Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Food fight breaks out as locavores defend their turf
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Food fight breaks out as locavores defend their turf
AFP - Monday, September 6
Send
IM Story
Print
Food fight breaks out as locavores defend their turf
WASHINGTON (AFP) - – A new food fight has stirred up the locavore movement, which promotes eating of local products, after fresh challenges to the assumption that the practice promotes environmental sustainability.
The locavore movement, which has been gaining steam rapidly since emerging in California in 2005, is now boiling over following a commentary last month suggesting that the "math" underpinning the practice is flawed.
Author and journalist Stephen Budiansky stirred up the pot with a piece appearing in the New York Times arguing that locavores are mistaken on the notion that local food is better for energy conservation and the environment.
"Words like 'sustainability' and 'food-miles' are thrown around without any clear understanding of the larger picture of energy and land use," Budiansky wrote.
Budiansky has his own vegetable garden, but argues that on a commercial scale, large farms are far more energy-efficient than small ones and that transportation energy costs are often overstated by local food advocates.
"It takes about a tablespoon of diesel fuel to move one pound of freight 3,000 miles by rail," says Budiansky, who calls the transportation fuel costs "a negligible amount in the overall picture."
"The real energy hog, it turns out, is not industrial agriculture at all, but you and me. Home preparation and storage account for 32 percent of all energy use in our food system, the largest component by far," he said in the commentary titled "Math Lessons for Locavores."
Budiansky added that "eating food from a long way off is often the single best thing you can do for the environment, as counterintuitive as that sounds."
He said that "the relative pittance of energy we expend on 'industrial' agriculture... pays huge environmental dividends which the organic and local gurus always ignore."
The comments heated up the debate about the locavore movement, which has been gaining ground among groceries, restaurants and consumers in the United States and elsewhere, based on a philosophy of using more foods produced closer to home.
Elanor Starmer of the watchdog group Food & Water Watch says Budiansky misses the point, and that locavores want more diversity in the facing of growing concentration of the food chain in the hands of multinational companies.
"When I buy local food, energy use is not the driving rationale (no pun intended)," Starmer says in a blog posting.
"I buy from a variety of local farms when at all possible because if I don't, I will probably be eating from a stream of food that has passed through the hands of a tiny number of massive companies."
Kerry Trueman, cofounder of the website EatingLiberally, points out that "energy efficiency is only one small part of the equation when you add up the reasons to buy local."
She said factors include flavor and nutrition, support for ecological farming practices, avoidance of pesticides and more humane treatment of livestock and workers.
Dave Love of the Johns Hopkins University Center for a Livable Future, was incensed by Budiansky's argument.
"It is difficult to be in favor of a farming approach that relies upon mono-cropping using genetically modified seeds and synthetic fertilizers," he said.
"Why pick on locavores? Because when they seek local food, they may also be seeking to buy organically grown or raised foods, from small to mid-sized farms, which can impact entrenched agribusiness interests."
But James McWilliams, a fellow in the Agrarian Studies Program at Yale University, said Budiansky echoes his own views that the locavore movement relies on flawed logic.
"The recognized benefits of a local foodshed are numerous, but -- while small might be beautiful -- small is also expensive and, in turn, prone to exclusivity," says McWilliams, author of "Just Food: Where Locavores Get It Wrong and How We Can Truly Eat Responsibly."
Jennifer Wilkins, a faculty member at the Cornell University College of Human Ecology, says the strict economic and environmental calculations can be complex but that diversity in the food supply "tends to increase stability and resilience."
She said that recalls and accidents in the food supply can highlight problems when a small number of producers dominate.
"When something goes wrong in a highly concentrated and specialized system, as we are reminded by the recent recall of shell eggs, the consequences and costs related to public health, economic loss, food waste, and consumer confidence are on a much more spectacular scale and much more widespread," she said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Syrian soap causes Ramadan stir AFP - 7 minutes ago
'The American' reigns at weekend box office AFP - 39 minutes ago
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
George Clooney shoots first at box office Reuters - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
U.S. comedian Robert Schimmel dies after car accident Reuters - 1 hour 37 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
US troops fire back as suicide bombers kill 12 in Baghdad
78-year-old woman found alive after week missing in Alps
Technical glitch grounds homemade Danish rocket
Japanese rider Tomizawa dies in San Marino Moto2 GP
A month on, Chile miners face uncertain rescue date
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Japanese rider Tomizawa dies in San Marino Moto2 GP
Sharapova, Federer battle on in US tennis Open
Zeta-Jones 'furious' at late cancer diagnosis for Douglas
A month on, Chile miners face uncertain rescue date
BP spill costs hit 8 bln dlrs as crews unearth clues
More Most Viewed »
Earth's upper atmosphere shrinking, scientists say
Tiger's ex breaks her silence on sex scandal
Most US students think Beethoven is a dog
Unchecked migration would see Singapore swell, Haiti halve
Court blocks California gay marriage
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 6 September 2010 78-year-old woman found alive after week missing in Alps
Islamist threat to Germany is growing say police
|
Sarkozy pensions plan faces angry French street
Berlusconi rival Fini will not force election
|
Technical glitch grounds homemade Danish rocket
Attack on Iran would destroy Israel: Ahmadinejad
|
ETA declares ceasefire in Basque independence battle
Japanese rider Tomizawa dies in San Marino Moto2 GP
Teen star Noh boosts Order of Merit bid
Scandal-hit Pakistan well beaten by England in cricket Twenty20
Aussies muscled out of world basketball championships
Oracle offered job to ex-HP CEO Hurd says source
|
Food fight breaks out as locavores defend their turf
Historical Istanbul hotel revives glorious past
Greek island lovers star in taboo-breaking documentary
FACTBOX-Key political risks to watch in Taiwan
Michael Jackson auction 'not against his wishes': report
Taiwan's HTC: iPhone's `quiet' challenger
George Clooney shoots first at box office
|
U.S. comedian Robert Schimmel dies after car accident
|
Internet an equalizer for people with disabilities
Charter referendum new test for Turkey's PM Erdogan
Germany to extend life of nuclear reactors
Guatemala landslides kill dozens, toll seen rising
|
Iraqi troops in spotlight as Baghdad bombers kill 12
Nineteen killed in suicide bombing in Pakistan
|
Former HP boss may move to Oracle
Australia's Gillard expected to form new government
|
US servicemember dies in fighting in Afghan east
Cuban blogger Sanchez calls media prize a 'shield'
Basque separatists ETA declare ceasefire
US troops fire back as suicide bombers kill 12 in Baghdad
Japanese public backs PM Kan vs Ozawa by wide margin
|
US-TECH Summary
Bumper profits fail to dispel wider worries
Afghan toll of foreign troop deaths in 2010 hits 500
|
Oracle offered job to ex-HP CEO Hurd says source
Attack on Iran would destroy Israel
Quake-hit New Zealand city remains shut
|
North Korea to free fishermen after month in captivity
|
Australia close to forming government but new poll still a risk
Mideast talks to resume in Egyptian Red Sea resort
Bomb blast wounds five in Tajikistan nightclub
|
Quake-hit New Zealand city remains shut
Hit on Iran would spell Israel's 'eradication': Ahmadinejad
War, corruption swell number of Afghan street kids
|
Emergency extended in New Zealand's quake-hit Christchurch
Afghan Central Bank: Kabul Bank has `stabilized'
Japanese maestro Ozawa makes comeback after surgery
Charter referendum new test for Turkey's PM Erdogan
|
Vatican says in touch with Iran over stoning case
New Zealand capture fourth women's rugby World Cup
Two Infants Die In Arizona Car Crash
Legalize it: Mexico marijuana smokers gather
Las Vegas Casino Evacuated After Bomb Scare
Ohio Man Indicted For Locking Up, Abusing Family For 15 Years
Isaac Julien's art seeks to 'allegorise' news tragedy
Earl Fizzles, Gaston To Form
Syrian soap causes Ramadan stir
'The American' reigns at weekend box office
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
George Clooney shoots first at box office
Pirates rob tanker as attacks rise in S.China Sea
U.S. comedian Robert Schimmel dies after car accident
Seoul shares gain 0.7 pct on auto, tech issues
Pakistani c.bank buys back 19.85 bln rupees of govt paper
Taiwan cbank chief calls for Asian FX mechanism
China vows to increase foreign imports: report
China to have 200 million vehicles by 2020
PAKISTAN
Seoul shares gain 0.7 pct on auto, tech issues
S.Korea bonds weaker ahead of auction, on US data
TEXT-NZ's Tower sees NZ$5 mln impact from earthquake
Quake-hit NZ city remains shut, mkt reaction muted
World's Longest Trekking Route To Open In Nepal
Hariri says was wrong to accuse Syria over killing
Merkel sets stage for nuclear power battle
Iran boosts nuclear work, bomb concern remains: IAEA
|
Graft and threats of violence cloud hopes for Afghan vote
|
Spain rejects ETA truce, demands permanent disarming
Nokia bets on new smartphones for recovery
Russia, Israel sign military cooperation deal
Fresh suspicion over Pakistan-Australia Test
US mulls approval of GM salmon
Oracle offered job to ex-HP CEO Hurd: source
Blair cancels book-signing over protests
|
Afghans protest US church's plans to burn Quran
Spanish govt says ETA ceasefire is insufficient
KIA Motors America Posts 10 Percent Sales Hike
Avatar director vows to aid Amazon tribe
France faces serious disruption in pensions strike
|
Search For Body In California Landfill Enters Fourth Day
Police investigating Afghan journalist's murder
Russia's Putin says undecided about 2012 election
|
Ex-HP CEO Hurd In Talks To Join HP Rival Oracle's Top Brass
Black Widow Gobbles 181 Chicken Wings Securing Top Honors In Eating Contest
Afghans protest U.S. church's plans to torch Koran
|
Dog Treats Recalled After FDA Finds Salmonella
US-TECH Summary
George Clooney's "The American" Tops Box Office Weekend
Nokia bets on new smartphones for recovery
Study: Few Americans Able To Permanently Shed Pounds
Seven Boaters Rescued Off Charleston
Elective Mastectomy Effective In Lowering Breast Cancer Risk In Some Women
Suicide car bomber kills 19 in NW Pakistan: police
Nineteen killed in suicide bombing in Pakistan
Emergency extended in quake-hit New Zealand city
Malaysia, Indonesia bid to ease tensions after maritime spat
Nokia bets on new smartphones for recovery
|
China's 'miracle' Shenzhen marks 30 years
Oracle offered job to ex-HP CEO Hurd: source
|
Australia poised for new government
Indonesia's lax gun control a boon for militants
Jordanian websites shift political dissent online
|
Greenpeace two get jail terms in Japan whale meat case
Fresh suspicion over Pakistan-Australia cricket Test
N.Korea finishes preparing for key party meeting
A hoax? Joaquin Phoenix film gets viewers guessing
|
Giant hay bale kills former ELO cellist
|
Chinese film on 1960 labor camps cheered in Venice
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights