Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
High-profile U.S. case tests Haitian justice system
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Super Bowl win was destiny for Saints, says MVP Brees
07 Feb 2010
Study links sugary soft drinks to pancreas cancer
12:00am EST
G7 talk on Greece fails to soothe investors, euro dips
| Video
2:28am EST
Space shuttle fueling up for Monday launch
07 Feb 2010
UPDATE 2-U.S. Northeast digs out of monster snowstorm
20 Dec 2009
Study links sugary soft drinks to pancreas cancer
12:00am EST
Water at core of climate change impacts: experts
07 Feb 2010
At least 5 dead in Connecticut power plant blast
| Video
07 Feb 2010
Study links 45,000 U.S. deaths to lack of insurance
17 Sep 2009
G7 talk on Greece fails to soothe investors, euro dips
| Video
2:28am EST
High-profile U.S. case tests Haitian justice system
Joseph Guyler Delva
PORT-AU-PRINCE
Sun Feb 7, 2010 4:50pm EST
Related News
Bill Clinton urges solution to Haiti 'kidnap' case
Fri, Feb 5 2010
U.S., Haiti holding talks on detained missionaries
Wed, Feb 3 2010
U.S. missionaries see judge in Haiti child case
Tue, Feb 2 2010
U.S. missionaries go before judge in Haiti child case
Tue, Feb 2 2010
PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) - Haiti's quake-shattered justice system, grappling with collapsed courts, destroyed records and homeless employees, would be hard-pressed to hold a high-profile trial for 10 Americans charged with kidnapping children, Haitian lawyers and rights advocates said on Sunday.
World | Natural Disasters
The detained American missionaries, most of whom belong to an Idaho-based Baptist church, were charged on Thursday with child abduction and criminal association. A judge was scheduled to resume a hearing on their case on Monday.
The main courthouse in Port-au-Prince, known as the Palace of Justice, was reduced to rubble by the January 12 earthquake, and the chief judge, Roc Cadet, died in the collapse along with many judiciary employees. Others are homeless and scattered.
The Ministry of Justice partially collapsed and Justice Minister Paul Denis had to be pulled from the rubble. He is now working from a small office behind the ministry.
Court records were buried in the debris and with the system effectively shut down, jails are filling with suspects arrested for looting and other crimes in the aftermath of the quake.
"It is very difficult to give a fair trial to the Americans right now. The whole system has been affected," said Renan Hedouville, head of Haiti's Lawyers Committee for Individual Rights. "Even the president of the court died."
"We should not be bluffing by pretending we have the means to try that case," he said.
Last week, judges managed to conduct a series of hearings for the arrested U.S. missionaries. But virtually no other hearings are being held by a system criticized even before the earthquake for keeping suspects jailed for months or years without hearings or trials.
"The justice system is dysfunctional," lawyer Rodrigue Dumas said. "I believe, in these conditions, the rights of the Americans will not be protected. Therefore the judgment cannot be fair."
DIPLOMATIC HEADACHE
Haitian authorities say the missionaries tried to take a busload of 33 children across the border into the Dominican Republic without papers proving the minors were orphans or any official permission to take them out of the country.
The case is diplomatically sensitive at a time when the United States is leading aid efforts following the earthquake last month that killed more than 200,000 people and left more than a million homeless.
Aid groups have flooded into Haiti to provide emergency food, water and medical services to survivors, and several thousand U.S. troops are on the ground to help U.N. peacekeepers and Haitian police with security.
The U.S. missionaries have denied wrongdoing, saying they were only trying to help children left destitute by the quake. But authorities subsequently found that many of the children intercepted had living parents who had voluntarily given them up in hope they would find a better life in the United States.
The U.S. government has said it is providing the Americans with consular access and monitoring their case, but has made clear it does not want to interfere.
Haitian President Rene Preval -- notably silent on the missionaries case while his prime minister, Jean-Max Bellerive, has called them "kidnappers" -- said on Saturday it was up to the judiciary to sort the matter out.
"The justice system is an independent power," he said. "The justice system is the one in charge of that."
THREE-MONTH INVESTIGATION?
Secretary of State for Criminal Affairs Claudy Gassant told Reuters there was "a possibility" Haiti could try the Americans, since the investigation could take three months.
"We think in three months we would have time to make sure everything is in place," he said. "Wherever the prosecutor and the judges gather to deliver justice is a tribunal. The tribunal is not the building."
The five U.S. men and five U.S. women were questioned last week and authorities said an investigating judge would continue the examination on Monday and Tuesday before deciding whether to release them or proceed with the case against them.
The missionaries received a visit in jail on Sunday from American Buddy Shipp, who described himself as a military medic and said he was there to assess their condition. He said they were suffering from rashes and infected mosquito bites and would be treated.
"I think the best thing to say is they're extremely resilient, extremely resilient," Shipp said.
(Additional reporting by Jesus Frias, Rodrigo Gutierrez and Mivida Domercant in Port-au-Prince, writing by Jim Loney; Editing by Pascal Fletcher)
World
Natural Disasters
More from Reuters
Federal agencies to close Monday after blizzard
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The federal government announced it would remain closed on Monday and most schools planned to shut down as residents of the mid-Atlantic struggled to dig out from a blizzard that dumped two feet of snow on the region. | Video
Nikkei falls to 2-month closing low, Kirin slides
Opposition's Yanukovich claims win in Ukraine poll
| Video
At least 5 dead in Connecticut power plant blast
| Video
Toyota readies global Prius recall
| Video
G7 talk on Greece fails to soothe investors, euro dips
| Video
» More Top News
THE WEEK AHEAD:
Debt fears prompt re-think
Hurdles blocking what could be a long rally in risky assets are proving higher than anticipated. Full Article
Five world market themes for the week
U.S. Markets
Analysis:
BofA's big distraction
Joseph Price has already been moved from his job as CFO, but the lawsuit from the NY Attorney General's office has experts wondering if he should step down entirely. Full Article
Bank of America's share price
Blankfein's bonus: $9 million
Financials
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Monday, 8 February 2010 Actor in Israel's Oscar nominated movie detained
Geithner confident investors will stick by US bonds
Lebanon recovers crashed Ethiopian jet's black box
Taliban, NATO prepare for big Helmand offensive
|
Afghan assault to send 'strong signal': McChrystal
Iran tests radar-evading aircraft says commander
|
Iraq delays parliament debate on candidates row
Ukraine Tymoshenko's team cries foul before polls close
|
Israeli forces arrest two foreigners in West Bank
Afghan leader eyes return to conscript army
Iran leader orders new step in nuclear program
NATO chief seeks broader ties with China, India
An engineering marvel takes shape near Hoover Dam
Fifth victim identified in fatal RI fire
Officials: Some die in Conn. power plant explosion
Battle to electrify Kandahar shows Afghan dilemma
Researchers target whales in herring loss study
Hundreds flee south Afghan town ahead of offensive
Gibbons to deliver emergency State of State
Pakistanis doubt Taliban chiefs in Baluchistan
Al-Qaeda threat to US greater than Iran: Clinton
Afghanistan's NATO head: Military push needs gov't
US faces `serious and significant' cyberthreats
China 'jails porn website operator for 13 years'
Obama adviser: Stop criticizing anti-terror effort
Pakistani military seizes Taliban stronghold in NW
Authorities: 2 planes collide in Colorado; 3 die
India flight delayed after tip alleges terror
Obama adviser confident in Super Bowl security
Sri Lanka army denies plan to arrest former chief
Television executive shot to death in Nepal
Toyota loses some luster in hometown over recalls
Avatar loses box office crown to Dear John
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
"Avatar" dethroned at box office by "Dear John"
'Dear John' bumps 'Avatar' with $32.4M debut
Rihanna's celebrates, BEPs party late
Florez and his 9 high C's return to Met Opera
All eyes on Ellen in "American Idol" judge debut
Iraq MPs to meet over 'Saddam' candidates row
ETA seeking to move bomb-making to Portugal: Madrid
China shuts down largest hacker training website
Opposition's Yanukovich claims win in Ukraine poll
|
Saints go marching in with Super Bowl win over Colts
Defiant Iran set to begin higher enrichment of uranium
French police evacuate migrants' shelter
China seizes more melamine-tainted milk powder
|
PayPal temporarily suspends some India services
Yanukovich set to win Ukraine presidency: exit polls
Iran ratchets up atom work despite sanctions threat
US faces 'serious' cyberspace threats: advisor
Haiti protesters denounce aid corruption, hoarding
|
Israeli forces detain pro-Palestinian activists
Internet down in Iran ahead of demos
Argentine ex-Pres Kirchner has emergency surgery
|
Iran leader orders new step in nuclear program
Iran plans 10 new enrichment plants in 2010/11
|
Envoys go to North Korea for nuclear talks push
|
Costa Rica elects Chinchilla first woman president
|
High-profile U.S. case tests Haitian justice system
|
Iran tests radar-evading aircraft
NASA fuels space shuttle 2nd time, clouds back
NKorea threatens South amid push to restart talks
CIT names ex-Merrill CEO Thain as chairman, CEO
Activists want fair trial in Japan whaling case
China finds 170 more tons of tainted milk powder
CAPITAL CULTURE: First lady tackling child obesity
IBM begins Power server upgrade to battle HP, Sun
|
Taiwan firm on China ties after US arms deal
Cops attack homegrown gang in Calif heartland
NetEase suspends new user registration for hit game
|
Obama hasn't ruled out NY trial for 9/11 planner
Cowboy theme at American base in Afghanistan
China shuts down largest hacker training website
|
NY Gov. Paterson meets with lawmakers over future
Amazon reshelves Macmillan titles but not e-books
|
Obama in Super Bowl health care gambit
Singapore rite looks painful, yet smiles abound
Malaysia: Anwar wants sodomy trial judge removed
'Historic' snow strands countless in Mid-Atlantic
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
AP NewsAlert
2,000 hit by Papua cholera outbreak: WHO
Eight Vietnamese reported drowned
Kirin, Suntory scrap plans to combine
Pakistan stocks up; volume low after Friday bombs
Disgraced Lee returns to Olympics fold
JAL to stay with American Airlines: reports
PAKISTAN
Japan's Kirin terminates merger talks with Suntory
Seoul shares close lower on banks, Kumho issues
S.Korea KDIC to offer shares in Korea Life via IPO
Taiwan dollar rebounds sharply
S.Korea bonds steady ahead of auctions
South Africans celebrate Mandela, worry about future
Townshend, Daltrey are still The Who at Super Bowl
NBC considers lifting Emmys tape delay
Daughtry brings Saints, Colts fans together
The Who perform hits medley at Super Bowl halftime
|
"Valentine's Day" a date to forget
Cockfighting survives Haiti's earthquake devastation
France vaunts '40 virtues' of Armagnac
Private schools sprout in Zimbabwe as public system struggles
'Dear John' dethrones box office king 'Avatar'
Valentine's Day a date to forget
|
Iran plans major nuclear expansion over next year
|
Riding green wave, Philips says "let there be LED"
NetEase suspends new user registration for hit game
Iran plans major nuclear expansion over next year
U.S. and EU fear fresh government crackdown in Iran
|
Iran's leader vows to thwart protests this week
Yemen's al Qaeda calls for jihad in region: report
|
Israeli police raid Palestinian refugee camp
|
Saudi rights commission seeks divorce for child bride
Fifteen Indian soldiers killed in Kashmir avalanche
|
Iran launches production lines for unmanned planes
Taliban defiant as Afghans flee ahead of assault
China patents surge in 2009 as U.S. filings plunge
|
Iran plans 10 new enrichment plants in 2010/11
UK Afghan death toll matches Falklands loss
|
Barnes & Noble's Nook e-reader to hit stores
|
US shuttle Endeavour blasts off for space station
Disney, Google eye stake in China bus media firm
|
Bomb hits trucks carrying Thai soldiers; 7 wounded
Failed job seekers add to homeless problem in ND
Taiwan court extends ex-leader's custody
Charlie and Brooke Sheen due in court Monday
Tainted milk powder still on sale in China: report
Internet prompts the publishing itch in over-60s
|
China bus with 43 aboard plunges down valley: report
Riding green wave, Philips says let there be LED
|
Body found in airplane wheel well at Tokyo airport
5 men, 1 woman aboard shuttle Endeavour
Vodafone Enterprise signs 4-year Oracle deal
|
Sri Lanka journalists hold anti-government protest
Obama's Monday filled with meetings
Intel Israel exports jump 145 pct, seeks grant for expansion
|
US shuttle Endeavour reaches orbit
11 soldiers dead, 50 trapped in Kashmir avalanche
NKorea threatens South amid push to restart talks
Official: About 5 unaccounted for after CT blast
Thailand tightens security ahead of Thaksin ruling
Doctor finally looks at charge in Jackson death
LA-area cleans up from storms, new round coming
Senior Afghan official accused of militant links
Chinese police shut down hacker training business
Taiwan exports surge 76 percent in January
Sumitomo Mitsui triples nine-month profit
India sees 7.2 percent growth as economy recovers
Ex-NFL star Sapp released from Fla. jail on bond
Hyundai boss made to pay fine over losses to firm
Gary Coleman scheduled for Utah court appearance
The black magic of Massive Attack's new album
Google warns Chinese copycat website: report
Charlie and Brooke Sheen due in court
Berlin film fest looks back at 60 years of scandal
Toyota faces fresh questions over recall response
Pakistan's Soneri Bank says eyes RBS Pakistan
Hollywood names up for Olivier theatre awards
|
The Who perform hits medley at Super Bowl halftime
Bleak outlook for Iraq's lonely hearts
UAE hospital offers treatment that's for the birds
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights