">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
UK must pry on data to block threats: ex-spy boss
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Search
Search:
UK must pry on data to block threats: ex-spy boss
Reuters - Thursday, March 26
By William Maclean, Security Correspondent
ADVERTISEMENT
LONDON - Security at the G20 summit next week will rest in part on Britain's pervasive closed circuit cameras, but in future pre-emptive surveillance could extend to the entire country's personal data.
That is the vision outlined by former security chief David Omand in a study of intelligence methods seen by privacy campaigners as a plan for a vast breach of human rights.
"Finding out other people's secrets is going to involve breaking everyday moral rules," he said in the paper for the Institute of Public Policy Research, an influential think tank.
"Application of modern data mining and processing techniques does involve examination of the innocent as well as the suspect to identify patterns of interest for further investigation."
In an interview, Omand said: "If you have the advantage of pre-emptive intelligence, then you are able to use the rapier, not the bludgeon, of state power."
Law enforcement agencies can already access personal data in a criminal investigation. What is new is the proposal to examine the data purely to identify leads for further investigation.
Analysts say the study by Omand, the cabinet's Security and Intelligence Coordinator in 2002-05, may be an indicator of the kind of reforms the security agencies may seek in coming years.
It may also point to changes elsewhere, as British surveillance practice is often emulated by countries who see Britain as a leader in using technology to snoop on its own people.
Omand says a growing target for spies is not the street, where an estimated 4.2 million closed circuit television cameras already operate throughout Britain, but personal data held on computers that forms the stuff of personal life.
This means databases of airline bookings, advance passenger information, financial, telephone, tax, health, passport and biometric records and phone and internet communications.
"Where I disagree with many who warn of the dangers of the 'surveillance society' is that I think these methods are necessary for counter-terrorism, provided they are properly regulated," he said.
SACRIFICING PRIVACY
"I think the British public would be on my side given the still significant threat from terrorism," said Omand, a former director of the Government Communications Headquarters, an intelligence agency that intercepts electronic communications.
Omand says the state needs this power because Britain is more vulnerable to disruption as it becomes more networked and IT-dependent. Also, he says, sacrificing some privacy is preferable to other ways of boosting security such as altering the criminal law to make it easier to convict.
"This is a hard choice," he said. "But...it is greatly preferable to tinkering with the rule of law, or derogating from fundamental human rights," he wrote.
Omand says surveillance should be subject to an authorizing process with clear accountability to safeguard "public trust in the essential reasonableness" of British security action.
It will be for parliament eventually to decide the limits of such surveillance, and some analysts fear MPs will permit wide powers. Britons, with no experience of invasion or occupation in their modern history, are traditionally tolerant of state power provided it is seen to be wielded benignly.
Omand's critics have been quick to speak up.
Ken MacDonald, a former Director of Public Prosecutions, said if spies trawled the data of people suspected of no crime they "would become, in peoples' eyes, essentially objectionable and oppressive. They would be viewed with hostility."
"This is because to abolish the distinction between suspects and those suspected of nothing, to place them in entirely the same category in the eyes of the State, is an unmistakable hallmark of authoritarianism."
Omand's paper is available at http://www.ippr.org.uk/publicationsandreports/publication.asp?id=646
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: Technology
Last.fm to start charging some music usersAFP - Thursday, March 26
Bill introduced to help ailing newspaper industryAFP - Thursday, March 26
Netflix links online DVD service to FacebookAFP - Thursday, March 26
British pupils to get lessons on Twitter: reportAFP - Thursday, March 26
Japan plans robo-nurses in five years: govtAFP - Thursday, March 26
Most Popular – Technology
Viewed
Deutsche Bank might have to cut jobs: report
Red meat raises death risk, white meat lowers it
Snacking during labour is OK, study finds
Scientists in possible cold fusion breakthrough
Tuberculosis ravages HIV/AIDS patients: WHO
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 26 March 2009 U.S. urges Iran to give access to jailed journalist
| International
|
U.N. urged to reject bar on defamation of religion
| International
|
Nintendo Wii shipments top 50 million since launch
| Technology
|
Former 3-D hobbyist captains Monsters vs. Aliens
| Entertainment
|
Kelly Clarkson, U2 lead U.S. album charts
| Entertainment
|
New York museum opens exhibit on credit crisis
| Entertainment
|
Jeremy Piven Broadway exit heads to arbitration
| Entertainment
|
So true: Spandau Ballet reform, announce tour
| Entertainment
|
Child star turned driver recalls own Slumdog past
| Entertainment
|
Violinist Bell: Yankee Doodle for Obamas was dandy
| Entertainment
|
Netanyahu pledges to pursue peace with Palestinians
NATO needs better Afghan coordination, Obama says
| International
|
North Korea readies missile, U.S. warns
| International
|
Israeli archaeologists find ancient bathhouse
Suspected U.S. drone kills four in northwest Pakistan
| International
|
Netanyahu: Israel is Palestinians' peace partner
Scientists see asteroid hurtle to Earth
US: Attacks rise south of Baghdad, fall nationwide
Taliban attacks get help from Pakistan: report
| International
|
UN chief wants 'substantial' stimulus at G20
Israel marks 30 years of peace with Egypt
U.N. atomic agency votes for new chief in risky world
| International
|
Clinton arrives in Mexico with US mea culpa on drug wars
Suspected US strike kills seven in Pakistan: officials
14 die in Russian bus accident: ministry
| International
|
Papaua New Guinea forests reveal 56 new species
Sudan's Bashir visits Egypt despite ICC warrant
Hamas says resumes prisoner swap talks with Israel
| International
|
US to unveil stronger rules against fraud: Geithner
Fidel Castro says brother did not fire old rebels
| International
|
AP IMPACT: It's fear that keeps Baghdad's peace
British PM brushes off Chinese currency calls
Young Indians say no thanks to American dream
| International
|
Rights group slams Israel use of white phosphorous
Danish prince celebrates new Colo. wind plants
Twitter to seek revenue from businesses
| Technology
|
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,261
Last.fm to start charging some music users
Iran official on Iraq visit downplays US overture
Bill introduced to help ailing newspaper industry
Obama says NATO needs better Afghan coordination
Netflix links online DVD service to Facebook
Thirsty plants can Twitter for water with new device
| Technology
|
British pupils to get lessons on Twitter: report
Senate calls for Brazil to return boy to dad in NJ
Japan plans robo-nurses in five years: govt
Russian, Turkmen leaders vow work on energy deal
Nokia invests in mobile money firm Obopay
Clinton heads to Mexico armed with drug wars plan
EU parliament agrees to stop Le Pen
Baghdad envoy nominee optimistic on Iraqi security
UK must pry on data to block threats: ex-spy boss
Russian city mayor slain in office: official
Pro-Russia protest against US frigate in Sevastopol
Le Pen sparks Holocaust row at EU parliament
'Crucifix' killing in French pilgrimage town
Czech crisis has no impact on EU presidency: PM
Obama news conference slips in Nielsen ratings
| Entertainment
|
Rudd: Australia in Afghanistan for 'long haul'
U.S. says North Korea missile on launch pad
HBO serves up saccharine mush in Ladies Agency
| Entertainment
|
Dalai Lama envoy says China lying to Obama
NKorea places long-range missile on launch pad: US
NKorea believed to have placed missile on launch pad: Kyodo
Head of order started by Mother Teresa steps down
Jeremy Piven Broadway exit heads to arbitration
Malaysian PM's son-in-law to head party youth wing
China court accepts first milk scandal lawsuit: state media
Hanks set for new Hollywood toy story
S.Korea vice fin min says FX liquidity has improved
US official in rare talks with Myanmar regime
Seoul shares fall; N.Korea news, banks weigh
Japan, Ukraine PMs hail carbon deal
NZ current account deficit widens in Q4
Ariane chief decries China for satellite launch
IBM to shift 'large number' of US jobs to India
Singer Crespo accused of masturbating on plane
EU proposes extending duties on Chinese candles
Danger zone for `Grey's Anatomy' doctor
Nigeria 'politics behind scrapped Korea oil deal'
Penn lining up 'Three Stooges'
PetroChina profit falls 22 percent in 2008
Actress who played Winnie Cooper marries composer
British PM brushes off Chinese call to replace dollar
Hitler art to go on sale in Britain
China's ICBC says 2008 profit up 35.2 percent
U2 fills Barcelona stadium in just 54 minutes
List of cable TV's top 15 shows in Nielsen ratings
Former 3-D hobbyist captains "Monsters vs. Aliens"
Bali prepares for 'Nyepi' public holiday
New York museum opens exhibit on credit crisis
Child star turned driver recalls own "Slumdog" past
Iran to attend meeting on Afghanistan
Parents of imprisoned journalist plan Iran trip
UN says little progress made on key Gaza issues
Goods reappear in Zimbabwe shops
EU presidency blasts US recovery plans
Obama budget on the march through Congress
Climate speeds Japan's cherry blossom season
Envoy choice would shed his three stars in Kabul
Ice-jammed floodwaters, blizzard swamp N. Dakota
U.S. to blame for much of Mexican drug violence
Hope rising in US for national death penalty ban
Clinton: NKorea plan to fire missile 'provocative'
Thirsty plants can Twitter for water with new device
France 'Gallic Moan' proves answer to hard times
Last edition of Christian Science Monitor
Twitter to seek revenue from businesses
OnLive to stream videogames as online service
14 killed in Russian bus accident
Nintendo Wii shipments top 50 million since launch
Taiwan's Chen claims persecution as trial begins
China best-seller lashes "Mafia don" America
Australia defense dept probes illegal spying claim
Piven's Broadway exit heads to arbitration
China court upholds convictions in milk scandal
China upholds 2 tainted milk scandal convictions
Officials: Suicide attack kills 11 in NW Pakistan
Australia investigates spy agency over defence probe
China shares rebound on export rebate plan
Protesters in Thailand surround government seat
Taiwan dollar up in face of U.S. dollar weakness
Japan prepares crisis steps for NKorea missile
People of Athens fight for green space
Former AIG chief Greenberg criticizes bonuses
Adam Lambert hit all the right notes on `Idol'
Feuding villages' clash leaves 1 dead in China
Toyota to sell old Prius in hot hybrid battle
Former treasury secretary writing about meltdown
S.Korean won up 2.5 pct to hit 11-wk closing high
Obama news conference slips in Nielsen ratings
Unrest looms in Asia-Pacific amid financial crisis
Blacks 'hurting worse' in grim US economy: report
Chinese students head home to find jobs: report
US ballpark to sell 4,800-calorie burger
Asia to drive mobile broadband Internet access
EMI Music signs with Project Playlist
4 appeal sentences in China's tainted milk scandal
3 cops injured in shootout at Luciano's home
S.Korea to offer tax incentives to new car buyers
Mabius just not that into 'Ugly Betty' pairing
Piven's Broadway exit heads to arbitration
Bali shuts down for Day of Silence
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights