Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
You are here:
Business & Finance
The Great Debate
Do More With Reuters
Make Reuters My Homepage
Support (Customer Zone)
About Thomson Reuters
Human Rights Watch accuses Israel over Gaza drones
Tue Jun 30, 2009 9:04am EDT
Email | Print |
| Reprints | Single Page
By Dan Williams
JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Missile-firing Israeli drones unlawfully killed at least 29 Palestinian civilians during the Gaza Strip war, Human Rights Watch said on Tuesday.
Despite having advanced surveillance equipment, drone operators failed to exercise proper caution "as required by the laws of war" in verifying their targets were combatants, the New York-based monitoring group said, issuing a 39-page report that described six alleged strikes by remote-controlled aircraft.
Israel has a fleet of spy drones, also known as unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), but refuses to confirm or deny widespread beliefs that some of the aircraft also carry weapons.
The military cast doubt on Human Rights Watch's research methods -- a criticism echoed by some independent experts -- and, in a statement, asserted that all Israeli actions "conform to international law, as do the weapons and munitions used."
Israel launched its December-January offensive to counter rocket fire from Hamas-ruled Gaza, and has since weathered foreign censure over the killing of some 1,400 Palestinians, many of them civilians, during the fighting.
Human Rights Watch based its findings primarily on debris from Israeli-made Spike missiles, which it said are fired from drones. The report also called on Israel to publish drone surveillance footage, to show how targets were identified.
Spike's state-owned manufacturer, Rafael Advanced Defense Systems Ltd., says the missile, which has been sold widely abroad, can be fired by helicopters, infantry and naval craft.
Asked how it was possible to know that the Spikes in question had been fired by drones rather than these other means, Marc Garlasco, Human Rights Watch's senior military analyst, cited the corroboration of Palestinians who said they had seen or heard the pilotless planes.
The value of such forensics was disputed by Robert Hewson, editor of Jane's Air-Launched Weapons.
He said that while low-flying drones are often visible, the aircraft can reach operational heights of 12,000 feet, at which sightings would be much harder. The launch of a missile at that altitude would likely elude the naked eye.
Garlasco said he did not know at what height the drones described in the Human Rights Watch report were flying. He also said that two of the incidents cited in the report took place in the evening or night -- a further obstacle to witness sightings.
"Human Rights Watch makes a lot of claims and assumptions about weapons and drones, all of which is still fairly speculative, because we have so little evidence," Hewson said.
According to Garlasco, locals heard the buzz of drone propellers during the alleged air strikes rather than rotors that might have suggested the missiles were helicopter-fired.
Retired British army colonel Richard Kemp, a veteran of Iraq and Afghanistan, questioned whether such distinctions could be made, not least as the Spike's range is 8 km (5 miles) -- enough to put helicopters or naval boats out of earshot. Continued...
View article on single page
Also on Reuters
In U.S. scandals, wives don't stand by their men
Slideshow: U.S. combat troops pull out of Baghdad
Reggaeton fever shakes up Cuba's culture
More International News
Yemeni plane crashes off Comoros with 153 on board
Iraq regains control of cities as U.S. pulls back
Italy gas train derails and explodes, killing 16
Ahmadinejad calls election defeat for Iran's foes
Honduras battles tide of support for ousted Zelaya
More International News...
Israeli navy takes control of activist boat off Gaza
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Slideshow
Most Popular on Reuters
Obama says coup in Honduras is illegal
Yemeni plane crashes off Comoros with 153 on board | Video
Madoff To Rot Behind Bars
Iraq regains control of cities as U.S. pulls back | Video
Reggaeton fever shakes up Cuba's culture
Cybercrime spreads on Facebook
Infomercials lack starpower after Billy Mays death
Pirate Bay founders get rich in jail
UPDATE 11-Yemeni plane crashes off Comoros with 153 on board
UPDATE 2-Hungary passes 2010 tax law, key test for govt
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
Obama slams Honduras coup
Janet Jackson's tribute to Michael
Madoff victims speak out
No date yet for Jackson funeral
Many dead in Italy train explosion
Echoes of coups past In Honduras
China train crash kills three
China awaits Internet filter
Jackson funeral deferred
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
We want to hear from you
Join the Reuters Consumer Insight Panel and help us get to know you better
Please take a moment to complete our survey
Help and Contact Us |
Advertise With Us |
Site Index |
Thomson Reuters Corporate:
Professional Products |
Professional Products Support |
About Thomson Reuters |
Latin America |
United Kingdom |
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.