InfoAnda - Insight: Salesforce's plan for opulent campus a costly debacle |

Israel approves tougher war on Hamas | 8 January 2009

Afghan police are weak link in security force | 21 November 2009

Pakistani officials: Suspected US drone kills 12 | 17 January 2010

Korean Air notches net profit in second quarter | 14 August 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Insight: Salesforce's plan for opulent campus a costly debacle |

Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Home Business Business Home Economy Technology Media Small Business Legal Deals Earnings Social Pulse Business Video The Freeland File Markets Markets Home U.S. Markets European Markets Asian Markets Global Market Data Indices M&A Stocks Bonds Currencies Commodities Futures Funds peHUB World World Home U.S. Brazil China Euro Zone Japan Mexico Russia India Insight World Video Reuters Investigates Decoder Politics Politics Home Election 2012 Issues 2012 Candidates 2012 Tales from the Trail Political Punchlines Supreme Court Politics Video Tech Technology Home MediaFile Science Tech Video Tech Tonic Social Pulse Opinion Opinion Home Chrystia Freeland John Lloyd Felix Salmon Jack Shafer David Rohde Bernd Debusmann Nader Mousavizadeh Lucy P. Marcus David Cay Johnston Bethany McLean Edward Hadas Hugo Dixon Ian Bremmer Lawrence Summers Susan Glasser The Great Debate Steven Brill Jack & Suzy Welch Frederick Kempe Christopher Papagianis Breakingviews Equities Credit Private Equity M&A Macro & Markets Politics Breakingviews Video Money Money Home Tax Break Lipper Awards 2012 Global Investing MuniLand Unstructured Finance Linda Stern Mark Miller John Wasik James Saft Analyst Research Alerts Watchlist Portfolio Stock Screener Fund Screener Personal Finance Video Money Clip Investing 201 Life Health Sports Arts Faithworld Business Traveler Entertainment Oddly Enough Lifestyle Video Pictures Pictures Home Reuters Photographers Full Focus Video Reuters TV Reuters News Article Comments (0) Slideshow Follow Reuters Facebook Twitter RSS YouTube Read Hollie Cavanagh couldn't make 'Idol' fans love her 10 May 2012 Michele Bachmann to withdraw Swiss citizenship 10 May 2012 JPMorgan reveals $2 billion trading loss, CEO Dimon admits "egg on face" | 12:52am EDT JPMorgan has $2 billion trading loss, reputation hit | 10 May 2012 NBA's "Birdman" Andersen's home raided by Denver-area police 10 May 2012 Discussed 142 Obesity fight must shift from personal blame: U.S. panel 121 Florida nabs white supremacists planning ”race war” 118 Romney apologizes for bullying incident at school Watched Prince Charles fills in as TV weatherman Thu, May 10 2012 U.S. downs test missile with new interceptor Thu, May 10 2012 World's rarest gorilla makes camera-trap debut Wed, May 9 2012 Pictures Reuters Photojournalism Our day's top images, in-depth photo essays and offbeat slices of life. See the best of Reuters photography. See more | Photo caption Gay marriage battle A look at the legal battles and the controversies over gay marriage. Slideshow Wild weather Scenes of the awesome and sometimes destructive power of nature. Slideshow Insight: Salesforce's plan for opulent campus a costly debacle Tweet Share this Email Print Related News Facebook plans to raise $10.6 billion in mega IPO Fri, May 4 2012 Oracle trial against Google turns into CEO day Tue, Apr 17 2012 Oracle says Google's own emails show its guilt Mon, Apr 16 2012 Analysis & Opinion Principal reductions begin in earnest Super lucky, Super moon Related Topics Tech » Media » 1 of 5. Renderings of a proposed campus for Salesforce.com in San Francisco, California are shown in this publicity photo released to Reuters May 9, 2012. Credit: Reuters/City of San Francisco/Salesforce.com/Handout By Gerry Shih and Jim Finkle SAN FRANCISCO | Fri May 11, 2012 4:01am EDT SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - In early 2010, Marc Benioff, founder and chief executive of Salesforce.com, summoned several of his top real estate and finance executives to his San Francisco home to float a bold idea. He envisioned a world-class corporate campus to house the high-flying provider of online sales management tools, which employed more than 2,500 people in the city. Soon after, Salesforce bought 14 acres of waterfront property for $278 million. The company hired acclaimed Mexican architects Legoretta + Legoretta, who created an elaborate, avant-garde design for an office complex that would marry luxurious executive perks with expansive public spaces. City leaders got behind the project, which promised to be the biggest office development in San Francisco in decades. Then, this past February, just days before it was set to receive final approvals from the city, Salesforce abruptly pulled the plug. The company's stated reason for changing course was that the new campus would not be big enough for its growing workforce. But people closely involved with the ill-fated development paint a picture of an out-of-control project that lurched forward even in the face of stratospheric costs and tepid support among employees. Only a construction expert hired late in the planning process convinced Benioff that moving forward would be folly. The canceled development has already cost Salesforce tens of millions of dollars, and the price tag could rise further if the Web-based software maker fails to find a ready buyer for the land it bought, according to recent regulatory filings. The cancellation has also singed the company's relationships with city officials, including San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee, who had touted the development as an economic boon and was stunned when it was suddenly abandoned. A handful of real estate executives departed Salesforce in the aftermath, although the company would not confirm this was linked to the project. The cancellation also caused financial pain for some of the partners in the project, with one local contractor, for example, forced to lay off a dozen architects. The episode fueled concerns about Benioff's penchant for spending big to make a splash. "The rule is somebody builds a big shrine to themselves and that usually is the end of the company," said David Rudow, senior equity analyst with Thrivent Financial for Lutherans, a not-for-profit financial services firm that holds roughly $50 million worth of Salesforce shares. "They should focus on developing software, expanding their market. All this focus on a fancy building doesn't benefit customers in any way possible," Rudow said. Benioff rejected the notion that it had been a lavish, out-of-control venture. "The campus was always the best option, and we were all excited about the campus," Benioff said in an email to Reuters, adding that the cost "did not balloon" and was always forecast at $2 billion. "There was no excess planned at the campus," Benioff added. "We are very austere in our real estate operations. This is true in all of our offices today as well." Salesforce investors were relieved to see the company pull back, given that a number of companies over the years - including AOL Time Warner and CIT Group - have fallen into decline around the time they moved into expensive new corporate edifices. "One does not typically abandon course at the 1-yard line after spending millions of dollars for the whole kit and caboodle and going 99 yards down the field," said a person outside of Salesforce who worked on the project and spoke on condition of anonymity. BRILLIANCE, BRASSINESS, BIG SPENDING Benioff, 47, an imposing figure at 6 foot 5 inches, made his name in the 1990s as a young marketing star at Oracle Corp., where he forged a reputation for brilliance, brassiness and big spending. After leaving Oracle to start Salesforce in 1999, he threw a launch party that famously featured the B-52s rock band and cost $600,000, even though the company barely had revenue at the time. Since then, Benioff has become one of Silicon Valley's most prominent figures, traveling the world as a passionate evangelist for cloud computing, one of the hottest growth sectors in the technology industry. And he has not lost his taste for a good show. At the Salesforce holiday party last December, acrobats poured champagne while suspended upside-down from chandeliers. Salesforce reported an $11.6 million loss in its most-recent fiscal year and it forecasts another loss in the current year. But shareholders say it is hard to fault Benioff, whose singular vision has been credited for the company's surging top line year after year. Salesforce shares are trading at more than 12 times their 2004 IPO price. For Benioff, the audacious campus project represented another long-term investment in the company's growth that could instill a unified corporate culture and serve as a draw for employees, according to people outside the company who were familiar with his thinking. Splashy headquarters like the "Googleplex" - Google's corporate headquarters in Mountain View, California - can boost a firm's public image and stand as a physical reminder of its business success. Apple, for one, plans to build an enormous ring-like structure resembling a spaceship to house 13,000 employees in a headquarters complex at Cupertino, California. The Salesforce project began to take shape in late 2010, when the company bought the parcel in southeast San Francisco. The land was among the last vacant tracts in an area south of downtown known as Mission Bay, where a new University of California research center and a cluster of biotech companies have anchored a decades-long redevelopment effort. In an anteroom near his third-floor office, Benioff soon set up a 15-foot-long model of his dream campus: office buildings covered in orange terra cotta and mesh-like purple skins that rose from the waterfront like geometric blocks. A water taxi pavilion extended into the bay to receive commuters from a proposed ferry service; a planned parking structure featured a swimming pool and cabanas on its roof; and another pool shimmered on a patio outside Benioff's future executive suite, according to two people who saw the model. The CEO liked Legoretta's works, which included a towering community center at the University of California, San Francisco and a lavish beachfront home in Kona, Hawaii, built for retired financier Sanford Robertson, who sits on Salesforce's board. "I was taken by them," Benioff told Reuters in an April interview, referring to Legoretta's works. "The design was perfect." The campus was to be situated directly across the street from another project Benioff was deeply invested in: The University of California, San Francisco Benioff Children's Hospital, which took that name after Benioff and his wife Lynne donated $100 million in 2010. "There was a lot of momentum with the campus - the pictures, and the graphics, and the approvals," Benioff said. "Every time we got one more approval, we kind of always came back and said, 'Is this a good idea? This is a good idea.' Let's keep going." Some employees were less enthusiastic. In a 2010 survey of more than 3,000 Salesforce employees, a slim majority indicated that while they were excited by the campus concept, they preferred to stay in downtown office towers near public transportation, a person with direct knowledge of the poll said. Benioff characterized the survey's results as "50/50" and described its purpose as "mostly just something to help us socialize the decision inside the company." "I felt the campus would be more aligned with our culture than (an) 80-story building," Benioff said. His enthusiasm and force of will were critical in overcoming concerns on the part of some city officials who were wary of how the broader community might view such a large corporate campus designed by an architectural firm known for unconventional concepts. Eventually, the city was assuaged by the inclusion of extensive public spaces within the development. Planning documents reviewed by Reuters showed a campus design laden with both splashy touches and generous space set aside for public use. In the atriums of one office building, four-story high waterfalls tumbled from the roof. Benioff personally proposed mounting an enormous television screen high over a large public plaza — dubbed the "Town Square" — to show programs including San Francisco Giants baseball games, a city official said. Accented with palm and lemon-scented gum trees, the leafy campus was designed to host farmers' markets and food trucks. An expansive gym, a child-care facility and several restaurants were intended to be partially open to the public. TROUBLE BREWING As Benioff pressed ahead, trouble was brewing behind the scenes. Linda Jansen, who served as head of real estate at Salesforce from 2007 until earlier this year, questioned the practicality of the project from the start, arguing that offices scattered around the Bay Area made more financial sense, according to three people knowledgeable about the project. Now a member of Google's real estate team, Jansen could not be reached for comment. When the Salesforce board approved the planned campus in late 2010, a preliminary estimate placed the cost at roughly $750 per square foot (about $8,000 per square meter), according to a person with direct knowledge of the project. By early 2011, amid concerns that Salesforce lacked the expertise to manage such a massive development, the company brought in Ford Fish, a veteran construction manager. By last autumn, word spread among local real estate insiders that new projections put the overall cost at over $2 billion, or roughly $1,000 per square foot (about $11,000 per square meter) — a 33 percent rise from previous estimates and far more than the market rate of $600 per square foot (about $6,500 per square meter) for new corporate offices. That would have made it the most expensive office development in San Francisco history, said Colin Yasukochi, vice president of research at commercial real estate firm Jones Lang LaSalle. Benioff maintained that the cost projection did not rise dramatically. There were external pressures mounting on Salesforce last year as well. By November, Salesforce shares had fallen to $109 from a high of $160 in July, as analysts criticized the company for what was perceived as Benioff's excessive spending on sales and marketing. It was Fish who persuaded Benioff to back away from the project in early 2012, Benioff said. Fish had identified a massive vacancy at 50 Fremont, a modern office tower a block away from Salesforce's current headquarters, and moved quickly to secure the deal. Even as Salesforce signed the 50 Fremont lease in January, company representatives assured the city that it was fully committed to the Mission Bay campus. But on February 28, Salesforce suddenly announced that it was suspending the project because the company was "going to need the square-footage before we can build it." 'CAUTION AND DISAPPOINTMENT' The withdrawal blindsided San Francisco officials. In an interview, Mayor Ed Lee said he was taken aback by the project's collapse. "My first reaction was caution and disappointment that the investment that they made wasn't able to get completed," Lee said, but added that he was pleased the company will expand in downtown San Francisco. Others were less polite. "The question is, as a publicly traded company, how did it get this far?" said a senior city official who asked not to be identified by name. "Nobody connected the dots — a really expensive campus, a public company with analysts and stock shareholders — and said, 'This just doesn't work.'" The project's cancellation sent some contractors reeling. Flad Architects, a local firm, laid off a dozen architects. Other contractors also cut jobs. "When you've got a $2 billion project that dies on you instantly, it wouldn't be difficult to say that it had an impact," said Andrew Cunningham, a principal at Flad. Salesforce has taken its lumps, too. In 2011, the company spent $33.8 million on interest and property taxes related to the land, according to the company's annual report. The company also warned shareholders that its financial performance may be hurt if the company fails to "realize any benefits in connection with our purchase of undeveloped land in San Francisco." Benioff emphasized the company's strong revenue performance. "The company is focused on top line growth and holding the land is immaterial to the company's ability to grow," he said in his email. The model of the project that used to be near his office has been removed, but Benioff did not rule out a revival of the campus proposal. "It doesn't mean that at some point we can't reactivate the project," he said in his interview. "We continue to have the best possible working environment for employees, regardless what form that takes. And we want to have every option on the table for them." (Editing by Martin Howell and Will Dunham) Tech Media Related Quotes and News Company Price Related News Tweet this Link this Share this Digg this Email Reprints We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/ Comments (0) Be the first to comment on reuters.com. Add yours using the box above. Edition: U.S. Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom Back to top Reuters.com Business Markets World Politics Technology Opinion Money Pictures Videos Site Index Legal Bankruptcy Law California Legal New York Legal Securities Law Support & Contact Support Corrections Connect with Reuters Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS Podcast Newsletters Mobile About Privacy Policy Terms of Use AdChoices Copyright Our Flagship financial information platform incorporating Reuters Insider An ultra-low latency infrastructure for electronic trading and data distribution A connected approach to governance, risk and compliance Our next generation legal research platform Our global tax workstation Thomsonreuters.com About Thomson Reuters Investor Relations Careers Contact Us Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Friday, 11 May 2012
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
British played central role in foiled bomb operation: sources |
Insight: Afghan women fade from White House focus as exit nears |
Putin flexes muscle in shunning U.S.-hosted G8 talks |
Scepticism main challenger in Algerian election |
Libya finance minister says to resign soon, cites wastage |
France's Hollande to fight firms that fire workers |
German police suspend officer over Salafist links |
Microsoft redesigns Bing, plays up Facebook link |
Facebook listing could trigger IPO surge: Nasdaq |
Audience shares rise in debut on Apple link |
Intel CEO plays down concerns about tech spending |
Russell Brand to host 2012 MTV Movie Awards |
The Simpsons go Gaga for season finale |
House finale bittersweet: Everybody Dies |
Tenacious D aim to revive hard rock with Fenix |
British played central role in foiled bomb operation: sources |
Lawyers for China dissident's nephew say they face threats |
South Africa's De Klerk stirs ire with apartheid remarks |
Syria suicide bombers kill 55, ceasefire in tatters |
Greek parties scramble to avert new vote |
Analysis: China's Hu could cast long shadow if top table trimmed |
French left set to win parliament vote: polls |
British PM faces scrutiny over ties to Murdoch |
Spain to approve banks cleanup after tough talks |
Civilian deaths in Afghanistan fall 20 percent: U.N. |
Facebook's IPO already oversubscribed: source |
Sony slides to three-decade low on strategy doubts |
Insight: Salesforce's plan for opulent campus a costly debacle |
Yahoo CEO says he never provided a resume: source |
Online music storage firm MP3tunes files for bankruptcy |
Google, Twitter quizzed on Facebook-Instagram: source |
Facebook listing could trigger IPO surge: Nasdaq |
Analysis: Cisco spooks, but IT spending seen on the mend |
House finale bittersweet: Everybody Dies |
Hollie Cavanagh couldn't make 'Idol' fans love her |
Long road to South Korean stage for Syrian drama |
ABC renews Modern Family and other shows |
CBS sues ABC, says new show copies Big Brother |
Howard Stern says will tone down act for Got Talent |
Syria says thwarts attempted 1,200 kg car bomb |
NATO head urges Pakistan to open transit routes in time for summit |
Analysis: Israel frets on sideline as fall of Assad delayed |
Egyptians vote abroad, leadership contest heats up |
New Tunisia constitution ready in October: speaker |
Czech restitution plan may unlock vast church lands |
Algeria declares ruling FLN winner of parliament vote |
Nvidia revenue, outlook beat Street; shares jump |
Analysis: Facebook friends Itaú BBA in nod to Brazil growth |
Viddy gets $30 million funding, aims to stand out from competition |
Cannes film festival puts spotlight on rising stars |
Zooey Deschanel to portray Loretta Lynn on Broadway |
The Dictator film launches in offensive style |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph	VPN on MacOSX	BlogMeter 1.01