Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Cyber-bullying cases put heat on Google, Facebook
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Cyber-bullying cases put heat on Google, Facebook
Reuters - Tuesday, March 9
Send
IM Story
Print
By Dan Whitcomb
LOS ANGELES - The Internet was built on freedom of expression. Society wants someone held accountable when that freedom is abused. And major Internet companies like Google and Facebook are finding themselves caught between those ideals.
Although Google, Facebook and their rivals have enjoyed a relatively "safe harbor" from prosecution over user-generated content in the United States and Europe, they face a public that increasingly is more inclined to blame them for cyber-bullying and other online transgressions.
Such may have been the case when three Google executives were convicted in Milan, Italy on February 24 over a bullying video posted on the site -- a verdict greeted with horror by online activists, who fear it could open the gates to such prosecutions and ultimately destroy the Internet itself.
Journalist Jeff Jarvis suggested on his influential BuzzMachine blog that the Italian court, which found Google executives guilty of violating the privacy of an autistic boy who was taunted in the video, was essentially requiring websites to review everything posted on them.
"The practical implication of that, of course, is that no one will let anyone put anything online because the risk is too great," Jarvis wrote. "I wouldn't let you post anything here. My ISP wouldn't let me post anything on its services. And that kills the Internet."
A seemingly stunned Chris Thompson, writing for Slate, said simply: "The mind reels at this medieval verdict."
'POLICEMEN OF THE INTERNET'
And Matt Sucherman, a Google vice president and general counsel, wrote in a blog post that the company was "deeply troubled" by the case, saying it "attacks the very principles of freedom on which the Internet is built."
Legal experts have been more sanguine, saying the verdict in Milan will most likely end up an outlier -- unable to stand the scrutiny even of the Italian appeals courts, never mind setting legal precedents elsewhere.
But in sentencing the executives to six-month suspended jail terms, the court may have seized on a growing desire to hold Internet companies responsible for the content posted by users.
"I actually think that this is probably not a watershed moment because the Google convictions violate European law and ultimately they will be overturned," said John Morris, general counsel for the Washington, D.C.-based Center for Democracy and Technology.
"Having said that, yes we are quite worried about the trend in other countries to suggest Internet service providers and Web sites should be the policemen of the Internet," Morris said.
If the trend takes hold, it could put the companies on the defensive, forcing them to spend more time defending such cases or fending off calls to restrict content in some way.
China polices the web and demands cooperation from web companies, while the United States has stuck up for Internet freedom in the face of censorship by more repressive governments.
But social pressure often comes from the ground up, as Facebook recently found out in Australia.
In that case Facebook pages set up in tribute to two children murdered in February, 8-year-old Trinity Bates and 12-year-old Elliott Fletcher, were quickly covered with obscenities and pornography, prompting calls for the social network to be more accountable for its content.
"To have these things happen to Facebook pages set up for the sole purpose of helping these communities pay tribute to young lives lost in the most horrible ways adds to the grief already being experienced," Queensland Premier Ann Bligh wrote to Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg in a letter released to the Australian media.
THE 'MYSPACE SUICIDE'
"I seek your advice about whether Facebook can do anything to prevent a recurrence of these types of sickening incidents," Bligh said in the letter.
A Facebook spokeswoman responded that the popular social network, which has more than 400 million users worldwide, had rules to check content and that any reports of hate or threats would be quickly removed.
"Facebook is highly self-regulating and users can and do report content that they find questionable or offensive," the spokeswoman, Debbie Frost, said.
Calls for prosecution of cyber-bullying first reached a peak with the case of a suburban mother accused of driving a love-lorn 13-year-old girl, Megan Meier, to suicide in 2006 by tormenting her with a fake MySpace persona.
Lori Drew, the mother of a girl with whom Meir had quarreled, was found guilty of misdemeanor federal charges in a case dubbed the "MySpace Suicide" in the U.S. media, but a judge later dismissed her conviction on the grounds that the prosecution was selective the law unconstitutionally vague.
But Meier's death and a series of child exploitation cases linked to News Corp's MySpace brought pressure on the site to increase its security measures and may have cost it in its apparently losing rivalry with Facebook for social network dominance.
Such issues point to the business risks for the likes of Google and Facebook as they seek to reconcile demands for accountability with the impossibility of monitoring everything posted on their sites.
"We are a society that expects companies and people of authority to take responsibility, not only for their own actions but for the actions of those beneath them," said Karen North, director of the Annenberg Program on Online Communities at the University of Southern California.
"The difficulty is, we've created an Internet culture where people are invited to put up content, but the responsibility falls in both directions," North said. " we all share the responsibility to monitor the content that we find and for our societal standards to be maintained."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 2 hours 15 minutes ago
iPad to hit stores April 3 Reuters - 2 hours 15 minutes ago
US eases web services sanctions on blocked nations AFP - Tuesday, March 9
Sony to start selling 3D TVs in Japan from June 10 Reuters - Tuesday, March 9
Lender putting www.sex.com domain on auction block Reuters - Tuesday, March 9
News Search
Top Stories
N.Korea says ready for dialogue and war with US
Boeing sole air tanker bidder as competitors exit
Obama, Greek PM set to discuss financial reforms
Chile quake moved entire city 3 meters to west: study
World's biggest oil trader ends supplies to Iran: company
More Top Stories »
Related Full Coverage
Internet Portals & Search EnginesLatest development in the online world
All Full Coverage »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
World's biggest oil trader ends supplies to Iran: company
Chile quake moved entire city 3 meters to west: study
HIV among newborns could be 'eradicated by 2015'
Shell, PetroChina bid for Australia energy firm
Ex-intelligence officer wins USA Memory Championship
More Most Viewed »
Chile quake moved Earth's axis, shortened days: scientist
Experts confirm asteroid wiped out the dinosaurs
Florida killer whale to stay in park after deadly attack
DNA reveals some mystery on King Tut, raises questions
Scientists recreate Big Bang heat of 4 tln degrees C
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 9 March 2010 PM Maliki emerges as front-runner after Iraq vote
Villagers bury their dead after Nigeria clashes
|
Torment for UK mother as child killer 're-offends'
Tentative Mideast peace talks begin
US-TECH Summary
Haiti frees U.S. missionary held over kidnapping
|
Europe moves to create rescue fund
N.Korea says ready for dialogue and war with US
U.S. says happy to work with Iran on tackling drugs
iPad to hit stores April 3
Scouts founder 'held talks with the Nazis'
Slow going as U.S. pushes Israel-Palestinian talks
Boeing sole air tanker bidder as competitors exit
US eases web services sanctions on blocked nations
Spanish police believe ETA decimated by arrests: report
Interpol joins search for Dubai killers
Obama, Greek PM set to discuss financial reforms
Sony to start selling 3D TVs in Japan from June 10
France urges world to turn to nuclear power
Lender putting www.sex.com domain on auction block
Greek PM urges G20 effort to rein in speculators
|
Israel okays new West Bank settler homes despite moratorium
Chile quake moved entire city 3 meters to west: study
More than three-quarters see Internet as right: report
Turnout for Iraq election solid at 62 percent
Israel weighing construction of nuclear power plant
|
World's biggest oil trader ends supplies to Iran: company
Interpol issues new arrest notices for Dubai killing
U.S. says happy to work with Iran on tackling drugs
|
HIV among newborns could be 'eradicated by 2015'
Iran parliament approves Ahmadinejad budget
|
New Greek strikes as EU ponders rescue fund
U.N. chief told Myanmar supremo of worries about vote
|
Cyber-bullying cases put heat on Google, Facebook
Sweden jails Uighur Chinese man for spying
|
Google testing TV search service with Dish Network: WSJ
No more food aid, Haitian leader urges
Google, Dish testing new TV search service: report
Indonesia's president in Australia for talks
Researchers Study Effects Of Breaking Up On Self-Concept
Obama targets health insurers in healthcare reform
Gates meets with troops in southern Afghanistan
US YouTube video views up 50 percent in January: comScore
Report: Indonesian anti-terror police shoot dead 2
Sony to start selling 3D TVs in Japan in June
|
US-TECH Summary
Supreme Court To Hear Appeal Of Anti-Gay Protests At Funerals
Myanmar says junta to pick electoral body members
Sony to start selling 3D TVs in Japan from June 10
Google, Dish testing new TV search service: report
|
Indonesian graft fighter appeals murder sentence
H&R Block Q3 Profit Grows, Revenue Sags On Declining Tax Filings
Cyber-bullying cases put heat on Google, Facebook
|
U.S. Markets Finish Mixed On Light Volume; AIG Advances
Philippines star 'sorry' in election campaign row
Lender putting www.sex.com domain on auction block
|
More 3D Movies Head To Theaters Following "Alice In Wonderland" Success
Public Pubic Primping Prompts Car Crash In Keys
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
IMAX Shares Jump After Strong Opening Weekend For "Alice in Wonderland"
N.Zealand sailor Coutts may bow out of America's Cup
6 New Jersey Women Hospitalized After Botched Butt-Implant Injections
iPad to hit stores April 3
|
New Zealand woman sells souls to highest bidder
ACLU Ad Warns Obama Against Reversing Decision On 9/11 Trial
Greece's Papandreou Warns Debt Crisis Could Impact U.S.
Myanmar provides details of first election law
Gay couples find surrogate mothers in India
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Leibovitz agrees loan deal with Colony Capital: report
CORRECTED: Guns N' Roses plan "secret" shows in South America
Sacre bleu! Britons challenging French in the kitchen
Latest Oscar telecast most watched in five years
Oscars ride 'Avatar effect' to ratings surge
Seoul shares flat;techs weigh, Hyundai Heavy gains
2K mobster videogame gets vintage Playboy touch
China Southern Airlines to raise 1.6 billion dollars
Indonesian president in Australia for historic address
Argentina euphoric after Oscar for best foreign film
China: US assets should not be 'politicized'
Climate forest deal in sight: Indonesia
Rapper Lil Wayne sentenced to one year in jail
Toyota hits back at claims of electronic defects
PREVIEW-South Korea rate rises seen in H2, no move this week
Hewlett-Packard says pilfered inkjet parts peddled
PAKISTAN
Latest Oscar telecast most watched in five years
|
S.Korea producer inflation boosts steady rate views
Rapper Lil Wayne sentenced to one year in jail
|
Seoul shares slip on techs; telcos, airlines rise
S.Korea bond futures edge up early, mood cautious
Leibovitz agrees loan deal with Colony Capital: report
|
Celebrities? So last season, say Paris fashionistas
|
Public Pubic Primping Prompts Car Crash In Keys
Guns N' Roses plan secret shows in South America
|
Haiti Frees 1 Of Last 2 Missionaries Held On Child Abduction Charges
Child Mistakes Gun For Game Controller; Accidentally Shoots Herself
Biden assures Israel of U.S. security commitment
Military plane problems drag EADS into the red
Biden assures Israel of security support
US pledges 'unvarnished' commitment to Israel security
US Defense Secretary visits troops near Kandahar
Couple Faces Charges For Serving Infant Alcohol
IBM makes biodegradable plastic from plants
Iran's Ahmadinejad plans Afghan visit on Wednesday
Fake Grenade Causes Student's Suspension
N.Zealand sailor Coutts may leave America's Cup
New York Rep. Massa Resigns; Says Party's Healthcare Push Forced Him Out
New Study Discourages Dietary Supplements For Prostate Cancer Patients
Ohio State University Shooting Suspect In Custody; One Killed, Two Wounded
Tim Burton's "Alice in Wonderland" Breaks 3D Box Office Record
Disabled Immigrants Work More Than U.S. Born Peers
Nigeria urged to end impunity after village massacre
|
UNC Researcher Suggests Making Junk Food More Expensive Will Make People Eat Healthier
Women Who Drink Moderately Gain Less Weight Than Abstainers, Study Shows
Britain heads for inconclusive election: poll
|
Betty White Confirms "Saturday Night Live" Appearance
Iran says hopes China won't bow to sanctions pressure
|
Critic throws feces at Thai prime minister's house
Soldier tells how he threw back Taliban grenade
|
Gates says "decisive phase" of war looms in Kandahar
Gates praises troops in southern Afghanistan
Ally denies Khatami barred from leaving Iran
|
Roadside bomb kills 3 in southern Afghanistan
U.S. and Russia in final push to clinch new START treaty
|
Sri Lanka's opposition leader ends hunger strike
First Iraq election results to be released Wednesday
|
Iran says hopes China won't bow to sanctions pressure
Yemen offers talks with separatists as unrest flares
|
Indonesia's president in Australia for talks
Bush intervenes as N. Ireland faces crunch vote
Indonesia believes top wanted JI militant killed
|
Bali bomb mastermind believed killed in Jakarta
Toyota hits back at claims of electronic defects
NKoreans seek asylum at South consulate: activist
Biden pledges full US commitment to Israel security
Indian MPs block debate on more seats for women
CORRECTED
India's Reliance 'eyes new prey after Lyondell snub'
Pakistani o/n rates flat; rupee firms; stocks up
Pakistan to announce monetary policy on March 27
Ford launches affordable made-for-India compact
China passenger car sales up 55 percent in Feb
Hong Kong to feature new local films at festival
China car maker shares jump after 2009 net profit soars
Indonesian police kill 3 terror suspects
Liv Tyler, Patrick Wilson join suspense film
Honda to build second motorcycle plant in India
Report: Indonesian police kill 3 terror suspects
Samsung Heavy wins huge deal from Royal Dutch Shell
Indonesian anti-terror police shoot suspect dead
Indonesia believes top wanted militant killed
Phantom of Opera sequel opens amid phan disquiet
|
Pink Floyd battles EMI in online royalties case
|
UK singer Cliff Richard turns to jazz to mark 70th
|
Liv Tyler, Patrick Wilson join suspense film
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights