">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
High court test for voting rights in Texas case
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
High court test for voting rights in Texas case
By PAUL WEBER and MARK SHERMAN,Associated Press Writers AP - 2 hours 25 minutes ago
AUSTIN, Texas - The community of Canyon Creek was ranchland rich with limestone and cedar trees when Jim Crow held sway in the South. The first house wasn't built until the late 1980s and not even a hint of discrimination attaches to this little slice in suburbia.
ADVERTISEMENT
President Barack Obama won more than 48 percent of the vote in November in this overwhelmingly white community northwest of the state capital.
Yet Canyon Creek, the heart of Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District Number One, is the site of a major Supreme Court battle over the federal government's often used and most effective tool in preventing voting discrimination against minorities.
The utility district's elected five-person board manages a local park and pays down bond debt. Because it is in Texas, the board is covered by a section of the Voting Rights Act that requires approval from the Justice Department before any changes can be made in how elections are conducted.
That requirement applies to all or parts of 16 states, mostly in the South, with a history of preventing blacks, Hispanics and other minorities from voting.
The utility district is challenging that section of the law, which Congress extended in 2006 for 25 years. The Obama administration is defending it.
The Voting Rights Act, enacted in 1965, opened the polls to millions of black Americans. The law "has been the most important and transformative civil rights act in our country's history," said John Payton, director of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund.
The federal government has used the provision, known as Section 5, to "stop things that would have perverted our democracy," Payton said. His group represents Texans and organizations seeking to preserve the section.
On the other side are the utility district, an array of conservative legal groups and some Southern Republicans.
Texas and other Southern states once might have deserved to be under federal supervision, but the time for this "unparalleled federal intrusion" on a traditional power of state and local governments has passed, the utility district says in its challenge.
The justices will hear arguments in the case this coming Wednesday.
Much has changed across the South and elsewhere in the country, not least of which is Obama's election, Gregory Coleman, the district's lawyer, has told the court.
If the justices side with Canyon Creek, they could strike down Section 5 entirely, eliminating the need for any jurisdiction to seek prior approval for election changes, or tailor a narrow ruling that applies only to the utility district.
Coleman, a former Texas solicitor general, had been looking for a way to take on Section 5. In Canyon Creek, with its lack of racially charged history and unstinting compliance with the Voting Rights Act, he found a willing partner.
As recently as 2002, voters in Canyon Creek walked up Jack Steuber's driveway to choose their utility district board. Bill Ferguson won a seat on the board, then sought to hold the next election in a school rather than in a neighbor's garage.
But first the board had to seek federal clearance to change the polling location. The community got it, but Canyon Creek's board didn't understand the need to ask Washington to sign off on a change in a tiny neighborhood where there isn't a trace of minority voter discrimination.
The community has about 3,500 residents, 80 percent of whom are white, according to the 2000 census. A number of families settled in Canyon Creek for high-tech jobs. Some work at Dell Inc., whose headquarters is nearby in Round Rock.
Don Zimmerman, the utility district's vice president, spent a recent afternoon installing a security camera to scare away teenage vandals who keep ripping planks off a playground set.
"It's insulting to me to be accused of having a racial bias just because you live in Texas," said Zimmerman, an engineer.
Ferguson, 53, said, "I'm sort of embarrassed that we're still subject to this because it makes us look like dumb crackers. I don't think it's appropriate anymore."
Resounding majorities of Democrats and Republicans in Congress, however, thought it was necessary when they voted in 2006 to extend the advance approval requirement for 25 more years. President George W. Bush, a Texan and a Republican, signed the measure into law.
"Today, we renew a bill that helped bring a community on the margins into the life of American democracy," Bush said at the signing ceremony in July 2006. "My administration will vigorously enforce the provisions of this law, and we will defend it in court."
A few Republicans have raised their voice in opposition to the extension of the law, which otherwise would have expired in 2007. Among them are Republican Govs. Sonny Perdue of Georgia and Bob Riley of Alabama.
Their states, the governors said, have worked hard to eradicate the government-sponsored discrimination that resulted in federal supervision. "Georgia has earned the right to be free" of asking the federal government to bless election changes, Perdue said. In Alabama, blacks and whites register and vote in similar proportions, Riley said.
Other numbers suggest, as Justice Anthony Kennedy said in a recent court case involving a different section of the Voting Rights Act, "racial discrimination and racially polarized voting are not ancient history." In Alabama, Louisiana and Mississippi _ all of which must submit proposed election changes for approval _ less than 15 percent of white voters chose Obama.
Evidence amassed at congressional hearings showed that hundreds of discriminatory proposals were rejected by the Justice Department or withdrawn when government lawyers raised questions.
The Supreme Court has upheld the advance approval requirement on four occasions before now. The outcome this time may be no different, but the recent additions of Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito have given hope to the law's opponents.
Roberts, in particular, has in several cases opposed the continuing use of race, once lamenting the "sordid business" of taking race into account to draw congressional districts.
In Canyon Creek, residents seem to care more about their tax squabbles with the Austin city government than the voting rights dispute, according to Ferguson, the board member.
And not all the utility district's leaders believe issue before the high court has run its course. Chris Bowers, 40, was elected last May on a platform that questioned why this was even Canyon Creek's fight. Bowers believes his victory shows many agree with him.
"I think it's dangerous to be using the government entity which has this narrow focus of paying off ... bonds" to challenge a federal law, Bowers said. "This really seems out of scope."
___
Supreme Court Writer Mark Sherman reported from Washington.
___
On the Net:
Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act: http://tinyurl.com/clg2br
Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District No. 1 v. Holder: http://tinyurl.com/dltf56
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
0 users recommend
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: World
Belatedly, White House aide pays for renovationAP - 23 minutes ago
Obama urges new cost-saving initiativesAFP - 26 minutes ago
Tsvangirai sees no going back on Zimbabwe unityReuters - 37 minutes ago
Turkey says Obama failed to mention slain TurksAP - 43 minutes ago
Interior secretary announces $500M for tribesAP - 46 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Charred meat linked to pancreatic cancer risk
Downturn hits Elton John, Paul McCartney
Albino buffalo a first for Kenya
Fertility doctor on brink of cloning human: report
Ford sees light at end of tunnel
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Saturday, 25 April 2009 U.S. weighs Zimbabwe reform pace, no aid yet
| International
|
Poor countries pushed into danger zone: World Bank
| International
|
U.N. council to Sri Lanka: Let U.N. into conflict zone
| International
|
Two die in new violence in Madagascar capital: reports
| International
|
NATO extends anti-piracy mission off Somalia
| International
|
Conficker virus begins to attack PCs: experts
| Technology
|
Facebook surfing while sick costs Swiss woman job
| Technology
|
Blagojevich still hopes for a part in TV show
| Entertainment
|
Meryl Streep to be honored at Rome film festival
| Entertainment
|
Cyndi Lauper shares screen with husband
| Entertainment
|
Cocteau memorabilia up for auction in Paris
| Entertainment
|
Beyonce says definitely wants Broadway role
| Entertainment
|
Clinton makes surprise visit to Iraq
Female suicide attackers kill 58 near Baghdad shrine
U.N. council to Sri Lanka: Let U.N. into conflict zone
| International
|
60 killed in double bombing at Iraqi shrine
US stars rake in funds for fight on malaria
India presses for Sri Lanka truce as casualties rise
| International
|
Sixty die in Iraq shrine attack
Chrysler reaches agreement with Canada union workers
Canadian soldier found dead in Afghanistan
Group of Seven sees crisis begin to unwind by year-end
Baghdad shrine attack kills 55
Economic activity to pick up this year: G7
Major attacks in Iraq since Jan. 1
'Gaps' remain as G8-led climate talks move towards global pact
Ford sees light at end of tunnel
Tsunami aid often bypassed conflict victims: report
| International
|
Albino buffalo a first for Kenya
U.N. committee puts 3 North Korea firms on blacklist
| International
|
New momentum for global climate pact despite 'gaps'
Gore pleads for unity on climate, despite divide
'Gaps' remain as G8-led climate talks move towards global pact
Dalai Lama: Economic crisis teaches money's limits
Concern grows in Mexico, US over killer flu
Murder brings scrutiny to fast-growing Craigslist
Microsoft to release version of Windows 7 next week
| Technology
|
Northern Mariana Islands official convicted
Twitter a global sensation: Hitwise
Lost laptops cost companies dearly: study
Plane diverted to Boston after man rushes cockpit
Cell phone vital, air conditioning not so much
| Technology
|
Latin American banks look to mobiles to battle crisis
Murder brings scrutiny to fast-growing Craigslist
| Technology
|
US military told torture yields 'unreliable' info
Cell phone vital, air conditioning not so much
DVD software backups challenged in U.S. court
| Technology
|
EU's Barroso says he has Sarkozy's support to stay
NYC Heath Department: 75 kids sickened at 1 school
Facebook democracy debuts to low voter turnout
NYC house explosion shakes block; 1 dead, 6 hurt
Medvedev sacks military intelligence chief
Former Facebook executive named MySpace CEO
Penniless German couple abandoned their children
Finance leaders want cooperation to end recession
Finland allocates new 4G mobile frequencies
Estonia plans broadband for all by 2015: report
BULLETIN KILL
Facebook surfing while sick costs Swiss woman job
Lost laptops cost companies dearly: study
Bus-truck crash in China's southwest kills 18
Wounded Thai protest leader discharged
UN humanitarian chief to press Sri Lanka on civilians
Chronology of NKorea's nuclear, missile programs
Simon Cowell to Susan Boyle: Get yourself together
| Entertainment
|
Taliban withdraw from Pakistan's Buner: officials
Fox faces uncertainty over fate of Idol judges
| Entertainment
|
US aid threatened by missile range row: ambassador
Taiwan envoy heads to China for talks
NKorea restarts nuclear programme
Thai 'Yellow Shirt' protest founder leaves hospital
HK university students oust union president
Forbes names Madonna Hollywood's hardest working mom
Japanese banks Shinsei, Aozora in merger talks
Forbes names Madonna Hollywood's hardest working mom
| Entertainment
|
MSFG wins priority in talks to buy Nikko
Pakistani c.bank buys 32.75 bln rupees of T-bills
China bans foreign firms from express mail market
Reports: Sumitomo likely to buy Japan Citigroup
'Quiet' Copenhagen cracks down on deadly gang war
China Construction Bank 1Q profit down 18 percent
Torrent of bitterness on the Turkey-Armenia border
G7 hails China's crisis actions, pledges support
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
China buys half interest in Kazakh energy company
"Gossip Girl" star Meester signs record deal
World finance chiefs discuss crisis amid recovery signs
'Lost' actor and ABC face sex harassment claim
Toshiba says to cut British jobs, focus on Poland
Late night TV host Jay Leno released from hospital
| Entertainment
|
Rihanna seeking return of pricey jewelry
Bob Dylan, Willie Nelson and John Mellencamp to tour
| Entertainment
|
'Secret' Stone lawsuit was routine fees matter
Rob Thomas readies new album
| Entertainment
|
Nas says Grammy nod shows he's on right track
Page Not Found |
Simon Cowell to Susan Boyle: "Get yourself together"
Americans battle their bulge on TV dance show
| Entertainment
|
Fox faces uncertainty over fate of "Idol" judges
DVD software backups challenged in U.S. court
| Entertainment
|
Iran hits at U.S., Clinton sees progress in Iraq
| International
|
3 arrested in Lebanon on Israel spy charges
North Korea begins extracting plutonium
| International
|
Triple suicide attack kills five Afghan police
Flux in Pakistani valley after Taliban retreat
| International
|
Toyota's Trulli on pole for Bahrain Grand Prix
5 Palestinians injured in West Bank clash
South Africa's ANC wins huge poll victory
| International
|
Turkey objects to Obama's view of Armenian killings
| International
|
No going back on Zimbabwe unity government: Tsvangirai
| International
|
India says Pakistan still aiding Kashmir rebels
| International
|
U.N. dispatches top humanitarian to Sri Lanka
| International
|
Thaksin red shirts gather again in Bangkok
| International
|
Drilling drives a wedge at climate change summit
Somali pirates seize German vessel, crew unhurt
| International
|
Protesters, police clash near IMF meetings in DC
WHO chief calls swine flu outbreak 'serious'
Obama: Give me ideas on tightening federal belt
Quotes from Obama's first 100 days
Key events in Obama's first 100 days
100 days of Obama: Energy aplenty, no miracles
A glance at states covered by Voting Rights Act
High court test for voting rights in Texas case
Independent streak flashed by newest Democrats
Clinton says US will back Iraq after troop pullout
Thai protesters hold new rally in Bangkok
India says Pakistan helped Kashmir rebels
Fear a high school reunion? Hire a stripper
| Entertainment
|
UN humanitarian chief to press Sri Lanka
Thaksin "red shirts" gather again in Bangkok
Asia protests, Beijing quiet on Falungong anniversary
India says Pakistan still aiding Kashmir rebels
A look at North Korea's nuclear program
Profit at top Chinese state firms down 42 percent
Asia takes precautions after swine flu outbreak
North Korea begins extracting plutonium
Newspaper columnist takes stage in The Soloist
| Entertainment
|
UN humanitarian chief: Sri Lanka situation 'dire'
Fear a high school reunion? Hire a stripper
Newspaper columnist takes stage in "The Soloist"
Guests for the Sunday TV news shows
Rob Thomas readies new album
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights