Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Little future for Google in China without search
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (5)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
NBC's Leno drama might have a happy ending
13 Jan 2010
Troops, food headed for Haiti as quake toll soars
| Video
10:21am EST
Hymns, children's cries fill Haiti's night
3:23am EST
China defends censorship after Google threat
| Video
9:02am EST
Al Qaeda linked to rogue aviation network
13 Jan 2010
Al Qaeda linked to rogue aviation network
13 Jan 2010
U.S. 2009 foreclosures shatter record despite aid
5:23am EST
Hymns, children's cries fill Haiti's night
3:23am EST
Chronic sleep loss hampers performance
13 Jan 2010
Netflix in deal with Nintendo to show movies on Wii
13 Jan 2010
Little future for Google in China without search
Alexei Oreskovic and Melanie Lee
Thu Jan 14, 2010 9:02am EST
Related News
Google could find new road in China
8:17am EST
Google drama stokes online nationalism, regret in China
1:59am EST
U.S., Google and China square off over Internet
Wed, Jan 13 2010
U.S. urges China to work with Google on security
Wed, Jan 13 2010
Wall Street frets over Google's future in China
Wed, Jan 13 2010
SAN FRANCISCO/SHANGHAI (Reuters) - Google Inc, involved in high-stakes brinkmanship with the Chinese government, might still seek ways to market other products in the country even if it quits its China search business.
Technology | Media
But without search, its most important business in China, the technology giant would struggle to retain a foothold in the world's biggest Internet market by users, said analysts.
Google said on Tuesday it was no longer willing to censor search in China through its Chinese-language website Google.cn, putting it squarely at odds with the Chinese government, which has banned Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.
China, which prizes political stability and control, has since robustly defended its use of censorship online and is unlikely to yield to Google's requests to run an uncensored search engine within their borders, analysts said.
"We believe that the Chinese government and Google will not be able to easily (reach a) compromise," said UBS analyst Wang Jinjin in a research note.
Google currently offers Google Maps, Gmail and free music downloads to Chinese users, all of which could be in jeopardy if the company walks.
The most promising non-search area of business for Google, said analysts, is its Android platform, an open source mobile operating system, already adopted by China Mobile's OPhone and Dell's Mini 3, which was launched in China late last year.
But even this product could stall if Google were to no longer offer its most popular services.
"Android ... has potential but if it offers any of the Google services like Gmail or search then it may have a problems once Google leaves," said iResearch analyst Hao Jun Bo.
Other Google products hold even less promise in China's tightly controlled online market. Those include Google Voice and Google Books, a searchable digital library comprising millions of scanned books.
Google Voice, a service that allows users to place calls over the Internet, would likely encounter similar difficulties to those seen by Internet firm Skype, which offers a similar service. The free version of Skype is often blocked by government censors and a special version is monitored by Chinese authorities.
Google Books faces other difficulties, including legal challenges.
Last October a group of Chinese authors accused Google of infringing their copyrights by scanning their works into the Google Books library.
Google has since issued an apology for the lack of communication.
POSSIBLE COMPROMISE?
Google, which competes with Baidu Inc in China's $1 billion search market with over 360 million users, has said it views China as an important market.
The firm, which fought communication companies to crack open the wireless phone market and in the end opted to partner with some incumbent wireless firms rather than to go it alone, has a pragmatic streak.
This leaves open the possibility that Google and Beijing could reach a compromise that involves censorship, but not by Google itself.
Under this scenario, the government would censor through its own firewall, but Google would not directly censor results on Google.cn, said Stanford University Graduate School of Business Professor Haim Mendelson.
While Mendelson said he thought it was more likely Google would leave China, he said a compromise could give both sides something they want.
China wants to maintain its image at home and abroad, and being rebuffed by Google does not help.
"Google has some interest in maintaining a presence in China, and the Chinese government has an interest as well," said Mendelson.
"The Chinese government wants to project an image of the country where they do want U.S. companies to be present."
(Additional reporting by Joanne Chiu, Editing by Don Durfee and David Cowell)
Technology
Media
Comments
See All Comments (5) | Post Comment
Jan 14, 2010
Although thwarted temporarily, it is only a matter of time before transparency arrives in China and other societies that attempt to control information. Patience.
iVoteAmerica.com
iVoteAmerica
Report As Abusive
Jan 14, 2010
Wait and See.
hotmeal117
Report As Abusive
Jan 14, 2010
“China, which prizes political stability and control, has since robustly defended its use of censorship online and is unlikely to yield to Google’s requests to run an uncensored search engine within their borders, analysts said.”
Since when is change from governmental authorities ever an issue?
hotmeal117
Report As Abusive
Jan 14, 2010
Google has more intestinal fortitude than our Canadian Prime Minister who allowed himself to to be “scolded and chastised” like a grade school child by the Chinese Govenment.
Go GOOGLE!
wngf
Report As Abusive
Jan 14, 2010
Google should buy Tencent Holdings Limited. QQ has over 300 million user, the company is poised to beat Baidu in a few years with the right support, and with that many users the Chinese Government would think twice about it censor.
yeahright
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (5)
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Retail sales unexpectedly fall, jobless claims up
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. consumers curbed their Christmas spending in December and more people filed claims for jobless benefits last week, casting fresh doubts on whether the economic recovery can last once government support fades.
Obama to propose bank fees to recoup bailout funds
China defends censorship after Google threat
| Video
SEC eyes products structured before housing bust
Wall Street higher on Intel hopes, despite retail data
Cadbury up on Hershey bid hopes, doubts remain
» More Top News
Haiti quake leaves many dead
A major earthquake toppled the presidential palace and hillside shanties alike, leaving the poor Caribbean nation appealing for international help. Full Article | Slideshow
Live coverage of the Haiti earthquake
Factbox: Quake-stricken Haiti
Send us your photos and videos
NATURAL DISASTERS
Exclusive:
Al Qaeda linked to air network
Homeland Security ignored a report detailing a clandestine fleet of executive jets regularly crisscrossing the Altantic on drug runs. The problem is now a global security threat. Full Article
Graphic: Trafficking to Europe
Three in al Qaeda case plead not guilty
Mexico
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
ECVJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 14 January 2010 Israel apologizes to Turkey over insult
Fresh snowfall heaps more woe on shivering Europe
U.S. court revives suit on music downloads
Saudi, Syrian leaders to discuss Iran, Mideast peace
Top bankers admit missteps in financial crisis
Argentina 'death flights' pilot to stand trial
Haiti eye-witness reports, aid appeals flood Twitter
'Safe cocaine' use a myth: study
Expert testimony may boost case against Demjanjuk
|
'No way' Greece will leave euro, seek IMF aid: PM
Turkey threatens to recall envoy from Israel
French retailers urge national e-book hub
Nigeria to allow U.S.-trained air marshals on flights
|
S.Korea's LG targets 140 million phone sales this year
Iran knew Israel, U.S. planned "terrorist acts"
Google China spat shines spotlight on cyberspying
Ex-Iran leaders: Professor killing 'terrorism'
Seven killed in violence incited by Taliban: Afghan official
U.S., Google and China square off over Internet
Darfur rebels say attack government town
Saudi, Syrian leaders to discuss Iran, Mideast peace
|
China mobile users risk SMS ban in porn crackdown
China urges integration of Web, telecoms, broadcast media
Iraqi fights graft, crime in Interior Ministry
|
AFP launches iPhone app
Facebook teams with McAfee to tighten security
S.Korea's LG targets 140 million phone sales this year
U.S., Google and China square off over Internet
|
US senator: More trainers needed for Afghan troops
US husband saves wife trapped in Haiti rubble
Four seamen convicted over fatal HK collision
LaHood rescinds Bush transit spending restrictions
U.S. court revives antitrust suit on music downloads
|
French retailers urge national e-book hub
|
Indonesian anti-graft protesters clash during inquiry
Male chromosome evolves faster than rest of genome
Microsoft, HP to work together on cloud products
|
Michelle Obama: No need for first year do-overs
Attacks kill one, wound 14 in Thai south: police
AP source: Hershey plans solo bid for Cadbury
Japan govt funds scandal widens with new raid
Men more evolved? Y chromosome study suggests yes!
Chinese student kills woman in French stabbing spree
Exec: Ex-worker fired at random in Ga. rampage
China says its peacekeepers missing in Haiti quake
Taiwan defends US missile deal
Govt. says pastor's victims entitled to $2.7M each
N.Korea to admit more US visitors: tour group
China urges integration of various media platforms
Texas braces for fight over social studies lessons
Judge opens jury process in abortion slaying case
Google threat a rare show of defiance in China
Ahead of the Bell: Google's threat boosts rivals
American Idol debuts to solid viewership
|
Massey agrees to work with Indian company
LG projects 2010 mobile phone sales at 140 million
JAL shares dive 81 percent amid bankruptcy fears
Pop singer Ke$ha leads U.S. album, singles charts
|
X-Factor judge Dannii Minogue pregnant
|
'Slumdog' child star has $145,000 in new deals
Kate Hudson, Ashton Kutcher presenting at Globes
Ukraine, a nation divided ahead of vote
Indonesia rages over luxury jail cells for wealthy
Small cars make it big at Detroit Auto Show
Spain posts 8.7 percent drop in foreign tourists in 2009
Cyprus tourism dips 10.9 percent in 2009
Led Zeppelin's Page, Aerosmith to play free China gig
Claw of death is 'hand of God' at giant Paris art show
Poland's stolen Monet found, suspect arrested
Being straight with your boss cuts stress: study
Dutch PM accepts some of Iraq report criticism
Spain plans ambitious EU presidency, friction risk
Tens of thousands feared dead in Haiti quake
|
US-TECH Summary
Fiat CEO: decision to close plant 'irreversible'
US to take lead role in southern Afghanistan: report
Hymns, children's cries fill Haiti's night
|
World Bank plans $100 million in crisis aid to Haiti
Wycelf Jean Urges Support Of Haiti Earthquake Victims Through Yele Charity
China affirms control over Internet
French Filmmaker Eric Rohmer Dies At 89
Four US troops, French soldier killed in Afghanistan
Next-generation autos go for global connectivity
Celebs Come Together To Ask For Support For Earthquake Victims In Haiti
Iran speaker accuses Obama of state terrorism
Copts protest Christmas killings at Cairo cathedral
Police Believe Jon Gosselin Apartment Ransacking Was A Publicity Stunt
Power of genomics cracks soybean code
Slovenia, Croatia ready to clear way for Zagreb's EU talks
Israel to expel American journalist
GLAAD Announces Nominees For Annual Media Awards
Amsterdam-Aruba flight diverted after bomb hoax
|
Millions brace for holy Ganges festival
Ex-Qaeda man links motive to alleged U.S. abuse: report
|
Disney Ordered To Include Ex-Gays In Shareholder Resolution
Companies watch, wait as Google mulls leaving China
Israel apologises to Turkey in diplomatic spat
Haiti earthquake triggers massive Twitter response
Venezuelans yell Welcome to Cuba as lights dim
|
Ex-Iran leaders: Professor killing 'terrorism'
Guinea's Camara in Burkina Faso to convalesce
|
Google's cyber woes in China may aid security firms
Microsoft, HP to work together on cloud products
Mexico to send more police to drug war epicenter
|
Israel sends formal apology to Turkey
Jay-Z And Beyonce Named Richest Hollywood Couple Again By Forbes
"Two And A Half Men" Reaches Ratings High Following Charlie Sheen's Scandal
Iraqi fights graft, crime in Interior Ministry
Dutch PM accepts some of Iraq report criticism
|
David Copperfield Cleared Of Rape Charge
Cybill Shepherd's Son Arrested Over Plane Theft
China backs censorship after Google threat
|
Officials: Alleged US missiles kill 10 in Pakistan
Google could find new road in China
|
Police shoot five in China land protest: official
Countless help calls in Haiti don't reach target
40 dead in PNG bus smash: reports
Google drama stokes online nationalism, regret in China
|
Sheen seeks to bar TV camera from Jan. 20 hearing
US drone strike kills 10 in NW Pakistan: officials
Companies watch, wait as Google mulls leaving China
|
Defiant China web users back Google
Haiti earthquake triggers massive Twitter response
|
Study: 1 in 4 female teens involved in violence
Largest religious festival on Earth under way in India
Google's cyber woes in China may aid security firms
|
Libraries more wired, financially stressed
AP NewsAlert
U.S. drone attack kills 10 in Pakistan's Waziristan
AP NewsAlert
SKorea has new outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease
Tenn. lawmaker applauded by pro-pot activists
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Fire fear nixes Mount Rushmore July 4th fireworks
U.S. urges China to work with Google on security
|
Obama expresses condolences for peacekeeper losses
Gay awards nominate Lady Gaga, Ford film
|
Court halts broadcast of California gay marriage case
Obama, Democrats declare progress on health care
Indie rockers Vampire Weekend eye U.S. album crown
|
Jackie Chan targets kids with low-budget Spy
|
Depp gets statue in Serbia
Punk musician Jay Reatard dies at 29
|
China investigates toxic jewellery claims: report
Google's decision on China traces back to founders
China moves to rein in lending, cool economy
Japan's core machinery orders fall to record low
S.Korean firm launches fightback against iPhone
S.Korea web firm not to blame for hack hit: court
Korea Hot Stocks
Jackie Chan targets kids with low-budget "Spy"
Seoul shares up on techs, shipyards; eyes on POSCO
S.Korean bonds edge up on foreign buying
Bassist who toured with Lauryn Hill fatally shot
Are Leno, O'Brien going at it?
Japan's core machinery orders down 11.3 percent in November
"American Idol" fever spreads anew
Indie rockers Vampire Weekend eye U.S. album crown
Punk musician Jay Reatard dies at 29
Stiller, Pitt, other celebs urge quake relief
Depp gets statue in Serbia
NBC's Leno drama might have a happy ending
B'way's 'Billy Elliot' recoups production costs
Afghan market bombing 'kills 20'
German inflation hits 19-year low of 0.4%
Celebrities appeal for Haiti quake relief
Blast kills up to 20 civilians in south Afghan bazaar
|
US computer market ended 2009 with a bang: IDC
Afghan market bombing 'kills 15 civilians'
Half a million bathe in India's Ganges; crush kills 7
|
In Gaza, Hamas calls prayers for rain
|
China: Web firms to operate 'according to law'
Iraq sentences 11 men to death over Baghdad bombings
Yemen in war with al Qaeda, urges citizens to help
|
Google drama stokes online nationalism, regret in China
Prehistoric building found in modern Israeli city
Pakistan Taliban chief said targeted by U.S. drone
|
U.S., Norway protest over tense Azeri region
|
Nazi camp trial session canceled, Demjanjuk ill
|
Israel in talks to buy 6th submarine from Germany
|
Libya's anti-Qaeda drive must target youth: ex-rebel
|
China tells Web companies to obey controls
Little future for Google in China without search
|
Japan royals rejoice in marriage at poetry session
R&B singer Pendergrass dead in Pa. at 59
Brother: Police say China lawyer 'went missing'
Immigrant sheepherders endure harsh work, low pay
US missile strike 'targets Pakistan Taliban chief'
Officials: US missiles kill 12 in Pakistan
Official: Obama seeking tax on biggest banks
Suicide bomber kills 16 people in Afghanistan
Obama to propose new bank fee
Tests may shed light on Conn. museum's Egypt mummy
Festival expected to draw millions starts in India
TSA: Security fails to spot gun at Mont. airport
Yemen clerics urge jihad in case of foreign intervention
Malaysian church lawyers targeted in 'Allah' row
Prop. 8 backer questioned about child sex comment
Half a million bathe in India's Ganges
Immigration reformers see parallels in MLK's work
Truck crash kills 31 in India
Chow says Confucius will succeed along with Avatar
Google's possible pullout a boost to China rival
Tokyo taps venerable entrepreneur to lead JAL
ADB: Asia's recovery from global crisis fragile
R & B singer Pendergrass dead in Pa. at 59
Food prices push India inflation to 7.3 pct in Dec
POSCO posts sharp cut in 2009 earnings
Chow says Confucius will succeed along with Avatar
Fitch ratings indicate caution for booming China
Teddy Pendergrass dead at 59
|
S.Korea trade surplus hits record in 2009
NBC's Leno drama might have a happy ending
|
"Dexter" star battling cancer
Tintin embarks on new adventure in China
Wall Street lead lifts Asia shares
Dexter star battling cancer
|
Record-chasing Aussie teen sailor rounds Cape Horn
S.Korea wins Jordan R&D nuclear reactor order
Johnny Cash releasing another posthumous album
Sony delays release of hit game Gran Turismo 5
Johnny Cash releasing another posthumous album
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights