Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Harry Potter plagiarism case may come to UK trial
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
World
Harry Potter plagiarism case may come to UK trial
Reuters - Friday, October 15
Send
IM Story
Print
By Mike Collett-White
LONDON - J.K. Rowling may have to defend herself in court against charges that she copied the work of another children's author when writing "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire," the fourth of seven Potter novels.
A judge overseeing the plagiarism case in London's High Court said in a ruling on Thursday that the claims made by Paul Allen, trustee of the estate of the late writer Adrian Jacobs, were "improbable."
But David Kitchin also turned down an application by lawyers for Rowling and her British publisher Bloomsbury for an immediate judgment dismissing the case outright.
The judge is expected to order Allen to pay a sum of money to the court as a security against the costs of the case should it eventually go to trial. That "conditional order" will be made at a later hearing, possibly before the end of the year.
Legal experts say the costs of the case would be "substantial."
Bloomsbury denies allegations that Rowling copied "substantial parts" of "The Adventures of Willy the Wizard -- No 1 Livid Land," written by Jacobs in 1987.
Jacobs' estate has said that the plot of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire copied elements of the plot of Willy the Wizard, including a wizard contest, and that the Potter series borrowed the idea of wizards traveling on trains.
Rowling's book, published in 2000, was the fourth installment of the hugely successful boy wizard Harry Potter series that has sold more than 400 million copies worldwide and been turned into a multi-billion-dollar film franchise.
According to his estate, Jacobs had sought the services of literary agent Christopher Little who later became Rowling's agent. Jacobs died "penniless" in a London hospice in 1997, it added. Bloomsbury said Rowling had never head of Jacob's book before the copyright claim was first made in 2004, almost seven years after the publication of the first book in the highly publicized Harry Potter series. Judge Kitchin said in his ruling that her evidence to that effect was "very powerful and Mr. Allen has no direct evidence with which to challenge it."
"Plainly these are disputes which I cannot resolve upon this application," he added, according to the Press Association. "But the evidence to which I have referred raises a real possibility that Mr. Little's account of events is simply not correct."
Allen claims Little was given copies of Jacobs' book, but the agent, who described Willy the Wizard as "an appalling book," said Jacobs had never done so.
Both Rowling and her publisher told the judge that behind the allegation "lies a consortium seeking to use this claim to extort a settlement from the defendants and sell more copies of Willy the Wizard on the back of the publicity it generates."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
A Minute with: Clint Eastwood on death, afterlife Reuters - 28 minutes ago
Hitler exhibition breaks taboos in Berlin AFP - 1 hour 31 minutes ago
Japan to export hit samurai drama AFP - Friday, October 15
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - Friday, October 15
Harry Potter plagiarism case may come to UK trial Reuters - Friday, October 15
News Search
Top Stories
US trade deficit swells, gap with China hits record
OPEC maintains oil output quota
OPEC begins output meeting, oil price firms
Indonesian civil servants stumble over unusual test
OPEC set to maintain official oil output
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Time to find a second Earth, WWF says
'Bandit' Obama billboard sparks storm in US city
In Chile mine accident, 33 is lucky number
Hubble captures first images of suspected asteroid collision
World's 'smallest man' undergoes final checks for record
More Most Viewed »
Too much TV psychologically harms kids: study
Workers swarm Europe's streets in anti-cuts protests
British lottery winner gets record 129 mln euros
'A billion people' go hungry in 2010: report
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 14 October 2010 France fuel supply threatened by pensions stand-off
Oppression and wealth gaps spurs satire in Egypt
Facebook rejects ownership lawsuit as a 'scam'
Court clears way for Liverpool FC sale
Six NATO soldiers killed in Afghanistan
Britain, Russia fail to heal scars of agent's murder
Rapturous welcome for Iran's Ahmadinejad in Lebanon
World's 'smallest man' undergoes final checks for record
NATO: 6 troops killed, including 4 in Afghan blast
Facebook tightens security for members on the move
OPEC 'consensus' to hold oil output steady
US-TECH Summary
G8 seeks Sahel anti-terrorism progress at Mali meet
|
European bid to freeze deepwater drilling collapses
Judge mulls residence issue in Facebook case
Hurricane Paula weakens on track to western Cuba
|
Experts warn of 10mln TB deaths in next five years
Hero's welcome in Lebanon for Iranian leader
Michigan to get 5,300 charging stations for electric cars
Gold strikes historic high point
Danish court blocks media from quoting Facebook 'friends'
JP Morgan quarterly profit up 23 percent
Amadeus says no decision on sale of Opodo
Time to find a second Earth, WWF says
U.S. Republicans likely to take House
Intel posts three billion dollar quarterly net profit
Cyber bullying campaign against Korean singer dies down
Apple executive to meet South Korea lawmakers on iPhone
FCC eyes an end to shocking mobile phone bills
|
Tech giants Samsung and Apple more friends than rivals
Microsoft deepens Facebook ties in Google battle
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Apple stock breaks $300 for first time
|
Hollywood blogger Perez Hilton vows to quit bullying
Some fever scanners work, U.S. study finds
|
Corrected: Sirius XM adds more subscribers, offers debt
|
U.S. steps up military-civilian cyber defense coordination
|
Judge mulls residence issue in Facebook case
|
Spain's bullfighters hail cultural recognition
Bosnia revokes filming permission for Jolie film
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Hollywood blogger Perez Hilton vows to quit bullying
German minister hits out at US over China forex criticism
Serbian NGOs hail Gay Pride amid threats of more violence
Renaissance Rome plays host to new 'Assassin' game
G20 chair S.Korea faces questions over currency moves: Japan
Coal India expects 25% rise in full year profit
Iranian director says politics force him to work abroad
Daimler aims for huge sales boost in China
Stripey plants are the bees' knees
Pakistan c.bank says auction result posted in error
Yo-Yo Ma, Paul Simon to kick off Kennedy celebrations
Michael Jackson solo music videos get DVD release
|
Three NATO soldiers killed in Afghanistan
France fuel supply threatened by pensions standoff
Rescued Chile miners recover, face celebrity status
|
AOL, private equity firms explore purchase: WSJ
US soldier 'may be disciplined' for aid worker death
Britain, Russia fail to heal scars of agent's murder
'Bandit' Obama billboard sparks storm in US city
Bomb kills 3 foreign troops in west Afghanistan
|
New Iraq govt will help Syria ties says Assad
Facebook and Bing fuse social network and search
Time to find a second Earth, WWF says
U.N. could police parts of north-south Sudan border
In Chile mine accident, 33 is lucky number
Global PC sales slow in third quarter
Iran says to stand by Lebanon against Israeli hostility
|
Hubble captures first images of suspected asteroid collision
NATO lets Taliban leaders go to Kabul for talks
Microsoft deepens Facebook ties in Web search battle
US moves to enhance cybersecurity cooperation
NATO: 3 more troops killed in Afghan bomb blast
Japan PM: desirable for China to free Nobel winner
|
Study says iPhone 4 design fine -- unless you drop it
Iran says to stand by Lebanon against Israeli hostility
U.N. could police parts of north-south Sudan border
|
Tribes can solve Sudan's Abyei row alone
Sirius XM adds more subscribers, offers debt
Peru arrests Shining Path leader, two killed: report
|
Australian police find half-tonne of cocaine
Ahmadinejad visit to Lebanon is "provocative"
FCC eyes an end to shocking mobile phone bills
Rousseff holds ground in Brazil election race
|
Nepalese teen becomes world's smallest man
Some fever scanners work, U.S. study finds
Diminutive Hurricane Paula weakens further
|
'Mary Mania' as Australia prepares for first saint
Documentary shows Hollywood hard times for Chinese actress
Sony delays launch of latest "Gran Turismo" game
Deals already on offer for Chilean miners' story
Cuba on storm alert as weakened Paula approaches
Kenya marathon double on final day of Delhi Games
Global PC sales slow in third quarter
Hurricane Paula weakens in Caribbean to category one
Taiwan plans to allow small brothels
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Google urged to drop China name for disputed isles
IVF births result in taller children: NZ study
Private equity courts News Corp, AOL on Yahoo: source
|
Cricket captain Ponting blames himself for India loss
Microsoft deepens Facebook ties in Web search battle
|
Sea lion attacks New Zealand rowing boat
FCC eyes an end to shocking mobile phone bills
|
Pakistani flood children face winter peril
Sony delays launch of latest Gran Turismo game
|
Oliver Stone returns to "more complex" "Wall Street"
Tatar city emerges as new Russian sports giant
Third-quarter PC growth weaker than expected
|
Judges panel selected for Paula Abdul show
Verizon not in Clearwire spectrum sale
|
"Breaking Dawn" coven members cast
China local governments loan default fears
Eddie Murphy to star in "Tower Heist"
Pakistani c.bank sells 48 bln rupees of T-bills
Maroon 5's Levine speaks out against anti-gay bullies
Seoul shares up 1.3 pct; rate decision reaction muted
Australia, Indonesia agree more talks on Timor asylum centre
Steinbeck family lose latest round in copyright feud
Bruce Willis likes it when he sees "RED"
Dollar hits new 15-year low versus yen
Bosnian minister cancels Jolie's filming permit
Taiwan stocks have best day in 5 wks; banks, TSMC up
US senator calls on China to allow currency rise
S.Korea c.bank holds rates, says FX risk to economy
Taiwan: must evaluate carefully any "hot money" tax
Oliver Stone returns to more complex Wall Street
|
PAKISTAN
Peter Jackson: Hobbit decision in week or two
|
South Korea freezes key interest rate
Bosnian minister cancels Jolie's filming permit
|
Deals already on offer for Chilean miners' story
|
Judges panel selected for Paula Abdul show
|
Bruce Willis likes it when he sees RED
|
Breaking Dawn coven members cast
|
Steinbeck family lose latest round in copyright feud
|
Sony delays launch of latest "Gran Turismo" game
Beauty leads DVD sales, Karate Kid tops rentals
|
Ahmadinejad, near Israel border, says Zionists mortal
|
Witness: Two deaths and four years in Putin's Russia
|
NATO backs reforms, U.S. warns allies on domestic cuts
|
OPEC maintains oil output quota
Sony again delays release of Gran Turismo 5
OPEC begins output meeting, oil price firms
Abbas says: Let's focus on hope, not failure
|
Indonesian civil servants stumble over unusual test
French government calls for calm amid oil and rail protests
|
Dollar hits 15-year low against yen
Pakistan floods caused $9.7 bln in damage: ADB/World Bank
|
Thaksin 'to increase activities ahead of Thai polls'
Four shot dead in restive Thai south
|
Australia rout India to win fourth men's hockey gold
German universities to train Muslim imams, teachers
|
Indonesian militants go on trial over hotel bombings
Rainbow Warrior denied entry to Indonesia: Greenpeace
Japan PM: desirable for China to free Nobel winner
S.Korea buries N.Korean defector amid controversy
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates end up; rupee flat
Verizon to join AT&T in selling iPads
|
Aquino blames Philippine court for blocking reforms
Taiwan dlr at 26-mth high; c.bank muted
Japan to export hit samurai drama
Need a lift? Phone your car and it'll pick you up
|
Pakistan's forex reserves fall to $16.97 bln
Harry Potter plagiarism case may come to UK trial
Pop legend Cliff Richard still rocking at 70
China plans to expand investment in Africa
Adam Lambert uncowed by anger over sexuality
First edition of Orwell's 1984 found in charity bin
S.Korea benchmark treasury yield near 6-yr low
Smell, close your eyes, remember: chefs teach kids
NZealand unions keep mum on 'Hobbit' boycott
The unexpected rebirth of a Saxon village in Romania
Revolutionary Vienna social housing project turns 80
A Minute with: Clint Eastwood on death, afterlife
|
Adam Lambert uncowed by anger over sexuality
|
Harry Potter plagiarism case may come to UK trial
|
Sony again delays release of Gran Turismo 5
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights