delay trade talks: official
Former gov backs Poizner in CA gubernatorial race
Top Chinese judge jailed for life for graft
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
NBA star Mutombo honored for deeds in native Congo
Portland man's body found in backyard sinkhole
Cancer-stricken Dennis Hopper divorcing wife
Depp says sexiest man title is a 'joke'
Lax Indian rules still problem after Satyam fraud
Japan Airlines bankruptcy filing expected Tuesday
Taiwan raises overnight rate to rein in liquidity
Universal Studios to build theme park in S.Korea
Asian stocks lackluster ahead of more US earnings
NBC chief defends role in late-night debacle
|
Sony to sign deal with Simon Cowell: report
PAKISTAN
Australia: Qantas execs not focus of Vietnam probe
TV seen enjoying 2010, e-readers could struggle
|
Major redevelopment for Australian Open unveiled
Obama's State of Union speech forces TV shuffle
|
Leno anticipates return to 11:30, lauds O'Brien
Seoul shares rise helped by banks; gains limited
Obama's State of Union speech forces TV shuffle
Sony to sign deal with Simon Cowell: report
|
Japan Airlines set for bankruptcy filing
Clean, green cycling emerges from doping era
Obama's Popularity Slips But African Americans Still Supportive
"Country Gentleman" Carl Smith dies, age 82
Technology Enables Record Haiti Donations Via Mobile Giving
Cancer-stricken Dennis Hopper divorcing wife
|
Cancer-stricken Dennis Hopper divorcing wife
Election Watchdog Groups Fearful Of Electronic Voting Fraud In Massachusetts Senate Election
Country Gentleman Carl Smith dies, age 82
|
Small Plane Crashes In Iowa; 1 Wounded
TV seen enjoying 2010, e-readers could struggle
Seattle Middle School Suspends Students For Alleged Cyberbullying
Former Sen. Norm Coleman Won't Run For Minnesota Governor
Hunt for Russia's famed Amber Room leads to Nazi bunker
FDA Will Not Regulate BPA For Now
Depp says sexiest man title is a 'joke'
Family Of Five Found Dead In Texas Home
Israeli soldier discharged over protest sign
Google postpones Android phone launch in China
Cadbury melts into Kraft with $19bln takeover
China urges flexibility on Iran, downplays sanctions
|
Google probing possible inside help on attack
Yemen Shi'ite rebel leader alive but wounded
|
Iran police say public help in arresting "rioters"
Pakistan blocks agenda at U.N. disarmament conference
|
Taliban attack shows tactical skill, military limits
|
Iran welcomes West's new 'realism' on nuclear drive
Iran says arrests 4 suspects in prosecutor's killing
|
Iraq instructs lawyers to take on Blackwater cases
|
Nearly 150 dead in clashes in Nigerian city
|
Iran leader warns opposition ahead of revolution day
|
Cuba political prisoner tally drops in 2009
|
Google postpones cellphone launch in China
|
China says Google no exception to the law
|
War refugees struggle to rebuild in Sri Lanka
Pakistani soldier killed in Indian firing
New York Times may charge for online content: report
|
Vietnam to try democracy activists for subversion
Vietnam sentences 6 drug traffickers to death
Reputed al-Qaida supporter faces NYC trial
Google probing possible inside help on attack
|
Asian businessmen urged to protect Coral Triangle
Taiwan's top prosecutor resigns over scandal
Saving delta is at core of new Calif. water policy
Koreas hold 'serious' talks amid North's threats
China urges flexibility on Iran
Pakistan TV station's reporters attacked
Obama to visit Virginia elementary school
Death sentence sought for former anti-graft chief
Victim to speak `from the grave' in Peterson case
The nation's weather
Same-sex marriage judge dealt with other gay cases
For La. Haitians, earthquake rekindles terror
INSIDE WASHINGTON: Secret bill-writing on the rise
Pakistani rupee weakens further; stocks post gains
Asia shares mixed on Japan Airlines bankruptcy news
Google postpones mobile phone launch in China
China calls for stronger trade ties with India
China tells Google to obey laws after exit threat
France's Carrefour set for India breakthrough
Pakistani July-Dec c/a deficit narrows to $1.758 bln
S.Korea eyes record $12b resource spending in '10
Avatar unlikely to match Titanic Oscar haul
|
Leno gives his side as O'Brien's exit deal delayed
|
FACTBOX-South Korea M&A deals in the pipeline
Simon Cowell, Sony sign new TV, music, film deal
|
U.S. Military Begins Airdropping Of Food To Quake Ravaged Haiti
New Jersey Poised To Swear In New Republican Governor
Connecticut Sues Health Net For Data Breach Involving 446,000 Patients
Firearm Scope Maker's Bible Verses On Products Used By Military Ignite Controversy
Susan Boyle snubbed, gets no Brit Award nomination
More Than 860,000 Pounds Of California Ground Beef Recalled
Female artists lead Brit Award nominees
Michelle Obama figure shown at London wax museum
US Officials Update On Rescue Efforts In Haiti But Questions Remain
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Leno gives his side as O'Brien's exit deal delayed
NYC judge to rule on tossing Letterman extort case
Paris symbol of Jewish life reopens as jeans shop
"Avatar" unlikely to match "Titanic" Oscar haul
Pakistan's female squash player defies tradition
Beijing chocolate theme park set to open
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights